Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Pictured Above: BRAD CATHERS and KRISTINA CRAIG

Government invites affordable rental units proposals

The Yukon government is looking for ideas to solve the territory's affordable rental housing crisis.

By Ainslie Cruickshank on October 24, 2013

The Yukon government is looking for ideas to solve the territory's affordable rental housing crisis.

A request for qualifications, issued Wednesday afternoon, asks businesses and NGOs to submit project proposals to create and operate affordable rental units.

Brad Cathers, the minister responsible for the Yukon Housing Corp., said in a release the government intends to use the remaining $13 million of its Northern Housing Trust monies to stimulate construction of affordable rental units in the territory.

"We encourage proponents to consider inventive housing solutions that will endure for the long term, as there will always be a need for affordable rental accommodations,” Cathers said in the release.

The minister was not made available for an interview with the Star before deadline this afternoon.

Kristina Craig, the co-ordinator of the Yukon Anti-Poverty Coalition, said today the organization is pleased with the announcement.

"We've been talking about the need for more affordable rental stock for a long time,” she said. "So, no time like the present.”

But both opposition parties raised significant concerns.

"It's kind of like Groundhog Day, honestly, I'm like, ‘woah, this looks really familiar,'” Kate White, the NDP's housing critic, said this morning.

"What's different from what they did with Lot 262, where people came forward with innovative ideas for affordable rentals and the government didn't move forward?” she asked.

In the spring of 2012, the government tendered a project that was to include 30 affordable rental units, to be developed near the intersection of Range Road and Mountainview Drive.

The project was abandoned after the government received only two bids.

At the time Cathers, then minister of Energy, Mines and Resources, said neither bid met the minimum requirements. Both asked for subsidies beyond the scope of the tender, he said.

Now, instead of asking the public for their innovative ideas, White said it would be "fantastic” if the government brought forward its own, evidence-backed solution to shop around.

The Takhini-Kopper King MLA also wondered about the timing of the announcement, noting the government's housing strategy is still in development.

"I've got good communication with different groups in the community, and I know that there is a collaborative effort going forward on the housing strategy, and that gives me hope,” she said.

"But to talk about bringing in private developers and construction companies right now without that strategy being done, I wonder if it will cover the full continuum or if this is just kind of a feel-good, it's almost winter, so let's talk about housing.”

Michael Hale, the housing corporation's vice-president of operations, said the government "can't stop operating and make people wait while we develop a plan for the next 10 years.

"It's not in any way trying to upset that process; we're simply trying to make sure while we develop a housing action plan for the next 10 years we're still paying attention to the present,” he added.

Sandy Silver, the interim leader of the Liberal party, raised frustrations that the government's been sitting on the remaining northern trust money for seven years.

"Any time you asked in the legislative assembly ‘why aren't you spending this money?' the answers that we got back, all opposition parties got back, was that ‘this is complicated; you can't just spend this money, it's earmarked for very specific funding,'” Silver said.

"If you're going to get a request for qualifications that should have happened seven years ago. But we've been waiting and waiting and waiting for them to give us a plan and then at the very last possible phase they say ‘well, here's our plan, we're back to square one,” he said.

"This come downs to Yukon Party government classic mismanagement of capital money.”

The request for qualifications will close Nov. 19.

Any projects funded under this process must be able to guarantee affordable rental rates for at least a decade.

The housing corporation has adopted the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp.'s definition of "affordable,” according to Wednesday's release.

That means the rental rates must remain at or below 95 per cent of the median rates. The median rent for Whitehorse in June 2013 was $875 monthly.

Proponents must also be able to provide 50 per cent of the funding for the project, but Hale explained that could come in the form of land, or commercial partnerships.

The only stipulation is that the northern trust money can only be used for the housing component of any project.

Following the request for qualifications, successful proponents will be asked to participate in a more formal and detailed request for proposals process.

During this stage, proponents will receive a stipend to help offset the cost of developing the proposal, Hale said, noting the government's intention to equalize the process for private sector and NGO participants.

In 2006, the Yukon government received $50 million in funding from the Northern Housing Trust.

Of that, $32.5 million was shared among Yukon First Nations, while the territory retained the remaining $17.5 million.

Betty's Haven, a second-stage housing project for women and their children fleeing abuse, received $4.5 million of the territory's portion of the funding.

The government has yet to spend the remaining $13 million.

"Yukon Housing Corporation's five-year strategic plan is focused on helping to alleviate the most pressing housing challenges,” said Claire Derome, the corporation's board chair.

"I look forward to reviewing the innovative ideas put forward by proponents to this request for qualifications and proposals.”

Comments (7)

Up 9 Down 0

T Steele on Oct 28, 2013 at 1:50 pm

Jackie, your comment definitely isn't cold hearted it is just uneducated.

First of all whitehorse's crime rate has only showed a slight increase since the new jail opened which I guarantee is no fault of the "posh" stigma that is behind the new jail. Our crime rates are still much lower then they were in 2003.

Back to housing; when people are forced into social assisted housing programs most do not look at it as a freebie. It is a stepping stone for young families, seniors, and victims of domestic abuse to get back on there feet and move along. When a mother and her kids are forced out of their home on a January night, where do you expect them to go, the Salvation Army? There is no place for them to stay. What about when grandma or grandpa is forced into retirement due to age? Well there's social assisted housing for that too. You make it seem like anybody can just quit their job, stop paying taxes and live the good life. This sort of thinking is nothing more than ignorant and to me, lies around the same ideology. I am healthy, why do I need to pay taxes for those pesky hospitals?

Up 5 Down 2

Hello on Oct 28, 2013 at 8:29 am

Why, I must ask, First Nations are always part of the discussion? I work for a living and am a responsible "FN" person! Is this proposed Affordable Housing geared to just First Nations? I don't think so. Maybe some people did go to school, had a full time job and a house to live in, but due to unforeseen circumstances, had to walk away or maybe they were dealing with addictions, who knows? I have been there, I am lucky to have people in my life to support me and believe in me! The people that you see on the street are not "dumb" they are down on their luck. Believe me, if there is some sort of help out there, they will take it. A place to hang their hat at night, may be a stepping stone. Who knows?

Up 7 Down 2

Keeping an Eye on it on Oct 28, 2013 at 3:17 am

If the government allows the money to be spent at the same rate as it was for Betty's Haven ($4.5 million for 10 one bedroom units), we can expect to gain 29 one bedroom apartments for this $13 million. At least if it is private sector, we will not also be paying for supervision, management and upkeep of the 29 units.

Up 14 Down 5

yukoner168 on Oct 25, 2013 at 9:54 am

Just curious what happened to the 32.5 million given to Yukon First Nations throughout the territory? Is there any information as to where that money was spent? If the money came from the Northern Housing Trust should that money have been used to create affordable housing? If it was where and how was it spent?

Jackie It is great that you think for yourself and that you believe that you should ask the "hard" questions. However I would like to know what you have done to combat the "apathy" besides make grandiose statements about systemic social problems that you appear to have limited knowledge on.

I agree that the current government appears to be creating more problems then solving them at this time.

Up 10 Down 4

Arn Anderson on Oct 25, 2013 at 5:47 am

It would be nice to hear some stories from the people who benefited from affordable housing. I'm glad they are exploring ways to spend this money effectively and in the best possible way. I have my own ideas, maybe I should submit them.

Up 17 Down 13

Jackie Ward on Oct 24, 2013 at 9:21 am

You people have no clue of what the repercussions you create with this.

New jail? Crime goes up because it's a 5 star hotel. Free housing? Why work? Why be productive?

You will just cause more people to look at these types of things as freebies. If me, as a tax payer get no freebies, then why is it so weird to expect people who pay no taxes to get nothing. They contribute nothing to society.

I'm not cold hearted, I just speak the facts. This type of thinking will just make the problem worse. Why don't you people with your high paid education and jobs see this? You know these actions will solve nothing but will make it appear you are trying to solve the problem when in reality you will create more lazy people who just see the government as an entity to support them.

I'm so sick and tired of this. Why can't they teach common sense and critical thinking skills in college? Why? Because they don't want a society full of people like me who think for themselves and ask those tough questions. They just want a dumbed down population who follows ever order they get with their head down. Our society is pathetic. And yes, your apathy is part of the problem. *shrugs shoulders, what can I do about it"

Up 16 Down 0

yukoner on Oct 24, 2013 at 7:48 am

Whistle bend, great empty field go build there

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.