Whitehorse Daily Star

Government ‘not confident’ in Takhini Transport

The territory’s school bus system is about to make another U-turn with transportation providers.

By Aimee O'Connor on July 14, 2015

The territory’s school bus system is about to make another U-turn with transportation providers.

On July 6, the Department of Education gave formal notice to school bus company Takhini Transport of its intent to terminate its existing busing contracts for students.

Ronuk Modha, the department’s communications director, told the Star this morning there had been concerns regarding safety and operations in the company that had triggered the department to closely monitor the company’s services for the past year.

The Star has obtained access to a July 30, 2014, letter from Valerie Royle, the former deputy minister of Education. It was obtained by the opposition New Democrats under the Yukon’s access to information legislation.

It details several areas within the contract Takhini Transport had failed to comply with.

According to the letter, the bus company had failed in the following areas:

• to meet bus certification requirements;

• to have buses serviced and repaired by a certified mechanic; and

• to provide proof of documentation for a number of drivers in the areas of RCMP checks, first aid certificates, defensive driving, smart driver for school bus training, Yukon driver examiner road test, assertive discipline training and driver abstract.

In the letter, Royle stated, “The above deficiencies are substantial and their rectification important to ensuring the safety of children to and from the commute to school.”

“We found something that points out that there have been concerns over two years of service,” Lois Moorcroft, the NDP’s Highways and Public Works critic, told the Star early this afternoon.

“My question is whether or not the government made sure those deficiencies were rectified.”

Moorcroft noted that the opposition did ask questions of the government during the 2014-2015 school year, but did not receive any information back.

Within a week of school starting last August, frustrated parents created an outlet for complaints – a Facebook called “Concerns with Whitehorse School Busses (sic)”.

A range of problems were reported on the Facebook group including buses that simply didn’t show up, and kindergarteners dropped off at high school and being told to walk to their elementary school.

As well, kids were dropped off on the busy Alaska Highway, and there were issues about the new school bus schedule that had been newly implemented.

“Towards the end of the school year, we were just not confident that the company could provide the level of service that we needed and were essentially required by contract to provide for the upcoming school year,” Modha said.

The 30-day notice given to Takhini Transport applies to the termination of the two busing contracts that were ratified on July 1, 2013.

Both contracts – one applying to Whitehorse and the other at the territory’s rural communities – were set to run until June 30, 2018.

The contracts are valued at about $14 million – a pretty price tag for other transport companies.

Modha confirmed that the department is “examining their options” and had had discussions with other bus companies.

Standard Bus Contracting Yukon, the company that held the school busing contract before Takhini Transport, confirmed this morning that the government has been in “talks” with it, but nothing has been finalized as of yet.

Standard Bus Yukon ran an advertisement in the Star last Friday looking for part-time charter and school bus drivers.

The ad states, “If being part of child’s education by getting them to and from school safely and in a comfortable environment is important to you then we will help you get the above qualifications needed, with your commitment, we can make this happen.”

Ron Swizdaryk, Standard Bus Yukon’s general manager, said the advertisement is a standard one the company runs every couple of years. It is not related to the conversations being held with the government about school bus contracts, he said.

Standard Bus and Takhini Transport have competed against each other for busing contracts in the past.

In 2011, Calgary-based Standard bus was the lowest bidder for a two-year contract in all 10 Yukon communities, shutting out Takhini Transport for the first time in a decade.

It was Takhini Transport, however, which outbid Diversified Transportation in 2001, taking over school busing in most communities which had been held by Standard Bus’ subsidiary for about 30 years.

Modha stated that the department’s main focus and priority at this point are to ensure there are buses on the roads for the beginning of the school year and minimize disruptions to families of the 2,000 students Takhini Transport had been ferrying in the territory.

“Bus service is essential,” Moorcroft said.

“The government needs to have a contingency plan that they can operate at (short notice).”

Takhini Transport owner Ernie Jamieson could not be reached for comment before press deadline this afternoon.

According to a Yukon Employees Union press release, there are about 70 workers with Takhini Transport.

Comments (9)

Up 16 Down 0

Just Sayin' on Jul 18, 2015 at 2:35 pm

This is disgusting! If the buses were so unsafe why in the world did they let the children continue to ride them? Should Valarie Royle's information be trusted? Oh, someone was driving with a record, perhaps one should inquire as to what the record was for? IF it was for a DUI 20 years ago then should it not be forgiven? I mean really, we have Minister's in cabinet who have been pardoned for their actions and we still let them be part of the Government (Wade, Darius) just to name a few!

Up 38 Down 32

@what on Jul 16, 2015 at 12:19 pm

Not confident in Takhini Transport ? I am way less confident of the dept of education and even less of the govt. Nothing like laying everywhere but where it belongs, unfortunately for the employees of Takhini Transport, they don't have the government employee's union to cry foul.

Up 30 Down 2

north_of_60 on Jul 15, 2015 at 10:49 pm

There's enough school bus work for both companies. One could take the North end and the other take the South.
Government mismanagement by inept bureaucrats and politicians has been the biggest problem for both bus companies.

Up 62 Down 0

Gord Bradshaw on Jul 15, 2015 at 2:24 pm

As a driver for Takhini I never felt that the children were placed in unsafe conditions. A huge part of the trouble was that the department decided to re-write the schedules. To do this they brought in someone with no student transportation experience who didn't put much stock in the information they received from both Takhini Transport and the Dept. of Ed. people who knew how the runs worked.

The result was a huge mess when the new schedules were introduced. Much of the public blamed Takhini for the things that didn't work, not realizing they were contractually obligated to follow the Department's new schedules.

Up 62 Down 1

Guncache on Jul 15, 2015 at 7:42 am

"As well, kids were dropped off on the busy Alaska Highway". To the best of my knowledge this has been standard practice since buses started picking kids up. We are talking decades here. What is the bus supposed to do, pull into a driveway? And is there some reason kids can't walk to a central point and get picked up? Does the bus have to stop every block to pick up and drop off? I used to walk a mile to catch the bus.

Up 62 Down 5

Joseph Campbell on Jul 14, 2015 at 10:12 pm

Lois Morecoft, always looking for a platform to present her BS. If her NDP asked questions over the years, why didn't the public hear about it? The truth is the bureaucracy created most of the problems with the schedules when they ignored the advice from the seasoned and experienced bus drivers. The schedules for the most part didn't have to be changed, but the wise bureaucrats had to have it their way. Kids are always picked up and dropped off on the Alaska hwy, that's why they have signs for pick up areas along the highway. That is not going to change. And I believe that only one child was dropped off at the FH Collins high school and the child just walked across the lawn to Selkirk (I walked 4 miles to school and back everyday in Northern Ont. from grade one. We didn't have school buses.) Granted, there were a few minor problems, but we experienced bus drivers got our children to school and home safely. And for that, we are proud of the work we do. So, Ms Morecroft, shove the politics.

Up 4 Down 29

Duh on Jul 14, 2015 at 9:17 pm

Surprised they lasted as long as they did. Takinni transports service was poor at best. I'm sure there is a lot of happy bus drivers right now.

Up 77 Down 9

blame where blame is due on Jul 14, 2015 at 3:44 pm

ok....so the standards part and the buses not being serviced, etc, sure they didn't live up to that.

But for the service part, wasn't that the Government's cluster-f? Didn't they create the schedules? And wasn't it bad, disorganized parents who didn't get their kids' info in on time that created the terrible schedule that didn't work? You can't penalize the bus company for that.

Up 44 Down 45

rocket science on Jul 14, 2015 at 3:20 pm

Shocking. Standard Bus Contracting did a great job; why YG switched back to Takhini Transport but to save a few dollars at the expense of safety and care is beyond me. Glad to see Takhini Transport out, although I wish the drivers well - that is NOT an easy job, regardless of what people might assume.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.