Whitehorse Daily Star

Lawyers approve new same-sex preference policy

The Catholic Episcopal Corp. has released a new draft policy on same-sex attraction and is asking for public feedback.

By Ainslie Cruickshank on September 5, 2013

The Catholic Episcopal Corp. has released a new draft policy on same-sex attraction and is asking for public feedback.

Yukon government lawyers have confirmed that it complies with existing legislation, including the Yukon Human Rights Act, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Department of Education's relevant policies.

The draft policy has removed references from the previous guidelines which called homosexual acts morally wrong and intrinsically evil, and seeks to promote a "safe and caring school environment.”

"From the perspective of the Roman Catholic faith, every human person is created in the image of God,” the document says.

"Every human being is a child of God. Thus, respect is due everyone regardless of race, gender, age, stage of development, disability, sexual orientation, class or religion ....

"The scourge of bullying in education and in society must be resisted in Catholic schools and in the Catholic community at large. Bullying, be it verbal, physical, or social, is not to be tolerated in any measure whatsoever.”

The document goes on to express understanding that LGBTQ students, who are referred to as "students of same-sex attraction or same-sex identity” in the policy, are at higher risk of bullying and discrimination and outlines actions schools can take to promote a safe and inclusive environment.

The draft policy also allows for a support group for "students of same-sex attraction,” which must include "One Heart” in the title.

It suggests the group could be called "One Heart: Gay/Straight Catholic Allies.”

But the policy notes that the bishop reserves the right to disassemble the group if he becomes aware that it is providing instruction and/or counselling contrary to the teachings of the church.

It also includes a complaint procedure and provides suggestions for staff who may be approached by a student who wants to discuss his or her sexual orientation.

The document does direct the reader to "A guide for Pastoral Ministry to Young People with Same Sex Attraction” for more information on the Church's teachings on homosexuality.

The letter by the Commission for Doctrine of the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops which accompanies the guide outlines the Catholic teachings that "sexual relations belong within the marriage covenant between a man and a woman, for it is only within this covenant that the two inseparable ends of marriage can be achieved: the deepening of love between spouses and the procreation and education of children.

"Any genital act outside the covenant of marriage cannot fulfill this twofold purpose intended by the Creator and thus is morally wrong,” it says.

The letter goes on to say that that "sexual relations between persons of the same sex are not in accord with God's original intention expressed in the plan of creation.

"For this reason, the Church has consistently taught that homosexual acts can never be approved.

"While homosexual acts are always objectively wrong, same-sex inclinations are not in themselves sinful or a moral failing,” it continues.

The new draft policy is publicly available online at oneheartfeedback.weebly.com.

Community members wishing to comment can either respond through the website, through a letter to one of the three Catholic school councils, or at public meetings to be held in October.

Controversy over the previous Catholic school policy on homosexuality exploded last February after a parent publicly raised concerns about it in a letter published by the Star.

Stories of bullying at Vanier Catholic Secondary School further fueleld the debate, which culminated in a public and well-attended school council meeting in late March.

At the time, the Department of Education committed to developing a new policy, hoping to have it ready for late April.

Then-education minister Scott Kent later sent an open letter to Catholic Bishop Gary Gordon mandating that the new policy would have to align with Yukon human rights laws.

Comments (13)

Up 0 Down 0

Max Mack on Sep 12, 2013 at 9:30 am

The issue of funding for Catholic schools is a red herring in this context.

Many parents that send their kids to Vanier do so because they believe that it is the "best" high school in Whitehorse. Not because they are Catholic. Not even because they are Christian.

They are really elitists that believe that their children are special and shouldn't be contaminated by the "poor education" at other schools.

I do not agree that the former policy contravened the Charter or human rights legislation. However, the fact remains that Vanier is attended by large numbers of students that are not Catholic and may not even be nominally Christian.

Removing funding for Catholic schools will change nothing in this context.

Up 0 Down 0

Geoff Capp on Sep 11, 2013 at 9:12 am

and by the way, I am not a Catholic, have never been a Catholic, have never been related to a Catholic. I call myself a Christian while some would refer to me as a "Protestant", which I would dispute since I'm not protesting against anything in the core Christian teaching and doctrine. So my defence of the Catholic schools is as someone who thinks of his taxes as being used for his own kids, and my Catholic neighbours' taxes as being used for their kids. I'm not protecting my own interests when I speak up on their behalf, because my kids go to non-Catholic schools because I don't share some of the particular teachings in their church, even though I respect their right to believe those teachings.

Up 0 Down 0

KC on Sep 11, 2013 at 7:50 am

I'm sorry I must have missed where we had a "right" to demand and receive public services through a religion of our choice. There is no right to receive Catholic health care, or Lutheran roads, or Muslim police services. Schools should be no different. Schools only have the kids for about 30 hours a week. Parents have them for the other 138. Indoctrinate your kids on your own time.

Up 0 Down 0

Geoff Capp on Sep 10, 2013 at 9:07 am

Taxpayer, have you looked at the balance sheet and income statement of the Catholic church in Whitehorse? Can you prove they're swimming in gravy? That's not the issue - that money is freewill donations by worshippers.

You are talking about tax money extracted by force of law to provide a service used by all children. If 40% of the children are Catholics and 40% of the taxpayers are Catholics, who are you to say that 0%, rather than 40%, should go to schools that serve the 40%? Unions aren't poor, are we going to decide that employers don't have to pay union employees because the union could do it instead? No. Worship and education are separate functions, and it is absurd for you to claim that Catholic schools don't need tax money.

Consider that the schools in Whitehorse would suddenly be inadequate if they had to absorb the students from suddenly-unfunded schools, because you'd be expecting Catholic parents to pay extra to support their children's tuition, PLUS pay the taxes to support your children's education, while you would only have to pay the taxes. Why do you expect individual Catholics to pay more than you?

I guess the democratic thing to do is abolish all education taxes, and people can use the extra money in their pockets to pay the tuitions for education themselves.

Basically, all I hear from you is that you want their money but you won't respect their freedom. You want them to respect your freedom and pay for it. I hear you insisting on having it all your way, simply because you think the Catholic church is independently wealthy, and not simply receiving the donations of its adherents.

And Jesus did not have a middle initial or a family name. He was simply named "Jesus", and "Christ" is one of the many titles, not a part of His name.

Up 0 Down 0

Jesus H. Christ on Sep 10, 2013 at 7:20 am

What would Jesus do?

Up 0 Down 0

Tax Payer on Sep 10, 2013 at 5:33 am

Let's try your line of thought and see where it leads us shall we? Your taxes should only go to Catholics on Welfare? Or cover healthcare costs for Catholics? You should only pay a portion of city taxes for the sewer systems tied to the homes of Catholics? This country does not work that way. No religion should be getting this kind of preferential treatment. I notice that you have avoided my question as to whether the Catholic church needs this extra cash...

Up 0 Down 0

Jesus N Palz on Sep 10, 2013 at 4:18 am

You are not a true Catholic if you change your stance due to a couple of vocal parents. Public money or not. That's just being used as a red herring.

Up 0 Down 0

Geoff Capp on Sep 9, 2013 at 8:40 am

Well, Tax Payer, why? If you're entitled to have schools represent you, why aren't the Catholics? If you want their money, shouldn't you respect their views as much as you expect them to respect yours? Can't you be tolerant of their wishes, as you wish them to be of yours? If you want their money, then you should accept their right. Flip it 180: what if Catholics were 85% and decided all money goes to them, and none to yours. Wouldn't that bother you? If Catholics are a large enough group that you need their money, then they're large enough to have their say. If they're too small to have their say, then surely you can manage without their small tax contribution?

Up 0 Down 0

Tax Payer on Sep 9, 2013 at 12:51 am

Nope, I am not ok with that Geoff. All tax moneys should go to Public schools, even the Catholics taxpayers money. Once again I say that the Catholic Church has plenty of cash and does not need the public to support them.

Up 0 Down 0

Geoff Capp on Sep 6, 2013 at 12:43 pm

Tax Payer, if you don't want your tax money going to the Catholic school, are you okay with not one cent of Catholic taxpayers' money going to your public schools? Maybe Catholics' taxes can go to Catholic schools, and everyone else's money including yours can go to public schools. That would be fair, wouldn't it?

Up 0 Down 0

Hmmm on Sep 6, 2013 at 5:56 am

So you need laywers to change wording wow get rid of the lawyers why do you think our society is so screwed up!!! As for not giving private and religious schools tax payer dollars, I have been screaming that for decades...ooops dating myself hahah. Public tax money should not go to private or religious schools period!!! If you want to go to them then pay the full pop!!!

Up 0 Down 0

Tax Payer on Sep 6, 2013 at 2:06 am

I am totally fine with this new policy as long as not one cent of my tax money goes to fund this religion. Remove them from being publicly funded and send that money to actual public schools. Is someone going to argue with me that Catholic Church needs our tax money?

Up 0 Down 0

bobby bitman on Sep 5, 2013 at 1:05 pm

Awesome. I am actually amazed by this. It is not easy to just admit you were wrong and change, yet these people make it look easy! Why not? A lot of organizations and people could take a page from the Catholic Episcopal Corp. Thanks for having the courage to do this right.

This sure has deflated my negativity toward the Catholic church.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.