Photo by Photo Submitted
Brandy Vittrekwa
Photo by Photo Submitted
Brandy Vittrekwa
A teenager pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the death of 17-year-old Brandy Vittrekwa on Thursday in Yukon territorial court.
A teenager pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the death of 17-year-old Brandy Vittrekwa on Thursday in Yukon territorial court.
The male teenager, who was 15 when he was arrested last December, pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter.
A publication ban prohibits the reporting of any information that could identify him because of his age.
The boy was arrested on April 28 of this year and appeared the following day in court.
Vittrekwa was found dead on the evening of Dec. 8, 2014 on a trail in the McIntyre subdivision.
Three days later, the youth was arrested a first time and considered a suspect, but wasn’t charged in connection with her death.
He remained in custody for unrelated offences.
“It’s a relief in a sense for her family; they’re not going to have to go through a long trial,” Doris Bill, the chief of the Kwanlin Dün First Nation (KDFN), told the Star.
She noted the plea came at a difficult time for the Vittrekwa family, a little more than a week after the one-year anniversary of the young woman’s death.
“Our community will be thinking about them,” said Bill.
Vittrekwa was a Gwich’in citizen from Fort McPherson, N.W.T.
She moved to Whitehorse with her family in 2012.
“I’m glad he has taken responsibility for his actions but I guess I’ll have to wait until more details come out,” Bill said.
In cases of guilty pleas, facts of the case are read during the sentencing hearing.
So far, little is known about what happened that night.
“I have some deep concerns about this young individual; I will have to wait and see what his sentence is,” said Bill.
She expressed some concerns a youth sentence may not deal appropriately with potential issues of violence the offender might have.
“Particularly to how it relates to missing and murdered indigenous women, this has always been a concern in cases of homicides and manslaughters that these underlying issues are often not addressed by the justice system,” she said.
“When it comes to indigenous people, the solutions have to be hollistic.”
Crown prosecutor David McWhinnie has filed a notice of intention to seek an adult sentence.
“Seeking an adult sentence is effectively a two-step process though, where an assessment is usually sought/obtained before the application actually proceeds,” McWhinnie told the Star Thursday afternoon.
“Today, the court was asked to order a Section 34 assessment, so the required notice has been given, but not all the evidence which may affect the decision is yet known.”
The Youth Criminal Justice Act contends a youth can be sentenced for up to three years for manslaughter, but only part of that sentence is to be served in custody.
If the young man was to be sentenced as an adult, the Criminal Code sets a maximum sentence of life in prison, but no minimum.
A couple of months before Vittrekwa’s death, another McIntyre resident was killed.
Allan Waugh was found dead at his home on May 30, 2014.
Nobody has been charged in Waugh’s death, despite repeated pleas by his family for anybody with information to come forward.
The two deaths prompted the KDFN to implement measures aimed at improving safety in the community.
On Monday, the First Nation announced an anonymous tips line for residents to report potential crime concerns (see Thursday’s Star).
The boy is scheduled back in court Jan. 28 to fix a date for sentencing.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (15)
Up 21 Down 5
Yukoner 98 on Dec 24, 2015 at 9:54 am
'Don't call him a boy' You wish this was the states so we could lock him up forever? So how would you like to pay for a massive prison system like the states has.... maybe trade our health care system? A big tax hike? I would love to hear your ideal plan. The U.S. has by far the largest prison population in the world and in case you haven't noticed crime is still through the roof there.
Up 8 Down 74
Yukoner 98 on Dec 24, 2015 at 9:47 am
I understand everyone here is running on pure emotion, what he did was vicious and horrible for sure. But that doesn't make him a man. Just like Omar Khadr the 15 year old kid (at the time of his actions) who killed a soldier in a war zone.
Rehabilitation is a real possibility when getting them at this age. Their brains are far from being fully developed and they have very little life experience. The other option is to put them in jail for 20 years which will cost a LOT of money and then put them back on the street as a criminal. Unless of course you think 20 years or more in crime school will result in them coming out as a well adjusted and responsible citizen.
One more thing, if we are to treat 15 year olds as adults, should your 15 year old daughter be allowed to marry a 40 year old man? Or become a stripper? Become a porn star? Because hey..... they should know better right....
Up 47 Down 9
BeenNorth on Dec 23, 2015 at 12:18 am
I hope he is sentenced to the Max. If his sentence does not equal the brutality of her death, then you're going to see a lot of upset people in this community. So we are left with a 14 year old who cannot be identified, but he could possibly be out in 2 years roaming the streets without being treated which isn't very comforting.
What kind of treatment and rehabilitation will he get at YOF? Will he even get it in a Federal prison?
Up 11 Down 96
Karyn Atlin on Dec 21, 2015 at 5:14 pm
Thank you Chief Bill for being so non judgmental before all the facts are heard, and for taking precautionary steps for your community. It must be so difficult when your community takes so much of the load. My heart goes out to both families. One who has lost a child permanently and the other who will lose one to a system who may not give this young person what he now needs.
Up 70 Down 36
Disgusted on Dec 21, 2015 at 2:46 pm
Hollistic, you can't heal a 15 year old murderer. Come on, he will most likely spend the rest of his life in a correctional setting. Give him an adult sentence. At least give her the justice. A life wasted and for what? No one will ever know, no trial and he doesn't have to testify and answer to anyone.
Up 48 Down 13
Just Sayin' on Dec 21, 2015 at 9:32 am
No, perfect aspect for the Gladue reports to be used. He might be a 3rd generation residential school survivor. I think this a perfect crime for circle sentencing. I am sure if Brandy was a different ethnicity, people from the aboriginal community would be demanding leniency based on his past and residential school. I hope people can see that I am being facetious. Criminals do not see colour, they see opportunity ergo they should all be punished based on their current crime.
Up 78 Down 36
John Gould jo on Dec 20, 2015 at 2:44 pm
Absolute crap- manslaughter. This guy murdered this little girl and shame on the chief for endorsing such a repulsive act. Everyone knows this kids last name and who his relatives are but I guess if they can get found guilty and get sentencing postponed till March then manslaughter instead of second degree murder makes sense. The Yukon justice system is a farce and a joke normalizing murder and drug dealing. Wow, good job.
Up 132 Down 54
Don't call him a 'boy' on Dec 19, 2015 at 12:59 am
The accused is not a 'boy'. This makes him sound naive and young, which he is not. He is almost of adult age, a young man. A young man who did a violent, horrible crime and must be punished. In one sentence you call him a 'young man' and then at the end you say 'boy'. Wish this was the States, youth here have way too much protection when they do a heinous crime.
Up 121 Down 48
Dennis Allen on Dec 18, 2015 at 8:02 pm
Calling the offender a "boy" is a dangerous and reckless. He acted in a viscous and horrific way that took an innocent victim's life. Someone missed the boat.
Up 112 Down 34
jacine fox on Dec 18, 2015 at 4:29 pm
I think it is complete B.S. that he's permitted to enter a guilty plea to mandate.... An to boot the Chief of KDFN to endorse that action is unbelievable....Thank goodness the Crown is seeking to try him as an adult.
Up 113 Down 42
Adult Sentence REQUIRED on Dec 18, 2015 at 4:17 pm
A three year manslaughter conviction is a JOKE. Brandy's life was worth more than that--way more. He deserves life in prison and he needs to get help (if ever he could be rehabilitated, so jail is the place to get counselling and reform his behaviour). Three years he won't get any help and he will do more violence to others.
We are scared of this type of individual walking among us and our children--get him help and lock him away to do that. One only needs to look at all of the mistakes with Mark Lange--going soft on big crimes only makes it easier to murder, rape, torture and beat people....First Nations women who are murdered need the law to show that consequences are severe, not a Gladue softy softy sentence. Oh, and btw, how is beating a person to death manslaughter? Manslaughter is accidental, there is no accident when you beat somebody to death...2nd degree seems to be the right guilty plea. Plea bargains are pathetic.
Up 101 Down 43
holistic on Dec 18, 2015 at 4:14 pm
Holistic? Lock him up and throw away the key.
Up 63 Down 40
good for him on Dec 18, 2015 at 4:01 pm
Good for him he took her life he should get life!
Two young lives lost.
RIP Brandy, may you rest easy.
Up 105 Down 43
Thomas Brewer on Dec 18, 2015 at 3:53 pm
Would like to know why the Crown accepted a plea bargain of manslaughter. Were they doubtful they'd get a first or second degree conviction? Hope this does get elevated to adult court as this Young Offender is unlikely to be rehabilitated - protect society, send him away for a long, long time.
Up 106 Down 30
June Jackson on Dec 18, 2015 at 3:43 pm
He should get the same sentence he gave Brandy.. bleeding hearts will say he was young.. he has a long life in front of him.. blah blah blah.. so did she..and now she doesn't and neither should he.
15 is old enough to know how wrong murder is.