Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

THE MAN WITH THE MONEY – Premier and Finance Minister Sandy Silver jokes with members of the media Thursday afternoon before taking questions on the 2022-23 fiscal year budget he had tabled in the legislature a short time earlier.

Mammoth budget approaches $2-billion echelon

It’s another high-spending budget for the Yukon government.

By Tim Giilck on March 3, 2022

Revised - It’s another high-spending budget for the Yukon government.

Premier Sandy Silver, who is also the Finance minister, introduced his latest, $1.97-billion budget Thursday afternoon in the legislature.

“This budget will make sure all Yukoners benefit from our territory’s historic economic growth,” Silver said in his budget address.

“We are improving access to housing through strategic investments and innovative partnerships.

“We are prioritizing health and safety as we create more effective and sustainable health and social support systems to better meet the need of all Yukoners.

“We are empowering the next generation by making life more affordable for families and modernizing the Yukon’s education system,” Silver told the house.

“We are creating a diverse, resilient and green economy that will contribute to healthy, vibrant and sustainable communities across the territory.”

Then came the numbers.

The federal transfer payment to the Yukon is about $1.5 billion this year.

The 2022-23 fiscal year budget includes $1.97 billion in planned spending, Silver informed MLAs.

That compares to an estimated $1.62 billion for the current fiscal year, which will end March 31.

“Of this, a record $546.5 million in capital expenditures is identified, representing a 26 per cent increase from last year and nearly double the capital budget from just five years ago,” the premier said. (See details, p. 6.)

The operations and maintenance expenditures account for a total of $1.42 billion.

“Budgets are fundamentally about choices,” Silver said.

“With limited resources, choices must be made about where to focus government spending to ensure it is responsive to the needs of the present while creating the conditions for prosperity in the future.

“This budget addresses critical needs in the territory while making necessary investment to make sure all Yukoners benefit from our territory’s historic economic growth.”

During a media scrum following the address, Silver noted the record spending comes without any new taxation, something he is pleased with.

“We have not made any new taxes in this budget, and no new fees and no new taxes.”

As for how the government will “sell” its record-setting budget to the public, Silver said it was a fair question.

“How much is enough?” he asked. “How much can we sustain over a long-term basis? These are excellent questions.

“We’ve done an awful lot of ‘catch-up and keep-up’ in our first few years,” Silver explained.

“Promising a whole bunch of things in the spring budget and not being able to deliver on them doesn’t help industry grow. Now what you’re seeing here is a steady progression into the future with half-a-billion dollars in spending.

“We really need to invest heavily in housing, we need to invest in recreation facilities.

“We’re maintaining a surplus, and we’re exponentially increasing the capital dollars going out the door. We’re doing a lot of work to keep an eye on what’s fiscally responsible.”

The main estimates show an annual surplus of $39.5 million with year-end net debt of $207.5 million.

In his 65-minute budget speech, Silver said, “The Yukon’s economy is seeing tremendous growth that truly set it apart from the rest of Canada,” Silver added. The government is forecasting “robust economic growth of 9.6 per cent in 2022, along with continued growth each year out to 2026.”

During the scrum, Silver addressed that forecast in some detail.

“That’s the largest estimate I’ve ever seen in my 10 or 11 years in politics. It’s nice to see these estimates, but I’m never going to guarantee it’s going to come. If you look at the forecasts over the last five years and the reality of our economy, they’ve been really good. I have more confidence in the private sector, and more confidence in this government will have the money there.”

“The Yukon’s economy is seeing tremendous growth that truly sets it apart from the rest of Canada,” the premier said in his speech.

“Indeed, our economy continues to see strong growth despite the impacts of COVID-19.”

In 2020, the Yukon had the strongest GDP growth in the country, and was one of only two jurisdictions to experience GDP growth, Silver noted.

“We also continue to have the lowest unemployment rate in the country, as we have had for much of the last few years.”

According to the Finance minister, “This year’s budget shows a surplus of $39.5 million, which reflects our government’s enduring commitment to responsible fiscal management even in the face of COVID-19.”

Silver also touched on his government’s new five-year capital plan.

“I am very pleased to present the Government of Yukon’s latest five-year capital plan, which includes average annual spending of $519 million for a total of nearly $2.6 billion in spending.”

Last year’s plan included $434 million in spending. The total for this budget is $546.5 million.

“I am proud to once again deliver a balanced budget that reflects the prudent fiscal management Yukoners expect from their government and which they deserve,” Silver added.

Among the other highlights, the budget includes more than $60 million for housing initiatives across the Yukon.

“We are investing $255 million in capital over the next five years to support access to stable, affordable housing and allow for future development,” Silver said.

“Over $5.5 million in this year’s budget will support our government’s response to the Substance Abuse Health Emergency.”

That emergency, spurred by the territory’s high numbers of opioids-related deaths, was formally declared on Jan. 20.

“More than $11.6 million in this year’s budget is dedicated to the Health and Social Services resources necessary to manage the ongoing risk of COVID-19 in the territory,” the premier said.

“We also have included a $10-million COVID-19 contingency fund to ensure we can respond effectively as we move from pandemic to endemic.”

The operations and maintenance section of the budget ($1.42 billion) reflects a 4.6 per cent increase over the record 2021-22 main estimates.

“The spending increase is driven by investments in new and expanded health services,” Silver said.

Last year, the operations and maintenance budget was estimated at $1.36 billion.

The Department of Health and Social Services account for more than $563 million. It’s the highest-spending department, followed by Community and Transportation at nearly $432 million.

The Department of Education is budgeted at nearly $224 million.

The Department of Tourism and Culture is at the bottom of the departmental pile for budgets, with just less than $91 million.

The government will table a $410.7 million Interim Supply Bill to fund operations and maintenance and capital spending for April and May while the full year of 2022-23 spending authority is debated.,

Of that amount, $321.1 million is for O&M and $89.6 million is for capital expenditures.

Also to be tabled is $10.9 million in supplementary spending for the 2021-22 fiscal year. This includes a $24.7 million increase in O&M spending, with an offsetting increase of $3.1 million in recoveries, and a $10.8 million decrease in capital spending, with an offsetting decrease of $13.1 million in recoveries.

A revised surplus of $25.5 million is forecast for 2021-22.

See related coverage.

Comments (14)

Up 9 Down 0

Yukoner61 on Mar 7, 2022 at 9:03 pm

@ibrian

Yes that's exactly right. Housing prices go up in every place where there is a hot economy. It is not a "Crisis", it's literally the market acting as it should. If people can't afford to buy housing in Whitehorse, then houses wouldn't be selling and the prices would come down. But houses ARE being bought. If anyone thinks I'm wrong, please look up any other region in Canada with a hot economy and you will unsurprisingly find that they are in the same situation we are. So any 'Housing Summits' or studies etc. done by YTG are a big waste of time and money. This is just economics 101. The people who can't afford to buy a house are typically those who will not sacrifice anything to do so. Or they expect to be able to afford a house by the age of 25.

For those who want to benefit from the current housing market, encourage your kid to get a trade since tradespeople (think carpenters, plumbers, electricians etc.,) are making out like bandits right now building houses and commercial buildings (just look at all the cranes you see around the city currently) OR if you are retired, you can sell your expensive house and move to a more depressed area of the country where you can buy a similar house for 1/4 what you sell for here and then have the other 3/4s to pad your retirement.

Try to look on the bright side!!

Up 18 Down 2

iBrian on Mar 7, 2022 at 8:48 am

The schools don’t teach financial responsibility. They teach now that you can have anything you want, and if you don’t get it; Protest.
So with people thinking they can smoke 2 packs a day, 7 grams pot a week and 6 beers every night with a full party on the weekend. They see it as a”RIGHT”. But really it’s $560 a week out of your pay.
We ate a lot of rice and fish we caught for a year to afford what we have. I sold our rental unit last year (Thanks NDP) and invested those funds into precious metals.
Too many people are not willing to make the painful adult decision to actually save money.
Most of the whiners who say they can’t afford a house don’t work capable adult jobs. minimum wage jobs are for kids and low achieving adults. Gets your foot in a door, but it’s up to you to find a better paying job to achieve your goals.

Up 14 Down 3

Groucho d'North on Mar 6, 2022 at 12:27 pm

The data used to brag about Yukon's GDP was from 2020- two years ago. It was also two years ago that our tourism sector was effectively shut down by government decree forcing many Yukoners out of a job which impacted other economic sectors as well. All the while Trudeau is borrowing against the future of our kids increasing our national debt, stimulating inflation and what we pay for the necessities of life. I miss having an economist as the PM rather than a part-time snow board instructor with a shady past and a silver spoon in his yap.
Things are not as rosey as Mr. Silver portrays. Perhaps he should talk with shop keepers, residents in the seniors homes, retailers, college students and others that are more directly impacted by a cost of living that shows no signs of slowing down. He can cherry pick all the stats he likes to spin a yarn about how good things are in the Yukon, but we know better.
One question Mr. Silver; What are you doing to make life here in the Yukon more affordable for all residents?

Up 9 Down 2

Vlado on Mar 5, 2022 at 1:59 pm

@ Sunny - I like what you write. However, I miss on what you said about the housing. The housing in Whitehorse grows like mushrooms after a good rain. It is usually sold before being finished. Wonder who is buying that when nobody can afford it?

Up 19 Down 9

Yukoner61 on Mar 4, 2022 at 9:18 pm

@Tired and Sunny

You are both concerned about housing. Well maybe you haven't noticed but people are making more money than ever before. If you have a good education, there is no reason you can't find a good job or start a good business and afford a house. I have lived here for over 20 years and everyone I know (including their kids) who wants a house, has a house. My neighbors kid is a carpenter - 28 years old and works his butt off. He almost has the deposit required for a 2nd home and will soon purchase it. So how come my hardworking neighbors kid is about to buy his second home before the age of 30 to use as a rental, while you 2 are saying no one can afford to buy a home? Unless you don't know how to budget, love to party and buy unnecessary toys or you don't have the work ethic to go get a trade or get a higher education, there is no legitimate reason you can't buy a house.

By your logic, Fort MacMurray should have stopped most production of its oil sands because housing prices there went through the roof.
You guys probably love the NDP since Kate White and Emily Tredger are basically saying that everyone who makes minimum wage should be able to afford to buy a house even if it destroys the equity for everyone who already owns one.

Up 33 Down 6

Sunny P. on Mar 4, 2022 at 1:51 pm

Funny how everything is always so perfect when a politician speaks, but then you talk to the people who have to provide this money from their income: nobody can afford housing in the Yukon, nobody can farm because no land is made available, nobody has green energy because the dam only covers some 18% of energy, mining is leaving the Yukon due to government overreach, and just start talking to people about the health care system, which absolutely needs to scratch the word 'care' as there is none. How about those that aren't allowed to fly someplace, but still pay taxes for the airport. And talk to parents about the abysmally horrifying school education offered in government schools. All in all? The only ones with a positive outlook are the politicians who are using it to hang off the rest of Canada like a gigantic parasite.

Up 32 Down 8

Max Mack on Mar 4, 2022 at 9:57 am

The Feds probably pump +$2 billion annually into the various levels of government in the Yukon. This figure does not include direct and indirect subsidies to businesses, NGOs and individuals (e.g. covid relief),

These very generous gifts from the Feds are helping to push inflation through the roof and creating supply constraints from goods transport to labour to goods and services.

And nary a word from Silver about saving for the future. It's all spend, spend, spend. Gotta spend it all to keep it out of the hands of the next government.

Up 25 Down 3

AdmiralA$$ on Mar 4, 2022 at 7:02 am

Hey now, let's not go insulting drunken sailors like this...I mean even they knew how to and the importance of burying some coins and saving for a rainy day.

Up 35 Down 7

Vlad on Mar 4, 2022 at 1:02 am

" Historic Economic growth" can somebody explain to me how we could have a historic economy over the past two years when businesses were shuttered, supply chain in shambles and inflation skyrocketing?

Up 19 Down 8

Not an economist and I don’t play one on tv on Mar 3, 2022 at 7:59 pm

@Juniper Jackson: I agree with your concerns about rising inflation, which is occurring in both Canada and the US, largely as a result of Covid federal government stimulus and relief spending, combined with a worker shortage. This inflation, which leads to higher gasoline and heating fuel prices, higher electricity costs, higher food prices and increased new and used car prices, is hardest on fixed income seniors, but impacts every family. But it’s unlikely we will experience another “Great Depression.” In a depression, you experience falling prices as the supply of goods and services exceeds demand. Unemployment soars, so more families and individuals are unable to purchase essential goods, or make their mortgage payments. That leads to plummeting housing prices as there is a surplus of homes for sale.
We are currently experiencing rising prices, almost full employment, a shortage of skilled workers, doctors, tradespeople. While it’s technically possible to have both a depression and some aspects of inflation simultaneously (sometimes called “stagflation,) it doesn’t look like these conditions are developing in Canada or the Yukon right now. Of course, war in Ukraine foisted by an unprovoked Russian attack is the joker in the pack. But we are very fortunate in the Yukon to have excellent financial transfers from Canada and a large number of well earning government employees, along with a housing boom that supports many private sector tradespeople, a healthier than usual mining sector, and many very successful First Nations governments and development corporations. An unfortunate byproduct of our current booming economy is a very difficult housing situation, with high purchase and rental housing costs.

Up 26 Down 8

bonanzajoe on Mar 3, 2022 at 7:44 pm

“We are prioritizing health and safety as we create more effective and sustainable health and social support systems to better meet the need of all Yukoners." Yeah, that's like locking people up, locking down, firing people who refuse the vaccine, closing businesses, forcing people to live under draconian mandates and covering our faces with masks - which by the way, the citizens have to pay for themselves. So, Silver, how much is that coming out of this budget and how does it relate to the enormous budget?

Up 36 Down 7

Tired of the lies on Mar 3, 2022 at 3:47 pm

“We are empowering the next generation by making life more affordable for families and modernizing the Yukon’s education system,” Silver told the house.

Yeah, I grew up in the Yukon and will never be able to afford a home here. Thanks.
From covid to this, to whatever it will be tomorrow.

Everything this government does and says reminds me of Ralph Wiggum saying, "I'm helping".

Up 20 Down 44

Kailer on Mar 3, 2022 at 2:54 pm

Great budget. Economic outlook section was my favorite.

Up 87 Down 15

Juniper Jackson on Mar 3, 2022 at 2:15 pm

Gas is 1.79.. a 3 lb rib roast is 109. With budgets like this, we could see double these prices in a year. Inflation over 5%. This isn't "free" money.. I pay taxes, i have a stake in this money.. stop spending it like a drunken sailor. My God..we are staring the 'great' depression right in the face.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.