Whitehorse Daily Star

Deceased’s mother sues Yukon government

The mother of Cynthia Blackjack,

By Rhiannon Russell on November 6, 2014

The mother of Cynthia Blackjack, a Carmacks woman who died after a medevac to Whitehorse, has filed a lawsuit against the Yukon government and health care providers who looked after her daughter, alleging negligence that caused her death.

Blackjack was 31 when she died last November of multi-organ failure as a result of hyperacute liver failure at the Erik Nielsen Whitehorse International Airport.

An inquiry last summer into her death by the Yukon’s chief coroner detailed several issues with equipment and delays in the lead-up to Blackjack’s medevac.

The coroner made eight recommendations for the Yukon government, including a review of medevac policies and procedures.

Shortly after, the Department of Health and Social Services said it would examine its clinical practice guidelines.

Theresa Blackjack alleges in a statement of claim filed Tuesday:

• that health centre nurse Deborah Crosby failed to recognize that Cynthia needed urgent medical care;

• that medevac doctor Jake Morash failed to assess her in a proper and thorough way and failed to determine whether a medevac was appropriate under the circumstances; and

• that two medevac paramedics, Mark Loewenberger and Erik Miller, failed to ensure that the correct medical equipment was on board the flight before leaving Whitehorse.

The Department of Health and Social Services also failed to keep the Carmacks Health Centre supplied with proper functioning equipment, she further alleges in her lawsuit.

Due to the parties’ negligence, her daughter died, Theresa alleges in the document.

She’s had to cope with that loss, as well as pay for grief counselling and Cynthia’s funeral.

In her August report, coroner Kirsten Macdonald listed “significant factors” in Cynthia’s death:

• a blood transfusion was delayed because the wrong type of IV tubing had been brought to Carmacks;

• there appears to have been hesitation about whether to intubate her for the flight, despite signs of shock, decreased level of consciousness, and high respiratory rate;

• once decided on, intubation was delayed due to a lack of pressure oxygen to attach to the health centre’s ventilator;

• the first ventilator tubing circuit failed;

• there was no functioning suction apparatus at the centre, which delayed and could have compromised management of Cynthia’s airways; and

• the paramedics and physician weren’t able to use the mechanical ventilator on board because of several pressure alarms, so she was ventilated using a hand-held device.

Cynthia was well-known to staff at the Carmacks Health Centre, Macdonald wrote.

On Nov. 4 and 5, 2013, Cynthia called the centre, complaining of dental pain.

The day before her death, she dropped by, and staff noted dental decay and slight swelling on the left side of her face.

They tentatively diagnosed her alcohol-induced gastritis, and gave her medication for nausea and morphine for pain.

Cynthia was released that morning, and was told to return to the health centre if she couldn’t find a ride to Whitehorse by later in the afternoon.

On Nov. 7, a family member called to say that Cynthia was disoriented and yelling out in pain. Staff at the health centre drew blood for a series of tests, some of which had to be done in Whitehorse.

At 11:15 a.m., they decided to medevac her to Whitehorse General Hospital. The medical team, consisting of a doctor and two paramedics, arrived about two hours later, but the flight didn’t leave Carmacks until 5 p.m.

About 10 minutes before landing in Whitehorse, Cynthia’s heart rate began to slow. At 5:40 p.m., her vital signs were lost and the team started CPR.

She was pronounced dead at 5:59 p.m.

An autopsy revealed she had 10 abscessed teeth and “rampant” generalized dental decay. She had fluid in her lungs and her liver was pale and fatty, the coroner’s report states.

Macdonald wrote that health centre staff’s assessment and management of Blackjack’s condition on Nov. 4, 5, and 6 was “reasonable given the presenting symptoms, medical and social history.”

But sending her to Whitehorse on Nov. 6 for more thorough testing – Carmacks has limited ability to conduct lab work – would have provided a more complete assessment, the coroner said.

A case management conference for Theresa’s lawsuit has been scheduled for February of next year.

Comments (10)

Up 91 Down 88

Clayton Johns on Nov 13, 2014 at 5:52 am

Heart goes out to the family, so sorry you have to go through this!

Up 99 Down 100

john gould on Nov 11, 2014 at 1:20 pm

It's nice to see that racism is still alive and well here in the Yukon, funny how the coroners report said 10 abscessed teeth, which in itself is enough to kill you, but here in the Yukon if you're young and native it's always the alcohol that did it. Shame on anyone that doesn't understand the hurt and distrust that this family has endured and "Winter is here" your comment about suing the liquor store is insensitive and proves that you like many others here think that you can say what you want about native people and nothing will be said. But in fact it just shows that all the bull crap about equal rights for all races is just that, bull crap, shame on you and anyone who thinks like you. And to answer your question am I native? "NO". I am a proud Irish man who has had to learn how to accept people for who and what they are and look at things through others eyes so that I don't humiliate myself making public statements about a race of people who have been thru decades of abuse and still are able to smile and accept me. Grow up and listen instead of speak and maybe you will learn something. My condolences to the family for your tragic loss and I hope you are successful in your suit against the people responsible for your daughter's death.

Up 118 Down 92

Angelina on Nov 8, 2014 at 11:24 pm

Yes, the right equipment and procedures should have been in place to help her. However, would it have helped her or just patched an underlying problem? The mother should be offered some sort of counselling and perhaps speak out against alcoholism.

Up 106 Down 93

gina on Nov 8, 2014 at 2:02 am

Yes it might not matter to the Yukon Government "Who or Why" she passed away but Yes it does to Us in the community and like what June Jackson was saying is true and right, built a foundation in their child's name that educates, promotes safety, does a lot of good. In some way, that gave meaning to their child's death. Do it, Do it for Cynthia.

Up 122 Down 93

William on Nov 7, 2014 at 3:06 pm

She was my childhood friend and now I gotta live with the loss of a good friend. I think they should have sent her in earlier and having the wrong equipment is not good. They have to take things seriously even though it is a small community .. it's just so sad to not have her around anymore.

Up 110 Down 102

Blame the victim on Nov 6, 2014 at 8:37 pm

In Watson Lake the Dr. seemed to have made some assumptions about the health status of the individual and she died. The Health Professional had / has a duty to set aside assumptions and treat as if they had never seen her before - and that means looking at all potential issues. This is akin blaming the person who has been abused or raped because of the clothes they where wearing.

Up 117 Down 97

Erin Kinney on Nov 6, 2014 at 5:22 pm

Alcohol being a factor or not - a loss was made and could have possibly been prevented with the proper equipment and procedures in place.
If this was a patient who did not have alcohol in their social life; I am more than certain there would be an uproar regarding how this life was lost under these negligent circumstances.

A human life is a human life regardless of their back ground or self inflicting ways.
Bless the family and I hope the Creator will ease the pain this loss has brought them

Up 105 Down 136

winter is here on Nov 6, 2014 at 4:52 pm

The mother should sue the Yukon Liquor Corp. They make huge profits off of people who have addictions. The gov. knows how much grief alcohol causes but, they continue to profit from it anyway and this is done at the expense of peoples lives. Further, the Yukon doesn't even have a treatment center for Yukoners who need help with their addiction. I am sure the health care system does the best they can with what they have in a small community but, they are also carrying a burden which is caused by the government selling alcohol for profit. Alcohol should be illegal just like pot. What purpose does booze serve in society......it causes nothing but destruction for families and it only makes government more profitable.

Up 188 Down 117

JB2109 on Nov 6, 2014 at 4:37 pm

This is going to sound slightly heartless. But it's quite clear that this woman's alcohol abuse led to her death. While I agree that YTG could have done a better job is it really them who caused her Mother's grief, suffering, need for counseling or was its her daughter alcoholism?

Up 139 Down 123

June Jackson on Nov 6, 2014 at 3:40 pm

I understand grief.. for whatever reason, a mother is without her daughter.
But it always seems to end up about the money.

There was a case not terribly long ago where the government was sued, the family took an awful lot of money, built a foundation in their child's name that educates, promotes safety, does a lot of good. In some way, that gave meaning to their child's death.

This article didn't say if Ms. Blackjack had similar plans.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.