Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

LISTENING IS CRUCIAL – Touring the country and listening to people is part of creating a successful inquiry into missing and murdered aboriginal women, says Indigenous and Northern Affairs Minister Carolyn Bennett, seen Monday afternoon in Whitehorse.

‘Everybody wants to seek justice with the victims’

Yukon families affected by missing and murdered aboriginal women spent Monday in pre-inquiry conferences with a federal minister at the Kwanlin Dün Cultural Centre.

By Aimee O'Connor on January 12, 2016

Yukon families affected by missing and murdered aboriginal women spent Monday in pre-inquiry conferences with a federal minister at the Kwanlin Dün Cultural Centre.

They unloaded painful and personal stories and gave input on what they would like to see for the impending national inquest.

“It was unprecedented that a minister would spend an entire day listening to people and their input,” Yukon MP Larry Bagnell said in an interview.

“Some people said it was the first time they felt comfortable speaking freely.”

Indigenous and Northern Affairs Minister Carolyn Bennett arrived in Whitehorse on Sunday evening, with the purpose of holding private meetings with family and loved ones of victims across the country.

Prior to Monday’s gathering, Bennett had already visited Yellowknife and Thunder Bay, Ont.

Taking the time to tour the country and listen to people is part of creating a successful inquiry, according to Bennett.

“I do not think that a report with a few quotes in it is the same as actually hearing these stories,” Bennett told a press conference Monday afternoon.

Success, she said, will be measured once the commission is announced and people believe they had been truly listened to.

What the government needs is for the people, such as those in Whitehorse yesterday, to see their fingerprints on the blueprint of the commission, Bennett said.

Several common themes emerged from the stories heard Monday.

“Everybody wants to seek justice with the victims. This issue of prevention keeps coming back to the forefront,” Bennett explained.

People want their daughters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters to be able to walk freely in their communities without worry. People want injustice and discrimination in the criminal justice system to cease, she added.

In Whitehorse specifically, some families raised concerns about trafficking and the Sixties Scoop, the practice from the 1960s where aboriginal children were “scooped up” from their families and placed in foster homes or adoption centres.

Other families were concerned about serial killers who only had charges laid on white, non-indigenous victims while indigenous victims where ignored.

“Those are the kinds of things that are about injustice,” Bennett said.

While the morning meetings focused on why the families were participating, the latter part of the day was allocated to answering nine discussion questions about what the form and design of the inquiry should look like.

Examples of the questions, as seen on the federal government website, include who should lead the inquiry, the key issues to be addressed, what supports may be needed during the inquest and how the process should be set up to provide concrete recommendations for action.

Locally, the families spoke about how cultural and ceremonial practices should be incorporated to the inquest – the day began yesterday with a sacred fire and drummers to open the sessions.

“People really appreciated that,” said Bagnell, who was also present at the discussions.

The Yukon MP also expressed how the gathering showed him the large number of Yukon aboriginal people who are directly or indirectly affected by this issue.

“The majority of Yukon aboriginal people know the victims,” he said.

Due to the subject matter, the talks unsurprisingly made for a highly emotional environment.

“Part of my previous job was to hear stories and to take in how much hurt there is,” Bennett said, drawing on her previous experience as a family doctor.

A poignant moment in the meetings for Bennett has been the people who came with the purpose of supporting someone else and ended up telling their own stories.

“It fills us with tremendous emotion of that courage,” she said.

“That they’ve been triggered by the support in the room and the need for them to finally be able to tell their story.”

Summaries of each meeting, including what was heard, will be eventually posted on the federal government’s website.

For Yukoners who were unable to attend Monday, submissions via an online survey, phone and email are being accepted on the web page for the national inquiry into missing and murdered indigenous women and girls.

With the aim of creating a commission that isn’t one-size-fits-all, Bennett explained that once the meetings conclude, the commission will have an outline based on what was heard during the pre-inquiry sessions.

She also stressed the commission’s separation from government.

“It will be arm’s-length from the government, like any decent national public inquiry,” she said.

“It means people don’t think we’re quietly telling them what they can or cannot do.”

The reason for this, Bennett added, is to ensure that people believe the process is authentic.

“What we’ve heard almost at every place, but at least a couple of times this morning, is that it’s been a long time coming.”

Comments (10)

Up 1 Down 0

celticapache on Jan 18, 2016 at 7:13 pm

From my perspective as an immigrant life without First Nations would be bleak, desolate, and boring. What Elders of FN gave to me is the key to my true identity.
An unforgettable, life transforming treasure. The disappearance and murders of FN women is a terrible reality and a symbol of an even greater terrible truth. The destruction, pollution, disappearance of species and Eco-systems, the desecration of our sacred Mother Earth. The waters, the Earth and nature all come under the sign of the feminine. It is the sign of a deeper problem facing the world.
A problem First Nations Elders, Chiefs, holy men and Prophets of been voicing since the Europeans arrived. Show some respect for these Great people revered all over the world for their wisdom and power.

Up 3 Down 0

Icefog on Jan 18, 2016 at 11:46 am

While I believe there are many social problems as a result of residential schools I don't know about the need for yet another enquiry. I am empathetic to the victims and there families but unlike Ms. Deacon I am not ashamed to be caucasian and neither should anyone else or made to feel this way. Ive spoke to many first nations that at one time were ashamed to be First Nation and we know the repercussions of that. We know white priveledge exists, yes, we know Nations have been victimized and are over rrepresented in the criminal justice system, we know many citizens in Canada and North America are missing and murdered every day. What will an inquiry assess and provide that hasn't been looked at already? Is this not a RCMP issue?
In my opinion we are better off putting the millions of dollars that will be spent on this initiative to assist First Nations in developing healing initiatives and community infrastructures that support a healthy community rather than generating more paper to tell us what we already know. The issues that exist in First Nations communities will remain regardless of this inquest. This inquest will not change the poverty, victimization, safety or third world conditions that many First Nations in Canada live with. What will change those realities is assistance and support in building healthy individuals which in turn will transfer to healthy communities. I have no problem with my tax dollars supporting initiatives such as community development if there is accountability and buy in from First Nations governments. Failing that, the money spent on an inquest will have little impact other than adding to a growing body of research and facts we already know.

Up 15 Down 20

Cathy, you said it! on Jan 18, 2016 at 1:23 am

Yup, I second Cathy's words, 'walk a mile in their shoes.' Angel Carlick's death is STILL UNSOLVED--last year we had a 17 FN female killed. We need this to stop--we need Angel's murderer to be found (NO, JUSTICE hasn't been served--what if that was your kid, murdered, body found months later and a crazy phycho walking amongst us? Who can it be? It makes me hold my children tighter to me, I'll tell you that). Respect for FN and all people. Inquiries into women's deaths shouldn't be compared....they are so vulnerable, you have no idea unless you've lived in a FN community which most of you negative posters have NOT. You only know judgement. Get over it and be human.

Up 22 Down 17

Cathy Deacon on Jan 15, 2016 at 10:07 pm

to Yukoner on Jan 13 above; ignorance is bliss. Would you say that to Angel Carlick's mother or all the other families that have lost children? This is a vitally important issue that needs to be openly discussed so that we can understand why First Nations women are marginalized, missing and murdered. It's about healing and prevention. Look up the word empathy and try to understand what these families have gone through and what First Nation people go through on a daily basis; walk a mile in their shoes buddy. I am ashamed of being white when ignorant white people are bigoted and racist.

Up 12 Down 17

north_of_60 on Jan 15, 2016 at 5:32 pm

If aboriginal groups want to redirect their existing funding for an inquiry, would anyone stop them? Why aren't they using their resources to address the cause of the 'missing women' problem which everyone is pretending to ignore?

This is a predominately aboriginal problem that begins with abuse at an early age, usually in their own families. The aboriginal communities are the only ones who can fix this and they already get enough money to do it IF they want to. If these communities spent less money on Chiefs and Councilors and more on raising healthy children, then this problem would be solved.

What has been done since the last call for inquiry to address the conditions in their communities that cause their children to get involved with gangs, drugs, and risky behavior, and usually leave the community and go missing? Also, since nearly twice as many aboriginal men are killed, why the selective outrage about murdered women?

Up 16 Down 16

redisright on Jan 14, 2016 at 6:05 pm

The inquest is definitely needed. We need an inquest into the entire problem of red and white relations from the day the Europeans set foot on this continent and unleashed an orgy of destruction in what could only be described as a religious psychosis. "The balance of the whole universe is keyed to the spiritual life of the individual." Hopi Elder.

Up 20 Down 4

Max Mack on Jan 13, 2016 at 2:04 pm

How is it that a national inquest is being demanded for "missing and murdered aboriginal women", but no inquest is being called for "missing and murdered aboriginal men"? In the same reference period as the "stats" used to justify an inquest for MMIW, many thousands of aboriginal men and boys have gone missing and have been murdered. Many times the rate of aboriginal women. If this is not clear evidence of systemic gender bias on a social scale, I don't know what is. How is it that women are deserving of an inquest, but men are not?

Up 12 Down 14

question? on Jan 13, 2016 at 10:54 am

Reinstating capital punishment might just solve this issue. Not sure an inquiry is really necessary

Up 35 Down 11

confused on Jan 13, 2016 at 10:20 am

If the vast majority of these crimes have been investigated and prosecuted wouldn't this indicate that "justice" had already been delivered?

Up 48 Down 14

Yukoner on Jan 13, 2016 at 8:31 am

Let's just keep beating this dead horse there is no need for an inquest. The same question is asked and the first nation people don't want to deal with the problem with in so why throw good money at this. The problem is home you don't need an inquest to figure that one out.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.