‘COVID-19 has changed the world’
The Arctic Winter Games were cancelled on Saturday due to concerns over the novel COVID-19 virus. A press conference was held to announce the cancellation (see full coverage in Sports).
By John Tonin on March 9, 2020
The Arctic Winter Games were cancelled on Saturday due to concerns over the novel COVID-19 virus. A press conference was held to announce the cancellation (see full coverage, in Sports).
Dr. Catherine Elliott, the acting Chief Medical Officer of the Yukon, made the recommendation to the City of Whitehorse, the Government of Yukon and the Arctic Winter Games Host Society.
The decision to recommend the cancellation of the Games involved consultation with the other chief medical officers of the nine contingents. Elliott noted public health preparations for the Arctic Winter Games, or any games, begin a long time in advance.
“With the event of COVID-19, we began conducting real-time rapid risk assessment factors that might impact the Games,” said Elliott.
“I’ve brought together the CMO of Health from the regions that are sending athletes to the Games and the Public Health Agency of Canada health operations and we worked with Canadian border services to assess all the communicable disease risks including COVID-19 and to co-ordinate risk-based mitigation and triggers for decision making.”
The novel coronavirus started in China in December 2019. Elliott said it has caused more than 100,000 cases globally, mostly in China, but the majority of the spread is outside of China.
COVID-19 is a contagious disease that spreads person-to-person rapidly through respiratory secretions. It is not spread through the air.
“COVID-19 has changed the world,” said Elliott. “It is a contagious disease that spreads from person to person rapidly through respiratory secretions.
“In a setting like the Arctic Winter Games, where people are sleeping and eating and playing together, the potential to spread is amplified greatly.
“Even in the absence of COVID-19 here, a single case of suspected COVID-19 would have serious impacts. For example, a person with a cough travelling to the Games would need to be isolated while waiting for results.
“The necessity for rapid and rigorous health response for that individual, for their contacts, for their guardians, and the isolation while waiting even for a negative result, the potential for fear, the concern here and the circumpolar North, these would be challenging in the setting of the Arctic Winter Games in Whitehorse,” she added.
Although the risk of contracting COVID-19 in the Yukon remains low, Elliott said, preparations are underway if it does spread to the territory.
“I want to assure you that in Yukon, we are already responding to the potential threat of COVID-19,” said Elliott. “We are taking this time of low risk to mobilize our public health response and our preparedness for acute care services.
“We are actively monitoring for cases, conducting surveillance by leveraging our existing influenza surveillance systems.
“We are ready to ensure excellent care in a way that protects the health of our population and of an individual should COVID-19 arrive here.”
COVID-19 affects people differently, Elliott said. It is worse for the elderly and people with underlying medical issues. The fatality rate for the aged and the sick is two per cent.
Eighty per cent of people who contract the virus get mild to moderate disease and the person does not require hospitalization. Fourteen per cent develop critical disease which causes respiratory distress and five per cent develop critical disease where they have failure of an organ system.
Elliott said there is no vaccine and no specific treatment. She also said it is less severe than SARS but more contagious and it’s more severe than influenza but less contagious.
The anxiety COVID-19 is spreading throughout the world also makes the virus dangerous, said Elliott.
“Fear can be more dangerous than the virus itself,” said Elliott. It causes people to do things that are unwise, like stockpiling goods, trying to protect themselves in various ways and this is also a concern.”
Elliott told the crowd at Saturday’s announcement that scenarios were considered so the Games wouldn’t have to be outright cancelled; however, no scenario mitigated risk.
“In the next week, things are not likely to get better globally,” said Elliott. “The most likely scenario is more spread globally and potentially affecting more areas where people are coming to the Arctic Winter Games.”
Elliott said it was with a “heavy heart” that she made the recommendation since the Games are a way to bring together northern communities.
“It is with a heavy heart that I am making this recommendation. A heavy heart for all that has come together – for the planning and the dreams of so many.
“This is an event that can bring together so many northerners from across Canada and from other circumpolar regions – it is the beauty and the strength and the cohesion of northern peoples.
“This beauty, strength and cohesion must remain strong through this announcement and in the coming days.”
See related story and statement.
Comments (33)
Up 0 Down 2
Harvey on Mar 16, 2020 at 6:52 am
Nicky how can you be taken seriously? Consider the state of the plastics in the ocean just during our lifetime alone.
Up 13 Down 5
Nicky on Mar 13, 2020 at 8:18 pm
@Snowman is probably too young and doesn't listen to elders, otherwise they should be able to understand that nothing climate related that we've experienced in their short lifetime is in anyway alarming or unusual. Perhaps when they get older and wiser they might realize how foolish they've been.
Silly Doomers.
Up 8 Down 5
Obi on Mar 13, 2020 at 5:42 pm
The WHO has said that dogs can get the virus, but they will not have them controlled. So it’s official, as to WHO let the dogs out!
Up 9 Down 0
Expat on Mar 13, 2020 at 5:09 pm
@Jack, good point regarding gas prices. On the east coast gas fell 10.5 cents per liter Wednesday and an additional 7 cents Friday to 86 cents per liter. It didn’t take weeks to filter through the supply chain, the first price drop at the pump was literally a day after world oil prices fell.
Up 14 Down 31
Snowman on Mar 12, 2020 at 8:57 pm
What are you talking about Nicky? Climate change is very much a real and continuing threat. You must have a short memory if you don't remember the record heat and fires in Australia just a few months ago. But don't worry, this spring and summer will bring fresh reminders of floods, fires and tornadoes. You can keep pretending its all normal though.
Up 8 Down 2
AL on Mar 12, 2020 at 3:13 pm
So Maxie what is your PhD in ? Aside from your rambling note it offered nothing to the concerns of many a folk.
Just a side note - since your 11th of March epistle did you notice how many events and restrictions have been given nationwide. Oh I see, you likely believe that everyone else is playing chicken little. Perhaps they are or maybe it is your take on how this is unfolding.
Up 31 Down 14
Nicky on Mar 12, 2020 at 3:04 pm
And Just Like That, Coronavirus Stopped Climate Change
Up 17 Down 4
Forrest’s Lump on Mar 11, 2020 at 8:29 pm
My momma always used to tell me that life was like a box of chocolates. You never know what you’ll get . ( T Hanks , 1994 ) .
Up 12 Down 6
question compitence of our CMO on Mar 11, 2020 at 8:01 pm
I agree with the do not panic and things our low. But I do have to question our CMO. How does she know more about this than the CDC and the WHO?
Stated today on another new site in reference to the PDAC news:
Dr. Catherine Elliot said Yukoners at the conference may have been exposed to COVID-19, but advised people without symptoms to carry on normal day-to-day activities.
She said people who have no symptoms cannot pass COVID-19 on to others.
As apposed to the WHO:
Can CoVID-19 be caught from a person who has no symptoms?
The main way the disease spreads is through respiratory droplets expelled by someone who is coughing. The risk of catching COVID-19 from someone with no symptoms at all is very low. However, many people with COVID-19 experience only mild symptoms. This is particularly true at the early stages of the disease. It is therefore possible to catch COVID-19 from someone who has, for example, just a mild cough and does not feel ill. WHO is assessing ongoing research on the period of transmission of COVID-19 and will continue to share updated findings.
Seems to me perhaps she should be studying more before giving information.
Yes the chance that people caught it and brought it back is low. However only isolation those that show symptoms is false. not a 100% guarantee.
Up 12 Down 46
Kafka Esque on Mar 11, 2020 at 5:53 pm
Not so Al.
Max Mack is right.
The decision to cancel the games is and will continue to be an irresponsible decision.
One really has to wonder at the apparent ridiculousness of the decision. You might as well put screen doors on a submarine! Many, many more people travel through the Airport in a given week who have come into contact with all sorts of people who have come into contact with all sorts of people who come into contact with all sorts of people who have something...
Absolutely asinine! You have not stopped or prevented anything but what you have done is escalated the panic and elevated the hype while causing economic hardships.
Up 11 Down 13
JC on Mar 11, 2020 at 5:48 pm
Al, trust me, the virus is coming. So don't expect the CMO to have everything under control. They haven't even told us what their plans are when it eventually comes. All they're telling us is not to panic. It'll be here when it comes. You're on you're own when it does. Make sure you got a lot of toilet paper. Or save your Sears catalogues.
Up 3 Down 19
Max Mack on Mar 11, 2020 at 3:44 pm
@Al
Right back at ya. Surely you don't buy what you're saying.
The so-called medical "experts" are over-reacting. The risk is low. Repeat. The risk is low. Repeat. The risk is low.
According to a former Ontario Chief Medical Officer of Health, COVID-19 doesn't appear to be all that transmissable. When someone does become infected, they are most likely to have no or moderate symptoms. And, quarantine is a questionable method of dealing with such an outbreak.
If you truly believe that population health is an absolute priority, then every person's activities should be managed minute-by-minute by a team of "medical experts" -- from sleeping, to eating, to drinking, to exercise, to supplementation, on and on. After all, left to their own devices, people do all kinds of things that might lead to injury or disease at some point. I'm sure you'll be the first to offer to pay for everyone to "enjoy" such a program.
Up 53 Down 6
Al on Mar 11, 2020 at 1:22 pm
Max Mack - surely you don't subscribe to what you are saying!
When it comes to decisions such as this I don't want a round table discussion about trade-offs and impacts (other than health). I want to see qualified people making the call - in this case the CMO.
No event is worth the health of our population. The last thing any one of us wants to see (particularly those of us that have lived our whole lives here) is a virus like this being taken back into the high arctic communities.
Not only was a sensible call it was "the right" call for all concerned.
Up 22 Down 8
Update on Mar 11, 2020 at 12:00 pm
Please change "self quarantine" to "monitor themselves for symptoms of coronavirus"
Up 19 Down 5
Update on Mar 11, 2020 at 11:58 am
As of today WHO has upgraded the threat to pandemic. And anyone who has attended the mining conference in Toronto has been asked to self quarantine https://business.financialpost.com/commodities/mining/pdac-mining-conference-participants-asked-to-monitor-for-coronavirus-symptoms-after-sudbury-area-man-tests-positive
Up 17 Down 36
Max Mack on Mar 11, 2020 at 10:42 am
The chief medical officers (cmos) are behaving completely contrary to their own statements about risk of infection. Risks are low - or so we have been told repeatedly.
But they (cmos) agree among themselves that the AWG should be cancelled and then the AWG committee, probably with an eye on limiting their own liability, acquiesce.
The consequences of this decision are substantial, affecting thousands of Yukoners and Canadians and affecting many businesses, which illustrates to me that these decisions should not be made in isolation and only after a prudent, balanced assessment of risks and trade-offs. Other voices should have been at the table when this decision was made.
Up 4 Down 3
Alan on Mar 11, 2020 at 10:14 am
A check out clerk at Superstore told me there would be no truck deliveries for 3 weeks because of the virus. This is not a joke, this is fake news. The guy should be fired. I overheard a new comer to the Territory talking about making a trip to Montreal and Toronto and driving back to Yukon. I know someone who is going to be coming back from Thailand. What is the strategy for testing people returning from virus locations. And what is the tourism expectation from China, Europe and Japan to Yukon?
Up 4 Down 4
SheepChaser on Mar 10, 2020 at 10:37 pm
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/bruce-aylward-coronavirus-who-covid-19-1.5492085
Up 45 Down 5
Jack on Mar 10, 2020 at 6:46 pm
Covid-19 has impacted oil prices significantly. Whitehorse Star, can you please investigate the price of fuel in Whitehorse? Gas prices have plummeted across Canada and yet they still remain so high here without any explanation. Gas in Edmonton has gone down to 84 cents per/L yet we are paying 75% more per litre at 1.42 cents.
Up 7 Down 4
Nicky on Mar 10, 2020 at 3:58 pm
Those who fail to learn from the lessons of history are doomed to repeat them.
During the critical period, from November 1918 to May 1919, not one case of influenza was reported anywhere in the Yukon.
On April 18, 1919 the quarantine was lifted in Skagway, and Whitehorse followed on May 2.
Once the quarantine was lifted, however, influenza made a quick arrival in the territory.
The hardest hit, however, was the First Nation population. Dr. Clarke rushed to Champagne on May 25 to deal with an outbreak; 37 natives were afflicted. He sent for a nurse and a cook to tend to the sick. By the time they arrived, there were 48 stricken, and the first death.
Almost a year later, influenza struck again. Residents from the native community at Carcross fell sick while working in Skagway. They were sent home before they had recovered, and the entire village was infected, save one individual, and four died, including Kate Carmack. The nearby residential school was also afflicted and one student succumbed to pneumonia caused by influenza.
--excerpted from Michael Gates' excellent article in the Yukon News
https://www.yukon-news.com/letters-opinions/yukon-and-the-flu-epidemic-of-1918-part-1/
Up 15 Down 26
JC on Mar 10, 2020 at 3:52 pm
Kafka, I would have given you 10 thumbs up for your comment, but I only have two and they only allow one.
Up 49 Down 12
Groucho d'North on Mar 10, 2020 at 12:52 pm
Canceling the AWG was the right thing to do. If just one kid from one of the arctic communities contracted even the plain old-fashioned flu while here, it could have serious repurcussions for all the people back home. According to the Medical Health Officers, a second wave of influenza is now making the rounds in the Yukon.
Up 35 Down 8
Not ideal on Mar 10, 2020 at 10:05 am
It would have been great to have the live press release take their own initiatives in to action. They probably shouldn't have had anyone who was remotely sick, regardless of the type of sickness, making any sort of speech.
They especially shouldn't have had one of the community representatives
coughing and sneezing, being offered tissues, and then grabbing the podium.
Up 6 Down 61
Matthew on Mar 10, 2020 at 5:41 am
Its ONLY a virus, even the CMO Mrs.Elliot knows virus' only grow in acidic environments, balance yiur bodies pH level to NEVER get sick again!
Up 47 Down 9
SheepChaser on Mar 10, 2020 at 12:00 am
"It causes people to do things that are unwise, like stockpiling goods, trying to protect themselves in various ways and this is also a concern.”
Human behavior is, by far, more dangerous than this virus. From panic selling in the global market to hoarding masks. The flaw in all human systems is us.
Then again, maybe the disaster (fire, earthquake) preparedness recommendations for the Yukon are a little unrealistic. Two winters ago, the shelves in Whitehorse were almost bare for a week just because a rollover and spill on the Alaska Highway blocked freight from Edmonton. That clued me into the need for three weeks, not three days, of the basics. I have a feeling that the shortages soon to come due to this pandemic will teach us all that three months is probably the new normal.
And yes, there will be supply chain storages. Call me alarmist all you like, but most governments are planning on a 25% absentee rate. If that holds true for the shipping, food and oil industries, shortages are inevitable.
Up 23 Down 17
Crunch on Mar 9, 2020 at 7:41 pm
You can tell by the look on Curtis's face that he lost that vote. Slivers abstained.
Up 48 Down 54
Kafka Esque on Mar 9, 2020 at 6:33 pm
No. Covid-19 has not changed the world. This is a Chicken-Little hyperbolic communicated to sell the Liberal Circus of mass hysteria. Quite clearly what has changed the world is the downward pressure of Liberal Dogmatism leaving us collectively dumber, fearfully impulsive with diminished self-efficacy.
Up 46 Down 25
JC on Mar 9, 2020 at 4:35 pm
And one more thing, tell Larry Bagnel to stay in Ottawa and don't make anymore trips to the Yukon until this virus is under control.
Up 55 Down 10
SH on Mar 9, 2020 at 4:32 pm
An hard decision (especially for the athletes/volunteers who have been working so hard), but probably the right one.
Up 25 Down 53
JC on Mar 9, 2020 at 4:31 pm
If the government is going to cancel Winter games over this, they better put a large sign at every entrance to the Yukon telling tourists to stay away and man the entrance points with police. They better forbid Yukoners from going out. Shut down all air and road traffic. This whole thing is getting ridiculous.
Up 46 Down 12
Rob on Mar 9, 2020 at 4:27 pm
This really sucks for all the athletes, coaches, organizers, parents and volunteers. So many memories these young athletes will miss out on. It’s a tough call and I’m not sure it was the right one. But if the chief medical officers are saying this is the best course of action I have to believe it is.
Sucks for all the parents from surrounding communities who have been driving their kids in religiously over the last few months for practices. But like I said before the worst part is the memories these kids would have made! Sorry to everyone involved but thank you for all the efforts you put in.
Up 41 Down 13
JC on Mar 9, 2020 at 4:25 pm
Have you ever seen such a mournful looking lot coming from the leaders of the Yukon. They look like they are about to cry.
Up 51 Down 24
North_of_60 on Mar 9, 2020 at 4:18 pm
I am not worried, I know the Liberals will do what they always do to get this under control. Trudeau will be announcing a Toilet Paper Tax to Fight the Corona Virus.