Civil liberties group files two complaints over in-custody deaths
The B.C. Civil Liberties Association has filed formal complaints with the RCMP's watchdog over the deaths of a man who died in a Whitehorse RCMP cell and another who died shortly after being released from the Mounties' custody.
The B.C. Civil Liberties Association has filed formal complaints with the RCMP's watchdog over the deaths of a man who died in a Whitehorse RCMP cell and another who died shortly after being released from the Mounties' custody.
The complaints to the Commission for Public Complaints Against the RCMP relate to the deaths of Raymond Silverfox, who died in a police cell in December 2008, and Robert Stone, who died in the local detox centre last month, several hours after he was released from custody.
The association issued a statement Tuesday announcing it has filed one complaint asking that information and the outcome of internal code of conduct investigations into officers involved with Silverfox be made public.
Five officers face conduct investigations, but RCMP have not released their names.
The other complaint asks for a review of why Stone, 34, was taken into custody when he needed medical care.
"News reports of this incident (Silverfox's death) are very troubling,” association president Robert Holmes said in the statement.
The 43-year-old died in December 2008, after lying on a filthy cell floor where he vomited more than two dozen times over the course of 13 hours.
A coroner's inquest into his death ruled he died of natural causes, noting that one factor was an acute infection caused by aspirating his own vomit.
In particular, Holmes noted an audio recording played at the coroner's inquest of officers making fun of Silverfox as he lay on the cell floor dying.
The audio surveillance tape from the cell block revealed officers laughed about the condition of his cell and complained about having to clean up after him.
"The idea that law enforcement officers would laugh and deride someone in a cell is bad enough, but the idea that they would do so while the person was sick and lying in filth and vomit is callous,” Holmes said.
"The fact that this situation ended up with the death of the person in custody underscores the concerns that exist and the need for a thorough review of the matter.”
Holmes said acute intoxication is a serious medical condition, and should be addressed as a medical issue first, before a legal one.
"Far too many cell deaths involve cases of acute intoxication from drugs and alcohol,” he said. "A public inquiry needs to explore that and find a solution to what appears to be a recurrent problem.”
The coroner's inquest heard that Silverfox was a hard-working and respected member of his community, but had begun binge drinking in the months before his death.
He was brought to the drunk tank by ambulance after he began vomiting at the local Salvation Army shelter and refused to go to the hospital.
The death of Silverfox, a member of the Little Salmon-Carmacks First Nation, prompted the Yukon government to announce a review of policing in the territory.
His daughter has filed a lawsuit against eight Mounties, three guards and the government of Canada for her father's death, claiming it was the result of "intentionally negligent, grossly negligent, deliberate indifferent, reckless and bad faith conduct.”
Federal New Democrats have renewed calls for a civilian oversight agency because of the case, saying there have actually been five suspicious in-custody deaths in the Yukon since 1999.
The RCMP already have a policy of calling Outside police forces to investigate its officers in serious cases, and earlier this year, the federal government said it plans to create a new RCMP watchdog, although it's not clear whatit will look like.
THE CANADIAN PRESS
Comments (17)
Up 0 Down 0
Patty O on Jun 18, 2010 at 4:04 pm
Mr. Raymond Silverfox, may he rest in peace, is a very sad and unfortunately typical example of the ongoing and even escalating problem faced by peacekeepers like the police and shelters like the Salvation Army.
Mr Silverfox had too many civil rights. It was his right to drink alcohol until he was vomiting uncontrollably. It was his right to drive into Whitehorse on a winter's day with friends and fail to dress properly for the weather.
Most importantly, it was his right to refuse medical attention when he sorely needed it. Alas, Mr. Silverfox had severely impaired judgment when he made that decision. But it was still clearly his decision.
The dilemna of peacekeepers and shelters alike is, how far does one go in respecting the rights and decisions of people whose judgments are severely impaired?
For another, even sadder example, totally unrelated to Mr. Silverfox's untimely death, how much rights does a drug addict have to systematically destroy their body and their soul and, let's say, have the right to give birth to one child after another who will be born unhealthy and raised by society or worse, by a junkie who depends on increasing the welfare payments by having more children.
Civil rights are a double-edged sword when viewed separately from personal responsibility.
Up 0 Down 0
White Female on Jun 18, 2010 at 4:32 am
Angela,
I think your statement saying that we all dislike natives is disgusting. It's just as narrowminded as JC's stupid comments.
Yes, Native People should have pride in their heritage, if settlers had learned from them we wouldn't have half the ecological problems we have today. But I really don't think this issue deals with native pride, it deals with a lack of compassion in today's society.
Up 0 Down 0
White Female on Jun 18, 2010 at 4:25 am
First of all I would like to point out not all white people are racist.
JC could be any colour, I could care less, all I care about is that fact that his comments come across offensive and are obviously not appreciated.
As for the rest of you who jump out and assume he is white, you're just as biased as he is and I take offense to your assumtions.
Haha, it's kind of funny to see another person being judged as biased by using a biased statement to do so don't you think? Things will never change because everyone is just as bad as each other. All they want to do is feel sorry for themselves because face it, we're all selfish in a way.
Up 0 Down 0
DG on Jun 17, 2010 at 4:18 pm
I think people need to start making choices. Do you become part of a society that forges the path ahead and remembers the mistakes of our past and avoids them in the future if at all possible, or do we not evolve as a society and a species.
Yes we all had our own original cultures I myself am a mix of Scottish, Welsh and some German. Do I have any of those cultures in my daily life? Honestly I don't know but probably a mix. What I do know is that I live in a society that is more likely to fight amongst itself than to truly reach out and grasp our future.
The people who originally resided in North America need to get over the indignities of our collective pasts and forge ahead.
I was not born in the times when natives were taken to private schools and had their culture taken away. Sorry but I was not a part of it. Yet I am a white person nonetheless. Do you blame me for the actions of persons who may not have known any better.
Why should it be NATIVE PRIDE why can't it be CANADIAN PRIDE.
Up 0 Down 0
Anonymous on Jun 17, 2010 at 9:55 am
Why is it that anytime a story takes place about first nations almost all comments turn to racism - both from white people and first nations - look you all are being racist, so stop blaming each other cause that will never get you anywhere and start to take responsibility for your own words. Racism will get us nowhere.
Its very sad what happened to Mr. Silverfox and it probably could have been avoided. but also if Mr. Silverfox refused medical attention and refused to go to the Hospital - what do you expect the RCMP to do knock him out and drag him to the hospital? Now that does not justify leaving him in his own filth - that is totally uncalled for and the RCMP members who partook in Mr. Silverfox's care should be diciplined for that.
But stop the racism it does not matter if your white or first nations we are all people, most of us were born and raised in the Yukon- take some pride in where you live and try to move forward - racism should be dying people common it will only live if you let it
Up 0 Down 0
Angela on Jun 17, 2010 at 1:07 am
now, now-do you feel better?
i posted a comment days ago, but didn't get a response-oh well
this is only my opinion-i think you all dislike natives-bottom line
IT'S ALL ABOUT NATIVE PRIDE..........
Up 0 Down 0
Dianne on Jun 17, 2010 at 12:11 am
White Pride:I really don't think I have assumed anything, I have read the comments from JC and it is his/her words .such as "their people" and "our people" that he/she is non native or why try to segregate into catagories?
Where did you ASSUME that I was saying all whites react this way?? I'm intelligent enough to know that not all people share the same cynical view as JC and I would be as small minded as he/she is to paint all people with the same brush.So perhaps you should read a little more of what point you are writing about and if you followed this story you can see the many other questionable comments made by JC, you can then draw your own conclusion.....
Up 0 Down 0
Nicole Kowalchuk on Jun 16, 2010 at 8:21 am
Everyone here has forgotten the real issue here. Instead of aruging about native or non native my cousin who is Raymond Sliverfox's daughter is fighting for the loss of her father who was a hard worker and dedicated to his people. Deanna Lee Charlie Raymond's daughter have read these comments and it amplifies the anger and disgust that maybe there is no hope in Human Rights. So JC think about other's before yourself and maybe mind your own damn business if you don't like this story dont read it and move on somewhere else.
Up 0 Down 0
White pride on Jun 16, 2010 at 12:18 am
Ok Dianne,
Just because JC made the comments doesnt mean you have to assume he is WHITE! "If you weren't "white” why would you say "you People” and "the trouble their people are bringing on OUR people”
So are you saying all whites react this way? I think not! maybe you should read little more into what you are writing before anyone calls anyone racist!
Up 0 Down 0
Dianne Gonet on Jun 15, 2010 at 12:35 am
Ah, JC, I was wondering what negative and demeaning comments you might come up with this time.
First of all I have walked and have even made moccasins as I am a first nations woman, my father was a polish immigrant and my mother a Tlingit, so I personally know what it is like to live both native and non-native.
I also have walked "many a dusty road" and have tolerated racism from people who think they are superior to others simply because of their skin color and closed mind on different cultures other than their own, and I DID learn from my experiences. I learned to accept and honor peoples differences and their beliefs and culture, not to try and assimulate them to my beliefs and culture.
You still sound bitter when you say "you people now have your own land claims" I will tell you that it was a long and hard batttle that took many years and in some eyes it was still not fair to the native people who lost not only their culture and land but some people may have lost their pride and that maybe the cause of some of their dysfunction,but with someone so perfect as you, you may not understand.
I believe my ancestors and others ancestors would be extremely proud with the progress we as native people have made, overcoming disese, assimulation, segregation, abuse of all kinds and more all within a very short time period and as I mentioned before we will continue to make POSITVE progress.
And finally yes the Yukon is made up of every race so you should try and take off your blinders and see ALL people without negative stereotypes and cynical biased judgement. If you weren't "white" why would you say "you People" and "the trouble their people are bringing on OUR people" So there you have it Sherlock, your racist catorgorizing speaks for its self.
Up 0 Down 0
DG on Jun 11, 2010 at 5:44 pm
As a point of curiosity as a Caucasian will "my people" have to pay for the injustices served on natives and others forever. Can I get a time line here for how long my tax dollars get used to pay for stuff that happened in the past.
For myself, I consider myself a Canadian, I was born in the Yukon (Yep that's Canadian), and my parents were born Canadian. When do I get to call myself or my children natives.
Up 0 Down 0
p frost on Jun 11, 2010 at 11:06 am
Hey jc, when you gonna stop throwing toys out of your crib and onto society's lap with your childish and racial bullshit. WHSE would be a better place for us all, if bigots like you and the members that were working that night at the whse detachment weren't here scrounging for a racial society, if you don't like it here move on....I'm sure there's a place for people like you somewhere, and don't forget your white cloak!!!!
Up 0 Down 0
JC on Jun 11, 2010 at 11:00 am
Arn Andersen, Diane Gonet and Angela. I may not have walked in a First Nations moccasins and from what I've seen neither have any of you. But I have walked many a dusty road and survived while learning much from my experiences. You people now have your own land claims. You now have the opportunity to return to your roots - moccasins and all. From my much research your ancestors were a very great and proud people. Something tells me they would be a bit disappointed to see what later came from their loins. Now, the Yukon is made up of every race on the face of the earth and are contributing to society in a wonderful way. My question is, how do you know I'm white? Who really is the racist?
Up 0 Down 0
Angela on Jun 11, 2010 at 1:15 am
JC-Explain what you mean by the trouble our people are bringing on to you-the whites.For numerous yrs. our people are the one to suffer, and we still suffer.Before all this crap started,First Nations people didn't even know what alcohol tasted like!Who introduced it to us?!? We of all people are the ones to put up with racial abuse just about every day in this day and age. There is absolutely no excuse for the way that Silverfox was treated.No human being should be left to die the way that he did. I wouldn't even treat an animal that way. I guess "some" people are just cold hearted.And can you please explain, what kind of trouble it is that our people bring upon your people?
Up 0 Down 0
Dianne Gonet on Jun 11, 2010 at 12:24 am
JC, I have read many of your narrow minded comments over the last few weeks, and I have to say it is racist and bigotted comments like yours that perpetuate an intolerant and incompassionant society. You must have a misserable and bitter life to continually throw such hateful and biased comments around.
Native people took responsibility for their people for thousands of years before the non-natives settled in America, It has been difficult but we are stong people and we will continue to make positive progress with our people.
Maybe you should try and have a positive thought or comment as I don't think you have had one for quite sometime. By the way there is an old saying "never judge someone until you have walked a mile in their moccasins" in your racist mind you could say shoes but you get my drift....(signed deeg)
Up 0 Down 0
Arn Anderson on Jun 11, 2010 at 12:04 am
Do white people take responsibility for other whites actions, if so, please tell me? If you move to Bhutan and become the only white guy there do you expect yourself to take care of yourself lawfully?
Read the article, filed a formal complaint, finish daycare JC and then you can move on to Kindergarten!
Up 0 Down 0
JC on Jun 9, 2010 at 1:44 pm
How about First Nations taking responsibility for their own people. Will that be brought up in any investigation? I seriously doubt it. Perhaps its time for the non Native peoples to start suing the First Nations communities for the trouble their people are bringing on our people and the City of Whitehorse in particular.