Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

ENTERS NEW PLEA – The trial of Tamara Goeppel (above), the Yukon Liberal Party candidate in Whitehorse Centre in the November 2016 election, took a major turn this morning when she pled guilty to one count of violating the Yukon Elections Act.

Goeppel guilty of one offence; two counts withdrawn

A one-time Yukon Liberal Party election candidate pled guilty to one offence under the Yukon Elections Act this morning.

By Palak Mangat on August 28, 2018

A one-time Yukon Liberal Party election candidate pled guilty to one offence under the Yukon Elections Act this morning.

The remaining two charges were withdrawn – after testimony that had taken place over two days.

Whitehorse businesswoman Tamara Goeppel was the Liberals’ candidate in Whitehorse Centre in the November 2016 election, losing to incumbent NDP Leader Liz Hanson.

In February 2017, Goeppel was charged with three counts of violating the act:

• two counts of “aiding or abetting persons in making proxy applications”; and

• one count of “inducing persons to falsely declare on proxy applications that they would be absent” from the territory during the designated hours for voting.

Goeppel had initially pled not guilty to all three charges going into this week’s territorial court trial, which began Monday.

Late this morning, however, her lawyer, Robert Fowler, entered the plea after court was briefly recessed.

“We’re well aware of the allegations,” Fowler told the court, noting that the case has garnered significant attention in the last two years.

Monday and today saw two witnesses testify: David Wilkie, the assistant chief electoral officer with Elections Yukon, and Earl MacLeod, a one-time Whitehorse resident who testified this morning via video link from Vernon, B.C.

At least five people were subpoenaed by the Crown, Monday’s proceedings showed, with some not responding.

Before a court break yesterday, it was mentioned that some of those subpoenaed may have been dealing with alcohol and drug addictions or living without a fixed address, perhaps making it difficult for them to respond.

That was in line with Goeppel’s remarks to the charges: she was accused of arranging proxy voting for 10 homeless people, according to a November 2017 release from the Yukon Liberals.

She had previously said the plight of vulnerable people was close to her heart. She told the CBC in 2017 that’s partly why she was working to make their voices heard by encouraging them to vote.

Police charged her several months after the election.

Proxy ballots are meant for those who will likely be away from the territory on advance polling days.

The first witness, Wilkie, faced questions from Fowler under cross-examination Monday and today before the guilty plea was entered and two of the charges withdrawn.

Fowler questioned various publications issued or used by Elections Yukon, saying the language used was not consistent across the board.

To say that “there are different interpretations of legislation would be an understatement; there’s a complete lack of consistency,” he said, objecting to a part of the Crown’s questioning of Wilkie.

His client, he continued, “exercised diligence” by arranging a meeting between Wilkie, her legal counsel at the time, and other Yukon Elections officials after being notified that there were concerns about offences under the act.

Those concerns came in part from an Oct. 26, 2016 phone call from downtown resident Bruce Dent, who said he had been asked by Goeppel to cast a proxy ballot for somebody he did not know, Wilkie testified.

Two days later, on Oct. 28, a decision was made to investigate the allegations.

Judge John Faulkner responded to the Crown’s objection Tuesday, saying that “if the accused took steps to deal with the matter, that would be evidence” that was relevant to the case.

A document entered as an exhibit Monday showed a list of about a dozen names that were listed to vote by proxy during that year.

The list ensures that poll officials “(are) notified this person has applied to vote by proxy,” Wilkie explained.

Goeppel could face a fine of up to $5,000, one year in jail or both.

Faulkner also allowed for the ability of a couple of other witnesses, including a CBC journalist and MacLeod, to testify via video link Monday.

With the guilty plea and the other two charges being withdrawn, that will likely not happen.

Goeppel made a brief foray into federal politics before becoming a territorial candidate. She unsuccessfully sought the Liberal Party of Canada nomination for the Yukon for the 2015 election, losing to current Yukon MP Larry Bagnell.

The Crown did not comment after today’s plea and withdrawn charges.

Both the defence and the Crown are to make joint sentencing submissions Wednesday morning.

Comments (26)

Up 4 Down 5

Al on Sep 1, 2018 at 1:24 pm

Doug - the best present you gave to the Yukon was leaving. Thank you.

By the way Newbie, I have lived all my life here. Get some time in the north. Oh that's right you left - hurrah !!!

Up 5 Down 4

Doug Ryder on Aug 31, 2018 at 7:17 pm

@ AL - I lived and worked in the Yukon for over 30 years and I know a lot of people there still. I visit often. I have family there. I own property in the Yukon and pay taxes accordingly.

I am very well qualified to speak to Northern/Yukon issues.
You sir are an unqualified bully who appears to be incapable of articulating any real thought... Just bully and bluster without regard for any factual basis in your position.

Like your friend Harvey it must hurt you too... To hear an alternative opinion that does not fit your self-styled narrative. As was offered to Harvey - let me know and I can refer you to some local resources to help you to open up and become better able to tolerate the chaos of the world outside your mind.

AL - Are you one of those southern transplants who has spent a few years or so living in the Yukon who has come to see themselves as a true Yukoner? Do you believe you understand Yukon/Northern culture because your very simplistic postings suggest to me that you do not even understand yourself. But that is okay because there is help for that too... Let me know.

Up 14 Down 5

AL on Aug 31, 2018 at 3:30 pm

@Doug Ryder

So you spent a weekend here. I guess that makes you a Yukon/northern expert. For someone who does not "live" here you certainly have a lot to say about what goes on. In fact I would say way too much.

You right about one thing - we will never be "pals" in any sense of the word.
I urge you to keep your southern thoughts south of sixty.

Up 18 Down 3

BnR on Aug 30, 2018 at 8:36 pm

Ok Star, if you're going to print a comment as patently asinine as Yukons, how about this?
Yukon, Are you that stupid you can't even google Joseph Goebbels? Pretty damned easy. Christ on a stick.
And people wonder why Cons get labelled as brainless...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Goebbels

Up 1 Down 13

Doug Ryder on Aug 30, 2018 at 7:43 pm

@ My Opinion - Hopefully you ate a hamburger or two. If so, take some time to really digest what you have done. Avoid the Koolaid. Really mull it over and think about the consequences. If you have any intelligence you will likely conclude that you have been fed a bunch of bull and in the end it is all just a bunch of Schmidt!

Up 4 Down 15

Doug Ryder on Aug 30, 2018 at 5:47 pm

Dear AL who is not my pal - My tax dollars get transferred to “you people” up there at about 1.4 billion per year. Show a little gratitude and less attitude.

I spent some time in the Yukon and still have family there. I understand that some individuals in the Yukon like to advance a position of cultural differences as a way to separate themselves from more advanced society and to justify an argument they have no other way of winning... because of their backward views perhaps? But not all Yukonners are like this or suffer the frailties of perceived insult.

I will give you a little time to reflect on the irony of your Liberal commentary. An epic assertion of misunderstanding if I ever did read one. Another misguided deflection.

Mind your own business, another assertion of the weakly positioned. Again, not able to argue the facts, only able to label, name-call and shout down.

Who is the liberal here?

Up 12 Down 10

woodcutter on Aug 30, 2018 at 2:22 pm

@ cheatin LIEberals

So you saying my retired grandmother on a fixed income, that pays no taxes, because her income is so low, should not have a right to vote?

You pretty much saying that you would discount the rights of poor people because they don't have as much money as you. I am sure sitting around with your cronies making snowflake sounds , that this seems like a good idea, however in a real life rights based society like Canada it has no relevance. But your post does show in 2 short lines how out of touch the right wing fringe is becoming.

Up 9 Down 14

Doug Ryder on Aug 30, 2018 at 11:57 am

The violation of regulatory offences is a common practice. From my scan of the recent news articles concerning the labour disruptions in YTG they are ongoing.

They are common here as well and everywhere else. Why pick on Goeppel as a singular event? This flouting of regulatory law is ubiquitous and this seems somewhat persecutory. The following discussion regarding motivation seems gratuitous or sell the popcornish!

In Alberta we even involve children in our regulatory offending. In this way we can teach them to be better adult-regulatory offenders:

https://nationalpost.com/news/local-news/61-alberta-private-schools-running-afoul-of-gay-straight-alliance-law-minister-says/wcm/0f9e0a22-4b9c-456a-86e9-de0dfc0f7183?utm_term=Autofeed&utm_campaign=Echobox&utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Facebook#Echobox=1535649069

Up 28 Down 0

It wasn't just Tamara on Aug 30, 2018 at 11:32 am

The funny thing is that even after this all went down during the election process, the Liberal candidates were STILL pushing proxy voting right up until the election. I know because I was personally informed a few times by my Liberal candidate, who obviously knew I hadn't voted yet, that I could arrange a proxy on my behalf.

Maybe they need to look more in to this and stop laying the blame on just one of the Liberal Party.

Up 7 Down 27

Yukon on Aug 30, 2018 at 7:41 am

Her last name is the same as Hitler's right hand man!

Up 11 Down 7

My Opinion on Aug 29, 2018 at 10:21 pm

@ Better
I went to a riding association meeting today. They had Hamburgers there. I am afraid they were trying to buy my vote. What should I do?

Do you have any idea how much worse filling out a form to vote and putting your name in there is? I guess you Libs really do not know the difference between right and wrong. Seriously.

Up 4 Down 4

Jim Dunage on Aug 29, 2018 at 6:59 pm

Hey Nile: All the roaches are not there.

Up 5 Down 5

Doug Ryder on Aug 29, 2018 at 6:26 pm

@ Nile - Because of all the roaches counsel were able to make a “joint” submission.

Up 6 Down 5

Doug Ryder on Aug 29, 2018 at 6:21 pm

@ Nile - Regarding your comment on roaches. Absolutely brilliant. Come October this will literally be true. Roaches everywhere...

Up 8 Down 11

BnR on Aug 29, 2018 at 4:54 pm

"Those concerns came in part from an Oct. 26, 2016 phone call from downtown resident Bruce Dent, who said he had been asked by Goeppel to cast a proxy ballot for somebody he did not know, Wilkie testified."
OK, am I the only one who reads the articles?
Miss Goeppel was asking downtown residents of no particular party to cast proxy votes for these people. It's not like she had any idea whom these residents, Mr. Dent included, would vote for. He might have voted for Liz.
And really, 10 ballots?

Up 9 Down 10

AL on Aug 29, 2018 at 3:55 pm

@Doug Ryder - your thoughts are the true expression of a Liberal. By the way "you people in the Yukon" sounds to me like you are from outside. If you are then mind your business, if you are new here then I suggest you take some time to understand the Yukon.

Up 28 Down 22

Better go and charge the Cons too then on Aug 29, 2018 at 1:55 pm

Not too long ago I read about the Conservatives giving people alcohol and driving them to the voting stations....much worst than Goeppel's mistakes in my opinion. Politicians shouldn't be allowed to entice people to vote for them with favours, shouldn't be able to drive them to polls, or otherwise interfere with voting.

And as for 'Cheatin Liberals', votes and taxes are not linked. Everybody has a right to vote in Canada. We are not some dictatorship where only middle and upper class get rights.

Up 23 Down 8

Doug Ryder on Aug 29, 2018 at 11:35 am

@ AL - Give it up. You people in the Yukon cannot even keep sexual offenders and murderers in jail.

A year in jail for elections violations - LOL!!!

Up 28 Down 15

Jack on Aug 29, 2018 at 1:30 am

Given the premeditated nature of this election fraud and the calculated targeting of vulnerable people within our society for personal gain, a custodial sentence is more than warranted here. Outrageous.

Up 35 Down 9

north_of_60 on Aug 28, 2018 at 9:20 pm

They can skirt around the obvious as much as they want however most people realize she tried to get votes from people who don't understand the voting process or responsibilities, but were happy to help the nice lady by signing some form. That is clearly taking advantage of people.

Up 36 Down 8

Nile on Aug 28, 2018 at 8:35 pm

This whole ordeal still leaves a few questions. Namely what advice the Liberal in charge of their election team, a lawyer who also happens to be running for city council this fall, gave to Goeppel about this mess. When you see one roach there are 50 you don’t, but they are all there.

Up 26 Down 9

been here a few years and then some on Aug 28, 2018 at 5:16 pm

She should have stuck to buying drinks for them and then driving them to the polls like some candidates in the past have done. I'm glad the manipulation is being taken seriously, just saying it's nothing new.

Up 33 Down 19

Guncache on Aug 28, 2018 at 5:04 pm

Now we know how Larry probably won.

Up 34 Down 16

CJ on Aug 28, 2018 at 3:25 pm

I don't understand why the media is making a big deal out of witnesses being called and not showing up, because of their situation, in a way that implies that's why they "needed" Goeppel (it's been a central focus of both CBC and this article). That is just not the point.

I was hoping something more substantial in the way of a teaching moment would come out of this case, but so far reporters just seem to reinforce Goeppel's unfortunate and arrogant misinterpretation of her role. We become ever more alienated from the principles of the right to vote.

Up 37 Down 38

AL on Aug 28, 2018 at 3:21 pm

A year sounds good to me. Send a strong signal - no rap on the knuckles !!!

Up 17 Down 48

Cheatin LIEberals on Aug 28, 2018 at 2:39 pm

Cheaters never prosper...at least this time anyway. The way I see it, if you don't pay taxes, then you can't vote. Plain and simple.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.