Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Photo submitted

A MOTHER MOURNED – Diane Roby, shown on the left in this studio portrait, was killed in a head-on collision on the Alaska Highway, near the weigh station, in July 2008. She left behind a large extended family, including her only son, Carson Baker (right). The B.C. man responsible for the crash was fined $1,000 and sentenced to 30 days' house arrest Monday. Photo courtesy LINDA HILL

‘I'm responsible; I fell asleep,' driver told RCMP

The man responsible for the death of a popular Whitehorse hairdresser in July 2008 must pay a $1,000 fine and spend 30 days under house arrest, an acting territorial court judge ruled Monday afternoon.

By Justine Davidson on November 30, 2010

The man responsible for the death of a popular Whitehorse hairdresser in July 2008 must pay a $1,000 fine and spend 30 days under house arrest, an acting territorial court judge ruled Monday afternoon.

Jamie McBride, a manager with The Brick's franchising department, pleaded guilty to driving without due care and attention under the Motor Vehicles Act, after charges of impaired driving causing death were dropped.

As Judge Leigh Gower heard Monday, McBride had been awake almost 24 hours as he headed back to his hotel after an evening out with the new owners of Whitehorse's The Brick furniture store.

After having a couple of glasses of wine with dinner, McBride had joined the group at a downtown nightclub.

The 50-year-old Kelowna, B.C. man switched to non-alcoholic drinks because "he wanted to be alert for his flight at seven the next morning,” his lawyer told the court Monday.

But McBride was tired. So tired that he says he can't remember anything between leaving the night club and regaining consciousness after a head-on collision with a van driven by 50-year-old Diane Roby.

During a preliminary inquiry held while McBride was still facing criminal charges, the court heard evidence that a blood sample taken at Whitehorse General Hospital after the fatal crash indicated McBride was over the legal blood-alcohol limit.

That evidence never made it to trial because the prosecutor could not show beyond a reasonable doubt that the blood was McBride's and that nothing had been done to taint the sample.

The only evidence about McBride's behaviour or state of mind heard in court Monday was from a couple who watched McBride pass them as they were coming out of the Erik Nielsen Whitehorse International Airport.

They told the RCMP they saw his car driving south on the Alaska Highway "in the wrong lane, going in the wrong direction.”

Concerned, they followed McBride along the highway for about 1 1/5 kilometres, lost sight of him as he rounded the corner just south of the airport, then came upon the collision just moments after it occurred.

According to the emergency responders who were first on the scene, the first words out of McBride's mouth were: "I'm responsible; I fell asleep. Is everyone OK?”

As Crown prosecutor David McWhinnie pointed out during Monday's hearing, it is quite possible McBride fell asleep twice.

He was probably asleep as he passed the couple at the airport, McWhinnie said, woke up in time to negotiate the curve, then fell asleep again just before hitting Roby's van.

When police and paramedics arrived on the scene, McBride was trapped in his vehicle on the highway's west shoulder.

Roby's totalled van was on the other side of the highway. Inside, the driver's seat had been ripped off its footing and flung into the back of the vehicle.

Roby's male passenger told investigators he remembered seeing McBride's blue Pontiac coming toward them in their lane and shouting "Crank it!” Roby turned her vehicle toward the ditch, and the two vehicles collided on their drivers'-side front corners.

The two men were taken to the hospital and released. Roby was medevaced to Vancouver, where she died of her injuries the next day.

Her friends and family filled one side of the courtroom Monday, choking back sobs as the two lawyers made their submissions on sentencing.

Very little was said about Roby during the hearing, but outside the courtroom, her family described her as a warm and loving woman, whose death has left a hole in all their lives.

Her sister, Linda Hill, said she was deeply disappointed by the police who attended the scene and failed to give McBride a breathalyzer test.

"They didn't do their job,” she said.

Gower accepted McWhinnie's suggested sentence, giving McBride the maximum fine, plus 30 days of house arrest and a two-month driving suspension.

In handing down the sentence, the judge repeated several times that the punishment was in no way supposed to reflect the loss of Roby's life.

He reiterated what McWhinnie had said during his submissions to the court: that a Motor Vehicles Act conviction comes with "less moral blameworthiness and less social stigma” than a criminal conviction.

However, Gower did say that because McBride got behind the wheel when he was sleep-deprived, he is "more morally blameworthy” than someone who simply had a momentary lack of attention.

The charge of careless driving causing death comes with a maximum sentence of a $1,000 fine and 90 days in jail.

Comments (11)

Up 0 Down 0

yukoner on Dec 8, 2010 at 6:56 am

Why are some of you blaming the police? It was the driver's fault. If a breathalyzer can't be used at an accident scene then blood samples are taken at the hospital by a doctor before being mailed to a lab for testing. The prosecutor couldn't prove beyond a "reasonable doubt" that the samples were Mcbrides and that they weren't tainted. Sounds like a mix up at the lab. We have a habit for blaming the police instead of the person responsible for the crime. Mr. Mcbride killed Diane because he was driving drunk, something that seems all to common on our highways. Innocent people die every day from drunk driver's and there is no punishment great enough to bring them back. The message is simple, don't drink and drive.

Up 0 Down 0

Yukon Max on Dec 6, 2010 at 11:06 am

My condolences to Diane's family and friends.

According to news reports, a blood sample was taken from McBride to ascertain blood alcohol levels. (A breathalyzer in accident situations like these are inappropriate due to the possibility of injuries sustained by the driver.)

However, the RCMP appear to have mishandled the sampling protocols and this evidence was thrown out by the judge. Thus, there was insufficient evidence for the court to make a finding of "beyond reasonable doubt."

This is not a failure of the court -- it is a failure of the RCMP to follow well-established blood sampling protocols.

Up 0 Down 0

Mark on Dec 6, 2010 at 10:31 am

"The charge of careless driving causing death comes with a maximum sentence of a $1,000 fine and 90 days in jail"

WTF... ARE you kidding me.

Canadian Laws are so laughable. Not cool at all

Up 0 Down 0

Virgil on Dec 2, 2010 at 5:14 am

So guy gets drunk... not enough sleep... kills a mother, friend, and all around amazing person.

1000 dollars and house arrest?

who gets the 1000 dollars?

What lessons does this teach?

Up 0 Down 0

Doug on Dec 1, 2010 at 12:19 pm

I read the article with utter disappointment not only in our legal system in the failure to prosecute Mr. McBride to the fullest extent. I think the article does tell us in not so many words that Mr. McBride was seriously drunk, was driving out of control and, for no reason at all, took the life of one of the finest people in our community. If Mr. McBride is feeling tremendous guilt for the pain he has caused (as one person comments)..then he indeed needs to account for this for his entire life.

Up 0 Down 0

Arn Anderson on Dec 1, 2010 at 4:13 am

I have no idea why my other comment wasn't approved, but in response to JC, human life is extremely cheap. When there is only so much land, water and trees and human greed wants it all, yes, human life is dirt cheap like a bag full of gummy bears.

Up 0 Down 0

Dianne on Dec 1, 2010 at 3:43 am

This is the first I heard of the passing of Diane also my heart sank as I seen her picture. I moved away 12 years ago but always thought about her almost everytime I get my hair done, she was the best hairdresser I have ever had. My deepest condolences to her family and especially to her son. Diane was a great person and I was happy to have known her.

I wish the RCMP were doing a better job as this seems to be another botched investigation. There were witnesses who seen him driving on the wrong side of the road this in itself should of warranted a breathalyzer. Why was the blood sample not secured or proven as belonging to Mcbride? It sounds like another legal wrangling tactic used by people who can afford the "best" lawyers to get them off of any crime no matter how it is done.

Up 0 Down 0

JC on Nov 30, 2010 at 2:39 pm

$1,000.00 fine and 30 days house arrest. The cheapness judges place on human life these days is astounding. And then he has the gall to say repeatedly, "the punishment was in no way supposed to reflect the loss of Roby's life". I'm sure that makes her family and friends feel much better. And this took 2 and a 1/2 years.

Up 0 Down 0

John Macdonald on Nov 30, 2010 at 9:44 am

Just like we can't understand the pain the victim's family has felt, we cannot understand the guilt that this man feels.

I hope that people don't lose sight of the fact that this man lives with the guilt everyday of his life.That can't be easy.

He should have been given a breathalyzer, but just because he wasn't, we shouldn't just assume that he was over the limit.

He may have made the tragic error of driving when overtired, and remember people....he without sin caste the first stone...

Up 0 Down 0

Groucho dNorth on Nov 30, 2010 at 9:12 am

Had Mr. McBride been truly responsible, he would not have been behind the wheel that evening and Diane would still be cutting my hair.

My condolences to her family and friends. She is missed.

Up 0 Down 0

Don McKenzie on Nov 30, 2010 at 8:42 am

This is the first time I have heard about the passing of Diane.

My condolences to her friends and family.

:(

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.