Photo by Photo Submitted
A YOUNG LIFE LOST – After 17-year-old Brandy Vittrekwa (above) was assaulted, she was abandoned on a trail in the McIntyre subdivision, where she later died.
Photo by Photo Submitted
A YOUNG LIFE LOST – After 17-year-old Brandy Vittrekwa (above) was assaulted, she was abandoned on a trail in the McIntyre subdivision, where she later died.
Yukon territorial court has heard about the night a young man assaulted 17-year-old Brandy Vittrekwa and abandoned her on a trail, causing her death.
Yukon territorial court has heard about the night a young man assaulted 17-year-old Brandy Vittrekwa and abandoned her on a trail, causing her death.
On Tuesday afternoon, Crown prosecutor David McWhinnie read an agreed statement of facts he and the defence counsel had signed.
He reminded the court the young man, who was 15 as of last December, had pleaded guilty to manslaughter.
“He admits he is responsible,” said McWhinnie.
After asking the defence whether his client understood what the plea meant, Judge Peter Chisholm found the man guilty of manslaughter.
Anything that could identify the young man can’t be published due to his age.
On the night of her death, he contacted Vittrekwa on Facebook, inviting her to drink at a friend’s place.
He, Vittrekwa and another friend drank alcohol and socialized for several hours that night.
He tried to kiss her twice, and she found the attempt comical, the prosecutor said.
Both young people were intoxicated when they left their friend’s house.
It’s not clear what her intended direction was, but the young man offered to walk with her.
They were last seen near Elijah Smith Elementary school walking toward Granger – away from where Vittrekwa’s body was found.
Her body was discovered on the walking trails of the McIntyre subdivision on Dec. 8, 2014.
There was considerable blood, the prosecutor said.
Her face was swollen and bruised. Drag marks were found, and blood stains were in those drag marks.
The sequence of events surrounding the assault is not clear, McWhinnie said.
Vittrekwa’s coat was also found by a resident, and had blood stains. It’s not clear how she became separated from it.
Cell phone records show all activity had stopped at around 1:45 a.m. that night.
The temperature was between zero and -3 C that night in Whitehorse.
The autopsy revealed blunt force trauma to Vittrekwa’s face and neck and a broken jaw.
There was no evidence of sexual assault.
The exact cause of death couldn’t be ascertained, as it was likely a combination of asphyxiation, intoxication and exposure that killed her.
On Dec. 8, 2014, the Monday following Vittrekwa’s death, the young man had swollen knuckles, the prosecutor said, according to what his mother told the police.
He came back early from school that day saying he was unwell.
Three days later, he was arrested but charged for other matters.
RCMP officers noted his right hand to be swollen at the time.
A search warrant executed on Dec. 12, 2014 yielded a hoodie and shoes, both with blood stains matching Vittrekwa’s DNA.
The man was re-arrested on April 28, 2015.
The following day, he was charged with the second-degree murder of Vittrekwa.
He pleaded guilty on Dec. 17, 2015 to the lesser included offence of manslaughter.
Vittrekwa was a Gwich’in citizen.
The man isn’t a Kwanlin Dün First Nation citizen.
The Crown had filed an application for the young man to receive an adult sentence, but that doesn’t mean he will necessarily go forward with it.
“However, we are required on an ongoing basis to review and reconsider whether we can or will still proceed with such an application,” McWhinnie told the Star today.
The final decision on whether to ask the judge to come down with an adult sentence will be made once several reports about the young man have been done, he said.
Defence lawyer David Tarnow told the court he wants his client to get a proper Gladue report – a report that looks at systematic issues surrounding an aboriginal person’s life to be considered during sentencing.
He noted there have been problems with getting such reports done in the territory.
A sentencing hearing has been scheduled for May 20.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (26)
Up 0 Down 0
mary laker on Feb 23, 2016 at 5:43 pm
Why in the world would anybody give North 60 a thumbs down for informing them of the FACTS about murdered and missing aboriginal women? (and as an aside, the fact that far more men than women altogether are murdered and missing).
These facts must be really inconvenient to some people for some reason. I thought the idea was to find out what is going on and STOP IT. Not to brush reality under the rug because it doesn't jive with the tune that some people prefer.
Men are killing first nations women who they know or live with. That's 92% of the story right there, and 44% of them are drunk when they do it. Now if you want to ask why they are drunk, why they are violent, or how you can put a stop to it, fine. But let's stop pretending and let's start dealing with reality. It's a good place to start.
A drunk young man killed this FN girl. They knew each other. Fits the pattern. That's all.
Up 58 Down 0
SCallison on Feb 21, 2016 at 9:49 pm
For this boy to have go so wrong by 15 yrs old, I really think his parents or caregivers have to shoulder some of the blame. Don't get me wrong, he deserves to be punished, the moment he stepped over from victim of circumstance to murder he lost my sympathy, but I feel that his parents deserve to bear some responsibility for how he ended up so wrong, so young. That awful night, all it would have taken to change the outcome is one of those kids parents to say "where are you going?" "Who are you going with?, What time are you coming home? What time should I pick you up? That is 1 adult out of a possible 6 counting the unknown "friend" and it didn't happen and it's very sad, and by the way I am First Nations and for that to be an issue is ridiculous, she was first and foremost a human, her race should be a non issue.
Up 25 Down 17
Ban the trolls on Feb 20, 2016 at 1:58 pm
North 69 et all,
Have you ever heard "you can't see the forest for the trees"?
You people need to collectively get a life, all this hate will come back on you. Is there not something better you can be doing with your lives, volunteer or something.
Up 22 Down 2
ProScience Greenie on Feb 20, 2016 at 12:44 pm
Racism exists Politico but what you are seeing here is basic sadness, anger and outrage about the brutality of the incident. The racism that does exist is also very complex with many elephants in the room that get in the way of solving the issue(s).
Up 21 Down 0
valorie smokeyday on Feb 20, 2016 at 12:08 pm
The young lady deserves justice. In this day and age you never hit women or girls it is not acceptiable. I am a mother of a daughter who was murdered 11 yrs now still waiting for justice. Never found who did this horrible crime and took my baby's life
Up 22 Down 39
north_of_60 on Feb 19, 2016 at 8:29 pm
According to the RCMP:
6,420 missing persons in Canada 1,455 are women, out of those 164 are aboriginal
88% of murders of aboriginal women have been solved by police
89% of murders of non-aboriginal women have been solved by police
Between 1980 and 2012 there were 20,313 murders in Canada 6,551 of those victims were women and 1,017 of those were aboriginal women.
Almost 30% of the 1,017 aboriginal women were murdered by their husbands.
23% were murdered by another family member.
30% were murdered by an acquaintance.
So, only about 8% of aboriginal women were murdered by strangers.
44% of the family members and acquaintances who kill aboriginal women were drunk
74% of the murderers of aboriginal women are unemployed.
71% of the murderers of aboriginal women already had a criminal record.
53% had been convicted before of a violent crime;
62% had a history of violence with the specific murder victim herself.
Up 15 Down 16
SCallison on Feb 19, 2016 at 5:17 pm
I wonder about the parents of these children, I have a 17 yr old, he has a social life but I know where he is 90 percent of the time, and he is at home every night. I have never allowed "sleepovers" exactly because it allows to much room for nonsense like drinking and hooking up. Maybe that's old fashioned but my child is alive not in jail.
Up 37 Down 5
he should have known better on Feb 19, 2016 at 12:06 pm
people who say that... he should have known better. You can say that about any crime.
Up 43 Down 13
Yukoner on Feb 19, 2016 at 11:52 am
@Politico, This has nothing to do with race. A fifteen year old boy (SMASHED) the face of a young woman and killed her. I'm very sorry for her family which is first nations so that there in itself is me not being a racist. Now if that was my son that did that and if I raised a monster like that I would take him on that walk myself.
Up 22 Down 16
Mandeep on Feb 19, 2016 at 11:06 am
I think the native issue is kind of not at play here. Just recently a young teen made a dumb decision and ended up killing one person and ruining the life of another.
He could have done much worse...
http://bc.ctvnews.ca/killers-had-sex-with-dead-teen-court-hears-1.624429
Rahteah Parsons would be another example.
Teens have issues.
Matt De Grood - all walks of life have killers within them
Up 37 Down 10
Come on! on Feb 19, 2016 at 9:19 am
Come on North of 60 do you honestly believe that the M&MIW issue is strictly a indigenous problem.
I take it you have heard of Robert Pickton? I am sure once the Inquiry is complete you will have a much different picture then the one you have now.
Up 6 Down 41
Josey Wales on Feb 19, 2016 at 8:34 am
hey Yukoner...indeed he would, hence my attempts to reference a very fitting... Trevor the human, we have many.
Almost like we need a spay & neuter campaign "moved forward"
To the Trevor the human types, stay away from ol' Josey I play for keeps.
As is my primal right to preserve my breath, however it's done...matters not.
Up 27 Down 31
Politico on Feb 18, 2016 at 10:56 pm
Yukoner, he is a product of our racist society.
Congratulations, you're a member
Up 42 Down 9
GERALD MORRISSETTE on Feb 18, 2016 at 8:17 pm
GIV BRANDY THE JUSTICE SHE NEEDS MAXIMUM PUNISHMENT
Up 33 Down 14
wolverine on Feb 18, 2016 at 4:59 pm
Dogs that attack, maul, or kill humans are put down for good reason.
It's in their nature and can't be 'cured'.
Up 116 Down 53
Incredulous on Feb 18, 2016 at 4:23 pm
He beat her with his fists so badly that he broke her jaw. His hands were still swollen several days later. If this was my son, I would be the one pushing for maximum punishment. If this happened because she turned down his advances, what are you going to tell his next girlfriend if he gets a slap on the wrist and doesn't learn to control his temper? He will do this again. If he thinks hitting a woman or girl is ok, he will do this again.
Being young and drunk is not an excuse. Whatever his own background is, is not an excuse. I was abused horribly during my childhood and assaulted as an adult and I've never used it as an excuse to go beat the hell out of someone else.
Brandy deserves justice. Do not fail her.
Up 77 Down 37
Yukoner on Feb 18, 2016 at 2:00 pm
@Yukontrapper he is not a product of my community. If that was a dog that did that it would be put down. Do you see where I'm going with this? Unforgivable.
Up 60 Down 72
north_of_60 on Feb 18, 2016 at 1:29 pm
This case exemplifies the whole 'murdered and missing women' issue.
In nearly every case they're murdered by another aboriginal they know, and drugs and alcohol are involved.
Those who want yet another 'inquiry' are strangely silent on this.
Up 68 Down 41
moe on Feb 18, 2016 at 1:02 pm
Yukontrapper, "young boy"? He was 15 years old! I remember being in high school, 1200 teenagers for 5 years (in Ontario), and never, not once did anyone get drunk and beat someone to death for no particular reason. In fact not for a reason either!
This 'young boy' is psychotic in my opinion, and there's not much chance that his life is not already 'ruined'.
Up 101 Down 57
NWT on Feb 18, 2016 at 10:57 am
Gladue report seriously? He's 15 how much of a report could there be? Gladue report for Manslaughter is absolutely ridiculous. You can't blame your upbringing and whatever this guy went through on taking a life. It does not make sense to me. This 15 year old should be tried as an adult and given an adult sentence. Give Brandy the justice she deserves.
Up 44 Down 42
Josey Wales on Feb 17, 2016 at 9:57 pm
hmm a Y.O.A / Gladue royalty?
2nd to manslaughter, how Canadian.
Should be the hardest few weekends of its life.
Up 104 Down 52
Just Say'in on Feb 17, 2016 at 9:47 pm
You say you want to find justice for your Missing and Murdered. Here is your chance, don't let this guy walk. Adult Court and no plea negotiations. This is where the problems are, in the courts and their home communities.
Up 45 Down 102
Jean Dacko on Feb 17, 2016 at 9:19 pm
No one is a write off at 15. These two could be anyone's children who got drunk and out of control. What the lad did is terrible but no one knows the circumstances around it nor his circumstances nor his life. No one said it was acceptable.
Up 51 Down 96
Yukontrapper on Feb 17, 2016 at 8:28 pm
I was a friend of Brandy it's horrible that this happened.. but we cannot destroy 2 lives from this. One has been destroyed from this. The young boy who did this has to be punished no doubt about it but we cannot give up on this kid. He is a product of our community and we as a community should make damn sure that another tragedy doesn't occur, both by ruining this guy's life or letting him go without proper rehabilitation so he offends again. Keep him in the youth system don't allow him to be sent to the college of criminals known as the adult system.
Up 89 Down 42
Lock him away FOREVER on Feb 17, 2016 at 7:08 pm
I realize we can't say anything to identify the murderer....so I won't. He needs to be sentenced AS AN ADULT!!!! He committed MURDER in the first degree, doesn't matter what he pleaded to!!! Gladue or other documentation of his past isn't going to change anything. Lock him away to get some help and for heaven's sake, don't give him the legal sentence of 3-4 years for this crime.
Imagine all of the help many of us tried to give him and look at what he did. He is a complete waste of life, resources and now he'll get some slap on the wrist sentence for torturing Brandy before he brutally murdered her.
Up 172 Down 103
Yukoner on Feb 17, 2016 at 3:59 pm
If that is acceptable for him at fifteen he is already a write off.