Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

TIPPING FEES OUT, SURCHARGES IN – Jennifer Dagg, the Department of Environment’s manager of standards and approval, and Dwayne Muchosky, director of community operations for the Department of Community Services, speak at this morning’s technical briefing.

Disposal surcharges set for electronics, electric items

Yukoners will soon be able to receive a refund on their milk jugs and be able to dispose of electronics and electrical products for free.

By Pierre Chauvin on May 12, 2016

Yukoners will soon be able to receive a refund on their milk jugs and be able to dispose of electronics and electrical products for free.

Starting next Aug. 11, milk containers, including soy and other substitutes, and drinkable yogurt containers will be refundable.

And, starting Oct. 11, Yukoners will be able to dispose of electronics, electrical products and any tire for free.

But to finance the disposal, surcharges will be applied on these products at the point of sale.

That means purchasing a laptop will cost Yukoners an extra $10 next fall.

The surcharge will be $12 for printers, $15 for desktop computers and $2 for cellphones.

For tires, the added sale cost will go from $7 for 17 inches and smaller tires to $50 for tires over 22 inches.

For electrical products, it will cost from $8 for a microwave to $2 for a hair dryer.

“It promotes more conscientious consumerism and responsible management,” Dwayne Muchosky, director of community operations for the Department of Community Services, told a technical briefing this morning.

The surcharges will also apply to online stores, said Jennifer Dagg, the Department of Environment’s manager of standards and approval.

“We’re working with industry to ensure that all retailers, regardless of where they’re based, accurately collect the surcharge for sale of this product and remit it to the Yukon government,” she said.

The regulations also give the department the option to contract an Outside agency to ensure retailers are complying with the regulations, she added.

But because similar fees down south are already in place, people used to buying goods there won’t see a difference, she said.

The changes also simplify beverage container refunds.

Two categories now exist: fewer than 750 mL and 750 mL and more.

For the first category, a 10-cent surcharge is applied and the customer gets five cents back when the item is returned. For the second, 35 cents are applied and the customer gets back 25 cents.

Milk containers, regardless of their size, will get the under-750 ml surcharge and refund.

The difference between the surcharge and the refund will go into the Yukon Recycling fund.

That funds pay for all the disposal costs.

The Yukon is one of the last jurisdictions in Canada to create fees for electronic disposal.

The Department of Community Services says it’s ready to handle products that will be disposed of in the first months of the regulations taking effect, but that won’t have had the surcharge applied yet.

“We’re prepared to deal with those products,” said Muchosky.

“This is about environmental stewardship, and we’re prepared to do whatever it takes to promote waste diversion and recycling.”

Muchosky was asked about Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) during today’s briefing.

Under EPR, processing cost for the waste with the product are paid by the producers.

During a zero-waste conference held in the city in March, the strategy was brought up as a way to divert waste from the landfill.

“We believe the changes being made could be a step in the direction toward EPR,” said Muchosky.

“It’s been nationally recognized there are challenges in implementing EPR for the North,” he said.

The distance to market and small populations spread over vast geographic areas are obstacles, he added.

The changes were made in the Beverage Container Regulation and Designated Material Regulation.

It’s up to the cabinet to enact regulations based on powers given in different acts passed by the legislature.

Fore more information, visit YGrecycles.ca.

Comments (23)

Up 0 Down 0

stayyukon on Jul 4, 2016 at 6:06 pm

These fees are charged by other provinces and Territories. Go on to Bestbuy or another online retailer and try different postal codes for your order and see the different fees. So if you choose to buy outside online and have it shipped to the Yukon you will still pay the Yukon fee . If you choose to buy your Ipad or Tv while in another province while travelling you will pay a fee that will benefit the province you purchased it in and not the Yukon.

Up 4 Down 1

Dave on Jul 3, 2016 at 11:08 am

I'm ok with some surcharges. I was, however, struck with $12 for a printer. I believe I paid around $50 for my last printer. That's a pretty big % point for that particular product.
Also I do pay a surcharge for oil for my car and yet I'm only able to take it to the dump 2 days a year.
I'm also curious about how YG will be able to demand surcharge fees from online companies. There are a lot of them. This would cost a lot of $ to enforce and will probably never be effective.

Up 8 Down 0

computer owner on Jun 30, 2016 at 1:51 pm

I can't WAIT to see how Amazon responds to Government of Yukon's request to collect this tax on their behalf and submit it to YG.

Up 4 Down 0

Trevor M. on Jun 30, 2016 at 11:43 am

The $10 applies to iPads (and tablets). It will cost $10 more to purchase an iPad in Yukon compared to $1 more in BC and elsewhere. Yukon will still be stuck with the recycling costs, but the funds intended to support the program will not be there if persons purchase outside the Yukon. The program idea is good, but the execution and numbers will do nothing but damage local businesses and Yukon taxpayers will still be left paying for the "free" recycling. Somebody was away on vacation (this is actually true) on this one.

Up 9 Down 4

Ontario-itus? on May 16, 2016 at 4:45 pm

Cash grab?
Quite possibly...

I don't know...
But last time I checked Ontario was 6000 Kilometers away - what did it ever do to you?

Up 32 Down 4

Curious on May 13, 2016 at 5:28 pm

" But because similar fees down south are already in place, people used to buying goods there won’t see a difference, she said."
Why are tipping fees for Construction type waste (gyprock, used lumber, electrical) priced @ about $90/tonne in Whitehorse and they are only $10/tonne in both Grande Prairie and Kelowna?

Up 25 Down 7

This is on the Liberals and NDP on May 13, 2016 at 1:56 pm

bucket list over the last five years along with 100's of more tax increases which will add up to $100 million dollars deficit which parties are pushing for.

Up 30 Down 19

Drillbit on May 13, 2016 at 1:51 pm

Will continue to buy online and donate used electronics to the 'gun ranges' outside of town.....win, win!

Up 21 Down 35

Joe Boyce on May 13, 2016 at 10:46 am

There should be surcharges on many other things that are harmful to the environment.

Up 45 Down 13

Alex Franklin on May 13, 2016 at 9:47 am

WOW - what a stupid idea.

This will do nothing but hurt local retailers.

AND yet the Territorial government keeps screaming at us to support Yukon businesses.

Up 25 Down 41

Politico on May 12, 2016 at 10:35 pm

What a bunch of entitled consumers we have here. Charge them to take it to the dump they throw it in the bush. Make them pay a disposal fee in advance they take their business else where. Read the article, buying outside you are already paying a disposal fee. None of you have made any suggestion on how to finance the $28 million it's going to take to open a new waste facility.
@Francis, what an ugly attitude you have toward anyone wanting to come to the Yukon. If you don't want us to come maybe we'll just take out transfer payments and go home. Let's see how long your Yukon will survive then.

Up 35 Down 10

Jack Colby on May 12, 2016 at 9:40 pm

So - I'm expected to believe that Civil Servants can introduce new taxes whenever they feel like it ?
Why doesn't the name of the Yukon Party politician who is actually responsible for this appear in the article ?

Up 41 Down 12

jc on May 12, 2016 at 9:25 pm

Our taxes used to pay for all that disposal. What happened? Oh yeah those taxes now go to welfare bums and refugees.

Up 31 Down 11

Josey Wales on May 12, 2016 at 9:14 pm

Awesome..between being NOT a ESL instructor and loathing "Ontarioitus" more reasons not to buy stuff here. Eco taxes to feed a industry of hucksters.

Anything I pay extra for with BS grab-tax...online and outta territory.
Man I hope Ontario becomes a working province again when they ditch the witch...then our "newbies" can return and pedal their snake oil there.

Up 21 Down 41

Mr. Rogers on May 12, 2016 at 7:50 pm

Oh my here they go again "I'm a true blue Yukoner, born and raised, so this gives me free rein to rape and pillage the Earth without having to owe anything back to society". Give me a break guys. Why don't you stop with your comments full of hot air - at least if you did, in some small way you might mitigate some of the carbon footprint you produce.

Up 28 Down 7

Wolfe on May 12, 2016 at 5:18 pm

Oh well, it keeps a bunch of YG folks employed. Coming up with these absolutely
useless solutions ensures that they will all receive a big fat pension cheque.
And what exactly does this mean - "But because similar fees down south are already in place, people used to buying goods there won’t see a difference, she said."
More rules and regs from folks from Ontario..
What about those of us from "Up here' that are not used to buying goods with these taxes..we will notice a difference..in some cases a huge difference..but wait..we don't matter.

"“This is about environmental stewardship, and we’re prepared to do whatever it takes to promote waste diversion and recycling.” And what about this statement? How will putting a pre-tax promote waste diversion? If anything it will create more waste..because there is no charge to chuck it out now.

Up 59 Down 17

yukon 56 on May 12, 2016 at 4:45 pm

Ill just buy my electronics online, buy tires while out of territory etc. What a crock this is

Up 63 Down 22

Francis Pillman on May 12, 2016 at 4:27 pm

Please take me back to the old Yukon. I miss you. Sincerely an actual born and raised Yukoner. All this cap comes courtesy of all the new people from Ontario way. Just leave us alone with your greenwashed claptrap.

Up 61 Down 17

Does this never stop... on May 12, 2016 at 4:17 pm

...putting yet again your grubby little hands into the pockets of the working stiff. Tax, tax, tax - call it what you may. If it looks like a tax, collected like a tax then by golly it is tax - not a damn surcharge.

I feel so privileged that our government feels it necessary to grope through everyone's pockets to collect yet more money. Milk was the last thing in the world anyone would expect to be taxed - excuse me surcharged. If the federal government when it brought in the GST exempted Milk - why? Because it is considered a necessity not a fluff expense. But it is only $.10 some say. I don't care if it is only $.01. For once, just once, put a stop to the stupidity. There are far too many folks here in the Yukon that live from pay cheque to pay cheque. Of course the fat cats in government don't care as they draw their 100k+ salaries...

Up 57 Down 15

Max Mack on May 12, 2016 at 3:43 pm

A money grab by any other name is still a money grab. Your sophistry changes nothing. The amounts charged will not materially change consumption, but will raise a bunch of money that the government can give away to that money pit called Raven Recycling.

Correction - for the poor, the new charges on dairy products will have an effect on consumption. "Sorry, kids. We can't buy a jug of milk this week." Shameful, I say.

And, I almost choked when I read this:

"starting Oct. 11, Yukoners will be able to dispose of electronics, electrical products and any tire for free."

Actually, you will be charged for it in advance of disposal. Either way, the consumer is paying for disposal. I would also argue that you are being charged more up-front than you would in tipping fees at the time of disposal.

Up 38 Down 18

Dr Mantis Toboggan on May 12, 2016 at 3:35 pm

That's not very fair to people that just throw their electronics in the garbage. Why make us pay for a service we don't use?

Up 50 Down 23

Francis Pillman on May 12, 2016 at 3:21 pm

Oh look. Another tax. Another tax that accomplishes absolutely nothing. I'll continue dumping my car tires and whatever in the dumpster. And make sure I always buy used.

Up 53 Down 18

Broke on May 12, 2016 at 3:15 pm

Another reason to send money outside of the territory and shop online.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.