Chimney's inner lining had deteriorated
The Yukon's Fire Marshal says the deaths of the five people in a home in Porter Creek were accidental and caused by an ice blockage in the top two feet of the chimney.
By Ashley Joannou on March 5, 2012
The Yukon's Fire Marshal says the deaths of the five people in a home in Porter Creek were accidental and caused by an ice blockage in the top two feet of the chimney.
Valerie and Bradley Rusk, their two children, Gabriel, 13, and Rebekah, 11, and family friend Donald McNamee were found dead in their rented house on Jan. 29.
The Fire Marshal's office (FMO) has been investigating ever since, and has now submitted its investigation report to the Yukon coroner's office and the RCMP.
The report concludes that the ice blockage contributed a build-up of noxious gases, including carbon monoxide in the Centennial Street house.
The report, a summary of which was released Friday, also determined that the inner lining of the brick chimney had deteriorated and debris was found at the lowest point in the chimney.
This brick and mortar debris obstructed and slowed the flow of flue gases from the furnace to the exterior of the house.
"Low temperature flue gases coming from the high-efficiency burner in the boiler combined with the extremely cold temperatures at the time contributed to the build-up of ice. The combined factors were determined to be the cause of this tragic incident,” the report concludes.
Last week, the territory's coroner confirmed three of the five people in the house had extremely high levels of carboxy hemoglobin in their systems.
Carboxy hemoglobin is a mix of carbon monoxide and hemoglobin in the blood stream. High levels prevent oxygen from being carried through the body.
Anything exceeding 40 per cent is considered severe poisoning, while anything around 60 per cent is likely to be fatal.
Valerie Rusk had levels in the 80s. Her children's levels were in the 90s.
Results for the other two people have not been released by the Vancouver lab yet.
When fire officials entered the home, carbon monoxide levels were 10 times what would set off a standard alarm.
Officials are advising homeowners and renters to check their homes for hazards and install carbon monoxide and smoke detectors.
"The FMO recommends that residents, whether homeowners or renters, please check for icing on your chimney, especially during cold snaps, and ensure you have properly installed carbon monoxide and smoke detectors,” said Fire Marshal Dennis Berry said.
"We also recommend that people ensure their heating system is property serviced and maintained on a regular basis.”
Comments (4)
Up 0 Down 0
Christopher McNamee on Mar 12, 2012 at 6:51 am
For those that care Donald McNamee was buried March 10, 2012.
Up 0 Down 0
north of 60 on Mar 8, 2012 at 4:44 pm
A competent burner technician would have brought the chimney condition to the building owner's attention; an irresponsible owner would have ignored it.
Up 0 Down 0
Joel on Mar 8, 2012 at 3:14 am
I don't know if I would be so quick to fault the owner of the house nor the furnace technician that serviced the burner.
The heating system was fixed months before. A technician serviced the burner. This is simply one of those things that no one thinks of since faults like this very rarely happen. I personally get my oil furnace serviced every year. I get my wood stove chimney cleaned twice per year.
I don't think I have ever looked at my furnace chimney nor do I think many other people have...although I think I will take a look every once in a while now.
If it was fixed months before it could still clog...just the same as your pipes might freeze one year and never before or again.
It is good to know what happened for certain now. I am more sorry for the families that have lost than to try to find someone to blame.
Up 0 Down 0
Jaymanc on Mar 6, 2012 at 12:02 am
Thats it? Ice blockage. From a heating system that was supposed to be fixed months before this happened. If it was fixed it wouldn't have blocked up. This is sad. What does the owner of the house have to say about this?