‘It will be felt throughout the territory’
Two major cruise companies have cancelled all Alaska sailings for the remainder of the year, including those with inland trips into the Yukon, triggering a major blow to the territory’s tourism industry.
By Gabrielle Plonka on April 17, 2020
Two major cruise companies have cancelled all Alaska sailings for the remainder of the year, including those with inland trips into the Yukon, triggering a major blow to the territory’s tourism industry.
“Tourism is going to really get hit, and that’s true but it’s also the entire economy that’s really going to get hit,” Neil Hartling, the
chair of the Tourism Industry Association of Yukon (TIA), told the Star.
Holland America and Princess Cruises both announced this week that all operations will be paused until at least June 30 – with planned Alaska trips cancelled (see related coverage, p. 10).
According to Hartling, Holland America alone brings about 15,000 visitors to the Yukon every cruise season. This translates to a likely $60 million in revenue lost.
The trickle-down effect of these cancellations will be massive, Hartling said.
For example, it will serve a blow to Air North, which flies cruise ship guests from Alaska to Dawson City, and have a major impact on local shops and restaurants in Dawson, Whitehorse and Carcross.
He noted that even local farmers will feel the downturn, because they provide food to restaurants stocking up for the tourist season.
“It’ll be felt throughout the territory,” Hartling said.
Prior to this announcement, Skagway, Alaska was expected to host one million visitors from 473 cruise ship arrivals. A portion of that traffic would have travelled to Carcross via the White Pass and Yukon Route train.
In the height of the tourism season, Carcross sees approximately 1,000 visitors to the community per day – a number that will now hover closer to zero.
It’s currently up in the air whether businesses will be able to open their doors at all, particularly in the Carcross Commons.
Danny Cresswell, chair of the Carcross-Tagish management Corp., said local businesses still have the option to rent retail space in the Commons, but thinks most will abstain.
“It’s going to be a pretty slow summer,” Cresswell predicted.
“Most of those businesses in downtown Carcross won’t even open.”
With the situation changing so rapidly, it’s been challenging for the corporation and the community’s businesses to plan for the season.
The closed Alaska-Yukon border will exert an additional blow to the throngs of tourists usually expected from Alaska.
“We don’t know what rubber tire traffic is going to be like,” Creswell said.
“Your guess is as good as mine – it’s kind of hard to prepare for, it’s here, but we don’t know how severe it’s going to get, or for how long.”
Northern Vision Development (NVD), which operates three Whitehorse and two Dawson City hotels, are currently looking to
adjust plans for the summer season.
Michael Hale, NVD’s chief operating officer, told the Star the cruise cancellations were not unexpected.
“The announcement was not a huge surprise at this point, we had worked this into our planning anyway, but there’s no denying it’s just more bad news on top of bad news,” Hale said.
“It was going to be a challenging summer anyway, and this is going to make it more challenging.”
The largest impacts will be felt in Dawson City, Hale said.
NVD had recently purchased the Midnight Sun Hotel there, with plans for a grand opening this summer. That opening is now delayed indefinitely, while the Downtown Hotel continues to operate for the time being.
“We’re evaluating what we’re going to do,” Hale said.
“We intend to have one hell of a coming-out party when we can (for Midnight Sun) but if there’s no tourists in Dawson, we’re just going to have to be rethinking what operates and how things operate.”
In Whitehorse, NVD has closed the Edgewater Hotel and provided the Coast High Country Inn to the Yukon government as a health and isolation centre.
The Gold Rush Inn is now the only NVD hotel in Whitehorse currently open to the public.
“It went from expectations of a very good summer to absolutely collapsing,” Hale said.
“The hope was that with two hotels closed, the third hotel could survive and continue to operate, and so far it has.”
Hale said the mining industry has been a lifeline for the Gold Rush Inn, with mining operations hosting their workers at the hotel upon arrival in the territory as a safe place to self-isolate for the required 14 days.
The Gold Rush Inn has reserved a stand-alone floor for miners in isolation, with meals delivered directly to hotel room doors.
“It’s hard to express how important the mining industry has been to keeping tourism,” Hale said.
“It’s mining companies being incredibly responsible and careful.”
The Yukon government’s takeover of the Coast High Country Inn has also helped the corporation recoup operating costs. There is a similar situation there, where meals are provided to those in self-isolation at the hotel.
Hale said the federal government’s wage subsidy will save several NVD jobs, and the territorial fixed cost grant will be “a huge life
jacket” for both small and big businesses.
While government funding has provided relief to many Yukon businesses, Hartling said there are a few tourism businesses that
aren’t eligible to receive help.
This is because some seasonal operators aren’t able to prove a 30 per cent reduction in revenue before the tourism season, and cash flow, begins.
There are also several businesses who don’t meet payroll requirements, because they subcontract their services.
TIA is now working to communicate these challenges to the Yukon government, so some leniency can be made.
“We are trying to finetune the funding as much as possible, so as many companies can access it as possible,” Hartling said.
TIA is also trying to come up with a strategy, with the Yukon government to ensure that businesses weather the storm and come
out the other side.
“We need to ensure that these companies survive until next season,” Hartling said.
“Most of them, without that help, will disappear.”
The cruise ship passengers’ disappearance will have serious implications on such Dawson City attractions as the Diamond Tooth
Gerties casino.
No one from its operator – the Klondike Visitors Association – was available Thursday nor today to comment on how it will manage the coming clientele collapse.
Comments (23)
Up 1 Down 0
One One-Lesser-Voice on Apr 24, 2020 at 9:23 pm
The feds are throwing money around to keep most people and businesses going.
They will reduce transfer payments because there is greater need for the funding in some provinces. Think of Alberta.
The Bank of Canada will basically eliminate the interest rate but it will not help as much as you would think.
We will be paying more in both federal and provincial taxes, no way around it.
More money is needed for the national debt and social programs. We do have to offer covid protection but need to get the economy going.
Every week we spend shut down may translate into months and years of a depression-recession period followed by the new normal.
We have to move forward quickly economically or watch people and businesses falter and see people struggle and get caught in a welfare situation.
11 CASES NO HOSPITALIZATIONS OR DEATHS, time to open things up in stages.
Up 7 Down 5
Groucho d'North on Apr 23, 2020 at 1:41 pm
I am fascinated by the responses I stimulated by my comments of the Tourism sector going it alone after resource extraction was made a lame duck in our territorial economy. Either here or in other places in the nation or globe, mining is producing the metal materials required to support technology in its many forms that in turn support our societies and quality of life.
Metals will still be required and I think it is quite hypocritical for all the save the world folks to use and benefit from these products while trying to eliminate their benefits to the local economy in the form of jobs. Consider how many metals are in the computers, smart phones and infrastructure that allow you to bitch and complain about mining on a forum such as this. Yes mine operators could do much better in reducing the negative impacts to the environment, so why not focus your angst and energy on that rather than shutting it down completely?
Up 2 Down 2
Mon Dieu! on Apr 22, 2020 at 10:27 pm
Monsieur Parasite - Do not let the misanthropic become your biopic. You clearly demonstrate caring and concern and in time your humanity you will discern. Things are never as dire as our minds conspire. Even at our worse being human is not a curse and if you believe without feeling terse good feelings you can grow and nurse. So spread the good will and this verse - Darwin’s creed is a shill but it is not his bitter pill, rather, it is the result of some ill will.
A lot of people, some very well educated people, misunderstand and misapply Darwinian thought... Almost as if they suffered a clot or their brains were made of snot. Anyways, the Darwin Award is an irreverent play on an idea of survival of the fittest. But this is a gross oversimplification of his idea and this is the folly of the wo/man-hu - The tendency to essentialism. One might be forgiven for assuming reductionism but I think the tendency towards essentialism is borne out on the preponderance of the evidence.
But beware, for there ain’t no hope for the misanthrope and if they do by chance fail to cope their genes will be edited out of the human scope over generations and generations to come people might ask... any trace of that Apex Parasite... Nope, nope, nope... He lost all hope... Ironically the year 2020 should have been the year for greater clarity in vision.
Up 6 Down 6
Apex Parasite on Apr 22, 2020 at 2:59 pm
@Citizen
Glad you're swell with the status quo.
As a species, we are all recipients of darwin participation awards, no idiot left behind.
Up 11 Down 6
Citizens of the Idiocracy on Apr 21, 2020 at 7:24 pm
Ted Kaczynski and Apex Parasite provide excellent examples of fallacious reasoning and their submissions should be relegated to the wall of shame as perpetual reminders of the type of thinking we should avoid lest we all become Darwin Award recipients.
Up 7 Down 5
North_of_60 on Apr 21, 2020 at 6:34 pm
@Ted Kaczynski it's ironically foolish to use many of the benefits of the Industrial Revolution to claim it's been a disaster for the human race.
Up 10 Down 16
Ted Kaczynski on Apr 21, 2020 at 1:07 pm
@Apex parasite
The Industrial Revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race.
Up 4 Down 4
Emperor Marcus Aurelius on Apr 21, 2020 at 12:54 pm
@Armchairgeneral
"The impediment to action advances action. What stands in the way becomes the way."
Up 8 Down 13
Parasitic Delights on Apr 21, 2020 at 12:26 pm
The irony of the Apex Parasite. An economic system predicated on need - A most epic myopia from the socialist’s Utopia a veritable psychological cornucopia...
All hail the Apex Parasite sitting at the pinnacle with a wisdom cynical - Who will determine that need? What is right asked the parasite - Is it me, is it he or is it she?
And we thought that hyper-capitalism premised on an economy of ever increasing growth was bad... WTF!?!? There is no way to achieve your ideal unless we all give up everything we don’t need today? Tomorrow?
Define the distinction between need and want. Your words are troubling and the nature of them - stupidly irresponsible.
Up 20 Down 13
Apex Parasite on Apr 21, 2020 at 9:00 am
@groucho
What is already being felt literally around the globe is that the current economic systems are impossibly fragile and the myopic focus on profit above all else means that when that profit is unattainable the system shuts down in a cascading catastrophic manner.
Farmers are throwing away food because the system cannot get it to those who need it while maintaining a decent profit margin. Oil has gone into negative dollar territory. All the resources are there but the bottom line is always the top concern. We have what we need as a species but what we need is held hostage by a system that went seriously sideways with the dawn if the industrial revolution. Need always takes a back seat to greed. If there is no big money going into fat pockets then the fact that average joe just needs a job to feed his family means nothing and it all grinds to a halt. The fat pockets are still fat while the economy falls flat.
The covid phenom is revealing the weaknesses in our systems on a global scale. We focus on our narrow little lives, taking everything for granted with hardly a thought for long term big pictures and then something we should have been prepared for shuts the whole show down. Covid is showing us that there are systemic flaws that need to be addressed. Chiefly to me, that need should trump profit in all things.
The flavor of tourism up here is largely pandering to the most repugnant variety of traveler in my estimation of the current iteration. Upper middle class masses packed into various modes of transport like so many entitled chickens. The chicken trucks roll into town after town with stops along the way so they can get off, scratch around in the local dirt, then get back on the bus and onto the next superficial takeaway.
We are all getting a lesson on what is important these days. Question is will we be able to effect any changes to various systems that have shown themselves vulnerable because of a profit centric motive. Tourism is no exception and the resource sector is as vulnerable as any other endeavor that depends on a bottom line before basic needs.
Up 32 Down 20
Groucho d'North on Apr 20, 2020 at 12:16 pm
What is already being felt throughout the territory is the hole in our economy created when all things green demonized the resource extraction sector in favour of a tourism-based economy.
Reap what ye sow.
Up 25 Down 18
Citizens of the Idiocracy on Apr 19, 2020 at 8:17 pm
Hello jc - It is interesting that the Liberal and Dipper parties/governments impede the economic growth and development necessary to sustain the growing tax burden they thrust onto the middle class... It’s like watching a dog chase it’s own tail... However, the dog keeps growing and the damage to the house as it spins and spins increases accordingly... And then you have a bunch of people watching the dog... Isn’t that cute? Are you recording this... Are you getting this?
Up 6 Down 14
Armchairgeneral on Apr 19, 2020 at 1:29 pm
'We shall prevail.' Robert E Lee Gettysburg.
Up 40 Down 19
jc on Apr 19, 2020 at 12:03 pm
I don't hear much from the tree huggers, climate change gurus and Greta groupies these days. I guess clouds do have silver linings after all.
Up 49 Down 26
jc on Apr 19, 2020 at 11:57 am
And truth be told, the Federal Liberal Gov. and Yukon Liberal Gov. never planned for this kind of scenario. Like they always do, they spend, spend, spend tax money on their own favourite social programs which don't contribute a thing to society. Now, that this pandemic is upon us, they have no real money to spend, so they just borrow, borrow, borrow for bandaids and leave the payback to the future generations. That's the Socialist way. I really don't know who is worse the NDP or Liberals. One day, the conservatives are going to have to come back and try to straighten it all out. But like always, they won't last long because people like to get, but not have to pay back. And the Libs will get back in and start the mad process over again. I'm in my late 70s now and I have seen the same scenario throughout my life. I served my country in the military and paid taxes for over 60 years. But, thankfully, I won't have to pay the high national debt and deficit back. Good luck youngsters. You want freebees today? There's a great price to pay back later. And that only means higher taxes in your future. The Libs and NDP socialists love that. So, take a good look at your future before you vote next time.
Up 50 Down 10
Jason on Apr 19, 2020 at 7:55 am
@BnR. Very naive comment. Where do you think the base and precious metals come from to manufacture ventilators, health care worker’s PPE, fuel for transportation for food, etc? Mining is labelled an essential service for a reason, unfortunately for some they must believe that essential products are manufactured from “magic fairy dust”. The miners for the most part are taking very proactive measures.
Up 44 Down 3
iBrian on Apr 19, 2020 at 6:25 am
I think CarX will be hit harder then Dawson as CarX doesn’t have any mining industry operation from their community.
This is a big lesson for everyone, way too many people live cheque to cheque and taking on extra debt when your already strapped is just going to enslave you. Of course many businesses will fold. Many did after 9/11. Look at all the empty Hotels and roadhouses along the AK Hyway. This will be a similar reduction in overall Rubber tire traffic. It’s going to take 6-10 years to recover from what’s already happened.
It’s a wake up call for our Education system too. We need to bring Husbandry, Homesteading and real Financial management back into the system. You can’t trust the banks. They go on your Gross income not Net, and way too many people listen to the Pusher Bankman. Thinking that they are looking out for your best interest.
They even convinced people that Log Houses are not safe or efficient or cost effective.
I just hope those who are stressed and angry get mental help and not take it out on those around you.
We’re not even close to recovery, once there's a vaccine and then 1-2 years after we may go back. But things won’t be the same again folks. We all have a long road ahead of us.
Up 36 Down 26
Millennial Angst on Apr 18, 2020 at 7:31 pm
“It’ll be felt throughout the Territory...” much like the last Liberal election! Things will continue to spiral into chaos. Liberalism wrote large. A persistent and endless regression.
Up 19 Down 16
Miles Epanhauser on Apr 18, 2020 at 5:02 pm
Job creation programs and start letting people get back to work while protecting the vulnerable.
Up 11 Down 27
Morey Smith on Apr 18, 2020 at 9:13 am
This may help clarify why Dawson City Yukon T. withdrew their application for a UNESCO site designation.
Up 60 Down 18
Jack on Apr 18, 2020 at 12:42 am
As usual, it won't be felt in the public sector.
Up 39 Down 38
Max Mack on Apr 17, 2020 at 11:31 pm
“We need to ensure that these companies survive until next season,”
How? End the general lockdown. Target the vulnerable and let everyone else get back to work. Practice reasonable social distancing and good hygiene.
We simply don't have enough cash to keep everyone flush until next year. Meanwhile, people are dying because of the lockdown.
Up 40 Down 37
BnR on Apr 17, 2020 at 7:43 pm
Miners are showing up in Dawson from all over Canada and the US. Some foreigners too.
If the miners can keep going gang busters, why does tourism get shut down?
Ranj??