Photo by Whitehorse Star
Hoby Irwin and Shelly Cuthbert
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Hoby Irwin and Shelly Cuthbert
The Humane Society Yukon has found its way into the black following the settlement of a civil suit against its former board members.
The Humane Society Yukon has found its way into the black following the settlement of a civil suit against its former board members.
The society will receive $61,359 in damages. That will enable it to pay off approximately $50,000 in unpaid bills, president Hoby Irwin explained in an interview today.
The board will put the left-over money toward fund-raising efforts.
"The humane society basically is a fund-raising society,” Irwin said.
"It costs a great deal of money every month to run the (Mae Bachur Animal) shelter, upwards of $20,000 a month, and that's what the board does – we raise funds to run the shelter.”
Along with daily operation costs, Irwin hopes the board will be able to raise enough to finance several renovations. Those would include major repairs to the heating system before the temperature drops in the fall.
The territory's Registrar of Societies brought the suit against the former board members earlier this year after the board failed to comply with the Societies Act.
Philippa Lawson, a government litigator, explained today that this is a very unusual case.
The registrar resorted to filing a civil suit when the society refused to comply with orders he made after having informed the society several times of its violations and having encouraged them to comply voluntarily, she said.
"This is an unusual case,” Lawson said. "It's very unusual for the registrar to step in effectively as a public trustee on behalf of a society in Yukon.
"It only happens in really egregious situations like this, involving societies that perform an important public service to Yukoners, as the Mae Bachur Shelter does, and that receive a lot of government money.
"There's public interest in seeing this particular society function properly, and that's one of the reasons the registrar got involved,” Lawson said.
But the registrar is pleased that the society has been compensated for losses it suffered as a result of the former board's non-compliance with the act, she added.
"I hope that other boards of directors of societies in Yukon will take note of this and will inform themselves of their legal obligations.”
Those obligations extend beyond what's specified in the legislation, she noted, and include common-law and fiduciary duties.
Irwin said he isn't sure why the former board refused to follow the rules, but offered a moral to this story.
"I think whenever you get on a board, you have to know what your obligations are as a board member and what the legal requirements are,” he said.
The settlement will be covered by the board's insurance company, Irwin noted.
"The old board, nobody's out of pocket any money; it's just their reputations which have been soundly trashed,” he said.
In an email statement today, Shelley Cuthbert, the former president of the board, said she hopes the settlement monies will go toward the animals and not to any outstanding small claims court cases.
"The insurance company came to an agreement with the registrar to close this matter. As part of business, insurance companies will settle matters to decrease costs of litigation. This is the same for HSY,” she said.
Eric Dolden, the lawyer who represented the former board members in both the civil suit and their prosecution under the Societies Act in territorial court, did not have a comment on the settlement today.
Three of the former board members have pleaded guilty to the charges under the Societies Act.
They have been sentenced to two years' probation, restricting them from serving on the board of any society under the act.
Cuthbert has pleaded not guilty, and the case will proceed to trial in September.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (19)
Up 0 Down 0
Chris Nemeth on Jun 10, 2013 at 8:30 am
I reacted previously to this article. Please note in doing so my reaction was on behalf of myself and not the HSY Board. The Society has had a rough ride but now is the time to move forward.
Things are back on track and that is what matters most.
Up 0 Down 0
Bob Graham on Jun 8, 2013 at 10:59 pm
Wow, do commentors ever go back & read what they have posted? There are a lot of very hateful words being thrown around! Surely, a good cause such as a Animal Care Center would attract more humane behavior to both other humans as well as animals! A bit of looking in the mirror may be required & think, do I like what I see?
Up 0 Down 0
Freddie T. Yukon on Jun 8, 2013 at 11:22 am
I, for one, am tired of hearing about and from previous Board members.
I don't know about you, but this in-fighting and bickering smacks of High School - and personally, I graduated years ago.
There aren't a whole lot of comments in this thread because, at this point, people DON'T CARE about the baloney that went down in the past. We have new energy at the shelter now. The new BOD is moving things forward and seems able to work together without their personal egos being front row and center, as was the case in the past. In just six months, it has made great strides in regaining public trust for donations, while fixing up previous messes so they can get regular funding again.
During this time, we actually went several weeks at a time without the BOD being on the front page of the newspapers with more news about financial woes and near closures. I, for one, was happy not to hear about the BOD for a while, as the efforts were put towards the animals, repairs and repaying debt incurred under the previous BOD's.
Lost money? Suck it up and move on with your life.
Contrary to what you may think...it's not all about YOU. Not anymore. You had your time in the limelight. Wisdom is knowing when to throw in the towel and regain equilibrium and peace in your life instead of rehashing old news and banging your head against a wall until it bleeds. Nobody cares anymore!
As for your donations...they're really not charitable donations if you have any expectations of reward, payback or kudos. Rehashing what you have done for the shelter smacks of this. Don't give if you can't give freely, with the possibility of not getting reimbursed down the road. Lording it over the faltering shelter when things didn't go your way is bad form. Chalk it up to experience and move on.
I really don't want to read about the previous Board members anymore. I'm tired of the whining, complaining and constant jockeying for position and attempts to curry favour from the reading public.
Up 0 Down 0
Madeleine Girard on Jun 8, 2013 at 9:07 am
The calls that were placed to the RCMP against me were false allegations and I have undeniable proof of it. These allegations have since been withdrawn.
I have no record of ever receiving $400.00 from the HSY. I have asked for a copy of the cheque that was issued to me and no one could produce it.
It only stands to reason that I would have dropped the lawsuit because any new BOD would have had enough foresight to settle with me out of court. For the record, I was approached by the new BOD to settle out of court and this is exactly what I did even though I was not re-elected. That is how I proposed an in-kind receipt.
I am not bitter, angry, nor blaming. I only state facts. I recognize the great work the new BOD has accomplished so far.
I would caution "ruffledfeathers" as to his/her allegations in my regard (e.g. "continues to be a trouble maker in her personal life and work life"). Your comment is slanderous because it is unfounded and untrue. If truly you are a co-worker of mine, I invite you to a private conversation as I would be interested to hear your grievances against me face-to-face.
I will say it again, I have the courage of my opinions and refuse to hide behind a pseudonym. This cannot be said of the majority of postings seen here. I wonder if people would be so quick to post if the Star required people's real name...
Up 0 Down 0
ruffled feathers on Jun 8, 2013 at 2:08 am
First I am not related to Shelley and I do not know her personally. However, I do know the past BOD members and I am a co-Worker of Ms. Girard.
Facts- Ms Girard continues to be a trouble maker in her personal life and work life. The minutes from the past BOD was always posted until someone took them down. RCMP were called on Ms. Girard twice related to HSY - here is the file number-2012-1159259. Ms. Girard benefited twice from HSY as it clearly stated she received a cheque for $400 and no receipts were provided and then the current BOD gives her a in-kind donation, please. Ms. Girard was in charge of fund raising until she resigned. Ms. Girard continues her pursuit to defend her brother- Ovation Construction which caused a lot of the problems related to personal attacks against the previous boards.
The Society was not bankrupt - money had to be spent to keep the facility moving forward. Did anyone read how many animals went in and out of the shelter? The 2 rescues - does that not count as spending money? Changes in the isolation policy etc.
The staff have been at HSY since at least January 2012 what does that say? They are there for the animals.
Again I reiterate- Ovation Construction should not be paid. The company violated City By-Laws, the trailer has a stop work order on it so they cannot use it for any other purpose but storage, they violated the NFC and did not receive the required permits.
The new BOD is working to move things forward but if the BOD pays out ovation construction they will be condoning bad contracting work.
Stop the blame game and move on- Someday people will actually reflect on this and by the way- The other members of the BOD took a plea bargain- I guess you should have been in court to understand what actually happened.
Finally- Ms. Girard did you want to go on record as stating in the AGM "If you elect me to the BOD I will drop my lawsuit against HSY" You were not elected regardless. What type of person are you to basically blackmail the members at the AGM, really? I am glad you are not on the BOD and hope you are never part of the HSY again.
Up 0 Down 0
Madeleine Girard on Jun 7, 2013 at 5:27 am
Incorrect statement:
The owner of Ovation Construction is NOT my husband.
Correct statement:
The owner of Ovation Construction is indeed my brother.
Correction:
My name is MADELEINE GIRARD, not any other spelling combination.
Incorrect statement:
"So you just thought you would come on here to air your dirty laundry and what? Get the support of people for your cause?"
Correct fact:
I have the courage of my opinions, I tell the truth, and do not hide behind a pseudonym. I have not asked anyone to support any cause.
Reiterated statement:
The current BOD has made great positive strides in their short mandate and I support that.
Up 0 Down 0
HSY supporter on Jun 7, 2013 at 12:53 am
A series of bad decisions were made by the previous board, breaking the law, spending unbudgeted money on expensive and ill-conceived fundraising events, hiring a contractor who was brother to a board member (Ms. Girard), etc.)
I disagree that HSY has been "going into the crapper" before that. Previous boards took their responsibilities seriously, as far as I could tell, and nobody bankrupted the society before Shelley's board.
I'm happy to donate to the shelter again now that there's a new board. I've heard the same from a number of other people.
Up 0 Down 0
Concerned Member on Jun 6, 2013 at 9:56 am
Hopefully the past will stay in the past! The new BOD is Doing an amazing job! Go ask the staff for yourself. Everyone is happy as well as the animals. For once the focus is about them and not petty egos. I have also noticed the staff turn around isn't as bad as it used to be so something must be going right.
The money they are getting covers outstanding costs incurred by the previous board. Why they would even consider getting Ms Cuthberts opinion on this is beyond me.
Ruffled feathers- a blame game? Seriously? Ms Cuthbert is the reason the shelter almost went under. Who spends 40,000$ on fundraising only to bring in 19,000$? I get trying Pattison once but doing it a second time after knowing the out come the first time was stupid. The other members of the BOD should have said no. From what I get he was a bully. That being said, it's done and over with and the reputation is going up again. No reason to argue about it.
Good luck to HSY! They are doing a wonderful job!
Up 0 Down 0
Madeleine Girard on Jun 6, 2013 at 9:07 am
Hmmmm... it is a good thing that I am thick skinned and well-wrapped! Those who know me well know my true character and know that I am nothing like what "ruffledfeathers" implies in his/her post.
I believe I am far from trashing the HSY. I have always believed that the HSY is an organization that provides essentials services to the Yukon population and animals in need.
Contrary to "ruffledfeathers's" comments, I have been giving praise to the current BOD for the amazing work they have accomplished so far. I have known one of the directors personally for a great many years and trust to the integrity and good judgement of that person. I also vicariously know about several of the other directors and I am confident that they are responsible, intelligent, and professional people.
I support the HSY by continuing to contribute with cash and in-kind donations for the betterment of the animals in care.
Regarding the owner of Ovation Construction: he is old enough and strong enough to fight his own battles. I do not believe my previous post constitutes any defense of Ovation or the HSY.
My position is that of a concerned HSY member. As a member, I merely suggested that there are cost effective ways to settle disputes. In the end, the BOD will make their own decisions and I will respect that.
As to the in-kind donation receipt I received from the BOD, why would a responsible, sensible BOD not issue it? By making this decision, a court battle was settled, no more money was spent on lawyer fees, no money was issued to me and... In the end, the HSY benefited from a substantial amount of in-kind donations. I see that as a win-win situation.
Anyone - including me - following the current BOD and HSY via their website, Facebook page, and Newsletter will readily see the incredibly positive amount of work accomplished by the new BOD and staff of the Mae Bachur Animal Shelter since last December. Well done everyone! Keep up the great work!
Up 0 Down 0
Get a grip on Jun 6, 2013 at 6:56 am
Ruffled feathers:
I've seen your comments in the News as well. You are a very misinformed individual. Perhaps you need to review the HSY minutes again and read them this time as you will see that there is actually very little in the minutes about any of this discussion as the previous BOD was excellent at "holding” meetings and not recording what was actually discussed - if anything.
I truly don't understand how you can sit there and say that none of this isn't Shelley's fault. She was the president of a non-profit that was almost $100,000 TOTAL, in the red because of her inability to manage and work with the board she had in addition to illegally denying membership to specific people because they had a difference of opinion from her own.
Do you not enjoy the land of democracy that we live in? Would you prefer to be a part of a non-profit that doesn't want your input or opinion in order to make the society better? (these are designed to provide a service to the community - and not to serve the individual—in case you were unsure)
Further, a JUDGE has agreed that this board was responsible for this debt and should have done its due diligence in order to accommodate the members of the society. She did nothing of the sort. Not once has this woman made it seem as though she wanted to work with the other people on the board or even the community.
She has even decided to enter a plea of not guilty? And you want to support her? You must be related or it is Shelley herself writing this drivel. If the other BOD plead guilty and are given 2 years probation and can't serve on any non-profits—what do you think the Leader of the Society who has wasted the taxpayers time with more court costs is going to get from that judge?
I actually feel sorry for those Board Members who got caught up in all this. They were sheep led to slaughter.
Madeline: You were on that board with Shelley were you not? So you just thought you would come on here to air your dirty laundry and what? Get the support of people for your cause? I am guessing you must have something to do with Ovation since you are bringing them up when it is nothing to do with the article but if that is the case I am also guessing that Ovation must be asking for more than they deserve as I see that this New BOD for the society has done nothing but try to get right by the community and back in the black and now you are on here "mediating”...nice
Up 0 Down 0
Joel on Jun 6, 2013 at 5:38 am
Madeline, please leave your personal issues and that of your husband (Ovation Construction) out of other issues the Humane Society faces. 3 presidents of the board plus the boards themselves have decided to continue the lawsuits with your husband's company. I would suggest there is a reason for that.
You keeping this as a personal attack against Shelley Cuthbert does not solve the problems that you have, nor the good work that the current board is doing. I also hope that your bitterness is kept away from the shelter so they can continue to move forward.
Up 0 Down 0
ruffledfeathers on Jun 6, 2013 at 5:25 am
Well Ms Girard it seems like you are up to your old tricks of trashing the HSY once again in an attempt to defend your brother Ovation Construction. HSY current BOD better not pay out Ovation Construction and they should not have given you an in-kind donation. In the minutes it was very clear you were not authorized to spend the money but you chose to do this on your own and pay for things not authorized. Chris once again this BOD is showing their true colours and following the same pattern as other BOD's by playing the blame game. HSY has been in the crapper for years. Stop blaming and fix the problems. Stop allowing this negativity enter into HSY. It appears the previous BOD was trying to do this to save HSY but to many personal attacks as Ms. Girard is starting again.
Up 0 Down 0
Adele Sandrock on Jun 6, 2013 at 4:51 am
Joel - I agree with you. All is the sum of mistakes and infights of previous boards too and it came to a peak with Mrs. Cuthbert.
ruffled feathers:
quote from Mrs. Cuthbert: In an email statement today, Shelley Cuthbert, the former president of the board, said she hopes the settlement monies will go toward the animals and not to any outstanding small claims court cases.
When that is no unsolicited advice, what is it then?
One fact is for sure, Mrs. Cuthbert used the GIC's to pay bills, due to the circumstance they took too many animals into the shelter. She left the shelter without any financial resources and that is not my estimated guess, it is the ugly truth and all for the sake of the animals? Hallooo
Previous boards nursed their inflated ego's as well but Mrs. Cuthbert brought it to new heights. Amen.
Up 0 Down 0
ruffled feathers on Jun 6, 2013 at 3:34 am
Adele not sure what you are referring to with Ms. Cuthbert and giving advice. I do not recall her ever giving advice in the papers besides defending what was actually going on. She didn't run HSY to the ground. If you would have been following the facts you would have seen it was all about a contract dispute. In my opinion HSY should have questioned that contractor. Instead of resolving the contract dispute in court they made it personal. Personal does not mix with business and HSY is a business.
Up 0 Down 0
Madeleine Girard on Jun 5, 2013 at 2:29 pm
I am not in the habit of commenting on the issues surrounding the HSY. However, I feel I can't keep quiet on this one.
Regarding: "In an email statement today, Shelley Cuthbert, the former president of the board, said she hopes the settlement monies will go toward the animals and not to any outstanding small claims court cases."
What is Ms. Cuthbert trying to achieve here? In my opinion, her statement implies that the current BOD is unable to make responsible, wise decisions.
The public should be made aware that the current BOD used the settlement dollars to pay for debts incurred during Ms. Cuthbert's reign.
In my opinion, Ms. Cuthbert's e-mail statement feeds misinformation to the public.
For the public's information, I filed a Small Claims lawsuit against the HSY when former president Cuthbert refused to reimburse me for expenses I had incurred on behalf of the Society.
Shortly after the new BOD was elected, I proposed to settle out of court in return for a donation-in-kind receipt. My offer was readily accepted by the BOD. This means the HSY effectively received a donation from me in excess of $1600.00. This, over and above numerous other cash and in-kind donations I made -and continue to make- to the HSY over the past two and a half years. Pretty good yearly donation average by one individual to one organization! (not very humble you will say but I feel this disclosure necessary to support my point).
Those of you who follow the news related to the HSY will know that there remains an unsettled lawsuit against the HSY. This lawsuit remains pending because the new president, Mr. Springford refused two approaches by Ovation Construction to meet out-of-court to attempt to reach a settlement and stop the mounting court expenses (This now bears the questions: Who is paying for the HSY lawyer fees? Is the lawyer providing free services to the Society?).
Since Mr. Springford's resignation, the remaining board members gave direction to the lawyer to carry on with the lawsuit - this in spite of one more attempt for an out-of-court settlement on the part of Ovation Construction.
In my opinion, the continuation of this lawsuit could easily have been avoided had the current BOD agreed to meet out-of-court with the contractor. Mediation is a lot let onerous on everyone, helps create win-win results, assists in removing misconceptions, and helps alleviate ill feelings between the parties.
The new BOD has accomplished a tremendous amount of positive work so far. Could mediation be one more positive action on the part of the new board? Another glowing feather in their cap?
Up 0 Down 0
Joel on Jun 5, 2013 at 12:39 pm
It was going into the crapper long before Shelley got there. I am just hoping they can keep on the right track now.
Up 0 Down 0
Bella Toscana on Jun 5, 2013 at 10:07 am
The shelter has only 3 cats and 5 dogs...
Why does it take $20,000 per month, and 9+ employees, to care for these numbers?
We had more pets than this at one time, and somehow managed....
Up 0 Down 0
Chris Nemeth on Jun 5, 2013 at 7:37 am
The current board will now be able to settle all outstanding bills. Some of these relate to law suits started by the previous board.Shame on Shelley for suggesting that the present board might misuse Societies funds.
Up 0 Down 0
Adele Sandrock on Jun 5, 2013 at 6:08 am
I wonder what has to happen in order that Mrs. Cuthbert is remaining silent for a change and is not giving unsolicited advice - she ran the HSY into the crapper.