Photo by Whitehorse Star
EXPENSIVE ARSON – Acrid smoke permeates the air as Whitehorse firefighters battle the deliberately-set blaze at the Canada Games Centre on the evening of June 24, 2011. The damage bill exceeds $5 million.
Photo by Whitehorse Star
EXPENSIVE ARSON – Acrid smoke permeates the air as Whitehorse firefighters battle the deliberately-set blaze at the Canada Games Centre on the evening of June 24, 2011. The damage bill exceeds $5 million.
The pair responsible for the multimillion-dollar Canada Games Centre (CGC) fire ran by three fire alarms and multiple adults after starting the blaze and later lied to Whitehorse RCMP.
The pair responsible for the multimillion-dollar Canada Games Centre (CGC) fire ran by three fire alarms and multiple adults after starting the blaze and later lied to Whitehorse RCMP.
Those revelations formed some of the evidence presented Wednesday afternoon at a sentencing hearing for one of the girls.
The 13-year-old, whose name cannot be published under the federal Youth Criminal Justice Act, appeared before territorial court Judge Michael Cozens.
After listening to more than two hours of evidence and arguments, the judge opted to reserve his decision on her sentence until early February.
Both the teen and her 12-year-old co-accused have pleaded guilty to lighting speed skating mats on fire on June 24, 2011.
The blaze forced the centre to be shut down for months and caused more than $5 million worth of damage.
Crown prosecutor Bonnie Macdonald told the court that the two accused went to the ATCO arena that evening with an 11-year-old boy, who has not been charged in the case.
Using lighters, both girls lit the handles of speed skating mats, court heard.
When they looked back, one third of the mats were ablaze, Macdonald said.
By the time CGC staff were alerted, the flames were 13 or 14 feet high —much too large to contain with hand-held fire extinguishers.
Fire crews almost immediately believed the blaze was caused by arson, but did not initially suspect the girls, Macdonald said.
In fact, the trio was first interviewed by police that evening as possible witnesses to what had happened.
It was then that the girls concocted a lie about seeing a First Nations woman running from the scene.
According to a statement by the young boy, the 13-year-old threatened to punch him if he told the truth.
The court was also shown copies of text messages between the two girls following the fire, agreeing to continue with that story.
However, when police were able to view footage from surveillance cameras the next day, the lie was uncovered.
After being arrested, the teen admitted to lighting the mats, telling police she was concerned her friend would think she was a wimp.
She insisted it was initially the younger girl's idea.
This contradicts the statement to police from the 11-year-old boy who said it was the older girl's idea.
The second girl has yet to appear in court to tell her side of the story, her sentencing hearing was postponed earlier this month.
Most of the repairs to the centre have been covered by insurance.
The Crown is asking for a two-year sentence for the teen, which would include part probation and part house arrest.
Under Canadian law, the maximum amount of time a youth can spend under house arrest is six months.
Macdonald argued that a stricter sentence is warranted because of the amount of damage done; the fact that the pair attempted to pass the blame on to someone else; and the fact they had multiple opportunities to report the blaze before it grew so large.
The girl's lawyer, Gord Coffin, said that punishment would not be appropriate. He pointed out that his client has no previous criminal record and has followed all of the court orders placed on her since she was arrested.
Coffin said the girl panicked after what happened, which shows her level of immaturity.
The teen sat quietly for most of the hearing. She only spoke when the judge asked her what she thought of the situation.
"I'm so ashamed of myself,” she said through tears, adding, "I don't know how to explain how I'm feeling.”
The judge said he hoped she has told all her friends how ashamed she is and corrected anyone who said they thought it was a fun or cool thing to do.
"I can't think of anyone I know who hasn't been affected by this,” he said.
"I know you didn't intend to cause that much harm. I think it's really important that you make sure people know it's not cool and how ashamed you're feeling.”
The teen later read a letter in which she apologized to the community. Those people included local residents who missed out on using the facility during the prolonged cleanup and repairs period; CGC staff and the contractors hired to clean up the destruction she and her co-accused left behind.
"I completely understand why people would be angry with me,” she said.
"I have shamed myself and my family. I hope the community will be able to forgive me some day.”
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (15)
Up 1 Down 0
Awe, but look.. She's ashamed..... on Jan 30, 2012 at 12:53 pm
Wow.... a slap on the wrist for 5+ million in damages. That's insane. AND: they blamed another girl for their own actions. That's insane... AND: they created this fancy story - post meditated... why? Because they wanted to cover their bases... You bet if there had not been security footage, these girls would have done anything/everything in their power to grow old with this secret... And she feels "ashamed"? If you're old enough to commit that kind of crime, you should be sentenced for it appropriately. Give them a two year juvi sentence... then give them another two years of probation. Deny them access/entry to any activity based environment/centre: No CWC for them, No MT Sima, No public Parks... no millenium trail... no day use lakes.. Make sure they learn that there are CONSEQUENCES to their actions!!!! No previous record? GIVE ME A BREAK: SHE'S 13!!! Shouldn't it be an EXPECTATION to NOT have a previous record at that age?!
Up 0 Down 0
north of 60 on Jan 28, 2012 at 5:56 am
"Most of the repairs to the centre have been covered by insurance."
"Hopefully my property taxes don't have to go up to pay for this! "
Of course our property taxes will go up to pay for the amount not covered by insurance, and to pay for the increased insurance premiums in the future because the CoW is now a higher risk client.
These two 'snowflakes' have created quite a legacy for themselves and their families. This is a small town, their identities can't be hidden.
Why aren't the parents charged for negligence?
Up 0 Down 0
CC on Jan 27, 2012 at 3:09 pm
All I have to say is although the courts have to go by certain standards and laws, the judge can impose some things like what has been mentioned here, a couple weeks community service might be cool!!! but what bothers me is the fact that they blamed another innocent child! and yes she happens to be first nations....hell that just adds more racism to the pot! these kids are so not friggen cool! Did we just go back 50 years? did I miss something....never mind that they caused a lot of damage to the young boy, the young girl they blamed! what about all the other kids that benefit the facility? What if a life was taken? and they are under house arrest (grounded) and no cell phones...OMG!!
Up 1 Down 0
Any-Mouse on Jan 27, 2012 at 10:32 am
GIVE THEM COMMUNITY SERVICE FOR THE SUMMER AND NIGHTS UNTIL END OF 2012 AND MOVE ON TOO BETTER STORIES.
Up 0 Down 0
shenya on Jan 27, 2012 at 9:57 am
"It takes a community to raise a child"
While Whitehorse enjoy more and better recreational facilities its the youths who are experiencing more peer pressure or they tend to do property damages more today then when we were young ourselves. True these girls need to be accountable and if they are given house arrest their parent(parents) should demonstrate constructive teaching tools as well and to make sure the girls are abiding their conditions. The centre is a place where other groups and people enjoy.
Up 1 Down 0
not enough on Jan 27, 2012 at 8:25 am
I want to know their names. However, we can't publish their names because it would damage their delicate little reputations... Instead we will go out of our way to protect them from being identified, so real and effective recompense - like community service - will not even be considered.
"Say you are sorry, cry, you will just get a slap on the wrist." And here we go...
Up 0 Down 0
yukoner on Jan 27, 2012 at 5:26 am
who would have thought two lil sweet girls tsk tsk. i wonder what their excuse is. cant be residential school or hard life childhood. hahahah what a turnaround for you people always commenting on natives. wonder what you have to say now.
Up 1 Down 0
anonymous on Jan 27, 2012 at 4:28 am
What the hell is a 13 year old girl doing carrying a lighter on her in the first place?
Up 1 Down 0
Anonomyous on Jan 27, 2012 at 2:21 am
These girls should have a punishment, that will scare them into growing up a little bit and realising that acting cool, and not standing your ground when you things aren't safe, such as playing with fire, is not okay. Did this girl apologize to the little first nations girl they were blaming for the fire? She is family to me, and the blame was put on her for months, is anything being done to apologize to her? She was a victim of rumors and being falsly accused of a crime. It is not okay that these girls did this, and accused someone else, and nothing is being done to apologize to the girl they had blamed, her life was impacted and she did nothing wrong. I know these girls on a personal level, and I think that there is more then just punishment that needs to happen, not just an apology to the court, but some community service, and more apologies written to the people who were affected by this.- Personal opinion
Up 1 Down 0
north of 60 on Jan 26, 2012 at 5:57 pm
Why didn't the court ask the teens why they started a fire in a building? What would motivate anyone to commit such a destructive act? If they were asked, then why wasn't the answer reported?
An appropriate sentence would include cleaning washrooms and floors in public buildings.
Up 0 Down 0
almost been there as a kid on Jan 26, 2012 at 12:42 pm
While I in no way condone what happened at CGC I think back to all the dumb shenanigans I pulled as a kid that could have turned out so much worse. I must have had the worlds best guardian angel perched on my shoulder. Do I think these kids intended for the building to catch fire causing millions of dollars of damage and closing for weeks? No. It's to bad they lied about it originally as it's a hard way to find out the truth is the best policy...
Hopefully my property taxes don't have to go up to pay for this!
Up 0 Down 0
Craig Vandenhoek on Jan 26, 2012 at 11:59 am
I really don't think being grounded is going to teach them anything at that age the only thing you care about is being cool and unfortunately most of their friends will probably think they are so why not have them do some demeaning public service you know embarrass them in front of their friends let there peers see their not badasses there dumbasses
Up 1 Down 0
Susan Rae on Jan 26, 2012 at 10:48 am
How refreshing to hear someone admit to wrongdoing instead of making excuses and blaming everyone else....and it is a child...maybe others in the community can learn something from this.
Up 0 Down 0
J.Creighton on Jan 26, 2012 at 10:16 am
A shame they can't get two years in prison for their crime.
Up 1 Down 0
karen on Jan 26, 2012 at 8:34 am
You girls should also apologize to First Nations woman too. The best place to apologize is at the CYFN General Assembly.