Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

SATISFIED WITH ACCOMPLISHMENTS – Premier Sandy Silver speaks with members of the media Thursday afternoon. Insets Stacey Hassard, left, Liz Hanson, right.

Final day sees modern legislation passed

The territorial legislature wrapped up its fall sitting yesterday,

By Palak Mangat on November 23, 2018

The territorial legislature wrapped up its fall sitting yesterday, which will lead Sandy Silver’s Liberals past the two-year mark of its mandate, with the premier glowing about what he called a “very progressive session.”

That most recent sitting saw MLAs consider 10 government bills, the majority of which received first reading within the first week of the sitting in October.

They ranged from the Societies Act, Lobbyists Registration Act and Access to Information and Protection of Privacy (ATIPP) Act.

Some of the legislation looked at this sitting was in an effort to bring rules into the 21st century, the premier said.

“We heard from Yukoners about the need to modernize our laws and the legislation we brought forward this fall will help to move our society and the government towards more openness and inclusivity,” he said in a release issued late Thursday.

On a not-unrelated, also reflective note, the Premier offered some insight into the recently released public service engagement survey, done last May.

It tracks in part how each department can improve workplaces based on feedback from government workers – something perhaps fitting, given the government will head into its third full calendar year before making its way back to the legislature early next year.

“These internal reviews are exactly such, and I will take it on the chin,” Silver had said in the house earlier.

That was in reference to what the Yukon Party called a “failing grade” from his own department.

The survey shows in part that 80 per cent of respondents within the Executive Council Office (ECO) agreed in 2016 with the statement that they had confidence in the senior leadership of the department, while that number dipped down to 49 per cent as of this year.

Speaking to reporters shortly after, Silver echoed his remarks from earlier in the sitting.

“Change is hard, that’s for sure,” he said, noting that talk about finding efficiencies and “curtailing the growth of government” can be difficult to do and leave impressions on public servants.

Asked what those numbers meant, especially with him being part of the senior leadership in the department, the premier said he felt glad to have the feedback and would try his best to improve on them.

“When you have new mandate letters after 14 years of a certain government ... it takes time, it really does.”

The Yukon Party, which is currently the official Opposition, was in power for three terms lasting more than a decade before the now-governing Liberals assumed office in late 2016.

While the premier was proud of the overall progress of this sitting, opposition parties weren’t so convinced, with at least one remaining critical of what it said Yukoners are still left in the dark about.

That was the Yukon Party, whose interim leader, Stacey Hassard, continued to take aim at the government for what he saw was a taxation policy rather than an environmental one.

“I don’t think it’s fair to take money from Yukon taxpayers just on an experiment,” Hassard said Thursday.

He recalled the premier telling media in late October that “time will tell” about whether the carbon tax would majorly reduce greenhouse gases.

To Hassard, that meant the premier was on the fence about carbon pricing and its merits – despite travelling to Ottawa at least once this sitting to meet with federal counterparts about it.

“I think that’s a bit indicative of the way things are going with this government,” Hassard said, saying a lack of answers in the legislature can get frustrating for both the public and civil servants.

The last two weeks in particular were dominated by questions from the Yukon Party and the NDP about the carbon tax, with some coming almost daily.

For his part, Silver has and did reiterate much of the information already released about some exemptions and rebates while pleading for patience as he waited for Ottawa on details of how specifically the rebate mechanism would work.

“I hope so,” he said when asked if an announcement could be in the works for the holiday season. The premier also acknowledged the questions have been frequent.

“We don’t have a lot more time left,” he said, referencing the last time an announcement was made was in October.

That saw a formal release from the feds come down, saying that the Yukon would see the tax hit its territory come July 2019.

“I’m feeling the pressure absolutely.”

Hassard did note that he was happy to see some motions and bills passed unanimously, such as the Equality of Spouses Statute Law Amendment Act – which was the first to receive assent on Oct. 29.

Meanwhile, a release issued yesterday noted the legislation that elected officials passed this sitting. They include, but are not limited to:

• Societies Act to clarify process for creating, operating and governing societies in the Yukon;

• Coroners Act to clarify what the duties of the coroner are and reflect modern best practices;

• Equality of Spouses Statute Law Amendment Act to update legislation with language that is inclusive of LGBTQ2S+ Yukoners and rolls back Married Women’s Property Act;

• Lobbyist Registration Act that requires lobbyists to share their activities via a public registry; and

• ATIPP Act, with an aim to improve transparency around public decision-making while maintain privacy protection.

The sore thumb not on the list, opposition parties suggested, is the one on electoral district boundaries that was voted down by the Liberals this week.

The NDP took aim at the government’s rare move of defeating its own bill, saying it was reflective of a group heading into its third calendar year content on maintaining the “status quo.

“That’s their approach,” said NDP Leader Liz Hanson. “They’re not going to rock the boat (often), and that’s kind of unfortunate.”

Pointing to the more recent voting down, she said the government “out of the blue” put forward a bill before swiftly defeating it.

“I’m astounded at that kind of thing,” she said, noting it seems unprecedented.

“I think it’s going to not only damage their credibility but really cause them pause to ask.

“We can’t accept the recommendations of a non-partisan commission established by law, chaired by the chief justice of the territorial government?

“I’ve just got to shake my head,” she sighed.

All 10 government MLAs voted against the bill that would have in part seen an additional riding created (bringing the total to 20).

They were joined by the Yukon Party’s Brad Cathers, with the remaining Yukon Party MLAs and two NDP MLAs voting in favour of it.

The Liberals’ appointee to the commission to recommend the changes has since spoken out against the defeating of the bill, saying he is worried that it could have negative impacts by limiting rural representation in the territory, among other things.

Silver reiterated his stance on this ahead of the end-of-sitting wrap-up news conference.

“I’m going to stay with the fact that we think we did the right thing,” he said. The commissioner’s interim report from November 2017 didn’t make mention of an additional riding, something that did come up in its final April 2018 report, he noted.

“It seems to me, from the interim report, there was a box of ideas, and in the end, the raft came out with stuff in there that was outside of that box.

“We didn’t want to go in and cherry-pick individual pieces,” he explained, leaving just two options for the party: either vote down entirely or accept everything.

“And we believed most Yukoners didn’t want to see a 20th riding,” he said, calling it a “massive change that really was not at the heart and soul of the consultation.”

Asked what he made of the government’s own appointee blasting the decision to defeat the bill, Silver simply said, “Everyone’s entitled to their own opinion.”

For her part, Hanson did note that she was pleased to see the lobbyist legislation push through after tabling a private member’s bill in 2014.

“That’s (after) a long history of the NDP trying to get lobbying legislation in place,” the leader smiled.

The Yukon was one of the last jurisdictions in the country to adopt rules around lobbying, joining the other two territories and Prince Edward Island.

Meanwhile, Hanson announced Wednesday earlier that she would be stepping down as leader of her party, but remain on until a successor is chosen and as the MLA for Whitehorse-Centre.

The other NDPer, Takhini-Kopper King’s Kate White, told the Star Thursday she has not yet decided either way to throw her hat into the ring.

The fall sitting, which began Oct. 1, also saw a number of witnesses appear before the assembly. Among them were officials from the Yukon Hospital Corp. and the territory’s Information and Privacy Commissioner, along with an investigator hired to do an inspection of the Whitehorse Correctional Centre.

Among the things to look forward to come next year and the off-season are details of the territory’s comprehensive health review set to wrap up in the fall of 2019, the Ottawa-imposed carbon tax and the appointment of Hanson’s successor.

Also: the government issued a release around 3:30 p.m. Thursday indicating that key legislation would pass as the sitting wrapped up.

That was something Lake Laberge MLA Cathers took issue with in the assembly, saying it was premature to send out a release before some of the legislation had received third and final reading.

Alleging it was a disrespect and breach of the assembly’s process, he said it violated the privilege of members of the assembly too. The Speaker is set to rule on the matter come the spring sitting.

Comments (6)

Up 4 Down 6

Mike H on Nov 28, 2018 at 3:08 pm

Since Josey has all the answers I guess we will see his name on the ballot in the next election, maybe he could team up with Wilf and their rambling will cancel each other out.

Up 5 Down 6

Patti Eyre on Nov 26, 2018 at 1:25 pm

@JS you are right you do belong in the 7th century, and your hate speech has no place here in these "lands" you evidently occupy

Up 4 Down 5

Little Bo Beep on Nov 25, 2018 at 9:14 pm

@ Groucho - Very well written post. Unfortunately however people tend not to evaluate the facts of any given position.
People tend to make decisions based on feeling and emotion rather than practicality. It is true more often than not that because of people’s tendency to make decisions based on feeling and emotion they tend not to act in their own best interests.

This occurs ad nauseum at the individual level, through the institutional levels, and the societal level as well. This feeling/emotion based reactioning is the manifestation of the evolutionary mechanism associated with what is commonly referred to as the “fear response”.
However, thinking is also effortful and the human default is laziness.

Thus, we will continue to have shifts, swings, and polarities because at the individual level “we” are not that intelligent and the collective level where politics and politicians play out... We are less “intelligenter”... Shoals of fish darting between one predator and another... Sheep bleeting in between the ruminant... Wandering the meadows looking for the next big mouthful oblivious to the next shearing...

Voting is for sheeple!

Up 11 Down 3

Groucho d'North on Nov 25, 2018 at 10:27 am

Each of us, in our own way must evaluate the performance of a government against standards and expectations made from their promises delivered during the election campaign. There is no standard method of measure for this evaluation and eye of the beholder is often biased due to political ideology and what team you’re rooting for. What did they say they would do if elected? Did they do it as promised or is the final result accompanied with a boat-load of spin and interpretation of the outcome as 'good-enough'?
Weasel words and misdirection are the tools of today's political environment and results are not always as promised and very rarely justified for legitimate reasons. Yukon's Liberals are living in the shadow of their Emperor in Ottawa and are considered by that company they keep. Myself, I would prefer our territorial government to demonstrate some independence from the federal puppet masters and negotiate what's best for Yukon people and our economy, rather than to be a part of the force who believes they were elected to save the world.
Before writing this I read a story about the huge protests underway in Paris because of fuel taxes and the public being fed up with the dictatorial governance they have. Canada is not too different, the electorate is smoldering because of our taxation environment and all the bafflegab surrounding how our tax dollars get spent in far off distant lands. Yukon's Liberals may do better if they found their own voices on these issues rather than parroting what the spin-doctors in Ottawa are sharing with their counterparts here.

Up 12 Down 9

Josey Wales on Nov 24, 2018 at 1:46 am

Ahhhh....Canada’s Liberals, really accurate to suggest that they are metric democrats. Keeping everyone as subjects, whilst the charade virtue is played.
Not so much a commentary on SS, but his team leader and its direction.
Pandering to the alphabet, whilst herding Trojan camels to our lands.
Put a pantsuit on Mr. Dress Up, be hard pressed to tell it from Hillary or Angela....all would be good entertainment for a pop quiz on current real events, history or science.
...the 2spirits....what next the tooth fairy for minister of defence?

SS...enjoy your reign, tow the line, sell the snake oil.
Do those things SS, and these lemmings out here will ensure your reign runs long while.
If SS you choose not to do those things?
Then you may appear as a normal, critical thinking individual concerned about going down rabbit holes of lunacy....your team would have none of that type on theirs.

2spirits, only in Liberal Canada...what a effin mess.
Good thing for google translate, now everyone can read my freely expressed opinions in their new country....and back home after the ink dries.
Never thought in my life I would be under SS rule, boys can be girls, that the seventh century was freaking awesome, and that pac man NPCs would be residing in a 1st world.

...who knew? boy was I wrong and apparently continue to be so.

Up 11 Down 4

Will Dissandat on Nov 23, 2018 at 9:11 pm

Maintaining individual privacy while providing transparency in government decision-making... LOL!
How did you come to that decision? Because I said so! Why do you think that was a good decision? Because I said so! Can you tell me a little bit more about the decision-making process? Because I said so!

Any decision made by the government is political. There is no such thing as evidence-based, best-practice, decision-making in government. It cannot operate that way with partisan politicking.

Good effing luck with that!

You might as well forget that whole notion that democracy is the will of the people. Nowhere is this true. It is absolutely a tyranny of the minority that has little to do with the electorate but for the ritual act of granting their papal indulgences.

It seems quite odd that the preferred symbol for marking a ballot in Canada is the X.
While X may mark the spot we must be mindful that it is a symbol often associate with pirates. It is also used by individuals who cannot write in lieu of a signature. Perhaps the clearest association with the symbol X is that something is wrong

Wrong - Whether you vote Conservative, Green, Liberal or NDP - Wrong explains the ultimate election results. Democracy cannot be franchised! Democracy is an ongoing pursuit - Do not leave your “will” in the ballot box or democracy will die.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.