Energy, minerals called the foundation of life
Rex Murphy says he just doesn’t get the segment of society that doesn’t want anything to do with the development of Canada’s mineral and energy resources.
By Chuck Tobin on November 23, 2018
Rex Murphy says he just doesn’t get the segment of society that doesn’t want anything to do with the development of Canada’s mineral and energy resources.
In fact, he finds it mind-boggling, the CBC personality and national newspaper columnist told delegates attending the 46th annual Yukon Geoscience Forum in Whitehorse.
There are two things that provide Canadians with the quality of life they enjoy today, he said.
Energy and minerals are the very foundation of the quality of life here, Murphy added.
Take either away, and that quality disappears; vanishes just like that, Murphy told the audience.
Imagine, he suggested, a world without the minerals mined to support the needs of society.
No computers, no cell phones, no lots of things.
Energy. Everybody uses it.
Murphy’s hour-long presentation to delegates was punctuated with humour, to say the least.
It was the kind of humour that makes you chuckle, even laugh, not just smile.
Murphy joked – presumably – that when he was working on the fourth floor of the CBC edifice on Front Street in Toronto, one of his jobs was to go down to the lobby, water the ferns and light the candles at the foot of Bishop Suzuki’s alter.
But he also shared some of the harsher realities of life in his home province of Newfoundland and Labrador.
When the cod industry was shut down, Murphy said, there were thousands and thousands of people washed out of a livelihood that had sustained them and their families for centuries – literally.
He remembers people giving away their homes for airplane tickets. He knows a fellow who sold his dwelling for seven airplane tickets.
Murphy said he knows the despair unemployment brings.
It was the resource sector, including the oil sands of Alberta, that provided jobs for the unemployed from the East Coast. It was the oil sands that supplied the glue that cements Canada as a nation, he suggested.
Murphy said Canada is fortunate to have some of the greatest oil and gas resources on the planet.
The trouble is, we can’t get them out of the country, he told the audience.
Murphy said he knows a man who worked for nine years on the Keystone Pipeline project before he decided to move to Mexico – where he’s already built three pipelines.
The resistance has meant that instead of taking full advantage of Newfoundland’s offshore oil, the refineries are importing their crude from
Venezuela and Albania, he told the audience.
Murphy said he was not able to discuss the technical aspects of the mining industry, because he just doesn’t have that depth of knowledge.
He can, however, see the resistance to an industry that supplies jobs and economy, just as it provides the material used to in everyday life; the material that provides the cradle of comfort for Canadians.
Imagine, he suggested to the audience, a proposal these days to build the icon the Banff Springs Hotel has become.
It’s a work of magnificence from a time when it was sweat and hardship that laid one floor on top of the other, without any modern day cranes or sophisticated computer design programs, he said.
Murphy said suggesting such a project today, suggesting that a resort of such grandeur be built from the very rock it sits on, would likely bring the gallows.
He recalled the words of Samuel Jackson, his hero as a writer and poet who penned the the first English dictionary in 1755.
Jackson wrote that people more often need to be reminded than informed, he said.
Murphy said what Jackson meant is the importance of things most obvious in our daily lives can slip away from our minds; the things of importance can be the least appreciated at the same time.
As is traditional at the geoscience forum, guest speakers are given a gift.
Murphy was given a piece of driftwood with a painting on it by Jim Robb – a painting of a gold dredge.
Comments (15)
Up 12 Down 2
Apex Parasite on Nov 29, 2018 at 7:52 am
@Bob
I thought I pretty clearly stated that we need mining for things. I have a phone and a computer...many gadgets. I am a product of my environment and as such avail myself some of the niceties inherent to our pampered and entitled way of life.
By your tone I feel like were I to walk around in skins, living outdoors, willingly subjecting myself to all manner of privation would garner ridicule from you rather than respect.
Just because I use the tools available to me does not preclude me from seeing that we literally exploit resources to build garbage in many cases. A walk down any aisle of any dollar store will attest. Bigger is always better. More is always better. Today's best is tomorrow's crap.
The problem isn't that we do things with the resources we are blessed with. It is that we do many unwise things. Planned obsolescence is a great example. There are many. Letting the resource be exploited for huge profit as the prime motive is a classic scenario the world over. Profit trumps all...where it can. Equador is a sad but apt example of local indigenous populations suffering and extorted while big money pull strings and greases skids. Innocent and good people literally being terrorized, sometimes killed simply because they live in a resource rich locale.
I'm simply pointing out we do not respect our resources, or perhaps we do but for the wrong reasons.
I don't need a disposable plastic razor. I need one razor...forever. I want it to come in a simple cardboard box. I want it to be built to serve the need of shaving....not breaking to allow the manufacturer to sell more while the broken bits become garbage. Don't get me wrong, people need to make a living but making a living building garbage at poverty level wages for the likes of you and I to throw out when we get bored or the thing breaks....it ain't much of a living.
I actually saw a review of some device recently wherein the reviewer criticized the simple packaging. He literally wanted more plastic and crap and shiny pictures. He would love our government mandated doobie packages.
Thanks for piling in with the same old parroted crap though.
Up 7 Down 24
Rural Resident on Nov 28, 2018 at 7:54 am
This guy should have stayed home. They wanted a keynote speaker and got a mud slinging speaker with a distorted sense of humour.
Up 20 Down 8
Basic Bob on Nov 27, 2018 at 3:32 pm
Well Apex; I guess now that you have your computer or cell phone we should leave all the resources in the ground. You probably have quite a few other things that you could be thanking mining for. If we all only buy the essentials like food and minimal shelter, the economy would crash. There would be no power, no fuel (which means no freight in or out). Let me know how that works for you. Oh, but you won’t be able to. No internet, no phone. Rex was here to speak at a mining forum, not a tree hugger love in. Maybe when they have one of those they can talk to David Suzuki.
Up 7 Down 28
Apex Parasite on Nov 27, 2018 at 9:01 am
The tired rhetoric of "we wouldn't have anything without mining", while true, does not address the fact that we, as a species, consume and squander resources in an unsustainable fashion that is disrespectful to the planet on the whole.
That we exploit the resource to prop up a bloated and apathetic status quo of unchecked consumerism and greed is the real problem, yet this rarely acknowledged or discussed.
Next time you fire up your heated steering wheel think about that, the resources that it took to allow you to do that and how truly shallow we are collectively that we cannot recognize the true value of that which we exploit.
We should be leaving the goods in the ground where we can and develop the resources as NEED dictates....not greed or convenience.
Up 8 Down 3
Josey Wales on Nov 26, 2018 at 10:10 pm
Hey Cardinal...speaking of eyes, mine are now almost lacerated from the absolute vaporizering you gave my sarcasm meter.
I think it is now beyond repair, never mind recalibration.
In these times of perpetual outrage, the fits of hilarity those few well crafted words you gave us...were very welcome.
Thanks!
Up 7 Down 31
Snowman on Nov 26, 2018 at 9:26 pm
I still don't understand why the Chamber of Mines would bring up an anti-environmentalist. For a few years now they have been trying to show the industry up here as having respect for the environment and First Nations. Now they go and bring up this guy to poke them all in the eyes with a stick? I don't get it. Bringing up this dinosaur just confirms the stereotype about miners not giving a flying hoot about the environment, especially climate change.
If I was a large player trying to show respect to the locals in Yukon I would have a pretty serious talk with the Chamber of Mines on what they were trying to accomplish by bringing this guy up. This is no different than an environmental group bringing up David Suzuki. You know it's going to start fights and not build any good will.
Up 20 Down 20
Rural Resident on Nov 25, 2018 at 3:38 pm
If you look at the Living Planet Index which the World Wildlife Fund has developed based upon long term monitoring studies around the world of vertebrate populations which include fish, birds and mammals, the populations used have decreased on average by approximately 60% in between the period between 1970 and 2014.
This is very alarming. Just think of the status of many whale populations or woodland and barren ground caribou. To me this means there is an impact from development and human activities we should all be concerned about.
I am not opposed to responsible mining or oil and gas development, I just want a high level of environmental protection for now and for future generations.
Up 37 Down 4
ProScience Greenie on Nov 25, 2018 at 1:48 pm
We can't build solar panels, wind turbines and electric vehicles without hard rock metal mines.
Up 9 Down 31
CJ on Nov 25, 2018 at 1:40 pm
I always thought he was an intellectual, but it's surprising how much he declaims without any substance. On a clip on the radio the other day he said he thought environmentalists should have to work in mining camps, something like that -- that would change their minds. As though nobody with an environmental frame of mind ever had the opposite experience, or for that matter, any experience outside of the stereotyped box he puts them in. His mental picture of environmentalists is out of some 1970s sitcom.
"He knows a man" who has already built three pipelines in Mexico. Wow, that's solid information we need reminding of. And as someone else pointed out, the state of fisheries in Newfoundland wasn't an act of God. And the hyperbole about trying to build the Banff hotel today. "It would bring the gallows". You have to laugh. "Bishop Suzuki" -- please. Or to quote Rex, "Good lord!"
I suppose if you consider it stand-up comedy, no worries, then.
As an aside, I wonder why the gift wasn't a gold nugget or something.
Up 9 Down 31
yt on Nov 25, 2018 at 10:06 am
"Energy and minerals are the very foundation of the quality of life here, Murphy added."
Well, Russia has energy and minerals, so does say Indonesia, but I wouldn't necessarily want to live there for their quality of life
Up 43 Down 3
Jim on Nov 24, 2018 at 7:20 pm
True for life to exist, clean water and air are required. But for our quality of life we enjoy in Canada it is also true energy and minerals are the foundation. There are not many things I can think of that we use every day that don’t have energy or minerals involved. Even renewable energy such as wind mills and solar panels rely on minerals and yes even that dreaded oil. So unless you are sitting inside your dirt floored cabin with a grass roof, cooking over an open fire, crapping over a log, and chasing down a rabbit with a stick, take some time and make a list of what you have that has energy or minerals has made possible. Maybe use your laptop or iPad in case you don’t have a pencil or paper.
Up 17 Down 8
Cardinal on Nov 24, 2018 at 1:09 pm
You may not like his political stance but Rex sure is easy on the eyes.
Up 16 Down 40
Woodcutter on Nov 24, 2018 at 10:13 am
Energy and minerals the foundation of life? Here I thought it was clean water and air all these years. Phew now I can relax that Rex has set the record straight.
Up 11 Down 36
Linzel on Nov 23, 2018 at 5:06 pm
All true Rex, but the fisheries closed because of human impact and mismanagement. If we do the same with our water and air, all our standard of living is for nothing. Pushing pipelines to the edges of the earth to destroy the environment we are completely dependent upon for health is not the way to go. He is also right he isn't educated enough about topics he discusses. Early oil extraction a hundred years ago was 18:1 ratio of energy out from energy in. Oil sands ratio is four to one. Not including the water resources needed to make it distillable. Renewables provide jobs, AND protect the environment (moreso than oil).
Up 53 Down 8
ProScience Greenie on Nov 23, 2018 at 3:21 pm
Nothing Rex said in his talk was unreasonable or over the top. Good on the miners for getting him up here to speak.