Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Deputy Premier Tracy-Anne McPhee

Majority of poll respondents want McPhee to resign: YP

Politics continue to be a rocky road for deputy premier Tracy-Anne McPhee.

By Tim Giilck on January 26, 2022

Politics continue to be a rocky road for deputy premier Tracy-Anne McPhee.

She has been embroiled in the Hidden Valley Elementary School sex abuse scandal for months now.

While she has had comparatively little to say directly to the public, she survived a call for her resignation from cabinet that passed in the legislature last fall by simply ignoring it.

At the time, Premier Sandy Silver proclaimed to the opposition parties that as premier, “I decide who is in my cabinet.”

Both opposition parties voted in favour of the motion.

Now, an opinion poll commissioned by the Yukon Party has brought the issue to the forefront once again.

“A new poll conducted by Léger and commissioned by the Yukon Party has found that 64 per cent of Yukoners want deputy premier Tracy-Anne McPhee to resign over her mishandling of the Hidden Valley Elementary School sexual abuse scandal,” the official Opposition reported.

“This comes after the revelations that the deputy premier became aware in 2019 of the sexual abuse that occurred at Hidden Valley and failed to notify parents.”

(While McPhee was the minister of Education, the department failed to notify parents of the school community of a sexual interference charge laid against a then-education assistant at the school in 2019. He was later jailed for the offence, and more charges against him are before the courts.)

Yukon Party MLA Scott Kent said “that the majority of Yukoners want the deputy premier to resign for her failure to live up to her responsibilities as Education minister (until 2021) is not a surprise,” said Kent, the Copperbelt South MLA.

“That not a single person in the Liberal government lost their job over the fact that they were aware of what happened and did not notify parents is a complete failure of accountability by this government.

“The Liberals should do the right thing and listen to the express will of Yukoners and the legislative assembly by having the deputy premier resign from cabinet.”

The party also said “the polling also found that since the Liberals signed the Confidence and Supply Agreement with the NDP (in April 2021), their popularity has declined significantly.

“The Yukon Party is in first place with 37 per cent, the NDP are in second with 32 per cent, and the Liberals are in third place with 28 per cent.”

Those are similar numbers to an opinion poll released last spring just prior to the March election call.

The poll, conducted between Jan. 13 and 19, consisted of phone interviews with 500 Yukoners. It was conducted by live-agent telephone data collection from Léger’s virtual call centre in Winnipeg.

The margin of error is 4.35 per cent 19 times out of 20.

The Liberal government issued a terse response to the poll.

“We will not be commenting on a Yukon Party-commissioned poll,” it said in a statement.

“Our focus as a government remains on protecting the health and safety of Yukoners through the COVID-19 pandemic and the substance use health emergency.”

NDP Leader Kate White offered a brief comment on the situation late this morning.

“I haven’t seen the poll, but I thought we made it clear what our position on this was back in the fall when we voted,” she told the Star.

“I thought we did the heavy lifting then, making it clear we didn’t think Tracy should be in cabinet.

“It’s a Yukon Party poll, so I take that for what it is worth.”

Comments (34)

Up 0 Down 1

Observer on Feb 1, 2022 at 6:53 pm

Hmmm, no resignations yet, much a do about nothing, move on nothing to see here. All the neo cons have moved onto the Peel issue.

Up 6 Down 8

Patti Eyre on Jan 31, 2022 at 10:23 am

@bonanza: you support marxism, right, left, up and down. just be honest for once.

Up 37 Down 8

Resign just resign on Jan 28, 2022 at 7:34 pm

Minister McPhee if you had any integrity you would resign and so would the Deputy Minister of Education. You would acknowledge your mistakes and respect the will of the people who placed their trust in you and voted you in. The only honourable thing to do is resign and if you are unwilling to do that our “ethical and accountable” Premiere would ask you to step down. I laugh out loud, none of this will ever happen because it requires accountability, transparency and ethics - none of which our current government possesses. Resign.

Up 30 Down 9

NeilAlexGeddy on Jan 28, 2022 at 2:39 pm

@Truthful
Weighted against the Hidden Valley Liberal scandal, the lesser of the two evils. The only one who gained political points from Duramaxgate was Kate White because her response was proportional to the crime.

Silver is a bag of wind. A false prophet. Says the right things but makes no effort to deliver. I don't think he or his cabinet have the skills to organize a birthday party without screwing a fundamental task up.

Up 17 Down 45

Larry, Currie and Moe on Jan 28, 2022 at 2:30 pm

Watching Currie flail about from the sidelines is hilarious. It clearly shows he ain’t ready for prime time. I got called on that poll and in about 3 seconds it was clear by the weighted questions who was behind it. I hung up on them.

It’s like watching the 3 stooges stepping on a bunch of garden rakes.

Up 40 Down 10

Go now on Jan 28, 2022 at 2:28 pm

Yes, pleeasssee Ms. McPhee.... Go now. As soon as possible.
Let's not forget how you also took the right to appeal the dismissal of a complaint about a lawyer at the Law Society away from Yukoners on top of all your other blunders. Single-handedly protecting all lawyers at the expense of the public.
The Law Society website says their existence is to protect the public.... they will regulate legal professionals in the public interest. What a farce.
A Yukoner complains to the LS for example saying their lawyer took off with all their money they had in a trust. The Chair of the Committee, sitting in absolute isolation deciding ALL BY HIMSELF as to whether the complaint should go for further investigation or simply be dismissed says, no way. No lawyer in my brotherhood will EVER be subjected to disciplinary action... McPhee made sure of that as soon as she took office, thanks very much. I shall dismiss EVERY lawyer complaint that comes before me and there's nothing any Yukoner can do because it's now been sanctioned in the Legal Profession Act. No right to appeal my decision. Yukon lawyers can do anything they want and will NEVER see any disciplinary action whatsoever.
How TF does this relate, in any way whatsoever, to being in the public interest? How do lawyers in the Yukon get disciplined if there is no right to appeal the Chair's dismissal of your complaint. Answer that McPhee!
You lost all my respect when you made that ultra slimy move. The rest of the black cloud hanging over your head just confirms my thoughts about you. NO integrity.
The board of directors for the Law Society should be ashamed of themselves for not ensuring the organization acts to protect the public interest. You should be working to update the legislation to reinstate the public's right to appeal a decision to dismiss a complaint.
Talk about putting the administration of justice into disrepute when the DM of Justice protects her lawyer buddies instead of the public and the Law Society just goes along with it despite their mandate to protect the public interest. Shameful. Absolutely shameful. Please step down.

Up 26 Down 8

Groucho d'North on Jan 28, 2022 at 10:42 am

It looks like Liberals across the country are about to embark on a discussion about accountability. Mr. Silver for his decisions here and the Prime Misery who is hiding from his responsibilities as the leader of the government.
"The fallacy is to believe that under a dictatorial government you can be free inside." Orwell 1984

Up 41 Down 8

More of the same-arrogance on Jan 27, 2022 at 10:36 pm

This is just more of the same - We have a Premiere that takes no responsibility, he does not hold his Ministers accountable and basically flips the public who voted him in the bird! It is almost laughable that Minister McPhee is now in charge of Health and Social Services. The former Minister of that portfolio Minister Frost was not held accountable for the group home scandal. At least in that case the ADM was allowed to resign after she fired the whistle blowers. Like I said just more of the same.

Up 17 Down 35

Truthful on Jan 27, 2022 at 8:43 pm

@Neilalex Be truthful now my friend. The texting scandal was a lot more serious than you make it out to be. There was even a protest against the Yukon Party by women's groups as a result during the first day that the legislature went into session.

I can't believe that creepy Currie said he would punish Istchenko and Hassard by removing them from his shadow cabinet but then only did so for a total of 6 or maybe 7 days. Then on the DAY OF THE FEDERAL ELECTION he decides to quietly reinstate them hoping that the media would be too busy with the election to notice what he did. Very sneaky. It's also pretty horrible that none of the Yukon Party women who call themselves feminists spoke out against what happened. Yvonne Clark was the head of the Yukon Status of Women Council and said NOTHING.

Oh and this 'Bloodsport' started when the Yukon Party ran to the media because of an accidental email that John Streicker of all people, once sent out to the wrong person. So as you say, the Yukon Party reaps what it sows.

Up 4 Down 10

bonanzajoe on Jan 27, 2022 at 4:36 pm

DL: Bravo, well said!

Up 14 Down 13

bonanzajoe on Jan 27, 2022 at 4:34 pm

Patti Eyre. I'm not being paid to give solutions. But I have given solutions on many of my past comments. But, like you, I am basically an opinioner. But unlike you, I don't support the opinions of left wing marxists.

Up 16 Down 10

bonanzajoe on Jan 27, 2022 at 4:29 pm

So fed up ! on Jan 26, 2022 at 6:13 pm. And lose that big paycheck? Are you nuts? She knows that the NDP will support the Libs for the next 4 years and she isn't going to kill the golden goose.

Up 37 Down 23

DL on Jan 27, 2022 at 1:48 pm

Now, how about a poll on the most pressing issue: ending the covid mandates, and changing the 'emergency act' so that corrupt and inept governements can't ever again play this game to destroy our democracy and freedoms on the basis of such nonsense.

Up 34 Down 14

NeilAlexGeddy on Jan 27, 2022 at 12:43 pm

@Insult of Equal value

Duramaxgate lasted a total of about 3 days in the news cycle. It was followed quickly by election where the YP gained seats, and topped the popular vote. The texts was made public by Sandy Silver himself as a point of great social concern.

Now contrast that against the Hidden Valley Liberals scandal. This scandal has been a constant fixture in the media, lasting for almost a year now. The scandal resulted in a majority vote of the legislature for McPhee to step down. That's a first in Yukon political history. The story broke shortly after the last election took place and the impact on the next election will be significant if you believe the polls. The same level of concern displayed by Sandy Silver during Duramaxgate wasn't shown in this example because it would have negatively impacted The Hidden Valley Liberals in the last election.

Sandy Silver is reaping what he has sowed. He is the one who decided to turn Yukon politics into a blood sport just before the last election.

Up 17 Down 26

Patti Eyre on Jan 27, 2022 at 11:57 am

@bjoe: instead of slinging mud and slagging people through personal attacks, why don't you offer some real solutions? Or are you only a one-trick personal attack pony.

Up 32 Down 38

Yukoner32 on Jan 26, 2022 at 7:57 pm

It makes sense that the Yukon Party wanted to do this poll before a bunch of the reviews are done on what happened at Hidden Valley. They know that people are mostly focused on the Liberals right now but when the reports come out and people find out that the pedophile was abusing kids back in 2015 under their watch , a lot of anger will be directed at them as well. McPhee did a poor job with communications but at least the pedophile was removed right away when the Liberals found out about him unlike the Yukon Party which allowed him to stay working at the school back in 2015 or 2016 after the first 'incidents'. Though I'm sure many Conservative parents out in Hidden Valley will refuse to believe that their beloved 'Yukon Party' Old Boys club could do anything wrong.

They also want to show some favourable polling numbers before the Yukon Freedom Party eats their breakfast just like the PPC is doing to the federal conservatives. Speaking of which, the latest federal polling numbers show that all parties are down except for the People's Party which is UP by 13%.

Up 44 Down 14

Juniper Jackson on Jan 26, 2022 at 6:44 pm

Her constituents voted her back in..They must see something useful about her. I haven't seen her make a good call about anything. But, the Liberal way is, 'you can't tell me what to do'. The cards are falling on this one though.

Up 32 Down 45

Insult of Equal value on Jan 26, 2022 at 6:38 pm

If McPhee should lose her job for incompetence as a Government official then some so called 'Yukon Party' Mlas should also lose their jobs for gross indecency with the texting scandal. I mean fair is fair isn't it? Poll that.

Up 55 Down 16

So fed up ! on Jan 26, 2022 at 6:13 pm

Tracy, can you not see that the MAJORITY of the population wants you to leave your job ! After what you have or should I say haven't done in your positions in the cabinet....do the right thing now.....Resign !

Up 48 Down 18

Joe on Jan 26, 2022 at 5:52 pm

I think majority of Yukoners want an election to prevent liberal pension plan. They don't deserve it and are just trying to get to the April date regardless of anything else. Kate, call an election.

Up 28 Down 42

Nathan Living on Jan 26, 2022 at 5:52 pm

Many people and First Nations wanted two members of the Yukon Party to resign and Currie ignored them.

I think Minister McPhee should stay where she is and Kate ans Currie should bring constructive issues to the house.

Up 29 Down 32

Disgusted on Jan 26, 2022 at 5:38 pm

Was the so called poll valid in any way? I am not a professional pollster but when I responded to this so called poll it was just leading questions. The intent seemed to be more propaganda from Currie in a hurry. Surprisingly he has still not figured out that right now the Yukon is governed by a minority government and they are doing a good job.
I wish that they would stop this nonsense. We are still waiting on the facts from the many inquiries going on.
In the mean time maybe the Yukon Party can give us all a break.

Up 30 Down 23

numbercruncher on Jan 26, 2022 at 4:42 pm

64% of Yukoners is not 64% of poll respondents. That’s a greasy quote YP

Up 21 Down 14

bonanzajoe on Jan 26, 2022 at 4:06 pm

Patti Eyre: Do you even know what you are saying? What money? And what can the YP do as opposition party? Think before you comment.

Up 28 Down 23

bonanzajoe on Jan 26, 2022 at 4:04 pm

And don't expect the marxist Libs to care anything what the people say or want. And don't expect Justin Trudeau to give a rats @$$ about what the truckers will say when they reach Ottawa either. I would expect him to suddenly and conveniently leave Ottawa on a phony excuse so as not to have to face them.

Up 25 Down 15

bonanzajoe on Jan 26, 2022 at 4:00 pm

Kate White: “It’s a Yukon Party poll, so I take that for what it is worth.” So, does that make it illegitimate?

Up 32 Down 11

bonanzajoe on Jan 26, 2022 at 3:58 pm

Silver: “Our focus as a government remains on protecting the health and safety of Yukoners through the COVID-19 pandemic and the substance use health emergency.” Obviously Silver can't pat his stomach and rub his head at the same time. So, Covid and the drug problem are all he and his Libs can handle. So, opposition parties, don't screw up his head with dealing with anything else.

Up 72 Down 3

Groucho d'North on Jan 26, 2022 at 2:48 pm

They should conduct another poll after the Hidden Valley School report is made public. I wonder how much the numbers will change?

Up 112 Down 16

Concerned (ok, mad as hell) Parent on Jan 26, 2022 at 2:46 pm

Holy crap lady, seriously?

“This comes after the revelations that the deputy premier became aware in 2019 of the sexual abuse that occurred at Hidden Valley and failed to notify parents.”

Be glad my kids did not attend that school and be glad that people whose kids did, have shown restraint. The fact you were made aware and did nothing to alert the parents is criminal/immoral/plain and you should lose your position/job at the very least.

Up 64 Down 69

BnR on Jan 26, 2022 at 2:19 pm

"We polled our members at a BBQ and they want her to resign".
Yknow what I'd like? I'd like the sitting YP MLA who signed off on the Wolverine mine to be held responsible....

Up 65 Down 19

Bill on Jan 26, 2022 at 2:18 pm

Hm, so that is who was behind the poll. We were called. When I asked who the poll was being conducted for. The polling company said that information was not available to those conducting the poll. I know of Léger and that is exactly what they tell you each and every time. The other polling companies are the same. The only time I have seen where it is not if it is for a specific policy initiative and then then may say "on behalf of the Government of such and such". You know it is random because there is about a 5 second pause after you pick up and are then transferred to a person conducting the poll. Anyway that has always been my experience.

Nothing nefarious about the way the poll was conducted. Of course the Liberals would never put credence to anything the YP did, even when it is above board. I expect every Liberal and his brother, aunt, uncle, etc. will chime with the opposing view.

I think the response to the poll speaks for itself.

Up 52 Down 105

Patti Eyre on Jan 26, 2022 at 2:02 pm

Oh my word Yukon Partiers how about you start spending some of that money toward helping the situation rather than this odd, backhanded circus that does nothing to improve the situation! Let us all pray for a better path forward!

Up 162 Down 21

ThisIsInsanity on Jan 26, 2022 at 2:00 pm

After her incompetence as Education Minister Sandy Silver making her minister of Health and Social Services during a pandemic and record drug overdoses is insulting to all Yukoners.

Up 44 Down 4

unReal on Jan 26, 2022 at 1:26 pm

oh, say it ain't so!

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.