
Photo by Vince Fedoroff
THE FINAL APPEARANCE – Kirk Cameron resigns from city council Monday evening because of last week’s abrupt firings of directors Brian Crist and Robert Fendrick.
Photo by Vince Fedoroff
THE FINAL APPEARANCE – Kirk Cameron resigns from city council Monday evening because of last week’s abrupt firings of directors Brian Crist and Robert Fendrick.
Photo by Vince Fedoroff
OFFICIALS LOOK ON – City manager Christine Smith, right, and Valerie Anderson, the acting director of corporate services, are seen at Monday evening’s meeting of city council. Anderson is sitting where fired predecessor Robert Fendrick sat, and filled in for him when he was away.
City councillor Kirk Cameron has resigned suddenly.
City councillor Kirk Cameron has resigned suddenly.
Cameron announced his resignation at the end of Monday evening’s meeting.
He stated it was with “great sadness” that he can no longer serve on council as a matter of principle following last week’s sudden firings of Brian Crist and Rob Fendrick, two directors who had worked for the city for 17 years.
City manager Christine Smith fired the two without cause. No further details have been provided to the public, as it’s being called a personnel matter.
Cameron was also careful with his words.
Because the dismissals are a personnel issue, he said, he can’t go into details about the firings except to say he could no longer serve on council.
“Fundamentally, I disagreed with the direction taken by the city in this regard,” he said, adding he felt an obligation to state his point of view.
The seemingly abrupt resignation was something he spent a lot of time thinking about and consulting his family on over the weekend before he decided he could no longer keep his seat.
Smith would not comment on the councillor’s decision.
Cameron’s departure will not force a byelection, given the October general election – so it does not mean spending unnecessary money on a vote for the one open seat, he pointed out.
While Cameron expressed his confidence in council continuing to move forward with decisions without him there, his absence brings council down to six members, thus strengthening the possibility of tie votes.
In situations where there is a tie vote of council – say, 3-3 – the matter is defeated.
It was a byelection in 2011 that saw Cameron first elected to the role of councillor after Doug Graham – who now serves as the territory’s Education minister – was elected to the Yukon legislature that year.
Cameron won that byelection with 405 votes, just 36 votes over his closest of 12 competitors, Duke Connelly, a former councillor.
Cameron was then elected to his role as councillor once again in the 2012 municipal election.
Speaking to reporters following his announcement last night, he said the decision was a tough one, but “a necessary statement I have to make.”
It was a decision his family supported, also letting him know their concern as he decided on his course of action, he said, noting the presence of his sister and son at last night’s meeting.
“They know how much I love this office,” Cameron said after earlier stating the role of councillor is “not a job. It’s a calling.”
Though he had reached his decision to quit over the weekend, it wasn’t until all other business had been dealt with at Monday’s meeting that he made the announcement under new business.
Cameron went through the entire meeting as usual, asking questions of delegates and administration on a number of matters up for council’s consideration, ranging from the proposed extended care facility in Whistle Bend to recommendations for environmental grants.
As he explained to reporters later, he had thought council might not have had quorum for last night’s meeting if he hadn’t attended, with Mayor Dan Curtis and councillors John Streicker and Dave Stockdale not able to be there.
So he decided to serve out a final meeting before announcing his formal resignation.
He hadn’t realized both Curtis and Streicker would be attending via conference call, he said.
As for the now-former councillor’s future political plans, he said he has “no idea” what the future might bring.
Cameron, a former president of the territorial Liberal party, was defeated in his territorial run for the Whitehorse Centre riding in the 2010 by-election.
He has also served on the school council for École Whitehorse Elementary School and, though now a consultant, worked as a deputy minister for the Executive Council Office and the Department of Environment.
Questioned what he feels he achieved as a councillor over his more than three years in office, he pointed out the last two budgets have kept property tax increases to 1.7 per cent, the lowest boosts in the past decade.
It was during his first year in office that Cameron stated his opposition to a suggested 3.8 per cent tax hike, he said. Council eventually approved a lower tax hike of three per cent for the 2012 year.
Keeping tax increases as low as possible is something Cameron said he hopes to see continued into the future.
The former councillor went on to point to Porter Creek D, a piece of land in the area of McIntyre Creek that was identified for housing.
Council eventually decided – after significant opposition in the community – it would not do any planning for housing in the area until phase 7 of Whistle Bend is complete.
Cameron also cited the importance of the city’s plans to consolidate its operations and services into two main buildings.
He noted he has continually stressed his hope local suppliers and contractors will be on “equal footing” with Outside firms for work on the project, which could have positive impact on the local economy.
Meanwhile, all but one councillor at last night’s meeting expressed their gratitude for Cameron’s work over the years.
“I’m in a little bit of shock,” Curtis said by phone, after referring to Cameron as a great asset to council as well as a good colleague and friend.
The mayor said he would miss the knowledge, suggestions and advice Cameron has brought to the table.
Councillors Jocelyn Curteanu, Betty Irwin and Streicker echoed those sentiments, all commenting they were sorry to see Cameron go and thanking him for his service.
“I think he’s added so much,” Irwin said.
Coun. Mike Gladish was the only council member not to make any remarks on Cameron’s departure at last night’s meeting.
Reached this morning, Gladish explained there are times when everyone at the table weighs in, expressing the same sentiment. And that can become redundant.
In this case, he said, everything had been said by other council members.
He did note it’s Cameron’s choice to quit, and he won’t be “shedding a tear” over it.
Gladish said he respects Cameron’s right to make the choice he did, though it wouldn’t be the route he would take if he disagreed with a city decision.
Stockdale could not be reached for comment this morning.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (16)
Up 11 Down 19
Mandeep on Mar 20, 2015 at 2:45 pm
In light of this I stopped at the Mayor's office to get his take.
His secretary said he's on vacation. He only plans to return when the Mayor from Calgary arrives.
Up 12 Down 15
No ties -- Go to a shoot-out on Mar 20, 2015 at 5:41 am
With the possibility of important motions dying on the floor it seems to me that it's time to bring in the Dukester. He only lost by a slim margin last election and could cover until the next election. With Duke and Dave at the same table well, that's a lot of wisdom being applied on our behalf.
Up 23 Down 13
whitehorse res on Mar 19, 2015 at 1:05 pm
@Cassandra - And the political attacks begin! By your logic, if he had stayed and raised a s*** storm over the issue would he have been blinded by an obligation to his friends? Would he still not be fit to sit in the political arena?
Come on.... he is doing what HE thinks is right and by doing so may have brought the issues the council and the city are having come to the forefront. Look at all of the comments and people reading these articles over this issue... This may only be the beginning.
That being said...Had this not happened, I am pretty confident that this issue would have blown over in a few weeks. Also, people will remember what he did, and he may (conversely to what you are arguing for) get more votes from this (if he runs again) in the future... people in the Yukon quite often vote for the person and what he/she is willing to stand for. Again, you can stand for something by, in this case, leaving and bringing issues to light.
Up 17 Down 84
Cassandra on Mar 19, 2015 at 3:04 am
Considering the difficulty the decision was for the city manager to release two senior managers, I applaud the courage this style of leadership takes.
Kirk's reaction to the city manager's decision was based on friendship and he ignored his duty as an elected official!
Surely no political party wants to be associated with someone who, in an elected position, is blinded by obligations to friends.
Up 25 Down 35
Shirking Responsibility on Mar 18, 2015 at 2:58 pm
By resigning he removes all ability he had as part of council to address this issue; should it need addressing. He basically took the easy way out and calls it "principle". He shouldn't get any respect for this cowardly move.
Up 34 Down 17
Why don't the Mayor do himself a favor on Mar 18, 2015 at 2:39 pm
Mr. Mayor just resign and let the COW get back to business. You caused enough of a mess.
Up 104 Down 11
Stu Summer on Mar 18, 2015 at 11:14 am
He did note it’s Cameron’s choice to quit, and he won’t be “shedding a tear” over it.
What an inappropriate comment from Gladish. No one is asking anyone to cry, they are asking about the real need for the firings and most people view Kirk's resignation as that of a principled person. It's a loss and council and this city has lost their way.
Up 11 Down 8
Josey Wales on Mar 18, 2015 at 9:09 am
Hey 1st jwhite...I read GD's post too, and I read it very different from you. Your post reads as GD suggested the confused voters are because they are older..correct?
I guess one could read that into it, if your levels of sensitivity were set to irrational.
When ol' Josey reads it, I decipher the confusion coming from the MYRIAD of mixed messages and the iron wall of secrecy our "Nobles" have established.
Many folks feel I'm waaay out there very often, fair enough as I often am.
That said, calling someone a moron because your POV and GD are not in sync, is very childish and undermines any argument you present.
Folks can call me whatever they like here, in person, in their chair warming centers ..matters not to I as it discredit them not me.
Given the epic nonsense coming from our castle of nobles, I'll wail again how perhaps SCAN should set up shop INSIDE it.
Because malfeasance, their arrogance, the fiscal laundering, the questionable hiring practices..man I could go on a spell...
DO and HAVE created a unsafe community lacking ALL accountability.
I guess when I was a wee brat watching Batman, Spiderman etc...when the mayor was actually concerned and acted on crime in those cartoon towns...was merely a cartoon fantasy?
Folks white collar crime is as big if not bigger than blue collar crime, please do not underestimate anyone in that castle now...or in the future.
Up 25 Down 17
June Jackson on Mar 17, 2015 at 8:51 pm
Kirk and I did not share the same values, goals or opinions on how taxpayer dollars should be spent. Actually, I don't share so much as a smile with any of the current sitting council. I looked around for a tear about Fendricks departure and I couldn't find one. I felt Mr. Fendrick was not competent to do the job. I'm sorry Mr. Fendrick, but you are arrogant and irritating. Mr. Crist kept a pretty low profile..
Remember who voted to throw taxpayer money at Mt. Sima???
"Councillors John Streicker and Kirk Cameron were the only members of council to vote in favour of providing the funding,
Streicker and Cameron made impassioned speeches in favour of financial support for the hill, but they were not enough to convince the rest of council." No..I am not sorry to see Mr. Cameron leaving. Perhaps Mr. Streicker will follow suite.
Up 3 Down 16
mandeep on Mar 17, 2015 at 8:03 pm
So when do we post our private facebook convo's?
Up 13 Down 6
jwhite on Mar 17, 2015 at 7:16 pm
In fact, I've never been a fan, or a supporter, of K. Cameron. But today I admire him for having principles. That does not mean I would necessarily vote for him. Ageism, like all bigotries or generalizations, mars any attempt at reasonable dialogue, so we're done.
Up 17 Down 9
Principles or Strategy? on Mar 17, 2015 at 5:29 pm
Kirk Cameron quitting COW council - is that a principled stand or seizing an opportunity as a strategic political move? Let the games begin for his liberal cronies.
Up 12 Down 29
jwhite on Mar 17, 2015 at 4:14 pm
@jwhite, Your "politeness" aside, I'm judging by your comment that you're in one of the two camps I suggested are in support of Mr Cameron.
Up 58 Down 48
jwhite on Mar 17, 2015 at 4:08 pm
Great detail said, this might put K. Cameron in good with "confused and possibly older voters" .
Great detail, I tried to think of a polite way of saying this, but the best I can come up with is: You're a moron.
Up 85 Down 68
great detail on Mar 17, 2015 at 3:51 pm
Ladies and Gentlemen, the new leader of the Yukon Liberal Party!!! Didn't want to just step down this fall, had to make a big show. Watched all the commentary for the two canned and decided it would shine a great big spotlight on him and his "morals" which even though are 5 days late, will put him in good with confused and possibly older voters. Well played Mr Cameron, a perfect politician will you make. All hot air....no substance.
Up 154 Down 52
What a dysfunctional place on Mar 17, 2015 at 3:37 pm
What a dysfunctional place to work. It is just as bad as parts of YTG. Good luck Kirk and you did the right thing. Gladish if you run in the next election and lose you will shed a tear because you will lose your power and income. What a negative overbearing attitude for elected official to have and to represent the people of COW is totally embarrassing.