Whitehorse Daily Star

Four hundred people blacked out after tree damages power line

A tree blown onto a power line by Friday afternoon's powerful winds knocked out electricity to about 400 customers.

By Chuck Tobin on October 27, 2008

A tree blown onto a power line by Friday afternoon's powerful winds knocked out electricity to about 400 customers.

Jay Massie, superintendent of operations for Yukon Electricial Co. Ltd., said today the McIntyre, Logan and Arkell subdivisions and part of Copper Ridge were blacked out just before 4 p.m.

Electricity was restored to Logan, Arkell and Copper Ridge by 5 p.m., and McIntyre was back on at 5:20 p.m., he said.

Massie said a tree was blown onto the line running through the bush from the substation near Rabbit's Foot Canyon to the McIntrye subdivision.

"It did not do any damage to the line, but the tree had to be removed by the guys."

Down at the Whitehorse Rapids Dam, meanwhile, Yukon Energy has put the number three hydroelectric turbine back on line, eliminating the need to use its diesel generators during periods of peak demand.

An expert in the field of generators arrived in Whitehorse last week from Wisconsin to assist Yukon Energy with its assessment of the number three and four turbines.

"Number three has been back on line since 17:52 (5:42 p.m.) Friday afternoon," Yukon Energy spokeswoman Janet Patterson said this morning.

She said an inspection of number three didn't show anything wrong mechanically, so it was recalibrated to the same safety setting typically used by the Wisconsin company.

The safety settings, Patterson explained, will automatically shut down the generator if problems are detected, to avoid any significant damage.

Number three was tested, and put back on line Friday afternoon, she said.

"And it has been working fine ever since," she said. "Now they have turned their attention to number four."

Number four has been off line since Thanksgiving Sunday, when a faulty valve caused a lengthy blackout of the entire Whitehorse-Aishihik-Faro grid.

Patterson said Yukon Energy now suspects problems with number three may have contributed to the lengthy outage on Thanksgiving Monday.

The publicly-owned corporation, however, is not convinced number three was solely responsible for the outage, though there is no evidence to suggest what else may have contributed to the loss of power, she said.

Yukon Electrical has said nothing on its monitors showed any problems with the distribution system that Monday, and it didn't have to make any repairs before power was fully restored.

With number three and four off line, Yukon Energy was forced to fire its diesel generators last week during peak demands at breakfast and supper.

As a result, the 22 consumers of secondary power - cheap power that is normally surplus hydroelectric energy and is often used for heat instead of the more expensive heating fuel - were taken off.

Patterson said Yukon Energy doesn't want to restore secondary power sales until number four, the largest of the territory's hydroelectric generators, is back on line.

The Whitehorse General Hospital, for instance, is a consumer of secondary power.

While the Minto mine and Pelly Crossing are not yet receiving power from the Whitehorse-Aishihik-Faro grid, they may be fully tied in by sometime next week, Patterson said.

It was expected the new customers would be on line by the end of September, though there have been, and still are, delays in receiving essential equipment.

Comments (7)

Up 0 Down 0

Joel on Oct 30, 2008 at 4:36 pm

I now see there is a revenue shortfall rider for both Yukon Energy and Yukon Electric on the Whitehorse bill....I am wondering though, if they can't provide power to the people that are relying on it now, where would the missing revenue come from?

I agree, with some of the highest power rates in Canada and some of the most outages (not weather related) it is funny how they are short money all the time.....

Up 0 Down 0

Janet Patterson on Oct 30, 2008 at 9:57 am

Rest assured Scott T. that Yukon Energy is reading and taking to heart these comments. I understand people's frustration level...the employees here at Yukon Energy don't want these outages any more than you do. Many of us had hoped to enjoy a quiet Thanksgiving with family and friends, not working frantically to restore power. I was verbally abused and even received a death threat that week-end...neither of these helped get the power back on any sooner.

There are two electrical companies in the Yukon, and each has had its problems of late. I can only talk about the one I work for...Yukon Energy. I can tell you that a great deal of effort is going into finding a long-term solution so that we don't have the frequency of outages we've seen recently. We are also working to find more hydro and other sources of renewable energy. But hydro projects can cost hundreds of millions of dollars and they take years to complete. With the small population base in the Yukon, it would be unconscionable to expect ratepayers to come up with that sort of money. We're working to find federal/private/other funding for projects, but again, you can't just snap your fingers and make it happen.

I realize that none of what I'm saying will make you feel any better, but I'm just trying to explain that things aren't always as simple as they might seem.

Up 0 Down 0

SaraC on Oct 30, 2008 at 4:57 am

Great headline... Four hundred people blacked out!

Quick. Run for the smelling salts.

Did the tree also hit them all in the head after knocking into the powerline? Perhaps they were so shocked to see the power go out once again that they all fainted.

Up 0 Down 0

Scott T on Oct 29, 2008 at 4:33 am

Good Comment erik!

I second everything you said.

Bravo!

It would be nice if YEC would read it and take it to heart.

Thank you.

Up 0 Down 0

JT on Oct 28, 2008 at 8:04 pm

I'm sick and tired of all the power outages and for the most part we don't even hear why there was a power outage.

Every time there is a power outage and we can't go on with our lives normally Yukon Electric should have to compensate us. We are, after all, the customers.

If it was a once in awhile occurence it wouldn't matter but it's not. Power outages in the Yukon happen way too often. Three in one week was the most ridiculous and I never even heard a reason for it.

Get it together. I'm sick of it.

Up 0 Down 0

john brien on Oct 28, 2008 at 11:01 am

Great point there erik... and dont forget that nice monthly bill that follows even after a ton of outages weekly. I think alike the territory, yukon electric is behind the times. Spend some of that hard earned income that you collect and put it to use.. say.. upgrading equipement

Up 0 Down 0

erik on Oct 27, 2008 at 9:23 am

I wish Yukon Electric and Yukon Energy would drop the term 'grid' from their vocabulary. Grid, when applied to power transmission insinuates that there is some form of redundancy; when one supply fails secondary sources are able to provide immediate back up. Clearly this isn't the case with the *ahem* grid in Yukon where a raven, tree, bullet, ground squirrel or 'stuck valve' can plunge the Yukon into darkness for hours. The grid here is a closed system and is obviously teetering on the brink of failure daily. Remember the Christmas lights back in the old days? One bulb fails and you got to watch your dad swap out every bulb. God forbid two bulbs failed, Santa would never find your house! Christmas light manufactures resolved that problem a few decades ago and it is time for Yukon Electric and Yukon Energy to do the same. There are thousand rivers in Yukon capable of providing clean hydro electric power, build a dam.

My neighbourhood has seen six significant blackouts in the past three weeks and this is well before the peak demand in the coldest winter months. I've given up resetting the clocks on the various pieces of electronics around the house, now everything flashes: '12:00'. I recall a few years back when we had a long outage (seven hours) in January, it was -30. Our new house got down to 16 degrees, we had no secondary heat source and we had a newborn so of course we began to source out a warm friend's house to spend the night. The next day, YTG spokesbot Doug Caldwell made the callous remark that people should be prepared to spend three days in their home without electricity. Even if we had back up heat then (we now have a propane fireplace) you can almost guarantee that our pipes would have frozen, as would everyone else's. Something of that scale would have been in the tens of millions of dollars to repair, who do you think would pick up that tab?

It isn't 1930 where electricity is a luxury, it is a necessity. Without power everything grids to a halt, not just turkey dinner. Businesses and banks are unable to process transactions. Public health and safety are at risk, our analog phones stopped working after several hours in that January outage as backup power for NWTel failed. Security and fire systems stop working, so do street lights and stop lights. Only a couple of schools have diesel backup. Clearly some of the millions of dollars ratepayers are pouring into the system need to be funneled into infrastructure.

Here's hoping you don't screw up Christmas.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.