Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

FIRM ACTION ESSENTIAL – Emily McDougall, Kluane Adamek and Dana Tizya-Tramm, left-right, are seen at the Yukon First Nations Climate Action Gathering news conference late Tuesday afternoon at the Kwanlin Dün Cultural Centre.

Declaration embodies the Indigenous view

Elders, youth, leaders and representatives of the Yukon First Nations have declared a climate change emergency.

By Chuck Tobin on February 19, 2020

Elders, youth, leaders and representatives of the Yukon First Nations have declared a climate change emergency.

Regional Chief Kluane Adamek of the Assembly of First Nations (AFN) held a press conference late Tuesday afternoon after three days of a Climate Action Gathering in Whitehorse hosted by the AFN with financial support from the federal government.

Joining Adamek at the press conference were Vuntut Gwitchin Chief Dana Tizya-Tramm and Emily McDougall, a youth delegate and the AFN’s climate co-ordinator.

Together, they explained how it was a special gathering to bring together the views of the youth, the knowledge of the elders and the leadership of community leaders to create a declaration that embodies the Indigenous point of view.

It is the Indigenous people, after all, who have occupied, have lived on, who have been a part of the land since time immemorial, they said.

“We have spent two incredible days together,” Adamek said.

She said the declaration will be followed up with an action plan.

The declaration must be supported by an action plan, she said.

The plan, the regional chief explained, will be similar to setting carbon reduction targets in the Paris Agreement but it will be forged here.

Adamek said the declaration embodies the Indigenous view. The action plan will embody traditional knowledge, and a traditional approach to arrive at solutions, she said.

She said the climate emergency declaration is a step toward bringing together First Nations not just from across the North but from across Canada.

It will feed into the national two-day climate gathering the AFN is hosting in Whitehorse next month, Adamek said.

The regional chief said the people of the Kluane region know climate change is real, just like the Vuntut Gwitchin of Old Crow know it’s real.

“We know that climate change is here,” Adamek said. “We experience it in our communities more than anywhere else in the world.

“The declaration is seeking to bring together the First Nations.”

This week’s climate change gathering began Sunday with a day dedicated to providing the youth and elders with an opportunity to talk, to get know each other and to share their views.

Monday and Tuesday saw some 100 participants listen to representations from experts in the field of climate change and community leaders discuss a variety of topics, including renewable energy alternatives.

“It’s has been a very transformative and inspiring few days,” said the youth delegate and climate change co-ordinator.

McDougall said the gathering presented an opportunity to hear from youth who came from across the Yukon, northern B.C. and the Northwest Territories.

It was an opportunity for the youth and elders to share their thoughts openly, she said.

The Vuntut Gwitchin chief said the ability to deny climate change is a luxury Yukon First Nations simply don’t have.

The gathering provided delegates with a chance to provide a modern day view of how the world is changing by people who’ve been on the land for thousands and thousands of years, Tizya-Tramm said.

He said it has fostered the truest form of inherent self-government, supported by traditional knowledge.

Yukon First Nations know climate change is real, and they know they have to respond, said the Gwitchin chief, whose First Nation became the first to declare a climate emergency with its declaration last summer.

“We need to respond, and yes, we have our own solutions,” said Tizya-Tramm.

The climate change emergency declarations by the youth and the gathering as a whole were unavailable this morning as they were awaiting final approval.

The City of Whitehorse and the Yukon’s legislative assembly both declared climate change as an emergency late last year.

It’s commonly accepted that climate change is occurring in the North two to three times faster than anywhere else in Canada.

Comments (33)

Up 1 Down 0

Juniper Jackson on Feb 27, 2020 at 3:38 am

Youth. You come talk to me when you have a job, have to foot the bill for your clothes, your car.. talk to me when you have to feed your babies.

Youth have no responsibilities. They live in their parents home, eat food paid for by someone else. I don't have time or inclination to listen to "youth" spouting off in self importance. If you can, I'd suggest you get back to the land, and that right shortly. Canada is a mess, I am grateful to be living in the Yukon. But, the wing nuts have successfully shut down the country economically. What are you going to do when your money dries up?

Up 35 Down 6

george on Feb 24, 2020 at 4:35 pm

Unfortunately for the least wise, when opportunities like Teck fade away so does the tax revenues and job opportunities and, when you're a welfare state like the Yukon and NWT and the free money starts running out...it's too late.
Canada is poised to be a leader in environmental safety, maintain a healthy economy, exporting oil and gas to other countries and who have little or no environmental concerns and thus significantly reduce carbon emissions...but instead...let's grandstand and go broke...ya real smart

Up 14 Down 2

Mick on Feb 24, 2020 at 2:56 pm

@ Gringo

Weather and Climate are not the same thing.

Up 25 Down 3

Talking About My Generation... on Feb 24, 2020 at 12:32 pm

Dear Miles - Your most recent submission is the sort of commentary we should avoid. It is emotionally laden with non-factually-based opinion.

Please provide us with the stats to suggest that Yukoners have poor driving habits.
What is your evidence to suggest that homes are larger than they need to be?
Environmental protections within the city limits are poor - What is your basis for this?
Who is entitled and what are the basic conservation efforts you speak of?

Up 7 Down 32

Miles Epanhauser on Feb 23, 2020 at 1:58 pm

It seems to me that Yukoners have a low impact on the environment because of our low population base.
However per capita our impact is very high because of poor driving habits, high fossil fuel use in vehicles, and an infrastructure that does not produce enough green energy etc.
Homes are also much larger than they need to be.

Environmental protection is poor within the City of Whitehorse boundaries and there seems to be resistance to GY initiatives to protect sensitive areas outside of the communities.

It's nice to see young First Nation leaders addressing the climate change issue but there is a lot of resistance because many people are entitled and they resist basic conservation efforts.

Up 37 Down 9

Gringo on Feb 23, 2020 at 8:59 am

We cannot predict the weather 5 days in advance yet we have the SCIENCE to predict that the world will end by 2050 if we don't reduce emissions. Does this make sense?

Up 27 Down 5

Jack Schmidt on Feb 22, 2020 at 10:49 am

Dear Jack M. - Reasoning from an emotional platform should always be suspect... Arguments based on a foundation of feelings should always be refuted.
There was a popular game a while back called You Know Jack... Perhaps that is what we are playing now?

We should be teaching our children to have sound reasoning skills based on evidence, logic and rigorous methodology. Teaching them to propound their feelings instead of reason and logic is doing them and society a great disservice. We should be collectively ashamed for teaching them that “feelings” and “emotion” are a basis for defining a “reality” and “consequently” a society.

This was the inherent problem with colonialism, assimilationist practices, and their affirmations through policy and law such as the Indian Act. ALL “you people” need to give your head a shake!

“Relentless criticism”? Frack off! We must always be engaged with the alternatives to be certain that the next step we take has firm ground beneath it. It is the way all people learn to be better people. We cannot move forward in a bubble or our own self-confirmed echo chambers - GOOD Leadership understands this.

People learn nothing from their rescuers if those rescuers seek to protect those they rescue from the learning experience.

Up 22 Down 10

Al on Feb 22, 2020 at 4:08 am

Most people have no f*cking clue what they're talking about. Myself included.

Up 42 Down 4

Choosetobegreateveryday on Feb 21, 2020 at 9:05 pm

Dear Borntobegreat:
Your comment is profoundly wrong and it is absolute prejudice. You cannot describe people in their aggregate and have that description retain any meaning at the individual level. When you use these presumptive descriptors to suggest that one is lesser than another then it simply becomes - RACISM.
All Europeans are not Christians. There are 3 major religious structures in Europe with each of these groups capturing many variants within them. These are Judaism, Islam and Christianity.

“The European” has turned the Earth into a “rubbish heap”? This is not true. You need to open your eyes and look outside the confines of your own hatred. Have a drive around the communities and observe many FN neighbourhoods. Look at the pollutants and Industrial waste spewed into the environment from China, India, Russia, South America etcetera and you will see a different picture.

Many Europeans and other non-Indigenous people share a connection to the land and water. FN people are not “special” or “exceptional” in this regard.
We are all in this together and we need our leaders to stop treating “us” like we are in some No Holds Barred WWF Cage Match.

So, I challenge you, Borntobegreat, to be great right now!

Up 32 Down 8

JC on Feb 21, 2020 at 5:29 pm

Jack M. It's you climate change groupies that are doing all the complaining. The rest of us are just trying to make sense out of all this. It's why we research both sides of the issue. I suggest you do too.

Up 28 Down 5

Oya on Feb 21, 2020 at 3:30 pm

@ confused: What a good point you make.

Up 16 Down 46

Jack M. on Feb 21, 2020 at 3:20 pm

Not surprising with the "insightful" and "thoughtful" comments in this thread. Same old complainers. Very disappointing when young people are motivated and committed to make a difference. Relentless criticism, ridiculing, trying, but failing, to be witty - that's all I see on this site.

Up 44 Down 10

North_of_60 on Feb 21, 2020 at 2:09 pm

Chuck Tobin apparently believes "It’s commonly accepted that climate change is occurring in the North two to three times faster than anywhere else in Canada."

That's nothing but Doomer propaganda based on computer models, not substantiated by actual data or science.

Up 44 Down 10

Groucho d'North on Feb 21, 2020 at 9:16 am

All these declarations of climate emergency - It's the environmental #Metoo sideshow.

Up 43 Down 12

I. Will Assoom on Feb 21, 2020 at 7:11 am

For Fox Lake! Global warming, climate change and/or extreme weather phenomenon have been occurring since the creation of this planet.

There is no climate emergency. What we have here is a sense of urgency in the minds of those who have sustained a mental health pathology in the form of a mass hysteria. Like the Medieval Witch Hunts, the Red Scare, or the War in Drugs the current climate change scare is just another moral panic to keep the m’asses as stupid as it is necessary for the system to function.

And there you are saying... Please, just a little more fear, with a dash of hyperbole, a generalized blindness for facts and evidence, and some emotion, erm, lots of emotion...

Up 63 Down 9

Confused ... on Feb 20, 2020 at 10:11 pm

Don't y'all own half an airline? I mean it is a great business decision for the VG to have a 49% control in its own lifeline. Shrewd, in fact. But it's probably time to divest, hey? There's no way that burning countless liters of kero is reconcilable with the climate alarm agenda. So put your money where your mouth is and get back to dog teams for freight. Until then shush and stop getting in the way.

Up 43 Down 16

JC on Feb 20, 2020 at 8:52 pm

But I do have another question though to anyone of the FN. Before the white race came over to this part of the world, what were the Indigenous peoples using in the way of renewable energy? And what kind of laws were set up for oh, let's say, theft, assault, murder and even sexual abuse. Did they have any kind of police forces to enforce local laws and provide protection to the early citizens? Did any of that information come down by mouth? Just curious.

Up 14 Down 55

Borntobegreat on Feb 20, 2020 at 7:38 pm

For the uninformed and bigoted opinion mouth pieces, indigenous view refers to the sacred value system associated with all First Nations, " We are part of the land, and part of the water. It's like saying the European view is Christianity, the earth is God's footstool, not yours. But we know the European has lost all sense of the sacred and has turned the earth into a rubbish heap.

Up 36 Down 13

Nicky on Feb 20, 2020 at 7:19 pm

Yukon indigenous people have been here for thousands of years. If they listened to the elders instead of alarmist teenagers spouting UN climate propaganda on social media, then they might learn that the changing climate we are experiencing now is not alarming or unusual in the context of the Yukon's climate history.

Up 14 Down 49

Miles Epanhauser on Feb 20, 2020 at 4:00 pm

Think they are on the right track and they will champion renewable energy and low energy consumption and they will protect their land.

This commitment is what is usually symbolic in the rest if the world and it's why we should act now for future generations.

Up 56 Down 10

Anue on Feb 20, 2020 at 2:28 pm

Fascinating. This small group have taken it upon themselves to label their declaration as capturing the "indigenous view". What a huge ego exercise, to speak on behalf of 600+ first nations with elected governments as well as their who knows how many additional born-to-rule chiefs.

Up 44 Down 9

Anie on Feb 20, 2020 at 2:24 pm

Salt. Well said. Common sense seems to have gone by the wayside and we are all caught in a bunch of historical nonsense.

Up 22 Down 55

SH on Feb 20, 2020 at 1:50 pm

JC,
What have indigenous people done with the land before the white race came? They used it, of course, in a responsible, respectful, and sustainable way. However you want to look at it, they have a strong history in the area. As such, it makes sense that they should feel the need to make a statement on climate change and it's effects on the land that they've historically used. I don't understand what your issue is with that... shouldn't we be encouraging people to take action against climate change?

This view is coming from a non First Nations... just so you know that one doesn't have to be FN to disagree with you.

Up 15 Down 46

When someone says 'I'm not being racist' on Feb 20, 2020 at 12:13 pm

Guaranteed, the next words will be racist. JC, that's a very 1700-1900 attitude about use of land and concept of property

Up 71 Down 14

Salt on Feb 20, 2020 at 11:50 am

There is nothing inherently special about Native Americans ‘connection’ to the land. Not 1 in 10,000, if any, lives a truly traditional life. In the thousands of years that North America has been inhabited different groups/tribes have occupied constantly changing areas. Rising, falling, disappearing, reforming due to trade, conflict, weather, etc. Just like the entire rest of the world. There is this fairy tale view promoted that European settlers disrupted a magical place without conflict or conquest. That is a lie. The ‘traditional territories’ are a snapshot in time of the natural human tribal competition for resources.

Up 20 Down 53

BnR on Feb 20, 2020 at 6:36 am

JC, if you have to tell us you’re not being racist, well, I’ve got some news for you....

Up 50 Down 14

Matthew on Feb 20, 2020 at 5:41 am

It's yet another lie told to us by the UN.. I can prove it too.. can't have a 1 sided view on a topic without hearing others. Sad how the unelected UN controls EVERY aspect of Canada..

Up 47 Down 13

Josey Wales on Feb 20, 2020 at 2:17 am

A climate emergency eh?
Quite a proclamation, seems a popular, almost trendy proclamation to wail?
Climate action gathering 2020 eh?
Reads like a migration of herds to a never ending salt block of funding.

Reminds me of a the chicken lil effect, the sky is falling...the end is near...
you must fear...run for your lives...panic...we will save you...believe us and dare not challenge.
Tactics better suited to cults...that chug down the Kool Aid with complete blind faith in those that make proclamations infected with tainted virtue.

Speaking of proclamations, when one factors in the age old identity politics, the eco warriors, the SJWs and the PC Crusaders?
Seems fitting to proclaim that clearly mental health is suffering more
than our planet...and is easier to fix.

I know..I know, scoldylocks will now scowl my way with a emotionally unstable sour puss face.
“How dare you” ...said a entitled spoiled brat rife with serious issues around climate anxiety in need of a better acting coach.

Oh yeah, got it chief...climate emergency!
How much “more” funding required to heal your planet?
A few million tossed your way a good start to this Crusade?
Going old school and walking to meetings in deerskin now post proclamation?
Banning all colonial machinery on your lands, and the dinosaur juice required to run them?

“Good effin grief” Charlie Brown, fictional cartoon character
...speaking of fiction.

Up 48 Down 13

Greiko on Feb 19, 2020 at 9:42 pm

Climate emergency, climate change, global warming...what if it’s a good thing? What if global warming means trees grow faster in the north, agricultural blossoms in the north? What’s the harm? Perhaps people should YouTube Dr. Patrick Moore to see what’s real and what is not. We are led to believe a lot of nonsense that is costing million upon millions for nothing. Just read and remember a lot of these so called scientists are being funded by governments to say the right thing...it’s really interesting.

Up 39 Down 9

Holly Focher on Feb 19, 2020 at 8:50 pm

No it does not... It embodies some Indigenous peoples views. It is a thinking error to engage in absolutes. It is rather incredulous that someone would believe they can speak for anyone else. This has greater truth from an Indigenous worldview wherein one cannot speak for another. WTF? Is this the final solution? The consummation of Western European values into Indigenous forms?

Up 66 Down 14

Joe on Feb 19, 2020 at 6:50 pm

“It is the Indigenous people, after all, who have occupied, have lived on, who have been a part of the land since time immemorial, they said.” The planet is 4 billion years old, some indigenous groups can be traced 15,000 years or so, mixed DNA and such....not quite immemorial. So much self entitlement.

Up 59 Down 13

Max Mack on Feb 19, 2020 at 4:45 pm

Such grand-standing political arm-waving. All designed to funnel yet more money into FN coffers through "green energy" deals and other subsidies.

Traditional knowledge? I wonder if that includes the relatively sudden and massive warming that occurred about 14,000 years ago, shortly after the first people came across the land bridge? Does it include the still-unexplained Younger Dryas period, where the earth suddenly cooled for about 1000 years? How about the extremely rapid warming following the Younger Dryas? What about the Minoan, Roman and Medieval Warm Periods? The Little Ice Age?

Despite the near-constant alarms by activists and "woke" journalists, Canada is and will remain a very cold, population-sparse country. Substituting relatively abundant and cheap, energy-dense fossil fuels with "green" energy sources will be ENORMOUSLY expensive and will have no discernible impact on CO2 emissions or climate change.

Up 81 Down 35

JC on Feb 19, 2020 at 3:43 pm

Part of the land since time immemorial? What happened to the Berring Sea land bridge? Is that all a myth now. However, if this fable is true, what has the indigenous peoples done with it before the white race came? Can they point to anything that was built by their race? I'm not being racist here, I'm just saying there is another view and opinion. And what I see across Canada, the proof is in the pudding so to speak. You can say, all you want, but it's going to be hard to find genuine believers.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.