Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Community Services Minister Richard Mostyn and Piers McDonald

‘I guess it wasn’t meant to be in the end’

The Yukon’s hopes for hosting the 2027 Canada Winter Games stand all but dead today.

By Whitehorse Star on November 14, 2022

The Yukon’s hopes for hosting the 2027 Canada Winter Games stand all but dead today.

“The Government of Yukon has determined it can no longer proceed with the bid to host the 2027 Canada Winter Games due to a lack of federal support,” Community Services Minister Richard Mostyn announced this morning.

“The Government of Canada has indicated that it is only willing to provide a total of $16.75 million towards the games, including only $3 million in capital funding – the standard amount provided to any small jurisdiction hosting the games.

“This is less than three per cent of the requested contribution from Canada and less than the $11 million in capital funding the City of Whitehorse has already signaled it would contribute to the games.”

This means there is no funding to support the necessary projects that would have made the Games a success “and left a lasting legacy in Whitehorse, including a modern arena complex and infrastructure to incorporate Arctic and Dene sports into the games for the first time,” the minister added.

“We did not make this decision lightly, and we are extremely disappointed that we cannot proceed with this bid.

“Hosting the 2027 Games in Whitehorse would have been an historic opportunity to advance reconciliation and bring the highest level of sport in the country back to Canada’s North.

“We made it clear from the outset that substantial contributions would need to be made by all levels of government, including our federal and municipal partners, for this bid to succeed,” Mostyn added.

“Without any meaningful contribution from the federal government to support these Games, we were left with no other option.”

With the capital costs of hosting the 2027 Games estimated to be in excess of $185 million, and contributions from partners totalling less than $15 million, the minister said, “it is simply not feasible for the Government of Yukon to proceed with the bid at a cost of $160 million.

“Our government has a responsibility to manage taxpayers’ money responsibly. At this time, it is clear that the territory’s resources must be focused on housing, health care, education and tackling climate change for the benefit of all Yukoners.”

He thanked Piers McDonald, the chair of the 2027 Canada Winter Games Bid Committee, “and his exceptional team for all their hard work over the past 18 months.”

He also thanked the City of Whitehorse for its role in pursuing the Games.

“While this was not the outcome any of us had hoped for, I look forward to continuing to work with our partners to increase recreational infrastructure and support the development of sport throughout the territory in the coming years.”

Speaking to the Star late this morning, McDonald said that on behalf of the committee, he is “very disappointed that the bid to host the Canada Games will not proceed.

“I think a lot of people put in a lot of good effort to try to put together a bid proposal that would have been very good for the Yukon community and certainly as planned it was meant to be a reconciliation event, a partnership with First Nations in ways that had not been experienced before by a Canada Games movement ….

“It depends of course on the support of the hosts, particularly the Yukon government and the federal government in terms of providing for the facilities portion of the proposal and that’s their call, obviously. I respect that very much.”

He was asked if he felt blindsided by the decision.

“Like a lot of people, I had some wishful thinking going on that there were a number of alternatives and that one would be found to proceed, but I guess, weighing everything in the balance, the people who were making the actual call felt that they couldn’t proceed at this time with the new hockey infrastructure, the arenas, so they obviously have put an end to the process as a result.”

“If you ask me if I saw this coming, nobody singled that this was going to be an outcome, but I certainly understand the implications of what had probably gone into the decision-making … I’m prepared to move on.

“I guess it wasn’t meant to be in the end.”

McDonald confirmed today’s announcement effectively ends the Yukon’s bid for the Games.

“Oh, yes. I think the Canada Games Council at this point is going to be turning on the jets to find an alternative for Yukon’s hosting,” he said.

“They typically will go to – there’s a rotational schedule. They’ll go to the next people on the schedule – I can’t remember who that is– they’ll probably look to find a community that has all the infrastructure in place so there’s no need to worry about timing to build infrastructure,” McDonald said.

“So it’ll probably be a larger community within the next jurisdiction and they will negotiate and decide whether they can award it to someone else.”

He was also asked if there’s any chance the bid could be resurrected.

“Not without some sort of commitments to meeting the basic requirements,” McDonald replied.

“The alternative, of course, to building an arena is not to build an arena but move one more sport to another community like Fort St. John (B.C).”

McDonald reiterated that the bid committee had proposed to move long track speed skating to Fort St. John and had confirmed that opportunity with officials there.

“The next opportunity would have been to host a sport like ringette in Fort St. John and not build any new arenas in Whitehorse. Just fix up the Takhini Arena and do whatever we need to do.

“But in the end the hosts, the people in charge, determined that couldn’t realize some physical facilities and they didn’t see it worth the communities’ while to put in the effort for the Games themselves.”

McDonald said there’s little chance the feds might reconsider their decision.

“At this point, I doubt it … I’m sure the (Yukon) government has tested the position of the federal government many different ways and for the federal government to reverse itself would be astonishing.

“Not to say it wouldn’t happen, but I doubt that it would.”

McDonald added, “I’m disappointed, of course and I feel for all the people who put so much effort into the planning to date … it was a pleasure working with them and hopefully some new opportunities come forward before too long.”

Mayor Laura Cabott said early this afternoon that pulling the bid is a huge disappointment.

Aside from showcasing the city and bringing in tourism dollars, she said the biggest losses will be funding for infrastructure that would have lasted well beyond the games: housing and much-needed upgrades to – or the replacement of – the 36-year-old Takhini Arena.

Had the federal government committed enough funding, Cabott said $60 million to $65 million would have gone toward housing for athletes.

Just like the housing built for the 2007 Games, those residences would have become housing for Yukoners afterward, bringing welcome relief to the city’s housing crisis.

Cabott couldn’t confirm if any money the city or territory had set aside for the Games would now be spent on housing, but said housing is still a huge issue for her government.

Additionally, she said the Takhini Arena could have benefited immensely from federal funding.

Beyond necessary upgrades to the aging infrastructure, federal money would have allowed the arena to add more seats. Currently, it only holds 1,500.

“You can’t hold a concert, you can’t hold a big event, you can’t host major hockey tournaments, whether that’s a junior hockey (tournament) or women’s International World Championships.”

She said she’d hoped new infrastructure would have benefited the city like the Canada Games Centre did in 2007.

She called that facility a “gamechanger” for Whitehorse, offering new athletic infrastructure for competition and recreation that’s still used by about 3,000 people a day in the winter 15 years later.

But the lack of funding means those lasting benefits won’t be coming to Whitehorse, she said.

“I haven’t had an opportunity to speak with council yet,” she said.

“But I think it would be highly unlikely that the city would be able to host these Games on our own just considering the costs.”

– With files from Morris Prokop and Ethan Lycan-Lang.

Comments (38)

Up 8 Down 1

Low Priority on Nov 19, 2022 at 9:34 am

Given the size of our population and the lifecycle of our present infrastructure, there are more pressing issues than another sports complex et al.

I don’t understand the agendas of government folks being “all in” initially, then realizing the Feds won’t fund this silly project.

Yes, there are more important issues at hand that are immediate….too many to list but I will try…I find it disingenuous to think we are (had the project gone ahead) a community that values rec hockey more than affordable Housing?! More important that food security?! More important that aging inadequate snow removal equipment?!

Nope, we are going build more infrastructure to support outdoor/indoor leisure activities…. These hair brain ideas should never have gotten green lighted in the hopes the Feds would cut us a cheque?

How about talking to the Feds about a military presence, maybe a cold water port? Sooner rather than later, we will be forced into thinking how another country could literally walk, sail or fly into our shores….

Up 5 Down 1

Anie on Nov 18, 2022 at 3:10 pm

Confused said "I don't understand why the athlete housing is included in the capital cost if it's going to get sold afterwards as housing for Yukoners.". I don't think that selling was ever part of the proposal. The housing would be converted to affordable (rental) housing - much like the housing component of the last games were converted to YukU and seniors affordable rental units.

Up 6 Down 13

Paranoid Floyd on Nov 17, 2022 at 6:13 pm

In response to A much bigger problem on Nov 15, 2022 at 5:00 pm & Cilf Warter on Nov 17, 2022 at 3:16 pm:

Cilf - LOL, a vast conspiracy network of Conservatives and their upvote generator machines has taken control of the Whitehorse Star comments section - FFS!

Most people can understand what Wilf is saying just fine - Liberals are dangerously stupid! Most people can see that, they can understand that but what they cannot comprehend is how those so-called Liberal voters have been taken in, time and again, by Liberalism’s grift-class.

What kind of monster shuts down the oil and gas industry before having another plan in place and thereby intensifying power and wealth in the hands of similarly despotic regimes such as China, and Russia? Then there is the fact that this same monster has betrayed our allies in Europe and elsewhere, to see them freeze to death - Cold is the number one killer in the climate game and you freaks have just made it worse!

You should be ashamed of yourselves!

Besides, we don’t use a computerized upvote system - We drive around to different parts of town until we can vote on the same comment again. There are 3 of us who do this; Justin, Sandy, and Kate. Shhhhh… Don’t let anyone else know though, this will be our little secret…

Up 7 Down 25

Cilf Warter on Nov 17, 2022 at 3:16 pm

@ A much bigger problem

Those upvotes are coming from a local computer firm with deep ties to the YP. Do a bit of digging, easy to unravel that whole thing. They actively upvote any right wing sounding content and down vote facts.

Up 24 Down 2

Dentist 47 on Nov 17, 2022 at 1:46 pm

Thank you! This money can be put to far better use than bolstering Pier Macdonalds ego.

Up 39 Down 2

Charlie's Aunt on Nov 16, 2022 at 3:57 pm

Check out the article re this on CBC North. Quote from Kelly-Ann Paul, president and CEO of Canada Games Council: 'When asked whether the territory could have hosted the games at a lesser cost, Paul said "The proposal was definitely, you know, a shinier version than what would have been required to host the Canada games." "There could have been other opportunities presented that would have met the Canada Games standard, But this is the one that met the requirements for the city of Whitehorse and the government of Yukon to grow through this opportunity."' Bottom line is that Piers, YT and COW were too greedy with their wish list and Santa chose not to play nice.

Up 26 Down 2

Asleep at the wheel on Nov 16, 2022 at 1:30 pm

@Can't...
You do realize the federal budget is still funded by our tax dollars, yes? Whether it's federal or territorial funding we still pay for it in the end. And there are far more important things we can be looking at to try to make our territory a better place to live. We had our games in 2007, we can have them again, Some far more important issues to look at for the time being...

Up 15 Down 8

Juniper Jackson on Nov 16, 2022 at 12:21 am

I hope the upissue is dead..but these people are sneaky and underhanded. They must have something up their sleeve,

Up 9 Down 6

A much bigger problem on Nov 15, 2022 at 5:00 pm

@ Cilf Warter:
Never mind the incoherent comment of Wilf. What about the knobs who gave it 79 thumbs up?

Up 17 Down 9

Hunger games 2027 on Nov 15, 2022 at 4:57 pm

Lol. Even Justin, who believes the budget balances itself, doesn’t trust his Yukon Liberal brethren with lump sums of cash anymore. Larry knew the game to bag the Games; his replacement knows Pap smears and nasal swabs.

Up 10 Down 7

Confused on Nov 15, 2022 at 2:56 pm

I don't understand why the athlete housing is included in the capital cost if it's going to get sold afterwards as housing for Yukoners. Sure you have to borrow funds to build, or find an industry partner to finance it, but is this housing supposed to somehow end up a gift to the Yukon?

Up 44 Down 6

Mitch Bringer on Nov 15, 2022 at 11:45 am

Good. Now we don't need to tear down takhini arena and have no where for rec hockey for 3 years.

Up 55 Down 6

Good on Nov 15, 2022 at 11:29 am

Really glad we saved hundreds of millions. I am sure some are crying today because their visions of brown bags filled with cash just went poof.

Up 9 Down 48

Can't? on Nov 15, 2022 at 9:40 am

Mostyn should have said, "The Yukon Liberal Party has decided that it no longer wants to" instead of "The Government of Yukon has determined it can no longer proceed".

For all the people here who think it was a stupid idea to consider it in the first place, don't you realize that most of the money was going to come from the Federal budget? So many people don't take the time to think before they talk.

Up 31 Down 12

iBrian on Nov 15, 2022 at 6:51 am

I think it’s time we re-evaluate our commitment of time and effort to our children. I see in Haines Junction many parents who drive in 2-3 times a week for their kid to play hockey, and they are not good. Well for the Yukon they are… ok I guess. Too many parents not forcing proper behaviour (which I guess stems from their entitlement & ignorance). Too many people day dreaming their kids will be the next NHL superstar.
Going into a Recession as fast as we are, having talked with a few other people from across Canada. Seems we’re not the only jurisdiction having major funded events cut. Guessing paying out all the CERB and switching those people from CERB to EI has cost us enough that now if I replace my Farm truck at a value of $108,000 for a 1 ton dually, cause it’s my 4th vehicle I now have to pay 20% tax ontop. C.Freeloader is penalized those of us who save our money, been financially responsible our lives and give to the community.
Unfortunately the state of politics is where the general level of intelligence is with our country. It scares me.

Up 54 Down 6

iBrian on Nov 15, 2022 at 6:41 am

Hosting the 2027 Games in Whitehorse would have been an historic opportunity to advance reconciliation and bring the highest level of sport in the country back to Canada’s North.

Hahaha!!! A Reconciliation event???? Huh, in 5 YEARS?? Highest level of Sport too, hahaha, OMG. If only we had a Sports event that endorsed skills like Trades, Health Care, proper Money management.

Up 33 Down 6

North_of_60 on Nov 15, 2022 at 12:09 am

YES !!! Thank goodness sensible people, who can see beyond self-serving legacy aspirations, have prevailed. We need to spend our scarce, limited resources in making the Yukon better for everyone, not on a two week sports party to disproportionately benefit a few elites who live way above the economic realities most of us face every day.

Canada is poised on the brink of a major economic recession, and the only action that will slow that is reducing carbon taxes and increasing petroleum production. The largess that funds the Yukon primarily comes from Canadian oil & gas.

It is myopic insanity. to strangle the goose that lays golden eggs, to satisfy unjustified "anti-oil" ideology. Anyone with a shred of common sense can see that the Yukon is not getting catastrophically warmer because we use Canadian petroleum to make the North habitable.

Up 41 Down 4

CJ2 on Nov 14, 2022 at 10:39 pm

Hallelujah. I thought they must have had some kind of implicit agreement with the federal government to go ahead, so this is a nice surprise.

The response from the politicians is a little ungracious. Piers McDonald figures the federal Liberals are on an "austerity" program. That made me laugh. So much was wrong with the timing of the proposal.

Up 43 Down 6

Good! on Nov 14, 2022 at 10:37 pm

Yay!! Good! Saved by the federal government. The amount of money that would have been thrown around was absolutely ridiculous

Now let's stop renting the convention center from NVD (Piers and friends), to give out a dozen or so covid shots a day.

Up 31 Down 11

Bud McGee on Nov 14, 2022 at 9:25 pm

Everybody remembers the last games in Whitehorse and how everyone froze their rear ends off ... so the Feds were like "we're out". I remember the speed skaters getting hypothermia and frost bite. Probably best that Whitehorse is spared another embarrassment on the national stage.

Up 51 Down 9

Al on Nov 14, 2022 at 9:18 pm

Well after picking myself up off the floor from laughing so hard, and I might add nearly peeing myself, I could only shake my head. Not in disbelief but rather the awakening and startling comment by Lord Mostyn: “Our government has a responsibility to manage taxpayers’ money responsibly. At this time, it is clear that the territory’s resources must be focused on housing, health care, education and tackling climate change for the benefit of all Yukoners.” It seems to me you are plagiarizing what many Yukoner's were telling you months ago that you dismissed out of hand.

Frankly your lot can not be trusted to manage a piggy bank let alone the massive amounts of money you squeeze out of the Feds that you daily squander on BS.

Up 47 Down 6

John on Nov 14, 2022 at 9:11 pm

Lessons to be learned by this government and COW:

1. Before you leapt ahead of yourselves it would have taken but a quick letter or phone call to the minister in Ottawa to see how favourable they would be to in fact the funding you were seeking. Instead what you did was to jump the gun, make a commitment to CWG, spent a bagful of money in advance (deposit, research funding, etc) only to find out that your Liberal pals would only give you 10%. Next time do your homework "in advance" rather than post announcement.

2. Perhaps, just perhaps, seeking a mandate by going to the Yukon people in advance would have given you a clear understanding as to whether you had community support - not just your inner circle of friends and pals. Neither you, nor the COW, had a mandate from the citizens to go ahead with the games. It was all on you. You did not listen to the citizens that were raising concerns of wasteful spending in a time where we needed to more prudent and look after the priorities that really need our attention.

3. This is now twice in less than a week we have seen this government fail miserably with funding issues. First Atlin, and now CWG. We are not talking chump change either. Don't learn do you. You need to review the old adage - if you keep doing the same thing over and over again getting the some miserable results then perhaps - just perhaps - you need to change what you are doing.

You now have only benefited one business in the Yukon. The poultry businesses that sell eggs. Why? Well the collective lot of you have likely used up at least a weeks supply of eggs that is smeared all over your faces.

Don't feel sorry for yourselves - instead you need to apologies to the good people of this territory for yet another FU !!!

Up 36 Down 10

Jack on Nov 14, 2022 at 8:43 pm

No offence intended but Piers doesn't look well enough to pull it off anyway. He should focus on self and not stressing himself out cashing in on the games.

Up 50 Down 5

Terry Berezan on Nov 14, 2022 at 5:23 pm

Although I have participated and enjoyed sport for most of my life, I was happy to hear this project is not moving forward. We have far more pressing issues in the Yukon, such as food security, the climate crisis and unaffordable housing. It’s time to get away from the “obsession of growth” paradigm and start focusing on circular sustainable economies.

Up 30 Down 10

Guncache on Nov 14, 2022 at 5:07 pm

Does Piers need a hanky? Why at the outset did he think we could host this? Are we all flush with money? The liberal party already have us pinching pennies. Trudeau Jr has been busy blowing money every day. He has probably blown that much on his holidays he has taken. Good riddance to this. One more to get rid of.

Up 13 Down 7

Cilf Warter on Nov 14, 2022 at 4:58 pm

@Wilf who said: This is so ridiculous time to bid on games when we don't have basis in Yukon.
Again, typing from the back of a galloping horse? What does this mean?

Up 7 Down 54

Nathan Living on Nov 14, 2022 at 4:14 pm

It's too early to bail out on this.

The Terrotorial government can leverage federal funding independent of the games for the athletes village.
The City of Whitehorse can borrow around 50 million dollars for facilities upgrades. The territorial government can also borrow money. It will be our debt and I think most people will support a leaner version of facilities.

The local Canada Winter Games Committee can request lower seating capacity and a longer time period for hosting the games to make it work with existing facilities.

Local businesses can contribute millions and the CWG Committee can explore special funding from lotteries.
We need these games and can make it work. This is a legacy project.

Up 54 Down 6

Lost In the Yukon on Nov 14, 2022 at 4:08 pm

Everything today is being wrapped up in the "reconciliation" blanket. The mere use of the word is now intended to silent legitimate debate about the wisdom of any project. If you object, you can expect to hear the word "racism" whispered.

This project was a vanity project that would benefit (financially) a few select contractors and other connected (like NVD hotel properties?) the average hard-working Whitehorse resident would be left in the rear-view mirror and stuck with increased property taxes to pay for the operating costs once the photo ops are over and everyone has left town.

Up 31 Down 3

Groucho d'North on Nov 14, 2022 at 3:41 pm

Jeez mark the calendar! The Trudeau Liberals have finally done something I agree with. A spendthrift Prime Minister that might be listening to the financial critics- we can only hope.

Up 34 Down 4

Gordon of Riverdale on Nov 14, 2022 at 3:25 pm

YAWN - finally over
let's use the work hours and money to solve the rampant problems that WH has right now.

Up 37 Down 3

Rod on Nov 14, 2022 at 3:22 pm

Thank god! Next time maybe ask us tax payers first!

Up 133 Down 20

Phew on Nov 14, 2022 at 3:12 pm

That's a relief. Maybe now the city can focus on issues that really matter for is citizens instead of dreams of leaving a "lasting legacy". If we had the demand for all this new infrastructure it would already be on the books. The last thing we need is another costly money pit like the Canada Games Center.

Up 138 Down 25

Holy F@%k on Nov 14, 2022 at 2:54 pm

Morons for even thinking that this was a good idea.

Up 117 Down 15

maybe in 3027 on Nov 14, 2022 at 2:43 pm

Good. As a taxpayer I wasn’t asked my opinion on where my money should go, neither were you. Put the money to better use, perhaps on snow removal equipment, which seems lacking…

Up 125 Down 11

SH on Nov 14, 2022 at 2:40 pm

Not proceeding seems to be the correct move.

Up 127 Down 16

Roy on Nov 14, 2022 at 2:21 pm

Newsflash for all involved - you can have a "reconciliation" event without it costing $160 million.

It's embarrassing that no one in this article seems to be seriously reflecting on what a terrible and tone deaf decision it would have been to commit to these games right now - instead they are whining and complaining that the federal government (the much hated by Star readers Liberal government) said "the best we can do for this very bad idea is allow you to waste $17 million of Canadian taxpayer money"

The federal Liberals did us a favor. It's like a parent not letting a child play with matches.

Silver and Mostyn should ask for that $17 million to be put directly into housing and farming and for hiring nurses and quit whining about not getting $160 million to be used for a 2 week party disguised as a "reconciliation event"

Up 92 Down 26

Wilf Carter on Nov 14, 2022 at 2:18 pm

This is so ridiculous time to bid on games when we don't have basis in Yukon. All this shows is liberals and this minister is not touch in reality of today.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.