Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

UNPLEASANT CONDITIONS – Jim Fordyce is seen Monday on the balcony of his Takhini home. The dust has forced him to keep his doors shut.

Constant dust is impacting couple’s health

A Takhini resident says airborne dust containing fibrous glass and quartz particles is wafting from nearby roadways and adversely affecting his and his wife’s respiratory health.

By Gabrielle Plonka on July 26, 2019

A Takhini resident says airborne dust containing fibrous glass and quartz particles is wafting from nearby roadways and adversely affecting his and his wife’s respiratory health.

“We have runny noses and we’re coughing all the time,” longtime Yukoner Jim Fordyce told the Star Monday.

Fordyce said he and his wife first developed symptoms two years ago, around the same time they started to notice dirt collecting on their third-floor balcony.

They live near the intersection of Two Mile Road and the Alaska Highway.

“The windows are dusty,” Fordyce said. “You can smell the dust outside, so we keep the doors closed.” 

When he tried contacting city and territory officials, Fordyce said, neither were able to tell him the source of the problem.

Last April, he took matters into his own hands. He hired an independent contractor where his son was employed to test a sample of the dust on his balcony.

The resulting report, signed by Stan Fordyce, showed the dust contained cellulose particles, fibrous glass, quartz and some non-fibrous materials.

“Any number of these materials may cause ill effects on persons that may have breathing or health issues, as it is all over the deck of the occupants and migrates into the living space,” the report said.

“It may be assumed … that these airborne materials come from the hiway (sic) and street dust in the vicinity of this residence.” 

According to Dr. Brendan Hanley, the Yukon’s chief medical officer of health, dust is one of the only pollution hazards in a territory generally lauded for its clean air.

“We live in a place where the air tends to be really dry, conditions that lend themselves to dust quite easily,” Hanley told the Star Thursday afternoon. “It can be more of a hazard when you’re closer to dust-creating conditions.”

The 2019 Yukon State of the Environment Interim Report listed “wind-blown dust from gravel roads, especially in spring,” as one of eight sources of air pollution potentially causing health problems. 

However, Hanley said that most people are unlikely to be bothered by wind-blown dust, even containing quartz and fibrous glass, unless they have pre- existing health concerns.

“Outside of an occupational setting, (quartz) in dust blowing up from the road or from a construction site, or a residential area that is close to a quarry, doesn’t generally reach high enough levels to pose any specific concern,” Hanley said.

Quartz, often referred to as silica, is almost always present in dust, he added. It’s associated with the lung disease silicosis, but only in cases of excessive inhalation, usually by people working in mining operations who are crushing or grinding rock.

For most people, airborne dust is harmless. However, that doesn’t mean some residents won’t be adversely affected.

“There sometimes are projects that are not an issue for the general population, but may be posing conditions of exposures that are problematic for people with underlying medical issues,” Hanley said.

“You want to try and limit those exposures, especially if you have a susceptibility.”

When a resident like Fordyce files a complaint, Hanley said, it’s important for government institutions to evaluate whether more considerations for dust control need to be made in that area.

Even if changes can’t be made, it’s important that every complaint of health be addressed. This can mean simply ensuring that the individual has access to medical care.

Hanley suggested an air purifier or HEPA filter as a potential solution that is relatively inexpensive, assuming one is able to secure their house with good indoor air. 

According to Sunny Patch, the territorial cabinet’s communications director, the Department of Environment has reached out to Fordyce so he can file a complaint.

“I personally feel they should examine that dirt, and make sure that it isn’t creating a problem,” Fordyce said. “It’s not healthy.”

Comments (7)

Up 10 Down 1

Patricia O'Brien on Jul 30, 2019 at 8:43 am

There are relatively inexpensive filtered fans and aerators that you can plug in to improve the air quality in your home. Ionizers increase the number of oxygen molecules in the air which should also help with breathing quality. I suggest Mr. Fordyce look into some of these solutions. I have used ionizers during messy renovations and they helped a great deal with air quality.

Up 14 Down 1

Juniper Jackson on Jul 29, 2019 at 5:46 pm

No pavement where I live, the owners used to put down calcium in the summer to keep it somewhat cleaner, then they started saying, we're going to put down calcium, didn't do it.. and I think this year they said.."calcium?" In any case, lots of us these days have reaction to air born irritants..I have 3 air cleaners in my place, and I have to run them all year round, in the winter it's wood smoke..summer it's allergies, smoke from fires. The air purifiers are pretty good at keeping my breathing going steady... I do keep my doors and windows shut, except when its raining..

Up 42 Down 6

Steven on Jul 29, 2019 at 11:27 am

So what does he expect the City or YG to do about it? No seriously... You live by a road. That road was there this whole time. What do you expect the government to do about that? Build barriers between the road and your condo? And who will pay for that? And then who will bitch about it when taxes go up? Probably you.

Wow, the things people expect the government to solve are ridiculous.

Up 32 Down 5

Greg on Jul 29, 2019 at 9:19 am

I have asthma and sometimes in the winter the cold makes it flare-up, I should file a complaint to YG to get an investigation done as I don't feel this is healthy.

Up 22 Down 6

David on Jul 29, 2019 at 9:14 am

What does he expect the government to do?
Good thing he wasn't living in his current state 20+ years ago when Yukon summers were much hotter, drier, and dustier!

Up 32 Down 5

Politico on Jul 28, 2019 at 7:44 pm

OMG. You bloody live in the Yukon. The place is a dust factory. Sue mother nature because the clay cliffs are spewing massive amounts of dust all the time, it's not just the roads. Ask anyone who has their windows open and dusts their furniture.

Up 10 Down 38

Dan COW on Jul 27, 2019 at 1:18 pm

I hope the appropriate levels of government follow through with a definitive assessment of these concerns.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.