Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Dave Pruden

City core may be in for high tech parking enforcement

City council has identified the possibility of taking another step into the world of hi-tech to enhance enforcement of parking restrictions downtown.

By Chuck Tobin on December 30, 2011

City council has identified the possibility of taking another step into the world of hi-tech to enhance enforcement of parking restrictions downtown.

Council has already approved the $58,000 for the purchase of new hand-held ticketing devices for 2012, and $7,000 for each year after through to 2015.

But it has also identified $120,000 to buy a new vehicle outfitted with the latest technology to monitor street parking: the autochalk technology designed to replace bylaw officers walking around chalking tires.

The city's 2012 capital budget, approved by council earlier this month with spending forecasts for the following three years, has the expenditure penciled in for 2015.

Bylaw manager Dave Pruden emphasized Thursday that identifying the expenditure in long-term financial planning is by no means confirmation it will happen.

"It really means we will look at it further,” he told the Star.

"If administration does recommend we go ahead with it, the end decision rests with council. They could like it, or say, ‘We've looked at it and don't like it.'”

The technology is something akin to a Google Earth Camera Car.

Cameras are mounted on a vehicle specially designed for the constant starting and stopping mobile bylaw officers would likely be required to do as they monitor street parking, according to information provided by one of the suppliers.

The cameras would record the position of each vehicle using advanced GPS technology. They would be able to produce photographic evidence indicating whether a vehicle has moved – right down to comparing the position of the air valves on the tires.

If the city, for example, wanted to monitor a two-hour parking zone, the enforcement vehicle would simply drive the designated streets at the normal speed – up to 50 km/h – to record the information. Repeating the exercise two hours later would reveal which vehicles had moved, and which hadn't.

If the city chose that route, Pruden said, it would likely implement an enforcement protocol requiring three drive-bys. That would reduce the chance of nabbing individuals who had left the area but returned to conduct further business.

Parking in a two-hour zone, he said, means having to leave the zone after two hours.

Moving your vehicle from one parking spot to the one beside it, or even down the street, doesn't count, Pruden said.

"The other thing people will do is go out and erase the chalk marks,” said the bylaw manager.

The new downtown parking management plan adopted by council earlier this year calls for an eventual expansion of restrictions on all-day parking in the downtown core, where there are no meters nor other time restrictions.

It's common-place these days to see all-day parking up and down Strictland and Black Streets, along Third and Sixth Avenues, and up and down Hanson and Hawkins Streets, to name a few.

Under the parking plan five to 10 years out, those areas and more have all been identified as two-hour zones without meters.

But Pruden insists the city is not just going to wake up one day and bring down the hammer.

The parking management plan recommends that before measures are undertaken to expand parking restrictions, the city must identify alternative long-term parking options provided by either the public or private sectors, he said.

The management plan also mentions the need to encourage the greater use of public transit before increasing restrictions, Pruden added.

Furthermore, it will be up to the council of the day to decide how to handle recommendations meant to take effect years down the road, Pruden pointed out.

When council was considering adopting the new parking strategy last May, members did get an ear-full from one rural resident.

The resident of one of the rural neighbourhoods who parks along the street all day reminded council that buses are not an option for him.

Besides, he said, as a parent, his vehicle is absolutely essential in getting his kids to where they need to go after school.

Eliminating all-day street parking in the years ahead is not only unnecessary, but would cause grief, he said.

Product information about the autochalk system indicates the technology bolsters efficiency 10-fold, is not slowed down by rain, sleet nor snow, and reduces bylaw officers' risk of repetitive injury strain.

The system also reduces the risk of confrontations between officers and angry ticket recipients.

Comments (16)

Up 0 Down 0

Max Mack on Jan 4, 2012 at 9:51 am

An automated solution will only work so long as vehicle plates are unobscured, which means winter usage (approx. 8 months of the year) is ineffective. The bylaw officer will have to stop at every vehicle, sweep the snow off the license plate, rinse/repeat. Ridiculous.

In any case, this sounds like more of the ongoing escalation of CoW's misguided anti-parking and anti-automobile campaign.

Eventually CoW may win this battle and turn the downtown core into some kind of ultra-cool, hip, yuppie urban landscape where everyone walks to work (if they have a job) and eats organic granola.

However, Whitehorse is not Vancouver, nor Granby Island, and I suspect that businesses and residents will ultimately move out of the downtown core. I dread to think that our downtown core will become what CoW has envisioned.

Up 0 Down 0

north of 60 on Jan 3, 2012 at 10:14 am

This high tech proposal is just another waste of money, like so many other boondoggles the COW's Administration has committed.

Let the bylaw officers work for their money walking the beat, not sitting in the cab driving around.

Spend some of the money to hire more summer workers and spend the rest towards a multi-level parking facility.

Up 0 Down 0

johnjack on Jan 3, 2012 at 7:59 am

Polititions are ruining the Yukon more and more every day!!!! Every party included.

Up 0 Down 0

Anonymous on Jan 3, 2012 at 5:53 am

As an employee of a downtown business I for one would like to point out that I have to come to work at least half an hour early to try and get a parking spot in all day parking that is 4 blocks away from my office. Not to mention that even coming in that early I still usually get stuck with a two hour spot that is 4 blocks away from my office. I support two other people on my income, pay an arm and a leg for taxes and get hammered with at least $25.00 a day parking tickets (if I am lucky). I had one day where it cost me $150.00 just to park my vehicle and FYI I live outside of a city transit route.

COW needs to do something about the parking situation as there are many people in my position and it's ridiculous.

I mean should we really have to be stuck choosing whether or not to pay our parking tickets or pick-up groceries and eat?

Up 0 Down 0

Thomas Brewer on Jan 2, 2012 at 10:54 am

Somehow I don't see this working for the 5-6 months where everyone's license plates are (partly) obscured.

And don't try and tell me that they can do a positive identification without a complete and legible plate, the first challenge in front of a judge will tune Bylaw up.

Waste of money and the city should put those funds into building a multi level lot behind the Klondike Rib and Salmon.

Up 0 Down 0

it's even worse on Jan 1, 2012 at 10:49 am

Reed - Even worse than that - the limit on and around main street is one hour. And you commit an offense by spending more than this period of time in the "zone" - even if you manage to plug the meter multiple times. It is beyond ridiculous.

Up 0 Down 0

flyingfur on Jan 1, 2012 at 10:38 am

"The system also reduces the risk of confrontations between officers and angry ticket recipients"

Part of doing enforcement of any kind is dealing with people - whatever mood they happen to be in. I also consider it the right of the person being ticketed to have the reasons explained to them by the officer and/or to be able to make a plea to the officer should there be extenuating circumstances. You don't get a speeding ticket in the mail from the RCMP or a fishing without a license ticket from Conservation Officers in the mail either; part of doing the job and earning the paycheque is getting out there among the people and educating them on the rules and laws, not just sitting in City Hall counting the ticket money.

Up 0 Down 0

flyingfur on Dec 31, 2011 at 8:31 am

"The system also reduces the risk of confrontations between officers and angry ticket recipients."

I understand that the bylaw officers are doing a difficult and for the most part, thankless job. However, I think it's someone's right to question an officer at the time they are getting a ticket and fine. Yes I know about photo-radar. That said, you typically don't get a speeding ticket from the RCMP in the mail and have an opportunity at roadside to plead your case (if you have an excuse for speeding...likely not...but can question the validity of the offence and ask to see the speed gun) and you also won't get a ticket for fishing without a license without getting to talk with the CO about it either. Nobody needs to go off on a bylaw officer but by the same token, dealing personally with those you are ticketing is part of the job, and in my mind, part of a fair process!

Up 0 Down 0

Mike Hawk on Dec 31, 2011 at 7:36 am

I'm pretty sure out of town visitors can pick up a free parking pass at City Hall. Parking infractions should definitely be focused on locals, not visitors that bring their hard earned dollars to Whitehorse.

Up 0 Down 0

northone on Dec 31, 2011 at 6:19 am

For all of you complaining that downtown workers take up all the parking space which you think should be for short term use, give your heads a shake. Downtown workers keep downtown businesses going outside of the May to September tourist season. All the City's all-day parking ban will do is push offices out of the downtown core and up on the highway or into the industrial areas where land and rent is cheaper as it is. The transit system here is a joke so driving and parking is the only viable option for many of us who work downtown...businesses (business is the only voice the city listens to these days) will be biting the hand that feeds them by lobbying for all-day parking bans.

Up 0 Down 0

Billy Polson on Dec 31, 2011 at 5:26 am

Hilarious...repetitive injury strain and confrontation....why take the job? Pruden is being prudent when he passes the buck to Buckway and Council as the decision makers. Why not hire folks who want to do the job and maybe add 1 more position to lessen the burden..it's more cost effective than something (high tech sit on your behind thingamajigger) that likely hasn't been tested at -40C.

Up 0 Down 0

River Rat on Dec 31, 2011 at 4:34 am

I cannot believe the lengths that the COW will go to to penalize folks that need to park downtown. From what I can see a lot of those working folks who park downtown, spend a lot of money and pay a lot of taxes!

Parking downtown should be a major election issue next time around and any wanna be politician that will do something about the lack of parking downtown (that does not cost and arm and a leg!) will get my vote.

This bunch we have in there now are out to lunch on this issue!

Up 0 Down 0

Reed McCluskey on Dec 31, 2011 at 2:45 am

So if I'm reading this story correctly, when someone like myself drives to Whitehorse from Skagway for the day in order to make optical or dental appointments, have sushi for lunch, shop for sporting gear at Hougen's, browse artwork on First Avenue, get a paper or book at Mac's or to spend time in meetings in the government building downtown I should expect to be ticketed if my truck spends any more than 2 hours parked anywhere in the downtown area?? Well, I guess I'll just have to make sure to do most all of my shopping at Walmart and take my meals in the fast food joints on Second, shouldn't I? Or maybe just not bother coming to town at all.

Up 0 Down 0

YukonMax on Dec 31, 2011 at 2:41 am

Talk about some backward policies.

Council should look at ways to encourage traffic within the dying downtown core. A multi level parking facility may sound stupid today, but in a few years from now it will be needed and at triple the cost.

Downtown needs to be revitalized with urban designs in mind.

Up 0 Down 0

north of 60 on Dec 30, 2011 at 1:39 pm

All day street parking for free only west of 6th, except for residents, of course. The exercise will do the office workers good. Downtown parking is for people using downtown services, not for the lazy office workers who can't bother to walk a few blocks.

Up 0 Down 0

Gene Brown on Dec 30, 2011 at 7:55 am

City workers need a raise, eh?

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.