Photo by Vince Fedorof
INTERIM AMBULANCE STATION PROPOSED – Gerard Dinn, manager of clinical operations for EMS, told city council last night that ambulance stations are best placed where they're needed.
Photo by Vince Fedorof
INTERIM AMBULANCE STATION PROPOSED – Gerard Dinn, manager of clinical operations for EMS, told city council last night that ambulance stations are best placed where they're needed.
Moving some ambulances to the former Mine Rescue Station on Range Road would mean quicker service for residents at the top of Two Mile Hill and beyond.
Moving some ambulances to the former Mine Rescue Station on Range Road would mean quicker service for residents at the top of Two Mile Hill and beyond.
With it, however, would come the sound of more sirens for residents of the Takhini neighbourhoods.
City council members have been asked to consider rezoning the property at 456 Range Rd. to Public Service from Comprehensive Neighbourhood Commercial, to allow an ambulance bay to operate out of the building there. The new use would complement the current ambulance station at Whitehorse General Hospital.
The change would allow Emergency Medical Services (EMS) personnel to use the older building as a temporary ambulance bay while planning for a new structure to be built in the Two Mile Hill/Alaska Highway area.
Kobayashi + Zedda Architects were awarded a $420,000 contract earlier this year to design the station, though officials have yet to determine exactly where it will go.
As Gerard Dinn, manager of clinical operations for EMS, told council last night, the Range Road building is ideal in the meantime, with two bays and the response times it would allow in area neighbourhoods, among other features.
"We have significantly explored other options,” Dinn told council when questioned by Coun. Dave Stockdale on what other choices might be available.
Among those options was the fire station at the top of Two Mile Hill which will close later this year as the new, adjacent public safety building (under construction) opens.
That building required significant upgrades and was not available for EMS use, Dinn said. Being located out of the public safety building was also found not to be feasible, a staff report to council notes, though Coun. Ranj Pillai stated he would like to see that reconsidered.
Upgrades to the mine rescue building are estimated to cost the territory about $40,000, including exterior and interior paint, upgrading the garage doors and installing a new washroom.
Stockdale said he was nervous about the three to four years the ambulance bay is proposed to be in the area. Two years are something he could live with, but three or four seem like too much, he said.
He then questioned whether all the neighbourhoods along Range Road would be notified of the changes.
Typically, the city sends out notifications by mail of rezoning applications to properties within 100 metres of the site.
However, it can expand that area as it sees fit, said Pat Ross, the city's land development supervisor.
Mayor Bev Buckway also wondered about the close vicinity to homes and a school, questioning how common it is in other regions to have an ambulance station so close.
As Dinn noted, ambulances are stationed where they're needed, and in many cases, that means having them in residential areas.
In his 21 years working in ambulance services, that hasn't been an issue, he stated when Coun. Florence Roberts continued along the same line of questioning.
Dinn acknowledged the neighbourhoods in Takhini haven't been consulted on the matter; though unsuccessful attempts had been made to get in touch with a representative from one of the neighbourhood associations.
For residents, the new neighbour at the Range Road building would not only mean more ambulances on the main roadway, but also the sound of sirens throughout the day and night.
"EMS estimates that there will be approximately 2,000 to 2,500 ‘events' at this building per year, whereby an ambulance is dispatched,” notes the administrative report Ross presented to council.
"Approximately 1,000 of these events, or roughly three per day, would be an emergency call, where lights and sirens are, by law, required to be used as the ambulance leaves the station.”
Dinn also pointed out ambulances already use Range Road and travel through school zones on a daily basis.
Moving to the site until a new structure is built would mitigate some traffic concerns of ambulances travelling through the downtown core to get to a call, he added.
Ideally, EMS would be in its interim location "yesterday,” he commented, stating that while ambulance service has doubled recently, it is all operating out of one station in Riverdale.
Although residents haven't yet had a say on the proposal, if council goes ahead with first reading of the bylaw next Monday, a public hearing where anyone can speak to it would be held at council's July 26 meeting.
A report of that input would then come to council on Aug. 2 prior to council's vote on second and third readings of the bylaw, expected Aug. 9.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (8)
Up 0 Down 0
DL on Jun 28, 2010 at 1:33 pm
It is funny how people complain about the smallest things, try living in a real city, where you have trains passing threw every night blowing there horns. ambulace siren seems pritty mimimal. I would wake every night to the siren thinking about the poor person in trouble, not worried about my 5 minutes of missed sleep.
Up 0 Down 0
T R on Jun 27, 2010 at 6:39 am
We do get occasional emergency vehicles along Range Road - but most emergency traffic bypasses this residential area by using MountainView or Two Mile Hill/Alaska Highway to access Porter Creek and points beyond; but ALL sirens will start here with this proposal. EMS has been looking at a second location for several years now, and they have progressed nowhere, and created an "emergency". Sorry, but poor planning on your part does not create an emergency for me. And there is a major concern that "temporary" will become very long term due to continued poor planning and / or change of funding priorities (why commit to this capital expenditure when there is already one there?) Where is our MLA on this issue? Speak out for your constituents interests! I am AGAINST this proposal! Do NOT change zoning to allow this! (BTW, if zoning changes, will it change back after this temporary situation is over? Good luck!)
Up 0 Down 0
Ace on Jun 24, 2010 at 10:28 am
The city is spending tens of millions on a new building on top of Two Mile; couldn't they have planned for an ambulance station to go there!
Up 0 Down 0
DG on Jun 23, 2010 at 4:33 pm
Of course naysayers are gonna pop up. They tried to get in contact with one of the community associations but were unable to.
Having an ambulance station 10 minutes closer to the MAJORITY of our population may inconvenience some but just think if you had a heart attack they would be 250 meters from your home they are right there.
Up 0 Down 0
Jennifer Ellis on Jun 23, 2010 at 8:13 am
I live less than 250 meters from this proposed station and this is the first I have heard about the proposal to have 3 sirens a day sound very near my home. The same is true for many others who live even closer.
I wonder about the people who have recently bought expensive lots from the same City that is suddenly considering rezoning to allow for an ambulance station. Many are in the middle of building their new homes which are close enough that they will be able to see the station from their front step... won't they be happy about this little surprise!
Mr. Stockdale notes that 3-4 years of use is too much but he "could live with" 2 years of ambulances using this station. If he or the other members of council were asked to live 10-20 houses away from such a station in their neighbourhood (which is about 150-300 meters in distance)could they really put up with loud sirens and speeding emergency vehicles along their street at least three times a day, every day, for even 730 days and nights? Who would vote for that!?
The City and YTG have land holdings in industrial area that would make a better temporary home for the ambulance station and wouldn't burden a residential neighbourhood that is already going to have to deal with the nearby new public safety building and its sirens.
This last minute rezoning request, done with zero consultation and closed doors planning, is completely a seat-of-the-pants planning approach. I hope the City Council sees it for what it is - inappropriate and ill-conceived.
Up 0 Down 0
Mongo on Jun 23, 2010 at 7:17 am
When the last incarnation of WGH was built it should have been at the top of 2 Mile near the CGC which is essentally the center of the city as far as population disribution goes.
I can't see how having a hospital on the opposite side of a river (with one crossing) from 95% of the population EVER made sense.
Up 0 Down 0
JC on Jun 22, 2010 at 10:05 am
Makes perfectly good sense to me. Only 30 years too late.
Up 0 Down 0
anonymous on Jun 22, 2010 at 8:09 am
How would there be more sirens? If the ambulances would be coming up here from the hospital we would still hear them. All of a sudden because the ambulances are closer we hear more of them? As for the noise if you've ever been to Vancouver or any other big city all you hear is sirens. You get used to it.