Whitehorse Daily Star

Companies, clients are owed millions: lawsuit

A lawsuit has been lodged in the Yukon Supreme Court involving prospective Chinese immigrants,

By Emily Blake on April 3, 2017

A lawsuit has been lodged in the Yukon Supreme Court involving prospective Chinese immigrants, a Yukon nomination program, and a Whitehorse hotel.

The plaintiffs, two immigration companies, claim they and their clients are owed millions of dollars for investments in a fraudulent immigration scheme.

The suit filed by Ningbo Zhelun Overseas Immigration Services Co. Ltd. (Zhelun) and Mega International Labour and Immigration Services Inc. (Mega) names 11 defendants.

They include USA-Canada International Investment Inc. (UCII), Tzuchun Chang, Yukon Resources Investment Inc., and Elite Hotel and Travel Ltd.

According to the statement of claim filed with the court on March 20, Zhelun and UCII established a business relationship in 2012.

Under that arrangement, Zhelun would promote and market UCII services to people in China looking to move to Canada. Through an arrangement with Zhelun, Mega also sent clients to UCII.

UCII, based in Richmond, B.C., provides services and support in relation to visa and immigration applications to Canada.

In November 2013, Tzuchun (Joyce) Chang, a director of UCII, approached Zhelun with the Yukon Business Nomination Program (YBNP) as an easy way that client-investors could immigrate to Canada.

The program’s website states that the YBNP is, “designed to attract and retain skilled international entrepreneurs to add diversity and innovation to Yukon’s economy.”

Through the program, nominees receive a two-year work permit to start their own businesses in the Yukon or purchase an existing Yukon business.

After the permit ends, the Yukon will support them in applications for permanent residency if they meet certain requirements.

According to the lawsuit, Chang said it would only take one month to qualify for the program, there would be no immigration reviews, and many of the mandatory requirements for Provincial Nomination Programs such as language competency did not apply.

But Jason Mackey, a spokesperson for the territorial Department of Education, told the Star there are a number of requirements to qualify for the program.

These include language competency, a minimum of three years’ experience in entrepreneurship or business management, and five years’ relevant work experience.

Other requirements are a minimum $500,000 net worth and $300,000 in liquid assets.

As well, applicants can’t have been refused immigration by the Canadian government or have applications with other provincial or territorial nomination programs.

After the two-year work permit ends, to qualify for permanent residency support, nominees must settle in the Yukon and demonstrate an extended $300,000 capital investment in their business.

Mackey said YBNP staff follow up during the process to make sure nominees are on track, and that ultimately the decision on whether a nominee is successful in becoming a permanent resident is up to Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada.

Between late 2014 and the summer of 2015, Zhelun promoted the YBNP and recruited applicants.

They estimate that by this time, clients provided UCII with about $4,054,838.

In June 2015, many of their clients who applied for visas or permanent residency were contacted by Canadian immigration services asking them to travel to Hong Kong for screening interviews.

They were reassured by UCII that “these interviews were part of the immigration application process,” and, “that there was no cause for alarm.”

But the following month, about 60 applicants had interviews that were unsuccessful.

They were told that the certificates of nomination allegedly issued by the Yukon government were false or invalid.

They were also notified their applications for permanent residency cards or visas were denied, and that they may not be able to re-apply to immigrate to or visit Canada for five years.

“The applicants who attended the scheduled interviews were humiliated and embarrassed as a result of the failed Hong Kong interviews and failing to obtain their documents that would lead to their permanent residency cards or visas,” reads the statement of claim.

Following these failed interviews, Zhelun says they were told that UCII was looking into the matter and had sent letters to the Yukon government.

They were also reassured that the certificates issued were valid and that clients could re-apply for permanent residency cards or visas.

Frustrated by UCII’s response, Zhelun says they demanded multiple times that UCII repay the investments, but they have yet to do so.

According to the statement of claim, Zhelun and UCII completed an agreement in October 2014. Under it, UCII agreed to refund Zhelun and their clients if they were unsuccessful in getting immigration documents.

But Zhelun claims that Chang and UCII explained they were not able to repay the amount upon request, as it had been invested in various businesses in accordance with the YBNP.

Among these businesses are the Elite Hotel (2-0-2 Motor Inn), located on Jarvis Street in downtown Whitehorse, and Yukon Resources Investment Inc.

The statement of claim says Chang was a director of Yukon Resources at the time, and the Yukon Corporate Online Registry reveals that she is also a director of the Elite Hotel.

Zhelun and Mega are now seeking an injunction to prevent the defendants from “further encumbering, dealing with, or disposing of assets and properties where the plaintiffs or their investments proceeds were used.”

They’re also seeking several declarations that defendants breached the agreement, owed the plaintiffs a fiduciary duty, and failed to act with reasonable care in regards to the nomination program applications and investments.

According to the Vancouver Sun, Zhelun filed a similar but separate lawsuit in November 2016 in the B.C. Supreme Court seeking to recover $11,900,718 they claim 90 clients paid to UCII, as well as general and special damages.

Defendants have yet to respond to the claims, which have not been proven in court.

The lawsuit adds that, in the summer of 2016, the Canadian Border Services Agency and RCMP investigated and confiscated materials in relation to this matter.

Comments (11)

Up 0 Down 1

yukon56 on Apr 9, 2017 at 2:11 pm

Mary laker - Yukon kids do not to work for minimum wage that is why we have TFW.

Up 5 Down 0

Stanley Miller on Apr 7, 2017 at 6:49 pm

If local businesses pay more they will get more committed staff.
They rely on foreign workers because they make more profits that are used for additional business ventures, large homes, nice vacations and many assets.

The caring for local people is not high on their priorities.

Up 8 Down 1

BnR on Apr 6, 2017 at 8:04 pm

Mary Laker, what exactly are you trying to say?
"Take a walk down Second Avenue and visit the fast food restaurants that used to hire Yukon kids. Take a look at Canadian Tire and the Super Store. At least the people in those establishments are hard working Canadian citizen hopefuls, (not rich people buying their way in), but I think the Nominee Program is being abused when I see the sheer numbers coming in on this program while employers claim they 'can't find Canadians' who want the jobs".

Up 18 Down 17

Just Say'in on Apr 4, 2017 at 1:22 pm

Quit hitting on the Yukon Nominee Program. This has absolutely nothing to do with them, other then these crooks were saying they somehow were going to hook them up. This is purely a bunch of crooks and con men maybe even some organized crime connections taking advantage of people trying to emigrate to Canada legally.

Up 21 Down 2

ProScience Greenie on Apr 4, 2017 at 1:03 pm

We live in a very transparent territory Jane Smith. There is enough evidence of abuse in all the programs to justify a sweeping audit of everything. Those that were above board have nothing to worry about.

Up 21 Down 3

moe on Apr 4, 2017 at 10:49 am

This article says there are 11 defendants but only names four. Here are all the names, from a BC Legal website:

Defendants (accused)
USA-Canada International Investment Inc. and Yukon Resources Investment Inc. and Elite Hotel and Travel Ltd. and First Choice Immigration Services Ltd. and Ajay Sehgal and Kashif A. Ahmed and TD Canada Trust and Canada International Education Centre and Cornerstone International Education Inc. and Tzhuchun Chang aka Joyce Chang and Xunfan Jiang and Yueming Zheng

Plaintiff (people claiming they were ripped off)

Ningbo Zhelun Overseas Immigration Service Co. Ltd.

Claim (money they want back and why)

$4,054,838 for unlawful conversion of investment funds arising from defendants’ fraudulent immigration scheme.

Up 32 Down 3

mary laker on Apr 4, 2017 at 10:40 am

12 million bucks?! This Nominee Program is seriously lucrative business. I read in another article that the go-betweens who are now initiating these lawsuits also had their snout in the trough, charging $30 to $50,000 per client who wanted Canadian citizenship.

Take a walk down Second Avenue and visit the fast food restaurants that used to hire Yukon kids. Take a look at Canadian Tire and the Super Store. At least the people in those establishments are hard working Canadian citizen hopefuls, (not rich people buying their way in), but I think the Nominee Program is being abused when I see the sheer numbers coming in on this program while employers claim they 'can't find Canadians' who want the jobs.

The employee nominee program has its place, but there needs to be an audit, there needs to be more transparency if for no other reason than to put people's minds at ease. There should be a public website which registers every single time a Yukon business asks for a Nominee to be approved. Every application should be public, not the personal information on the applicant but the position and the statement by the employer as to why they need a nominee. Then the Yukon public can weigh in if they applied for the job and didn't hear back, and so on. I know for instance a person who applied for FIVE jobs at hotels in Whitehorse who did not get a single reply. It was not just the 202 either.

Up 18 Down 7

Jane Smith on Apr 4, 2017 at 8:43 am

@ProScience Greenie - read the article. These are not cases that were handled through the Yukon Nominee business program. That's the issue here. The name of the program was used by Chang to obtain millions from would-be immigrants, and now she's being sued for it. I know people who went through the business nominee program here (legitimately). They had to prove their qualifications, and they also actually had to start a real business!

Up 25 Down 2

This is only the tip of the iceberg on Apr 4, 2017 at 7:58 am

Just read the "NOC" job ads in the paper and you know who doesn't want to hire local. Not saying they are all scammers but some sure are.

Up 28 Down 0

surprised? on Apr 3, 2017 at 4:17 pm

Is anyone surprised?

Up 71 Down 6

ProScience Greenie on Apr 3, 2017 at 3:19 pm

Maybe every single case handled by the Yukon Business Nomination Program should be audited. No doubt the Yukon Nominee and TFW programs as well as they were run at full throttle by the previous federal and territorial governments with little oversight.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.