Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

EXAM TIME – In this April 2005 file photo, Phillip Merchant, left, prepares the antidote for the sedative as Dan Mulcahy, Gregg Adams and Lori Megyesi use ultrasound to see if the member of the Chisana caribouherd is pregnant. A new study has found that industrial disturbances are contributing to the decline of boreal caribou.

Industrial disturbances are harming boreal caribou

A research pa​per released last month confirms that significant declines in boreal caribou herds over the past 30 years are due to habitat disturbance.

By Whitehorse Star on September 1, 2020

A research pa​per released last month confirms that significant declines in boreal caribou herds over the past 30 years are due to habitat disturbance.

Boreal Caribou Can Coexist with Natural but Not Industrial Disturbances was published in the Journal of Wildlife Management by five co-authors. They include Dr. Fiona Schmiegelow, a Yukon University and University of Alberta professor.

The paper concludes that caribou can persist with wildfire.

However, they will continue to decline in disturbed areas as a result of cumulative industrial activities if preventative or mitigative actions are not taken.

Boreal woodland caribou span nine provincial and territorial jurisdictions and overlap Canada’s most valuable natural resources: oil, gas, minerals and timber.

This species is a recovery priority under the Canadian Species at Risk Act with fewer than one third of the herds categorized as self- sustaining.

The researchers examined caribou habitat disturbance in Alberta and found that caribou can co-exist with wildfire but not in combination with industrial development.

“Industrial development causes habitat fragmentation and vegetation change resulting in increased vulnerability to predators and additional stressors on caribou populations,” said Schmiegelow.

“Limiting habitat disturbance due to industrial activities helps reduce this stress, and mapping where industrial activity does occur provides critical information to inform management decisions.”

Population models are traditionally used to assess wildlife and inform management.

This paper suggests that these models need to be evaluated and updated with the latest information to bolster confidence in their application.

The authors conclude that the development of strategies to prevent population decline are key to sustaining caribou in relatively undisturbed landscapes where they may still thrive.

“In Alberta, there is limited potential for caribou persistence without intensive and expensive interventions that still may not reverse declines,” said Schmiegelow.

“Yukon is one of the few remaining jurisdictions with caribou populations that still support harvest, but with climate change and increased resource exploration and development, Yukon could see declines similar to other jurisdictions.”

Schmiegelow is the program director for the Northern Environmental and Conservation Sciences degree program through the University of Alberta and Yukon University.

Besides Schmiegelow, the research team consists of Frances Stewart, Natural Resources Canada; Joshua Nowak, University of Montana; Tatiane Micheletti, University of British Columbia; Eliot McIntire, Natural Resources Canada; and Steven Cumming, Laval University.

Comments (14)

Up 0 Down 0

Cole on Feb 5, 2022 at 12:22 pm

Thanks for sharing this! All the best!
Feel free to visit: https://www.flyingmag.com/

Up 2 Down 2

doubtful on Sep 7, 2020 at 11:17 am

Wilf Carter, here you go again. Posting on almost every topic, with the confidence that your experience trumps all other opinions.
Why, you deserve to be congratulated on being the oldest man alive!! You have to be 200, maybe 300 years old to have gained all the experience, exposure and expertise you purport to have.
No matter the topic - pipelines, railways, highways, construction, education, municipal territorial and provincial politics, and now even wildlife, you seem to have done it all or know someone who has.
I look forward to seeing an article about the first manned lunar landing, or the space station, or sputnik, to see whether you claim to have been on the technical teams for those events as well.
While I greatly respect freedom of speech, and praise you for weighing in on so many topics, your constant reference to your involvement and experience wears a bit thin.
I sincerely doubt any one person exists who could have lived a life with so much expertise in so many matters, as you seem to want readers to believe.
Just sayin'

Up 6 Down 8

Crunch on Sep 4, 2020 at 9:45 am

@ Wilf
Your in way over your head Wilf. Give it up . The cooperation of all stakeholders involved and the regulated restrictions has brought the herd back to approx 85,000 animals. The registration hunt allows for more govy control in not letting the same thing happen again. Open seasons, tons of access and the boys having unlimited toys is the ticket to diminishing wildlife populations. We are very close to going lottery in Yukon for most hunting. Let the whining begin.

Up 8 Down 5

My Opinion on Sep 3, 2020 at 9:54 pm

It seems to me that the only people completely disrupting and messing with wildlife is those guys in the above picture. Leave them the h*ll alone, how about that?

Up 7 Down 4

rangifer on Sep 3, 2020 at 6:30 pm

The main diet of caribou can't be replanted--it is lichen, which takes decades to grow. So any bio replanting caribou's main dietary survival item and bragging about it is wrong.

Up 8 Down 7

Wilf Carter on Sep 3, 2020 at 2:35 am

Where did the number come from on animals going from 150,000 to 7000. Who did the counts and how? Unfortunately, these are not true according to bio I talked to. In gold rush days wild animals were the only source of food. At one time there was 100,000 people in Dawson. What there now 1700. How many animals are taken a year in Dawson area? Is there any other cause for the population to go down like too many animals and a shortage of food for them because there was too many of them! What is the carrying capacity for animals in this area. Does any one know that number based on food supply? I have seen bad winters with a lot of snow kill 1000's of deer in NS and AB. Find dead animals all over the place because there's not enough food for them and to much snow.
Another thing is bad weather/winters female abort there babies.
There needs to be work done on the subject before any certainty can be determined on the subject of the animals. What the Wolf population is like and how many are they taking!!!!

Up 3 Down 4

Wilf Carter on Sep 2, 2020 at 5:13 pm

I find this interesting where site facts like the top of the world highway CB herd which has grown and is part of upper Yukon herd which is over 180,000

Up 15 Down 17

Crunch on Sep 2, 2020 at 1:24 pm

There is a registration hunt for the 40 mile cariboo herd on right now west of Dawson City. This herd which numbered 150,000 at one point dwindled to 7000 animals until controls and regulations were brought in to limit hunting. When driving the Top of the World highway one needs only to climb a mountain in order to diagnose the problem. There are roads running EVERYWHERE and tons of access into cariboo habitat. Why is it so difficult to figure this out? The spin gets really difficult to listen to and people " you look like total fools."

Up 18 Down 21

Wilf Carter on Sep 2, 2020 at 12:06 pm

The wild life in Northern Alberta is better than it ever was because of companies replanting the types of food the animals eat. I know some of bio who did the work on it. Wild population is growing faster than it ever did.

Up 20 Down 34

JC on Sep 2, 2020 at 10:19 am

Oh my, the poor Caribou again. Somebody call Princess Greta or the United Nations. In the meantime somebody tell those caribou to stay away from industrial areas.

Up 17 Down 28

Sheepchaser on Sep 2, 2020 at 9:31 am

The real pandemic is the mind virus of greed and entitlement that fuels these developments.
Also, the comments above and the dog-whistle racism of ‘it’s not the pipeline, it’s the traditional hunters’ stands as clear evidence of the bias and ignorance hard data has to face once politicized.

For the record, most of us would rather be broke with clean food in our bellies and clean air in our lungs than be jet setting, oil burning, rig pig talking, mortgage slaving, multiple ex partner supporting, child ruining, fart rocket riders. More money, more problems.

When I say most, I mean that a clear majority of Canadians do not want the resource extraction consequences or lifestyle as a mainstay to our economy. We can do better.

Up 23 Down 9

Max Mack on Sep 1, 2020 at 6:52 pm

Don't forget folks, this is "science" published by real genuine "researchers".

Up 35 Down 14

JohnW on Sep 1, 2020 at 5:31 pm

Industrial development in Alberta's boreal forest is impacting the caribou there. “Industrial development causes habitat fragmentation and vegetation change resulting in increased vulnerability to predators and additional stressors on caribou populations,”
Yes, forest cutlines, roads and pipelines allow predators [hunters] easier access to more caribou habitat.
The industrial development is not causing a problem for the caribou the humans are. Caribou have done very well around Alaska's North Slope oil fields because hunting is prohibited there.
Human predators are the problem, not O&G development.

Up 56 Down 6

Didn't mention something on Sep 1, 2020 at 1:58 pm

How much impact is there from unrestrained and unrestricted hunting? It may be some people's legal right to kill as many caribou as they want, but we should not overlook this contribution to the decline of the caribou. I see them mention wildfire, but not people shooting into herds then filling up pick up trucks with the ones that fell dead while others wander off to die slowly. These are things that do happen. Whether it's right or wrong, how does this affect the caribou herds?

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.