Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Dr. Robert Zimmerman

Interim assisted death guidelines in place

The territory has established its interim guidelines for people seeking physician-assisted death.

By Aimee O'Connor on March 4, 2016

The territory has established its interim guidelines for people seeking physician-assisted death.

In its landmark ruling more an a year ago, the Supreme Court of Canada unanimously ruled that the national ban on physician-assisted death would be lifted.

The top court gave the federal government one year to draft legislation, but last October’s election delayed the process.

Last month, the government was given a four-month extension, making the final deadline for draft legislation June 6.

But during this period of limbo, those seeking physician-assisted death can apply to the superior court in their home provinces for an exception if they meet certain criteria.

The Yukon Medical Council published its set of guidelines last month, though nothing has been legislated yet.

“The debate is over,” Dr. Robert Zimmerman, the chair of the Yukon Medical Council, told the Star in a recent interview.

“This is a right individuals have – given that, legislators have to design a system that makes it available to people. That’s the bottom line.”

It will start with a patient’s request.

From there, it is suggested that a period of reflection take place.

This could vary based on the urgency of the patient’s circumstances, but 14 days are recommended for patients with slowly progressing conditions.

“Most of the guidelines are reflective of this compromise, that there’s some time for sober thought while also not dragging it out,” Zimmerman said.

If, after reflection, the patient wishes to proceed, several things will have to be established.

Firstly, the physician is obligated to review all aspects of assisted death with patients, reminding them that they can take back their request at any time as well as offer other treatment options, including hospice care and pain control.

Two doctors must also determine whether the patient has the full capacity to make informed decisions and whether the patient’s condition is considered “grievous and irremediable” – in other words, impossible to cure or put right.

By requiring the patient to be of “sound mind”, it subsequently eliminates the possibility of family members making the decision for a patient who is incapacitated.

If this passes, the person would be eligible for physician-assisted death.

Within the guidelines, physicians may decline to provide assisted death if doing so would violate their freedom of conscience.

It is unclear exactly what would happen in the event that a patient disagrees with his or her physician’s ruling – the guideline simply states “other resources may assist in resolving differences”, citing a conflict resolution process as an example.

Another grey area is mental health.

The Yukon guidelines identify that chronic depression or other mental illness could be “grievous and irremediable.”

But a report released this week by a committee of MPs and senators stated that “widely diverging views” were heard on the topic of addressing mental health in the context of assisted death.

The committee also called for allowing mature minors to access assisted death.


But until legislation comes into force, all of these considerations are just that – suggestions.

“Right now we’re in this middle ground,” Zimmerman said.

“No physician can act yet, unless there was a court order.”

So far, nobody has applied to the Supreme Court of Yukon, said Dan Cable, a spokesperson for the Department of Justice.

Even when the federal legislation takes shape, there still may not be many people seeking assisted death.

“I think there’s a misconception that there will be a tidal wave of people requesting this,” Zimmerman said.

He wondered this at one point, and found an example that put things in perspective.

In Oregon, where assisted death has been legal since 1997, there had been a total of 859 assisted deaths as of 2014.

The numbers have risen over the 19 years since the law was passed, with the largest being 105 deaths in 2014.

Keeping in mind the state’s population of nearly four million people, the number of deaths accounts for approximately 0.02 per cent of the population.

This percentage of the Yukon’s population would account for seven individuals over the span of 17 years.

“You could say that, perhaps, the most on average would be two cases per year. It’s certainly not going to be in the 10s or 20s,” Zimmerman said.


In the meantime, the Yukon government is waiting for the Criminal Code changes to be adopted before embarking on establishing Yukon-specific legislation for assisted dying.

“There is a Yukon working group that is currently planning how we will implement this once the four-month reprieve is over,” said Pat Living, a spokesperson for the Department of Health and Social Services.

Within the working group are officials from the Health and Justice departments, Council of Yukon First Nations, Yukon Medical Council, Yukon Registered Nurses Association, Yukon Medical Association and the Yukon Hospital Corp.

Their first meeting was in August 2015, and there have been three more gatherings since then.

Living said that so far, no decisions have been made on how it will be implemented.

In addition, it is undecided as to whether assisted dying will be covered in the territory’s health care plan.

One thing that has been decided is that there will be no public consultation nor open forums to the public on the matter, according to another spokesperson at the department.

“There’s a lot of debate over how it should be provided initially. The thing is, this is a process you want to get right,” Zimmerman said.

“You want to err on the side of caution and safety for everyone. One of the errors could be rushing.”

Comments (11)

Up 9 Down 9

Politico on Mar 10, 2016 at 11:08 am

Wilf, are not a lot of Seniors and family members also opposed, not to the facility, but the way it was jammed down their throats? No one is opposed to a comfortable surroundings during their waning years but the nature of the surrounds, that the rub .

Up 45 Down 21

The liberals and the NDP still are playing politics on Mar 7, 2016 at 6:11 pm

with this piece by showing thumbs down. I can't believe the Liberals and the NDP still want to play politics, while our seniors suffer in pain because we don't have this home to help them.
Liberals and NDP you need new leadership because this issue is near and dear to most Yukoners and all you are doing is showing contempt for the Yukon people and voters.
Some of you or your family member may need this level of care and it will not be there for them and you want to stop this project and build 2 or 3 of them with a lower level of care at $350 million dollars which the Yukon does not have.

Wilf Carter

Up 56 Down 31

Speciality community care home for seniors that is build for to help seniors at the end of their life. on Mar 6, 2016 at 2:45 pm

I am so up fed with the NDP and Liberals wanting to kill the specialty care community home for seniors. I was so upset with the first piece I just wrote I sent it without finishing it.
Liberals and NDP will never live this down - harming our seniors for their own political gains.
What politician will do to get into power.

Wilf Carter

Up 29 Down 0

Great piece June on Mar 6, 2016 at 2:40 pm

I have a hard time with this but I spent 10 days with my uncle watching my aunt die one day at a time. She could not eat or keep anything down. She had cancer and there was no chance of recovery.
Her eye sight went first, her body slowly started to close down and then it was finally over with.
I would not want anyone to go through that again at the end of their life.

Up 15 Down 2

June Jackson on Mar 5, 2016 at 10:04 pm

A 70 page report has been produced by the assisted dying committee..its intent was to assist legislators in developing guidelines for 'assisted dying'. It talks about mentally ill people, it talks about 'mature' children that should be able to request termination of their life..for me..that's going too far. Please scan the report, the link is here..
http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/assisted-dying-committee-recommendations-1.3463392

That being said, what Dr. Zimmerman is proposing for guidelines seems far more sensible in that it reaches out to those whose lives have become intolerable and allows them to choose when they will leave this earth while offering some protection for people who are temporarily unable to go on. It can't be too easy, but it can't be too hard either.

JC..I totally agree that assisted dying should be made available in the prisons...especially for murderers and child predators. If someone is going to spend their entire life in prison, it would be merciful to give them the option. Who knows? Perhaps after death they will get a do over.

Up 39 Down 2

Mary Sloan on Mar 5, 2016 at 2:55 am

This is a huge step toward dying with dignity. There may come a time in anyone's life when simply letting go is the only choice. If it were me, I'd embrace the option.

Up 9 Down 40

jc on Mar 4, 2016 at 10:09 pm

It used to be called "assisted suicide". But the leftys had to take the sting out of it and give it a more "politically correct name "assisted death". Clears the conscience as well. But hey, its still suicide. Just wondering what the anti-capital punishment people think of this. After all they are the ones who used to use the phrase, "Thou shalt not kill" when it came to executing murderers. Does suicide
fit this criteria?

Up 28 Down 0

Bobby Bitman on Mar 4, 2016 at 9:03 pm

Glad to see we have moved on with this basic human right to end hopeless suffering. Another step forward.

Up 30 Down 2

Thanks Dr. Zimmerman who I have had the honor have known for over 30 years on Mar 4, 2016 at 7:30 pm

as our family doctor and a great contributor to the health of Yukoners for many years. When he told me he was retiring we had a a time of long history, when he over 28 years ago delivered my daughter into this world.
This is a great loving and caring person for the health that is needed in the Yukon especially our seniors with challenging heath problems and the people who are at life threatening situations.
I thank him and Dr. Storey for saving my life during a challenging medical time in my life a number of years ago.
Thanks Dr. Zimmerman for your 24 hour help so I could live longer in life.
What Dr. Zimmerman is doing is helping to make new real life choices for all of us.

Thanks Zim

Wilf Carter

Up 24 Down 0

This doctor has spent most of his life in the Yukon alone with his wife Dr MacDonald on Mar 4, 2016 at 7:13 pm

and are most of the greatest people in Yukon medical community.

Up 11 Down 24

Josey Wales on Mar 4, 2016 at 4:47 pm

"The territory has established its interim guidelines for people seeking physician-assisted death."

That is awesome, it is after all "2016"...and this person?
Seeks a few "physician-assisted " culls .....would be nice?
We have a few Trevor the human types free ranging, where do I pick up the paperwork?

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.