Whitehorse Daily Star

Coroner’s urgings on bear safety to be heeded

Environment Yukon will be reviewing its education methods for bear encounters and attacks over the course of the winter.

By Aimee O'Connor on December 30, 2015

Environment Yukon will be reviewing its education methods for bear encounters and attacks over the course of the winter.

In the wake of a coroner’s report into the death of Claudia Huber, killed during a grizzly bear attack in October 2014, it has been recommended that education for bear encounters be made better.

The department will review its current education materials and decide whether any changes need to be made.

“We can always revisit our efforts and ensure we’re delivering the correct message to the correct audience,” conservation officer Chris Gustafson said in an interview Tuesday.

Right now, the department has a wide range of reading material on its website regarding bear safety. Most of it is vetted through other agencies and experts throughout North America, Gustafson said.

Huber lived near Johnson’s Crossing, southeast of Whitehorse, with her partner, Matthias Liniger.

That day in October, a grizzly had come onto their property, made its way into their home and eventually attacked Huber, dragging her across a creek and up onto a bank.

Liniger grabbed his rifle and fired several rounds at the bear before having to return to the house to get more ammunition.

Liniger returned and killed the bear. One of the bullets fired, however, deflected off a branch and fatally injured Huber, the coroner’s report found.

She had been playing dead during the attack.

“It unfortunately wasn’t the correct response in this incident,” coroner Kirsten Macdonald wrote in her four-page report, released last week.

Gustafson said the best way to react in an encounter is determined in a case-by-case basis.

“Telling the difference between the type of behaviour and what actions should be taken depends on the behaviour of the bear and nature of the encounter,” he said.

On its website, Environment Yukon has a document titled How you can stay safe in bear country that identifies the two different actions one should take – and it all depends on whether the bear is acting defensive or predatory.

“Essentially, we ask people to stop and make some sort of assessment as to what the bear is doing,” Gustafson said.

In the case of Huber and Liniger, the coroner’s report stated the attack was predatory in nature.

“A predatory attack requires the victim to fight back against the bear,” the report states.

This type of attack can be distinguished by the bear’s demeanour, Gustafson said. A bear with its head up and ears pointed toward you with clear focus are signs of a predatory bear.

“We do not recommend you play dead,” he said.

“You use any deterrent you have. You’re fighting for your life, essentially.”

While the coroner’s report recommends more education is the answer, it also suggests that false information is also a problem.

“There appears to be ongoing misinformation in the public, despite efforts to get this message out,” the report states in its recommendations.

Part of this could be due to old information out there, Gustafson said.

While education forms a foundation, he said, there are just too many variables to predict how every person will react if the worst was to happen.

“Realistically, these are split-second decisions that people have to make,” he said.

In addition to more education on the types of encounters and corresponding actions, the report recommended Environment Yukon put out more information regarding leaving food and other bear attractants accessible.

“Most incidents of human-bear conflict are caused by poor handling of attractants,” Environment Yukon’s website states.

But in the 2014 attack, it might not have been the case.

“In this particular instance, there was no attractants at the site. It was immaculate,” Gustafson said.

“They did nothing to contribute to attracting a bear.”

Comments (9)

Up 0 Down 0

Chuck Bartlebaugh on Jan 20, 2016 at 3:06 pm

Always have bear spray and know how too use it. HIKE, HUNT, FISH, WALK, YARD WORK, HAVE IT NEAR BUY.

Up 1 Down 5

YTGuy on Jan 3, 2016 at 9:49 am

Dave o
I suspect you mean "affect" bear behaviour.

Up 6 Down 1

Groucho d'North on Jan 2, 2016 at 3:29 pm

I must live a blessed life as I have a growing collection of bear butt photographs, black and grizzly, taken while walking on the trails in the periphery of Whitehorse. Contrary to published advice, I don't make a lot of noise in my travels and I don't have a dog. Most encounters startle me and the bear(s) where the bear shows me its tail and takes off while I try to take a reasonable picture. Each spring I faithfully replace my Bear spray bottle and I am very pleased to report I have never needed to use it, nor even needed to consider deploying it. I suggest: Remain alert and calm and know what you're going to do if and when you do encounter a bear on your trail while being on the watch to non-typical behavior. Have a plan and make sure to tell somebody your travel plans before you head out.

Up 10 Down 2

chuck bartlebaugh on Dec 31, 2015 at 7:22 pm

always have bear spray

Up 11 Down 4

north_of_60 on Dec 31, 2015 at 6:40 pm

Bears in the summertime can appear to be easy-going, almost tame, and that's when most people see them. Those same bears can be very aggressive in the late fall when they're trying to get fat before they den-up for the winter. This is especially true for old bears with bad teeth. As well, bears in the spring can be aggressively hungry when they wake up from hibernation, and mama bears with cubs will be very defensive. People who fail to understand the seasonal nature of bears will continue to be the victims of unfortunate accidents.

Up 8 Down 6

TheRevenant on Dec 30, 2015 at 10:41 pm

'education for bears' eh? send em to get a 'university' education over at the college. That'll learn em ! (Fighting back during an encounter may not always be the best strategy by the way . Ask Leonardo DiCaprio).

Up 18 Down 1

Bears on Dec 30, 2015 at 9:50 pm

I don't think I've seen false information, it's just not easy to keep it straight, especially when it's an abstract problem. You have to really know which is which, grizzly or black bear, and most of the information says grizzlies generally attack defensively, which is probably true. How cool headed would you be in this situation?

Up 10 Down 2

Stu Whatman on Dec 30, 2015 at 7:47 pm

This was a very unfortunate incidence and it's so easy to think about ways in which the outcome may have been much better. It must be very difficult to react when a bear is aggressive.

Our home is within the city limits (rural sub-division); we have no firearms but multiple cans of bear spray in a location within our home. Hopefully they would be enough if a bear was showed up and was aggressive.

I hope the proposed bear education will save a few lives.

Up 27 Down 9

David o'Farrell on Dec 30, 2015 at 7:34 pm

There needs to be a discussion on how tourists, photographers and others effect bear behaviour when they sit just meters away snapping pictures for hours. This is especially true along Yukon roadways. There is no doubt in my mind that this will cause bears to lose their fear of people, then you have problems.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.