Whitehorse Daily Star

Bigotry was isolated event, Carmacks mayor believes

A scenario that escalated from racist slurs to an attempted murder charge in Carmacks is not indicative of what the community is really like, says the town's mayor.

By Justine Davidson on December 29, 2008

A scenario that escalated from racist slurs to an attempted murder charge in Carmacks is not indicative of what the community is really like, says the town's mayor.

"There's no room for prejudice," Mayor Elaine Wyatt said in an interview last week after learning the details of the case against Antoine Pierre.

"There's no room for bigotry. I don't think it's the majority of the community, and I'm sorry that it escalated to this point."

The 31-year-old Pierre, visiting the Yukon from Montreal, was charged with aggravated assault and attempted murder last June after a fight broke out in the Carmacks bar.

Pierre was accused of stabbing a man who had been harassing and threatening him almost constantly for the short time he was in the village.

Witnesses testified Eric Gulstad had threatened to shoot Pierre, his friend and fellow Montrealer Ernst Barthelemy, and anyone else who befriended them simply because the two men were black.

The witnesses told the court Pierre and Barthelemy did nothing to warrant the attacks, which began with words but quickly intensified.

"It certainly doesn't reflect how the people in the town generally treat newcomers," Wyatt said of the incident. "The fact it all happened in a bar doesn't help matters."

After just two weeks in Carmacks, the tension came to a violent climax.

A friend of Gulstad's, Bobby Gage, punched Barthelemy and the two started fighting.

Pierre tried to break it up, Gulstad jumped into the fray, Pierre took out his knife and Gulstad was wounded.

Pierre was ultimately acquitted by Judge Michael Cozens, who said in his reasons for judgment that "trouble came to Mr. Pierre."

Charges were not laid against Gage nor Gulstad, and neither of the two Montrealers provided statements about the harassment they suffered, according to RCMP spokesman Sgt. Mark Groves.

"Often times things come up in the trial that are not told to police when they are investigating," he said when asked why only Barthelemy and Pierre were arrested.

Some Carmacks residents have anonymously weighed in on the issue, via the Internet.

"These racist men are transits that are not even from Carmacks and act in that manner to make our peaceful quiet town look bad," wrote one woman identified as Yukongirl.

"I knew this (sic) two men that came to visit the Yukon and they are very nice young guys who wanted no trouble. Transits in our community should go back to where they come from or even ban from here. Racist people should be the one to have served 90 days. Good Luck Antoine and Ernest. Your friends in Carmacks."

Although Pierre and Barthelemy could have taken more precautions than they did, by taking refuge in the police detachment, for instance, or locking themselves in their cabin, the judge said the two men had a right as citizens to move and socialize freely around the community.

He did say Pierre's decision to tuck a knife into his waistband before heading to the bar was not the wisest thing he could have done, adding that had he worn the knife on a holster at his belt, he would have been entirely without fault.

While Pierre chose to fight the charges against him, Barthelemy pleaded guilty to assault and spent three months in jail.

"I'm glad if it was that bad that they were vindicated when they were in court," Wyatt said after the judgment. "I feel sorry for the gentleman who did serve a sentence."

The mayor said race relations in the town are generally friendly, with the people of the Little Salmon-Carmacks First Nation living side-by-side with the non-aboriginal community.

"Considering the makeup of the community, we work well together," Wyatt said.

Asked if she intends to address the incident in her capacity as mayor, Wyatt said she doesn't know what she could do.

"All you can do is hope that when this comes out, they'll be shamed into not continuing that kind of behaviour."

Comments (10)

Up 0 Down 2

Northerner on Jan 2, 2009 at 5:23 pm

Eric Gulstad simply brought it apon himself. He should have put his foot in his mouth instead of threatening people. He is not from Carmacks and he definetly should be charged too. Diversity is certainly not in his books. Still he is employed by the Carmacks Hotel and Village of Carmacks. Businesses and Governments should not tolerate racism. If the mayor is a good leader she would do something about this.

Up 0 Down 2

Michel Dupont on Jan 2, 2009 at 3:02 am

If the majority of Carmacks residents are not racists, then why no one spoke out for these guys during the whole time they were in the community? A hate crime took place and the majority of people did nothing. The mayor should never say she doesn't know what to do. That's not a leader's answer to a problem that has plagued the world for centuries. The community has to own the situation the same way it dealt with drug dealers, show our true colors.

Up 0 Down 2

Mike Grieco on Dec 31, 2008 at 8:58 pm

Racism in the Yukon? Imagine that!

"why haven't the perpetrators been charged?"--Because this would attract WAY TO MUCH attention in our "Larger Than Life" destination.

By the way: What does "Larger Than Lfe" mean? What is the definition of these words?

"Exploit North", anyone?

Up 2 Down 1

Carmacks Lady on Dec 31, 2008 at 11:02 am

Just because someone is mouthy doesn't mean they should be stabbed multiple times. Nowhere have I read that the person who got stabbed had any weapon except for his mouth. New evidence? It's my understanding that Mr. Pierre had left the bar with his friend and they came back with a knife. If he wasn't looking to get into trouble, why not stay out once he had left? It's pretty simple really.

Up 1 Down 2

Susan Rogan on Dec 31, 2008 at 5:13 am

Why is Eric not being charged under the Hate Crimes act? Statement or no statement from the victims, there seems to be plenty to work with from the statements from Carmacks residents plus the evidence presented at the trial in which Pierre was acquitted.

Racist violence needs to be seriously condemned.

Up 1 Down 2

Rachel Westfall on Dec 30, 2008 at 12:42 pm

If there's no room for prejudice, why haven't the perpetrators been charged? Why is it only the victims of racist violence who have lost several months of their lives in jail? In light of the new evidence that came out during Mr. Pierre's trial, I hope charges will be laid and justice served.

Up 1 Down 2

billy burden on Dec 30, 2008 at 10:06 am

if i move to carmacks with my half black son an i going to have a problem. plan on checking out you town this summer

Up 1 Down 1

John Lome on Dec 29, 2008 at 6:22 pm

Eric has always had problems "under the influemce."

The liquor act has provisions for this.

John

Up 1 Down 2

Ann on Dec 29, 2008 at 3:42 pm

I hope the racists will be shamed out of your fair town and out of the Yukon

Up 0 Down 2

waja on Dec 29, 2008 at 1:10 pm

Carmacks is a great place. If you need gas on the way to Dawson.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.