Kennedy counters minister Dixon's criticisms
Robert Kennedy Jr. returned yesterday from his rafting trip down the Alsek River to find he'd ignited a bit of a political firestorm.
By Ainslie Cruickshank on August 6, 2013
Robert Kennedy Jr. returned yesterday from his rafting trip down the Alsek River to find he'd ignited a bit of a political firestorm.
On Thursday, Kennedy offered his perspectives on the Peel planning process as he understood it, suggesting the government took a model planning process and turned it into an undemocratic undertaking. He also urged the select committee on hydraulic fracturing to conduct scientific studies before submitting its direction on the practice to the government.
In response Yukon's environment minister publicly dismissed Kennedy's concerns and attacked his credibility.
Yesterday, prior to a giving a lecture at the Yukon Arts Centre, Kennedy responded to Minister Currie Dixon's comments.
"First of all I want to thank him for welcoming me to the Yukon,” Kennedy said.
"Some of the issues he talked about were personal issues that he was erroneous about. For example, I see he spent a lot of time saying I was anti-vaccine, which is just the opposite. I'm very, very pro-vaccine and have always supported the vaccine program in the United States.
"It's a strange thing to say, it's a personal attack which I understand generally people make those kind of attacks when they don't want to argue the case on the merits,” he said.
"What I would like to hear from the minister is why he believes that this process was democratic, because maybe I'm wrong and that's what I said at the press run when I first got here.”
Kennedy came to the Yukon to raft the Alsek River, which would take him past Mt. Kennedy.
His father climbed the mountain in 1965 in tribute to his brother, President John F. Kennedy who had been assassinated two yearsprior.
Robert Kennedy was later assassinated himself.
"It was a magical experience for me and the children to see Mt. Kennedy,” Kennedy said.
He told media yesterday that a number of his brothers and a few of the kids in the family have talked about trying to climb Mt. Kennedy, maybe even next summer.
"It was fun for me to kind of beat them to Mt. Kennedy,” Kennedy joked. "I kind of wish I'd gotten a helicopter pilot to drop me on the top for just a second and then have my picture taken, climb the last 20 ft or something.”
Following his talk, Kennedy was presented with a number of gifts from elder Alex Van Bibber, who also greeted Kennedy's father back in '65.
It wasn't only the view of Mt. Kennedy the environmental lawyer and activist enjoyed over the course of his rafting adventure.
"The trip itself was amazing,” he said.
"I've been on rivers all over the world, almost on every continent and this is one of the best rivers I've seen from many, many perspectives. The scenery was extraordinary, the hikes during the day time, the views of those glaciers, one after the other and the geological history you can see written in the rock as you go through these canyons and just the size of the landscapes,” he said.
Kennedy spoke yesterday to an attentive crowd at the Yukon Arts Centre. His speech, titled Our Environmental Destiny, discussed the intricate connections between environmental protection and preservation and true democracy, arguing that wherever there is environmental destruction there is also subversion of the democratic process.
Kennedy shared his experiences working to hold polluters to account as well as working with green energy tech giants. He discussed some of the major barriers to widespread green energy production including an irrational market place that doesn't account for the external costs of non-renewable energy and green energy
infrastructure deficits.
"We're going to win in the long run,” Kennedy said.
What we need is true democracy and a true free market, he told the crowd, arguing that true free market capitalism is not the same as the widespread crony capitalism we often see.
A true free market, he said, properly values resources and accounts for all the costs of pollution.
Comments (11)
Up 0 Down 0
Grassy Knoll on Aug 11, 2013 at 6:06 am
I'm with just sayin'...the eco zealots are eating the crumbs outta "American Royalty" fortunate son hands.
Kinda feel like our conservative government is more like a socialist government.
....for SHAME!
Up 0 Down 0
Voice in the crowd on Aug 10, 2013 at 8:55 pm
Mr. Kennedy makes a valid point in stating that Minister Dixon was out of line commenting on his stance on Vaccine use. It is irrelevant to the issue at hand.
That being said, Mr. Kennedy contradicts himself as he is very much on record as being against vaccinations.
Now that leads me to wonder, where else has he contradicted himself?
One area I can see that he contradicts himself, and his Green Cause does it regularly is in true accounting/accountability. His quote "A true free market, he said, properly values resources and accounts for all the costs of pollution" suggests the environmental impact of "Green Energy" is accounted for. in response to this I ask you to look into simple facts of some green technologies. For example hydrogen fuel cells. deemed green energy sources for vehicles, claims of mass reduction of greenhouse gases and other pollution. Fact is, those gases are still created while creating the hydrogen, and associated fuel cells, the difference is they are localized, thus having a larger impact on a smaller area. Doesn't seem like this is accounted for, or very accountable to me.
Keep in mind, these individuals, these advocates are salesmen, they do not sell these ideas for free. To blindly follow the band wagon here on environmentally green alternatives is to follow a new set of "crony's" effecting Capitalism, and influencing democracy.
Results of studies are easily skewed, anyone that has studied basic stats knows that. Dig for the true information, make informed decisions.
Both sides have agenda's, both sides are paid well for the influences they bring to the political spectrum and the issue. Do not follow blindly.
Some of the comments on this story have insinuations of wrong doings on behalf of campaign contributors. Well, find the facts and bring it before ethics commissioner, or perhaps bring enough information to the RCMP and have a formal investigation launched. Anything less is unfounded allegations, and nothing more than political pandering.
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Aug 8, 2013 at 8:44 am
Some would call that greenwashed hypocrisy.
Up 0 Down 0
Max Mack on Aug 7, 2013 at 4:44 pm
Kennedy flies around the world in his private jet, all the while making a handsome living ny extolling "green" energy and enjoying white-water rafting and eco-tourism adventures on the public purse.
Meanwhile, he and his family oppose the Cape Wind project because it would interfere with their ocean views.
I say put your money where your mouth is.
Up 0 Down 0
Gary G. Anweiler on Aug 7, 2013 at 6:19 am
Please come back again soon Mr. Kennedy. We need all the light we can get.
Thank you
Up 0 Down 0
Stan Witherspoon on Aug 7, 2013 at 3:45 am
Unlike Mr. Kennedy I have not travelled the world and seen all those rivers.
But I have staked claims and climbed mountains and flown in float planes and helicopters all over the Yukon. I have also canoed a few of our rivers and seen the bush from a "salt of the earth” viewpoint.
Mining has changed up here. It's now big business and very international (Chinese and U.S. interests) and there is a lot going on with other countries investing and taking over both small and large Canadian mining companies. The same goes for oil and gas. We have to be very careful with what we give away.
The small town talk of Mr. Currie is out of step with a Minister who represents the environment and our government. We need to protect some of our natural areas forever and be very careful how we deal with non-renewable resources. We need to stop the Yukon Party taking in campaign contributions from the mining industry and then not so cleverly derailing land use planning process. We deserve much better and Mr. Kennedy has pointed that out very succinctly.
Up 0 Down 0
Sam Fister on Aug 7, 2013 at 2:48 am
Thank you Mr. Kennedy for being so gracious despite the inappropriate comments from our government minister.
"We're going to win in the long run,” Kennedy said.
I hope we win the conservation battle to protect the Peel in the near future.
Up 0 Down 0
Just Say'in on Aug 6, 2013 at 10:43 am
Please! I am so tired of seeing these self absorbed rich kids come in with their private jets telling me I am the problem. Gore, Kennedy, Trudeau, and dozens of others of the filthy rich living off of Trust Funds and paying no taxes, but very well schooled in how I should spend mine. Why don't you go back to Detroit, Cleveland, or LA and clean that mess up, and get out of my life.
Up 0 Down 0
Stella on Aug 6, 2013 at 10:37 am
Unfortunately for RFK Jr. a simple Google search can prove that he did in fact make those claims. Not that I expect an environmental activist to speak the truth.
Up 0 Down 0
Sam Winter on Aug 6, 2013 at 8:05 am
Thank you Mr. Kennedy for being so gracious despite the inappropriate comments from our government minister.
"We're going to win in the long run,” Kennedy said.
I hope we win with respect to protecting the Peel watershed in the near future.
Up 0 Down 0
meridian on Aug 6, 2013 at 7:59 am
Your move Currie.