Photo by Whitehorse Star
MLA Don Hutton
Photo by Whitehorse Star
MLA Don Hutton
Don Hutton, the MLA who bolted from the Liberal caucus to sit as an independent, continued to relentlessly prod his former colleagues over alcohol and drug issues.
Don Hutton, the MLA who bolted from the Liberal caucus to sit as an independent, continued to relentlessly prod his former colleagues over alcohol and drug issues.
For the second time this week in question period, Hutton assailed the government over what he sees as inaction on those issues.
On Monday, he sparred with Premier Sandy Silver. On Thursday, he once again took aim at the premier, but his questions were handled instead by two cabinet ministers, as Silver would not engage him.
“Mr. Speaker, we are dealing with two pandemics: COVID-19, and alcohol and substance abuse,” Hutton said.
“This government continues to ignore one of them. I am a firefighter, and any firefighter can tell you that, if you have multiple fires out there, you have to fight more than one at a time. If you don’t, you will find yourself with two raging fires — not one.
“In 2016, our chief medical officer, Dr. Hanley, said — and I quote: ‘We see a thousand visits to the emergency departments of Yukon directly related to alcohol use…’ He called for more resources and policy changes,” Hutton added.
“Mr. Speaker, the premier has followed the advice of Dr. Hanley to deal with COVID-19. Why has the premier ignored him when it comes to alcohol- and drug-related damage to our population?”
That question was answered by Pauline Frost, the minister of Health and Social Services.
“The situation in Yukon that we find ourselves in didn’t start overnight; it has been here a long time. We heard this quite clearly from our communities. That it is not the sole responsibility of this government is what we have also heard,” Frost said.
“We know that the shouldering of the responsibilities of wellness in Yukon and of ensuring our communities are well and taken care of falls on holistic solutions. The holistic solutions with respect to mental wellness and the whole care of individuals come from our communities. We are working with our communities.”
“To suggest that we’re not doing anything is absolutely not true.”
The government is “doing a lot, and the communities are doing a lot,” Frost added.
“We have heard really clearly from one of the communities in the member’s riding where they are doing a lot themselves, with the support of our partners, by hosting land-based camps for men, land-based camps for women, and working with children. “
Hutton didn’t pause his attack on the issue.
“The World Health Organization said in April that rules to protect health and reduce harm caused by alcohol, like restricting access, should be upheld and reinforced during the COVID-19 pandemic, but this past June, the government cut alcohol prices, going against public health advice,” the independent said.
“There are a million ways to support our small businesses to get through this pandemic, but, Mr. Speaker, this was not the right way.
“Making it easier for struggling people to get alcohol was not the right thing to do. More than just ignoring this issue, government has poured gas on this fire.
“Will the premier admit that reducing the price of alcohol in the middle of a pandemic goes against public health advice and was not the right way to support the restaurant and bar industry?”
Community Services Minister John Streicker entered the fray at that point.
“First of all, what I would like to say is that I have worked very closely with the chief medical officer of health,” he said.
“I have worked with him on COVID. I have worked with him on liquor. Actually, he was involved and on the advisory committee as we reviewed the (Liquor) act and rewrote the act and passed it here in this legislature.
“Currently, he is assisting in working on the regulations, which are there to reduce the harms of alcohol.”
That was the whole point of that act, Streicker added.
“We built in, throughout it, social responsibility. In fact, I did ask the member opposite — and I thank him for his contributions to that work.
“At the same time, I also talked to the chief medical officer of health about what we should do around reducing the prices. Now, we didn’t reduce the prices of alcohol, Mr. Speaker. What we did was that we supported those businesses to keep them going. I talked to them directly.
“I talked to those businesses, and I said: ‘If you reduce prices on alcohol, I will drop this right away.’ They understood that this was to support them as businesses through a pandemic — plain and simple.”
Hutton continued to force the issue.
“Right now, many First Nation governments are forced to send people to Victoria at great cost to get the help they need. This is unacceptable, Mr. Speaker.
“I add my voice to councillor Skookum’s and ask the premier to act now to deal with alcohol and substance abuse. When will the premier commit to the financial and human resources required to take care of our people?”
Streicker answered, saying “This pandemic has been tough on all Yukoners. It has been tough on our communities, for sure.
“One of the things that was hard for us was that we used to travel all the time to our communities, and I did travel to the community that the member opposite is talking about. It is his community. I invited him to come to that meeting when I spoke with the council there, but he didn’t make it.
“It doesn’t mean that there aren’t challenges that we continue to face, but we did go — we are in conversation with Carmacks, with Pelly, with Mayo, with Keno.
“In those conversations, we are working directly to make sure that those supports are coming to those communities to support them during this hard time and beyond.”
Later in the day, Hutton had a chance to respond to some of those comments from Streicker in the assembly.
“It’s really disappointing to hear that, because I missed one meeting in Mayo, somehow I’ve failed as the MLA for Mayo-Tatchun,” Hutton said.
“The failure lies on behalf of my colleagues who have been absolutely tone-deaf since 2016 to the MLA for Mayo-Tatchun’s issues.
“I have not asked my government for a lot, but I have asked them to pay attention to my communities. They have been ignored for far too long.
“I really wish that we could have had a half a day for me to have a conversation with my colleagues about the problems that are faced. In 4 1/2 years, my issues were never important enough to sit down and have a meeting with me.”
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (23)
Up 1 Down 0
drum on Mar 18, 2021 at 7:58 pm
He sure loved his paychque as an MLA for the Liberals for the last four years!!!!!!
Up 0 Down 0
Joe on Mar 18, 2021 at 5:38 pm
@ Cilf....sorry pseudo king whoever you are, my name is Joe. Your diatribe brings shame and embarrassment to genuine keyboard warriors. Don't lose sleep - Webster's dictionary 101- or Alt +F7.
Up 4 Down 2
Harvey on Mar 18, 2021 at 8:22 am
When is this guy going to fade into the sunset and write a book no one is ever going to buy?
Up 3 Down 3
Cilf Warter on Mar 17, 2021 at 3:32 pm
@Joe
Case in point there Wilf. Your grammar and spelling give you away every time no matter what name you use.
Up 8 Down 9
Joe on Mar 17, 2021 at 12:54 pm
I for one appreciate Wilf comments and his experience. He steps up with his real name and those keyboard warriors using pseudonyms (Patti like) are the real jokes.
Up 13 Down 11
Anti-go-nish on Mar 15, 2021 at 7:23 pm
I gotta wonder how many sock-puppet accounts Wilf has on here to back up his ramblings.
Wilf is a guy who ran for office more than once but never garnered more than 200 votes. You’d think the guy would figure out that he isn’t marching to the beat of a different drummer but there is no band playing at all. He’s just walking around an open field muttering away.
Sour grapes aren’t very becoming Wilf
Up 8 Down 2
TheHammer on Mar 15, 2021 at 6:41 pm
Dr. C.G.Jung to an alcohol addicted patient: "Your situation is hopeless, there is nothing I can do for you. The only thing you can hope for is a religious conversion."
The man in question had such an experience, and founded the AA program. Mr. Hutton seems to have other ideas. Over the last 40 years millions of dollars have been spent on addictions. All kinds of programs have been implemented, Hundreds of thousands of dollars have gone into the wrong pockets.
YCANADA was a curriculum developed in Yukon for Yukon schools to educate youth about the dangers of Alcohol and Drug addiction (1977-80). The program cost $400000. Why did it end up in Alaska? This is one instance of power & corruption in the field of addictions, and there's plenty more. But who has heard of them, who knows the history? What happened with the Wilderness Treatment Camp that was built in a swamp in Tagish (1988/9? Who was the mastermind behind that debacle, and why was it built to fail, and where did the money go? The field of healing and addictions has become over the last 40 years a giant money making scam.
Up 10 Down 8
Patti Eyre on Mar 15, 2021 at 5:08 pm
@Wilf maybe I do sound that way, but let’s be honest, you sound like you don’t know much about much
Up 11 Down 16
Wilf Carter on Mar 15, 2021 at 10:01 am
Hi Patti - what do you know about NS people? Where are you from? You just sound like Ranj, Sandy and Tracy just know it all but know nothing about real government.
Up 20 Down 17
Patti Eyre on Mar 14, 2021 at 3:11 pm
@wilf: you also are from Nova Scotia! You can’t criticize someone else for being from there, how dense are you?
Up 11 Down 22
Wilf Carter on Mar 14, 2021 at 1:45 pm
El NUEVO Sociopath Ranj Tracy and Sandy are NS rejects and came here thinking they could tell Yukon how and where to live! Plus what's good for them!
The real reason they came here is just to spend your money on things they are interested not what Yukoners need like housing, land development, mental health doctor.
I came because I love the out door life and fell in love with it after the first week. My kids were born here and are Yukoners.
Up 4 Down 7
Clifford on Mar 13, 2021 at 6:50 pm
Why does the term "wart " seem to come to mind for this story?
Up 25 Down 14
La Nuevo Sociopaths on Mar 13, 2021 at 2:48 pm
@ Wilf - I too am sick of the divide and conquer strategy of the Yukon Liberal party. They offer a distasteful and unpalatable brand of politics. They have the gall to speak about human rights, correcting discrimination, and righting the wrongs while actioning and legislating new ones.
They have dehumanized human rights by allowing them to become politicized weapons to afford one group privilege over another in some made up cultural tug of war between the races and the sexes that does not exist and for which they have no evidence. While doing this they have bankrupted current and future generations for decades to come. They should not be allowed to hold any position where they have the ability to make decisions that affect the lives of others.
They should be escorted back to Nova Scotia... And we should give the Province the courtesy of a Dangerous Politician public notification process...
Up 26 Down 13
Wilf Carter on Mar 13, 2021 at 2:21 pm
Our minister of health Pauline Frost states on CBC each community has a mental doctor in it. Which we all know is not true at all.
Up 19 Down 4
Al on Mar 13, 2021 at 2:07 pm
In the late 70's I was posted in Yellowknife. One of the roles the Canadian Armed Forces had in the North was to visit every community at least twice a year primarily to maintain our sovereignty. Many of the communities in the NWT (this was before Nunavut) were dry. This was mandated by the community and not imposed by the government. However, the government and the RCMP honoured the position and assisted in enforcing the measures. These communities were thriving and doing really well both economically and in health. Communities that were "wet" were for the most part the opposite. It was sad to see really. We would fly into one community, visit with the elders and then the next day another community the same. To see the difference between the two (one wet and the other dry) was always quite a shock. So yes it can be done and the proof is in what you see and leadership.
Now to be fair all these communities were for the most part isolated and only serviced by air. However there were several along the McKenzie Highway that were also serviced by road.
Don is right, but really the initiative must and should come from within the community to make it work. It does the need the support and encouragement from all levels of government and the rest of the larger Yukon community.
Up 24 Down 20
Wilf Carter on Mar 13, 2021 at 10:53 am
Just talking to seniors and elders in the Yukon and Yukon liberals are creating a cultural divide between different cultures living and several stated to me all this is going to do is create bad feeling among Yukoners. Folks Sandy Ranj and Tracy are all from Nova Scotia but do not represent NS beliefs or values at all. Just a group of misfits because they show no respect for all Yukoners. I am from NS and can't believe or support the actions of these three!!!!
Up 17 Down 17
Wilf Carter on Mar 13, 2021 at 10:46 am
I have know three mental health doctors who worked in the Yukon and they stated we need at 5 to 6 of them on full time staff to help Yukoners with their problems. Now with CV19 people can't go out. This increases the mental health problems much higher but liberals do nothing to help Yukoners.
Up 27 Down 19
Spud on Mar 13, 2021 at 10:40 am
Ah Hutton - give us a break. We are all tired of you making excuses for drunks who do not wish to stop drinking. This is a community affair who need to give the Police pertinent information. If you are so intelligent, it should start with you, their elected representative. Do something useful.
Up 24 Down 14
Liberal Brain Drain... Literal and Figurative: on Mar 12, 2021 at 6:01 pm
More evidence that Liberalism is a disorder and Liberals are the pathogen. Drugs, alcohol, sex in the streets, and high barriers to the imposition of personal accountability in governance, and the courts... Judicial independence ensuring criminal dependence with Liberal branded social Justice recompense. What an effing brain trust our country has become... Way too many debits in that ledger.
Sandy can take his 30 pieces of Silver and get going because that rooster has long finished its crowing...
Up 29 Down 17
Nathan Living on Mar 12, 2021 at 5:16 pm
Many people are dysfunctional and they do not want to change. Why blame it on the government?
Many government programs for alcohol and drug issues enable dysfunctional people and create an ongoing issue of addiction and dependence.
No simple solution but to blame it all on Sandy Silver and the Liberals is beyond silly.
Up 21 Down 4
bonanzajoe on Mar 12, 2021 at 3:29 pm
150 years, same old, same old, and still no solution. I don't think politicians and Judges want a solution. And for goodness sake, why don't the communities elect leaders that want a solution and have the ba** !!$ to do the job.
Up 56 Down 6
From the community on Mar 12, 2021 at 3:01 pm
Yes. There is a huge issue with alcoholism and drug addiction in the communities. How about spending some money on creating a way to stop the illegal sales of alcohol and drugs. Create Safety patrols for all communities and evictions for people who choose to sell alcohol or drugs? How about a bigger and better alcohol and addiction center for people and aftercare programs such as a sober living facility with check ins? Bootlegging and drug dealing is running rampant in communities and the leaders there need to step up and do something if they truly care for their people. Chiefs and councils need to work with the RCMP to stop bootleggers and dealers. If nothing changes... more people will die from alcoholism or overdose sadly.
Up 44 Down 21
Um. you're lying Streiker on Mar 12, 2021 at 2:43 pm
The argument made for reducing liquor prices wasn't for business's, it had to do with domestic violence. The argument was that if liquor supply was impaired or people had a harder time getting alcohol, there would be an increase in domestic abuse.
I'll add that Hutton is right in adding fuel to the fire. The CERB benefit contributed to the largest arrival of drugs in Whitehorse + alcohol consumption. People who previously didn't have the means to purchase large sums of either of these products were/are buying copious amounts. The crown prosecutor files show a sharp uptick in drug and alcohol related crime.
You know the benefit of telling the truth. You don't have to remember what you said. Because the facts are there.