Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

'IʻVE HAD ENOUGHʼ–Marco Paquet is seen with his daughter, Brienna, Thursday morning by the Robert Campbell Bridge.

‘Citizens are fed up,' says river crossing advocate

It was a common experience for many Whitehorse parents Tuesday which has spawned a petition calling for an alternative access into Riverdale.

By Stephanie Waddell on May 30, 2014

It was a common experience for many Whitehorse parents Tuesday which has spawned a petition calling for an alternative access into Riverdale.

A late-afternoon collision closed the Robert Campbell Bridge, backing up Riverdale-bound traffic along Second Avenue clear down to Strickland Street.

The traffic chaos turned Marco Paquet's 15-minute commute from downtown into Riverdale to pick up his daughter from daycare turned into a 90-minute ordeal. He finally arrived at 6 p.m., a half-hour after the daycare normally closes.

"I couldn't get to her,” he said in an interview.

He acknowledges he was fortunate the daycare ­– one of many child care facilities in Riverdale – didn't charge overtime for the additional staff time needed, as parents arrived late and he wasn't in an emergency situation.

However, the experience also made him move on calling for another access into the neighbourhood, which is home to Whitehorse General Hospital.

"I've had enough,” Paquet said, pointing to the serious implications the traffic situation could have for people trying to get to the hospital.

As he's learned after posting his petition online, in one case, a pregnant woman was sitting in the traffic jam wondering what would happen if she went into labour as police investigated the scene.

The bridge was closed for 45 minutes, and when it reopened, traffic moved extremely slowly.

While one lane would have been available to emergency vehicles, Paquet questioned what would happen in the case of an emergency that compltely closed off both sides.

Many small planes fly over the river to Schwatka Lake, he said as an example, noting a plane crash on the bridge would likely result in both lanes being closed.

"There are tons and tons of what ifs,” Paquet said.

While another access is needed, he argued, the bridge could also be made wider for vehicles rather than money being spent on the current construction project for the addition of bike lanes on each side of the bridge.

Tuesday's lengthy closure left much of the city at a standstill.

People were unable to pick up their kids or get to appointments or other commitments. Additional lanes could have enabled traffic to flow better, Paquet said.

"Citizens are fed up,” he said, noting this is not the first time the issue has arisen.

Along with other residents who have brought it up to officials, he said, he proposed it more than three years ago after his young son died after choking on a piece of macaroni.

With the family living in the Takhini area at the time, the situation highlighted the need for an ambulance station closer to the many Whitehorse neighbourhoods beyond Two Mile Hill.

While a second ambulance station now exists near the Alaska Highway at Two Mile Hill in addition to those parked at the hospital's station, Paquet said he also told officials then that it was clear a second access to the hospital is needed.

"It's time for it to change,” he said.

Paquet is hoping to get 10,000 people signed on to the petition (at http://www.gopetition.com/petitions/help-save-more-lives-add-a-second-bridge.html) before he presents it to the city.

He noted that while he originally planned to bring it before the Yukon government, he has since learned it would be the city's jurisdiction, though funding could come from the territory.

Paquet is hoping to book a meeting with Mayor Dan Curtis and Riverdale's two MLAs – the Yukon Party's Scott Kent for Riverdale North and New Democrat Jan Stick for Riverdale South – to discuss the issue.

Curtis told the Star Wednesday he doesn't believe a second river crossing is needed.

Before the current hospital was built in the early and mid-1990s, then-mayor Bill Weigand urged the territorial government to relocate it to the other side of the Yukon River because of the single-bridge access to the hospital.

City spokeswoman Jackie Hynes pointed out Thursday there is a crossing over the Yukon Energy dam that can swiftly serve as an alternative route for emergency response vehicles if it was ever required.

Comments (10)

Up 0 Down 4

john walsh on Jun 3, 2014 at 5:15 am

The city and territory spent millions of our taxpayer dollars to put in a much needed alternative road access and egress for Copper Ridge and neighbouring communities ie the Hamilton Boulevard extension. The city is considering an unneeded additional access to the Alaska Highway for Porter Creek and Whistle Bend. It's time for some creative thinking about another usable access to Riverdale.

Up 25 Down 1

yukon56 on Jun 1, 2014 at 10:29 am

Sandy??? What does this have to do with LNG??? Pull your green head out of the "woods"

Up 19 Down 1

Salar on Jun 1, 2014 at 8:05 am

If the river floods and takes out the bridge......wouldn't it take any bridge?....seems redundancy is an issue....and it's not about Riverdale residents....enjoy some part of life folks and quit with the sky is afallin...

Up 20 Down 1

north of 60 on Jun 1, 2014 at 4:01 am

It's all about people believing they're entitled to whatever they think they 'need';

so long as someone else pays for it.

Up 13 Down 22

Melanie Cole on May 31, 2014 at 1:24 pm

I am surprised that some commentators consider this a Riverdale resident convenience issue. Our ONLY hospital is in Riverdale as are 5/13 of our K-12 schools. An emergency access is not a solution for private vehicles who need to get to their kids or to the hospitals. Remember the flash flood last year? This isn't about being late for work. Something needs to be done.

Up 6 Down 28

Sandy Helland on May 30, 2014 at 11:41 am

Perfect solution! A second access over the dam. That should stop any LNG plans and that's a good thing. The dam has already been used as an alt-access. Perfect!

Up 47 Down 4

Jack on May 30, 2014 at 10:30 am

Um, Marco. You are fed up about personal inconveniences so we should spend a few million on a new bridge or an expansion? A plane might crash into the bridge. What about an asteroid? Hey, when was the last incident on the bridge? The bridge has been there for decades and the traffic is terrible for 15 mins in the morning, at noon and at 5 - but there has been no problems.

I agree that hospital services should be more centrally located so ambulance services can respond more quickly to Copper Ridge, PC and elsewhere - but that is not relevant to the bridge issue. People in Whse want everything, then they complain about their property taxes.

Up 10 Down 45

SAMANTHA CHIASSON on May 30, 2014 at 10:26 am

Thank god someone is speaking up. This needs to be addressed. All I know is I will not be voting for our mayor in the next election for sure. This is bs. I was late picking my kids up and I left my house which is downtown at 4:20. I didn't get home until 6:30. What happens if something happens on the bridge or my child gets seriously hurt and it's life threatening, what then? No one can come because the bridge had a closer? Answer that one mayor.

Up 45 Down 8

north of 60 on May 30, 2014 at 9:37 am

"...there is a crossing over the Yukon Energy dam that can swiftly serve as an alternative route for emergency response vehicles if it was ever required. "

Of course that's conveniently ignored by the "me first" petition signers who want their whims met on the taxpayers dime.

Ask those residents if they still want another bridge for their convenience IF they have to pay for it with property tax increases only in THEIR neighborhood.

Better yet, let them build it on their dime and charge a toll for use.

Up 42 Down 6

sara on May 30, 2014 at 9:36 am

The bridge cannot be expanded. The superstructure cannot handle additional load from cars. There would have to be a new bridge constructed, the cost would be 10s of millions.

The city budget is around 70 million operating. The capital budget this year was 12 million. There is no money for a second bridge over unless you want to drain all the city's reserves plus borrow.

It sucks, but you aren't getting a bridge unless YTG plays for it.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.