
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Education Minister Tracy-Anne McPhee
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Education Minister Tracy-Anne McPhee
Schools stayed open on Monday through the heavy snowfall – but delayed communication left many parents wondering about closures and bus service.
Schools stayed open on Monday through the heavy snowfall – but delayed communication left many parents wondering about closures and bus service.
“We recognize there was a delay in getting updates out to families Monday morning as we co-ordinated across government and with Standard Bus to gather information and provide updates,” Kyle Nightingale, a Department of Education spokesperson, told the Star this morning.
An email to parents from the department wasn’t sent until after 9:30 a.m. Monday – about an hour after the beginning of the school day.
That afternoon, parents were notified that school bus services would be delayed and normal stops adjusted according to road conditions. That correspondence was issued just after 3 p.m., when most students would be boarding their school buses.
Scott Kent, the Yukon Party’s education critic, said Tuesday the late email left many parents “scrambling” to figure out where their children would be dropped off.
Education Minister Tracy-Anne McPhee told the legislature that Monday presented an unusual situation.
“It was certainly weather that no one can predict,” McPhee said.
The department began communicating with school buses at 7 a.m. Monday, and difficulties presented themselves as the morning progressed.
“School buses were, on occasion, getting stuck in snow,” McPhee said.
“Communication back to central office, and therefore on to parents, may have been slower than we had wanted it to be.”
Nightingale said parents are encouraged to register for email notifications using the My School Bus Monitor.
Schools remained open for students’ safety, according to the minister.
“Parents are best-placed to determine whether they will send their child to school,” McPhee said.
“It remains essential that school buildings be open during extreme weather conditions to provide safe shelter for those arriving at the building and for those students who may have nowhere else to go if parents have to go to work.”
Several Yukon parents posted to social media this week, decrying the government’s response to the snowfall.
One suggested that keeping schools open was “putting bus drivers and kids at risk for no reason” – and contrary to the city’s advisory to stay home.
Another noted that by the time they received the afternoon bus delay notification – which informed parents that students wouldn’t be dropped on side roads, but on the highway – it was too late to pick their child up from school directly.
A third parent said they were hesitant to keep their child home from school, despite the poor conditions, worried their child might miss the tests scheduled for that day.
“I was checking for updates all morning … and nothing came,” another parent added.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (12)
Up 9 Down 1
Atom on Nov 9, 2020 at 11:52 am
It's the saddest thing to listen to folks who seem outright unhinged the Liberal government is in power. They should have! They didn't!
Irony is we are debating actions by Yukon Ed staff in dealing with the "parents' of the 'children' they are charged with educating.
Just pathetic. When in doubt, use own discretion.
Up 7 Down 1
Lost In the Yukon on Nov 8, 2020 at 11:00 pm
Dearest Dan ... you raise two questions/issues: 1. You claim each school principal makes the call ... so the principal at Selkirk can make one decision and the principle at FH (right next door) can make a different one and the principal at Vanier yet another. Seems to be a recipe for chaos does it not? Taking this scenario one step further add in when the decision is made ... so now you have three schools all making different decisions and at different times and now calling into the Department at different times ... well, you follow the thread.; 2. If that is the case then the Minister should simply apologize for the confusion, say it’s unacceptable and promise to do better.
Up 10 Down 18
Pikachu on Nov 6, 2020 at 9:31 pm
@Leadership
Yeah she could do a bit better by all means. But she is still doing quite well and light years better than what we had under the Yukon Party. At least people within the current government have all different sorts of education including Tracy (a Lawyer). For the Yukon Party, I don't think a single one of them has anything beyond a high school education. I mean Brad Cathers was feeding sandwiches to sled dogs in LaBerge one day and the next he was Yukon's Minister of Health LMAO. If Currie and the YP win the next election, Cathers will again be given a position way over his head (shudders).
Up 5 Down 6
Klaus G. on Nov 6, 2020 at 4:45 pm
Well stated Minister McPhee. I'm sure many who will be apologetic on here now know who calls what.
Up 13 Down 11
Leadership wanted on Nov 6, 2020 at 2:07 pm
#1 blunder here is the lack of communication with parents - another indication of the lack of confident leadership within Sandy's Club. I'm not sure it was McPhee's place to tell everyone to stay home, but someone sure should have.
However, the minister should have a prepared a plan, for blips such as this one. That includes vetting the busing contractor and making sure there has been a plan prepared, ahead of time, for blips such as this one. "Coordinating across government," aka winging it the day of a snow storm, is not a good look. Leadership wanted.
Up 24 Down 5
Dan Davidson on Nov 6, 2020 at 1:23 pm
Lost In the Yukon: It just happens that sometimes the correct answer sounds like an evasion. It is up to school administrations to make those calls, not the minister. The bus company calls the school and the school lets people know what the situation is. Most of this ought to happen before the minister ever gets to work and is advised of the problem.
Up 21 Down 6
Lennie on Nov 6, 2020 at 12:13 pm
Well Scooter Kent, your comments in the Leg were not well thought out.
The people ultimately responsible for the children are the parents, the parents, the parents. I have never known Schools to be Locked and children stranded outside. If the parents drive them to the school, the parent have a duty to ensure the students make it into the school. If the children arrive on the school bus, the school bus driver will not leave the students until they are safe, with a teacher or monitor. Those who leave children without ensuring their safety must be fired and criminally charged. A criminal Negligence charge will draw everyone's attention.
Up 18 Down 3
M Hamm on Nov 6, 2020 at 7:00 am
Regardless of how unexpected this weather was there should have been a plan already in place to deal with the situation that just needs to be rolled out. This is still the Yukon, large snowfalls in winter months can be expected and alternate bus drop off sites are easy to plan in advance. The Yukon has historically never had a point where weather closes the schools, we don't have snow days and like another comment noted unless there is a problem with the building - they have to stay open to shelter those who still show up. I myself was rather confused when I got an email at 8:30 saying the school was closed because of the snow (only to be walked back 20 minutes later after I turned back home) which threw me off as it should stay open.
Up 18 Down 5
SashaW on Nov 5, 2020 at 10:36 am
Here is the thing. That snowfall was epic. The schools should be open. Select staff able to make it to the school should be at the school to open and supervise kids. BUT the Department should have advised parents to keep kids home if they could. Should have advised teachers to stay home other than those there to supervise. Sure - send the buses out in case some kids walk to the bus stop alone and need a ride. BUT ADVISE people to stay home if they can. There was none of that. The Minister should have made a call. She didn't. It's obvious more could have been done to keep people off the roads.
Up 38 Down 8
Always something to complain about on Nov 5, 2020 at 8:12 am
This really irks me. Everyone, I mean EVERYONE, was doing the best they could on Monday. It was unprecedented weather. And what are the chances that the parents complaining didn't even go to work because they, themselves, couldn't get out their driveway. Give your heads a shake and use some common sense. If you can't get to work, teachers and school bus drivers probably can't either.
Up 24 Down 12
Lost In the Yukon on Nov 4, 2020 at 6:05 pm
This is sad ... when Traci replaced Jan Stick as the MLA for Riverdale South it was a shocker but she started strong in her role as a Minister. She answered questions directly and clearly. She seemed very well informed and interested in honestly representing all Yukoners ... not her Party. Today she sounded like a politician, obfuscating and deflecting ... and not informed or interested in talking to Yukoners and willing to speak the truth. Very sad ... we need Jan Stick back, Traci has lost her way.
Up 59 Down 8
Dan Davidson on Nov 4, 2020 at 3:13 pm
Yukon schools always stay open in case some students actually come and need to get out of the weather. Having worked in three rural schools I can testify that they only ever closed if there was a problem with the actual building. In such a case, it would be up to the individual schools, not the Dept. if Ed., to contact the parents.