Candidates exchange barbs over housing benefit
The campaign of Barbara Dunlop, the territory’s Conservative candidate in Monday’s election, has called on Liberal hopeful Brendan Hanley to explain why he is “misleading Yukoners by making promises that are not included in the Liberal Party of Canada platform.”
The campaign of Barbara Dunlop, the territory’s Conservative candidate in Monday’s election, has called on Liberal hopeful Brendan Hanley to explain why he is “misleading Yukoners by making promises that are not included in the Liberal Party of Canada platform.”
But Hanley counters that the Conservatives haven’t done their homework on the issue.
“The Conservative Party of Canada Recovery Plan is the only plan that identifies ways to improve affordability for all Yukoners and northerners,” Dunlop said in a statement Monday.
“A Conservative government has committed to doubling the Northern Residents Deduction for every single Yukon resident, which provides a significant tax deduction for northerners.”
A Conservative government would double a northern resident’s current $11 daily deduction to $22, the party has said.
Dunlop said she has heard from many Yukoners that they were “surprised to hear Hanley’s new last-minute promise to expand the Northern Travel Allowance to Yukoners who do not currently receive it.
“Searching the Liberal platform, there is no such promise in the document at all,” Dunlop said.
“The Liberals have claimed that their platform is fully costed, which raises questions about these last-minute promises and whether or not the Liberals are actually committed to them.”
The Liberals’ “desperate campaign” has started promising new items outside their financial framework and costing,” Dunlop said.
“This is another example of the reckless spending and a lack of planning that our country can no longer afford.
“A Conservative government will get this under control,” she vowed. “Our plan will improve affordability and balance the budget over the next decade.”
Hanley told the Star Tuesday he is “disappointed by Conservative claims, and surprised by the lack of due diligence, in seeking the facts regarding the Northern Residents Deduction.
“The fact is that in Budget 2021, due in part to advocacy from Liberal MP Larry Bagnell, the federal Liberal government expanded the Northern Residents Deduction to allow residents without employer-provided travel benefits to claim up to $1,200 for eligible travel expenses, starting in 2021,” Hanley noted.
“In order to address cost of living concerns, the federal Liberal government increased the Northern Residents’ Deduction by 33 per cent in Budget 2016.”
Most budget measures are passed through a series of Budget Implementation Acts, the first of which passed earlier this summer, Hanley pointed out.
“This means that the travel benefit will be available to all northerners once the next budget legislation passes.
“The 2021 change is expected to cost the federal government $125 million over five years,” Hanley added.
“This is an existing, fully-costed commitment, already built into the Government of Canada’s budget framework.
“However, under a Conservative government, there is no guarantee of this benefit being implemented,” Hanley said.
Comments (17)
Up 0 Down 0
Observer on Sep 21, 2021 at 4:28 pm
tmtp (totally missing the point), have the cons not gotten it yet? It is not about popular vote, it is about seats, how long have we been at this? Get with the program.
Up 0 Down 2
TMYK on Sep 21, 2021 at 1:49 pm
@observer - You're talking about the Conservatives who won the popular vote for the second straight election right?
Up 2 Down 2
Observer on Sep 20, 2021 at 8:57 pm
Well another Liberal minority at the very least. Regardless of how the 10 neo cons who comment on this page, the results are the results. The cons are beginning to lose support nationally, time to rethink things and be more inclusive, tolerant, taking a more worldly approach to dealing with folks of a different color. It no longer is your Canada.
Up 4 Down 4
Seriously on Sep 19, 2021 at 8:24 pm
How can anyone seriously vote Lieberal when their ‘leader’ does not care about housing or anything else except his own ego?? He’ll have quite a big pension as well as his multi-million dollar trust fund to fall back on when everyone now and for the next 3 generations (at minimum) will be paying off his trillion dollar debt!
Up 7 Down 5
Groucho d'North on Sep 18, 2021 at 10:07 am
Robert Service wrote, "A promise made is a debt unpaid." Back in 2015 the Liberal platform document made many promises about improving Yukon's and the nation's housing woes. Here we are are six years later and the same promises are being regurgitated hoping citizens have forgotten how the first batch of promises are still outstanding. Don't be fooled again, Trudeau prides himself as being a Progressive when in reality he is stuck in neutral and thinks he is doing a good job. He is paid $1000 a day by Canadians to do a job is is obviously failing at, in the private sector he would have been fired long ago. On Monday let's make things better for Canadians and fire him.
Up 25 Down 8
My Opinion on Sep 15, 2021 at 6:11 pm
Mr. Hanley - What did you know and When did you know it? You don’t walk away from a job like you had without some promises being made. Federal minister of Health maybe???
Up 30 Down 9
My Opinion on Sep 15, 2021 at 6:08 pm
Mr Hanley. When you were in Ottawa being schmoozed by the Liberal brass were you still making decisions on our COVD controls? Is that why just before you announced your intention to run you let all businesses go back to full capacity with little or no restrictions even though we had way more cases then ever before? Opened borders including with Alaska. So the question is did you abuse your position as Chief medical officer to influence voters? Give us some timelines Doc.
Up 30 Down 8
My Opinion on Sep 15, 2021 at 5:59 pm
Sure!!!! You can trust the Liberals and Hanley. Remember the promise of Free daycare in the last five elections, how did that work out for ya? How about clean water for First Nation Communities? Good lord people can’t be this gullible…. Can they?
Up 11 Down 11
Wilf Carter on Sep 15, 2021 at 5:40 pm
Hanley was hand picked by the brass of liberals but he clearly shows he is not ready for the job. Liberals didn;t even have a say in who their candidate was going to be.
Than you have Barb Dunlop who knows nothing about affordable housing in the Yukon or across the north. If she did she would not have to read or answers from prepared answers. She shows by the comments here she can be a good yes person just like Larry B is.
Up 27 Down 10
Joe on Sep 15, 2021 at 5:30 pm
How anyone could even think of voting for Shamley is beyond me. Led us to believe COVID rules were for the people meanwhile he was making deals with the liberals. He should be forced to resign from his cmo job for misleading the public. Now he’s making promises that don’t exist.
Up 19 Down 10
martin on Sep 15, 2021 at 4:47 pm
So, the PC candidate is right. Hanley is Not. I made my choice
Up 32 Down 5
Matthew on Sep 15, 2021 at 4:30 pm
Am I missing something here? Where are they talking and how can I find info on how to attend, and ask some questions of my own!?
Up 61 Down 16
Rick on Sep 15, 2021 at 3:57 pm
Do you take us all for fools Hanley? You are making promises to what was already passed by the HofC. It is like saying "hey I promise we will no longer have troops in Bosnia" when of course they returned over 20 years ago. Sometimes I believe you are a tad brain dead.
You call out Barb for not doing her due diligence. It is the same due diligence that you gave us during Covid that was nothing but instilling fear into every living soul here in the Yukon with your daily regurgitation of the same ole, same ole drivel you garnered from your Liberal buddies in Ottawa. Where were you during the 3rd wave?
Up 22 Down 66
edie rue on Sep 15, 2021 at 3:48 pm
So far, this has been a very boring election. Hanley is clearly the best choice. Smith is the worst. Unfortunately, Smith might have the antivax followers, as alt-right is where they usually live, and Canada, as we are finding out, has a lot of them. Covid has divided us in the worst way, with camps growing for provax and antivax, or whatever you want to call them. Both think the other is pathetic and ridiculous. So, that's where I think the votes will go. Sorry PC and NDP, maybe next time.
Up 51 Down 16
Lost In the Yukon on Sep 15, 2021 at 3:19 pm
Yet again the dear Hanley is disappointed … gee whizz dad we’re sorry. But I guess when you sit on a pedestal for months on end ruling over your Kingdom you come to expect being serenaded in the halls of power by sycophants, not being challenged buy the ungrateful.
Up 49 Down 13
TMYK on Sep 15, 2021 at 3:11 pm
So in other words, Hanley is lying because it's not in the platform and the next federal fiscal budget doesn't exist yet. He's making a pretty big assumption that it will be there with no evidence to back it up.
Up 52 Down 16
JSM on Sep 15, 2021 at 2:51 pm
Yep, Liberals saying and doing anything they can to appeal to people is pretty par for the course. Conservatives bring sensibility while Liberal's bring dreams and financial illiteracy. This is nothing new.