Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Yukon Party Leader Currie Dixon

Daycare plan isn’t universal, minister told

The Yukon government’s plan to offer universal daycare was the subject of debate last week with the official Opposition.

By Tim Giilck on May 31, 2021

The Yukon government’s plan to offer universal daycare was the subject of debate last week with the official Opposition.

The Liberals were on the defensive as Currie Dixon, the leader of the Yukon Party, intensively questioned them on the subject.

“Since its inception, the Liberals have been referring to their new early learning and childcare program as ‘universal,’ which suggests that it is universally available to all Yukoners; however, we know that it is certainly not universal as it excludes over 1,000 Yukon children for several reasons,” Dixon said.

“One of those reasons is its uneven application in rural Yukon.

“I would like to provide the minister with a few examples. First of all, take Ross River. There is currently no daycare or childcare program in that community.

“Because the Liberals’ program only applies to licensed childcare spaces, parents and children in Ross River are left out.

“Can the minister tell us how she can call the Liberal program ‘universal’ when it is not available to children in Ross River?”

Education Minister Jeanie McLean tackled the issue on behalf of the government.

As has been the case with ministers answering questions this session, the question was not exactly answered.

“Our government believes that all children should have access to affordable and high-quality childcare and early learning opportunities,” McLean added.

“We recognize that capacity is certainly a concern. Work is ongoing to provide more integrative, collaborative programs and services to better meet the needs of Yukon families. This certainly does include working with our rural communities.

“We have made historic investments in childcare,” the minister added.

“Our new universal childcare program is making life more affordable for Yukon families, and we recognize that we have a lot of work to do with our rural communities, which we are endeavouring to do.

“Again, these investments are historic and a long time coming,” McLean added.

“This is something that our government has made a priority and will continue to do so as we move forward with all our partners throughout Yukon.”

Dixon followed up with more numbers provided by the government.

“Another example of rural Yukoners being left behind by the Liberals is in Dawson City,” he said.

“According to the minister’s own numbers that she provided earlier this sitting, there are 20 childcare spaces at the Little Blue Daycare, but the wait-list is 36 children. That means that, because of the way the Liberals have designed this program, the 36 kids who are stuck on the wait-list are out of luck. In some cases, we’ve heard that the wait time is over a year,” Dixon said.

“How can the minister claim that the Liberals’ program is universal when so many families in Dawson City receive no benefit from this program at all? “

McLean tried again to provide a definitive answer.

“Our government believes that all children should have access to affordable, high-quality childcare and early learning opportunities,” she said.

“As I’m standing today to speak about universal childcare and the accessibility, I want to point something out to Yukoners. In 2002, the Yukon Party had a platform that said that they would ensure that Yukoners have access to quality affordable childcare services. They did not deliver on this,” McLean said.

“Our government has made historic investments into early childcare and early learning opportunities for Yukoners.”

“Digging 20 years into the past is cold comfort for those Yukoners who are on wait-lists or unable to access affordable childcare,” Dixon replied.

“The minister said that affordable childcare should be available to all Yukon children — that’s exactly what we are saying — and it’s not right now.

“How can the minister call the Liberals’ program ‘universal’ when it excludes so many Yukon children?

“I agree that this program has made lives of some Yukoners better, but it has not made the lives of all Yukoners better, and certainly not all Yukon children,” Dixon added.

“That is the issue — that this program is not truly universal. That is the issue.

Comments (10)

Up 3 Down 1

YukonMax on Jun 4, 2021 at 7:25 am

Get your act together as a community and train some of your community members to become a daycare workers. If the situation isn't worth the effort, then maybe you just don't need it.

Up 8 Down 6

Anie on Jun 3, 2021 at 1:44 pm

"Why" asked why government is paying for childcare. We are government. We pay for education, whether we have children or not. All society benefits. Childcare is the same, and should more accurately be called early childhood education, then people wouldn't whine. And, by the way, I don't have children.

Up 7 Down 6

Anita Laperriere on Jun 3, 2021 at 11:36 am

As a parent in Dawson who is currently 35th on the wait list for my second child and receiving the benefit of the "universal" childcare for my 4 year old, I can easily say that I would rather have continued paying for childcare and see this money go into more childcare spaces rather than free childcare. While I am not a supporter of the YP I agree with Currie that this program only benefits a small group of Yukoners and leaves many others still struggling.
As to the person who said that childcare isn't a government problem, lack of childcare leads to many other issues such as families being forced to move from communities and the Yukon and Yukoners not being able to return to or join the workforce because they don't have childcare. These are all issues that effect the government.

Up 6 Down 2

Bongo on Jun 2, 2021 at 10:31 pm

Hey Bingo and SH, this isn't about the opposition shooting holes through announcements. BnR is correct about Currie and the YP leading on socialized childcare. In the election that just happened, Currie Dixon promised to have a childcare program that gave every parent $500 even if their child wasn't in daycare or needed it. In fact, the Yukon Party proposed a socialized system which they said would cost $3 million more than the current Liberal plan. But I'm guessing you are fine with socialism so long as it's the Yukon Party proposing it.

Up 8 Down 4

Yukoner on Jun 2, 2021 at 10:10 am

I wonder if she recites her lines in front of the mirror each morning.

Up 25 Down 9

why? on Jun 1, 2021 at 11:33 am

Why is child care a government problem? The government does NOT run the daycares. Why are people's life choices the government's problem? I chose not to have kids for many reasons, including childcare availability and expenses.

Up 11 Down 11

Disappointed on Jun 1, 2021 at 11:03 am

Nice to see the Liberals trying to slip around the question, it must be very aggravating to try and debate against. Instead of offering a history lesson about how the YP also failed with childcare, why not offer a productive solution, earn your pay. Admit you've left kids out of the equation and that you're working on a solution, not faffing about.

Up 14 Down 4

SH on Jun 1, 2021 at 9:14 am

BnR, they don't call him lead of the opposition for nothing. His job is to debate and critique almost anything brought forward by the Liberals. In this case, "universal" childcare is the subject of debate.

Up 12 Down 7

Bingo on May 31, 2021 at 8:34 pm

@BnR...I think what the opposition is doing, what they are getting paid for is to shoot holes through the swiss cheese announcements.

Up 31 Down 40

BnR on May 31, 2021 at 4:31 pm

Since when did Currie and the YP become the leader on socialized free daycare for all?
Did I miss something?

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.