Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Coun. Laura Cabott

Council to have greater role in local content issue

City council has voted to become more involved in assessing how much weight should be awarded for local content when seeking professional services.

By Chuck Tobin on June 30, 2020

City council has voted to become more involved in assessing how much weight should be awarded for local content when seeking professional services.

The motion to have more council involvement was first introduced by Coun. Laura Cabott on June 15.

Under current city practice, administration decides how many points would be awarded for local content when weighing proposals for the provision of consulting services, engineering and design services and other such professional work.

Local content is only one aspect of assessing proposals and is given a weight of anywhere from zero to 20 points.

Cabott initially proposed that from here on until next March 31, all local content in the request for proposals be automatically given the full 20 points unless otherwise directed by council, as a means of assisting local business during the fallout from COVID-19.

The councillor noted earlier this month and again during Monday’s council meeting there is already a provision in city policy dating back to 2011 that allows council to set the value for local content when calling for professional services.

Local content, she noted, is only one aspect of weighing proposals, and local firms would still be assessed on their ability to fulfill other requirements of the project.

Cabott told her colleagues again Monday night providing more weight for local content is a way for the city to support its local businesses, especially in these times of the COVID-19 pandemic.

With the widespread impact of the pandemic, there will be more firms from Outside looking for work everywhere, including the Yukon, she said. She added there is evidence it’s already happening here.

Providing a higher value for local content will provide local firms with a slight advantage, but they still have to be competitive in the other areas of the request for proposals, she emphasized.

Cabott did amend her motion Monday night to do away with the automatic award of 20 points for local content.

Under the amendment, council would instead review the requests for proposals on a case-by-case basis before they were sent out to decide how many points to award for local content in each case.

The amended motion did receive unanimous support from members of council.

Coun. Samson Hartland said it was the right resolution at the right time, and was the right thing to be doing.

“I do see an opportunity to work within our existing policy to give our local businesses a leg up until we have our new procurement policy in place,” said Coun. Steve Roddick.

Coun. Jan Stick did offer words of caution to her colleagues.

Council must be careful it does not stick its nose too far into the procurement of professional services; that it stick to assigning a value for local content, and that’s it, she said.

Stick said the city has the professional staff who do the work reviewing and assessing proposals received.

Council must not become any more involved in the procurement of professional services other than assigning the value for local content, she suggested.

City manager Linda Rapp told council it will not take a large amount of work by city staff to have council review and and assign value for local content before requests for proposals are issued.

Rapp said the administration is hoping to have before council in short order the new, overarching procurement policy the city has been working on for about two years.

City administration has suggested in its reports to council on the matter of local content that it really hasn’t been an issue.

All eight requests for proposals for professional services that were issued in 2019 went to local companies, administration has pointed out.

It has also noted there are instances where local projects could benefit by having expertise from outside the territory.

Comments (7)

Up 7 Down 7

Juniper Jackson on Jul 4, 2020 at 2:03 am

I do not want people out of jobs. If they can't do the job, train them until they can. Give local people first hire. The Liberals keep hiring Liberals from Ontario..nothing like padding the vote a little bit, there is not housing for them and they just will not shut up. They miss their home, so they want to turn the Yukon into Ontario. The City also does not hire Yukoner's first. But then, why would they when Mayor Dan is also a Liberal. These days, politics is everything. It makes me angry every time i hear this tax crazy, dumb *** council say.. "in BC they do it this way", "In Brampton we did it this way, it worked really good." The Yukon has many many unique characteristics that can not be compared to other places. If a contractor is going to pay an acceptable employee rate, hire Yukoner's first, purchase supplies from Yukon business.. yeah..their submission is going to be more than the guy from BC who is going to hire TFW at min rate, house 10 of them in one apartment, and have supplies shipped in from BC or Alberta. Especially in the summer when we have our students looking for work for the summer.
There are a lot of issues to consider besides who submitted the lowest bid, or who is a friend of someone on council. As far as the council goes..what is practical for someone making 100K a year or more.. Isn't Mayor Dan getting 145,000 now with perks? So his idea of practical is not mine, at 32,000. a year, no perks, and the government refusing to cover the cost of senior medical or health travel. At 32,000K before taxes, try to look at the bigger picture for Yukoner's before you let out contracts for any issue.

Up 20 Down 4

Randy on Jul 2, 2020 at 4:25 pm

@ Jake.

I'm with you bro. I avoid the downtown like a plague. No parking and many local businesses are just simply pricing themselves out of reach with little stock.

Like you elude: I can order something from my couch online and it will be here in a week.
It's a no -brainer.

Up 24 Down 1

Jake on Jul 2, 2020 at 2:08 pm

40+ years here now, I believe in buying local, BUT, there is a trend for private sector to focus on the juicy Government buyers. Today I wanted a car part and went to 5 businesses, one offered to bring it in a week for $200. It's a small part, I went online to a company I have used before. In 3 hours it is on it's way for under $50 Canadian including FEDEX and tax. Who deserves sympathy here?

Up 14 Down 2

stephen on Jul 2, 2020 at 12:47 pm

Right now council instead of doing its job is micro managing RFxs that they have no clue about and the legal ramifications.
There are ways to provide a standard scoring template to a RFx. It's not rocket science but evaluating it can be if you don't do it right the first time.

So because they think giving weighting to local businesses will make local businesses competitive you are sadly mistaken. I in 22 years have watched the local boys club at the bar sit around and set the price for RFx bids and who will win by ensuring the others bids too high. "Hey John your turn we will bid X you bid Y and you will get the contract this time. Who gets the next one?"

Up 18 Down 5

Klaus G. on Jul 2, 2020 at 6:23 am

Firstly can council vote to stay on budget with contracts and not go over on a continual basis with weak excuses that are normally lack of due diligence? Re:dump contract
Secondly could council make the decisions they were elected to make and not hire consultants on easily solvable issues? A bureaucrat could just as easily call up a consultant and get an opinion on something without wasting everyone's time and money. Say the manager of sustainability for instance.
Thirdly, if YTG doesn't have the resolve to ban Americans at the border for travel like the whole EU has done then at least we could call in license plate numbers and descriptions of wayward American visitors (or have bylaw come and fine them on the spot) who are strife with Corna virus in their homeland and care little where they spread it.

Up 27 Down 5

Joe on Jul 1, 2020 at 10:13 am

The time has come to shift. Time to clean up those bloated govy offices, streamline service to clients with on-line service, shift budgets to health and social areas and get rid of all the waste of time positions this stay at home test has shown are not required. Those govy positions who stayed at home and had little to do, you know who you are. We can’t afford to carry this extra weight anymore. Covid is a societal shift, not a passing phase, let’s adapt and move on. The City and YG could lead these inevitable changes.

Up 20 Down 1

Matthew on Jun 30, 2020 at 5:45 pm

Well then, put your money where your mouth is and KEEP local businesses going! You've already destroyed so many of them, least you can do is work with the ones left.. Yukon is unique in many ways, and outsiders simply don't know that.. there's a reason they're bidding up here, and it's not a good one..

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.