Whitehorse Daily Star

Deceased's daughter takes action against RCMP

The daughter of Grant McLeod, a man who died in police custody two years ago, is taking legal action against members of the Whitehorse RCMP.

By Elizabeth Hames on August 27, 2010

The daughter of Grant McLeod, a man who died in police custody two years ago, is taking legal action against members of the Whitehorse RCMP.

In documents filed in Yukon Supreme Court this morning, Elycia Carlick says she suffered, and continues to suffer, damages due to the officers' alleged breach of duty of care when they arrested her father in August 2008.

Carlick says she has lost the companionship and affection of her father, endured psychological injury, and incurred expenditures for treatment of her psychological injury.

McLeod died shortly after wrestling with police, and one of the officers attempted to put the man in a choke hold.

On the morning of his death, the RCMP were called to the Chilkoot Inn after receiving call about a man staggering around the lobby with a needle in his hand.

When they arrived on the scene, they found McLeod. After struggling with the man, they were able to cuff him.

Shortly afterward, McLeod was unresponsive. He was taken to Whitehorse General Hospital, where he was pronounced dead.

An autopsy found the cause of death was a cocaine overdose. A coroner's inquest into the matter supported that conclusion.

In the documents, Carlick claims her father died during the arrest due to excessive and deadly force by the officers, who allegedly failed to provide first aid care to McLeod.

She says the officers "displayed mob behaviour” while arresting the man. Their conduct was either due to a lack of police procedure and training, or failure to follow policy and procedure during the arrest, she argues.

Furthermore, Carlick says police breached the duty of care owed to her father through "intentionally negligent, grossly negligent, deliberate indifferent, reckless and bad faith conduct.”

The Attorney General of Canada is also listed as a defendant.

Comments (14)

Up 0 Down 0

Sarah on Aug 31, 2010 at 8:56 am

Here we go again with another case and someone else saying it's the RCMP's fault it's time for people to realize it's there own fault if they choose to drink excessively or take drugs. The RCMP is just doing their job, maybe if these people didn't choose to drink or do drugs they wouldn't be in this situation!

Up 0 Down 0

Yukon Wild on Aug 31, 2010 at 1:10 am

I am not a huge fan of the RCMP but blaming them for a drug overdose is ridiculous. Whether they RCMP were there or not this fellow would likely have died of the drug overdose. They were protecting other around him from possible harm. One of the stages of grief is anger and I suspect the family is angry and looking for someone to blame - the RCMP are a convenient target. Their loved one died because of his own actions - he is responsible for his actions, not anyone else.

Up 0 Down 0

fed up in whitehorse on Aug 30, 2010 at 5:15 am

I'm tired of seeing the RCMP take the blame every time someone who has messed up thier own life has to be dealt with.

The cops get blamed if they don't do anything and get blamed worse if they do something.

Why don't we just abolish police and then everyone could do as they pleased?

People no longer take any accountability for thier own actions and are experts at playing the blame game. No one has the guts to stand up and say 'You know what, it was me that was drunk/stoned/coked out and no one made me do that, it was my choice, I made the decision to take substances that destroy my body and had the possibility to end my life. I took a gamble and I lost.'

That's why street drugs are illegal, but anymore you'd think it was the cops that are illegal for trying to deal with with the after effects of whatever flavour of the day substance people pollute thier body with.

Up 0 Down 0

Yukon Hootch on Aug 30, 2010 at 4:46 am

People, just because the Whitehorse Star reported that the daughter said that excessive force was used doesn't actually mean excessive force was used. If this case gets taken to court they will make this determination; if it makes it to court.

Was the daughter an eye witness? If she was it should be noted that she wasn't even able to contain her father obviously considering he was wandering around. I am sure she was not present however so she is relying on the statements of those present which may or may not be reliable. OR she is just assuming the RCMP were too rough because her father passed away and she failed to consider other health issues, ei. health problems associated with drug use or just being high and not functioning properly.

The RCMP are employed to protect us however they also have a right to be concerned for their own personal safety. At that time the RCMP also needed to consider the risk of the public. No one wants to be stuck with a dirty needle and that is something that could have occurred inadvertently. A used needle should be regarded as a gun or knife because of the life long effect being stuck with one could have.

Ironically this lawsuit has surfaced since the RCMP are currently on the hot seat. If the family of the deceased gentleman felt so strongly why wait two years?

The family should take a personal initiative to review the circumstances which brought that deceased gentleman to a situation with the RCMP. The gentleman paid the ultimate price for choosing to engage in illegal activities; it doesn't have to be like that for the next person. Perhaps the family should become advocates and focus their energy on reducing drug use in their family and/or the community. When the RCMP have to get involved it's already too late. Maybe some people just feel taking a financial handout is easier than working towards solving the problem.

Up 0 Down 0

Go Elycia Go on Aug 30, 2010 at 3:26 am

oh come on now guys this article is just the tip of the iceberg dont pass judgment so soon. There are alot of things that are unknowns. A C A This case was one of the first in the Yukon to have family representation at the inquest. The family after hearing all of the facts of the inquest do not agree with the findings which is thier right. Use your mind do you think that it is easy to prove a case? Do you think that maybe it takes time to prepare a case and that may be why the timing would suggest that she is .... how did you put it... is taking advantage of the recent media craze over the other man who passed away while in custody. Maybe if she had been able to file her case sooner Silverfox may still be alive today? This case is not just about a drug addict that died in custody it is about how our RCMP treat the most vunerable in our community. Lots of Love and Prayers going out to ELycia and her family. I cant imagine how hard it would be to step forward with the Madison Jones, YukonPetes, Joan Smiths and A C As of the world passing judgment.

Up 0 Down 0

Anonymous on Aug 29, 2010 at 11:51 pm

I think in this example the only thing the RCMP could have done different would have been to call an ambulance to the scene and assisted the attendants with this individual. They are not medics and there is no way they could have saved this person. And the family should have been notified right away. I don't feel his death is the RCMP's fault. I think they could have done a few things differently, but they did what they are supposed to do, protect the other people in the area from this self destructive person's actions.

Up 0 Down 0

Mandy Cordelea on Aug 29, 2010 at 4:28 am

I think that Elycia is doing the right thing and everyone who has negative things to say should first, think about how regardless of the lifestyle Grant lived, Elycia is still out a father. The RCMP should give every person the same treatment and care. No matter the backround. Good For you Elycia for taking a stand againts injustice so that every person in the future will have the same oppertunitys and treatment as the next! I'm also sorry for your loss!

Up 0 Down 0

daddys girl on Aug 29, 2010 at 4:03 am

i know the truth...and soon you will too

god grant me the serenity the accept the things i cannot change, the courage to change the things i can and the wisdom to now the diffrence..

Up 0 Down 0

A C A on Aug 28, 2010 at 4:28 pm

She is NOT doing the right thing!! What is wrong with you people?! The RCMP are not responsible for someone not caring about themself. If I were to abuse drugs and cause a scene then die while in custody, it is no one's fault but my own.. Sadly I think that this young lady is taking advantage of the recent media craze over the other man who passed away while in custody.. these stories are completely different and she should respect the situation of the other - not take advantage of it.

Up 0 Down 0

Joan Smith on Aug 28, 2010 at 10:11 am

Damien you are ridiculous! She is NOT doing the right thing. It clearly states that the cause of death was a cocaine overdose, nothing to do with how the RCMP handled the situation that they were called to, to protect others in the area. How about we point the finger at who actually deserves it and stop trying to throw the RCMP under the bus.

I agree completely with Madison.

Up 0 Down 0

damien lankow on Aug 28, 2010 at 8:51 am

Dont you think if elycia could help her father she would have? Sometimes it doesnt work that way. You have probably had everything handed down to you and have never had any hardships. Lawsuits like this do NOT prevent officers from attending future calls, open your eyes. She IS doing the right thing,

Up 0 Down 0

yukonpete on Aug 28, 2010 at 5:26 am

when are people and the families of these people going to start taking responsibility?? It's a joke! How is it the RCMP's fault?

Up 0 Down 0

Monterey Jack on Aug 28, 2010 at 3:30 am

The RCMP are not the heroes people paint them out to be. If they do think that...they're either dilusional or have never actually known an RCMP member. With one of the highest divorce rates and spousal violence rates in any profession in canada its easy to see that simply having a high school diploma may not make the best officer. Out of the 6 of my friends who joined the RCMP 4 have left disgusted with either their bosses or compatriots for bigger metropolitan Police forces. Having said all that. I'm making sure its understood i'm no cheerleader for the RCMP like madison is.

Up 1 Down 0

Madison Jones on Aug 28, 2010 at 3:15 am

Elycia Carlick, why don't you sue the drug dealer who sold your father the cocaine he overdosed on? The RCMP aren't responsible for your father's actions, he is. The RCMP are responsible for the safety of those in danger from his drug induced behaviour. Luckily they were there to prevent anyone else from getting hurt. Furthermore, where were you when your father was abusing drugs? Why weren't you helping him with his habit and providing him with "the duty of care" you and your family owed to your father? The RCMP should sue you for not getting your father treatment and for endangering the officers lives. Did I miss the part in the inquiry where it was the officers who injected your father with cocaine? Is open season on the RCMP? Should I sue because I got a speeding ticket? It's not my fault they caught me on Radar. Your lawsuit is frivolous. Lawsuits like this will only prevent officers from attending future calls like these and then where will we all be? The RCMP deserve so much more praise than the daily tabloid style media bash we see everyday. God bless the RCMP. Thank you for risking your lives for the sake of ours.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.