Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Sue Harding

B.C. has siphoned off substitute teachers

The number of substitute teachers available in the Yukon is down by 50 per cent or more, says the president of the Yukon Teachers’ Association.

By Chuck Tobin on October 12, 2018

The number of substitute teachers available in the Yukon is down by 50 per cent or more, says the president of the Yukon Teachers’ Association.

Sue Harding said in an interview Thursday it’s a reflection of the teacher shortage across Canada, particularly in B.C.

She suspects the additional demand in B.C. that came about as a result of a 2016 B.C. Supreme Court decision on class sizes has had an impact on the availability of substitutes here.

The province had removed the provision for maximum class sizes, but the teachers went to court and won, she pointed out.

As a result, Harding said, the province has had to expand its number of teachers on call by 5,000.

If you’re a substitute – teacher on call – working in the Yukon, and have a shot at a full-time job in Prince George, for example, there’s a chance you’ll take it, she said.

Harding said raising the daily pay for substitute teachers would likely help as well. She noted that substitutes in the Yukon earn $218 a day compared to the $325 they earn in B.C.

Adding more financial incentive to the mix may be enough to keep teachers from moving to Prince George or somewhere else in B.C., she said.

The association president said substitutes here can work pretty much every day if they choose.

So making it more lucrative could keep them here, she said.

Harding explained at the end of April, before the arrival of post-secondary students on their summer break who sign-up as substitutes, there were approximately 350 names on the list of substitute teachers.

Currently, there is somewhere in the neighbourhood of 175, she said.

Harding said there’s no one reason to explain it, other than it’s part of the teacher shortage across Canada.

Graduating more teachers across the country would definitely help, she said.

Harding explains that having fewer substitutes available means if a school can’t find one, the other teachers have to fill in.

That means they have to use the 40 minutes a day they have for preparation time, wind-down time, or time to work one-on-one with students who need extra help.

It’s a case of one teacher using his or her prep time to fill in, followed by another teacher for the next 40 minutes and then another until the day is done, she explained.

“Otherwise, you have to start sending kids home, and you don’t want to do that.”

The association president said the risk is teacher-burnout, or having teachers feeling compelled to show up even when they’re ill and should be staying home.

The vast majority of substitute teachers in the Yukon have their teaching degree, she explained.

She said there are allowances for substitutes who do not have a teaching degree.

For those who don’t, but have another university degree, the daily pay is $180 rather than $218 for qualified teachers, she said.

There’s also a provision for substitute teachers without a degree, she added, though they must have been out of high school for three years, and their daily pay is $130 or a $140.

Substitute teachers in the Yukon are not covered by a collective agreement nor represented by a union, though the teachers’ association is trying to bring them under its collective agreement.

The association currently represents 800 members. They include educational assistants, vice-principals, principals and administrators.

Of the 800, between 450 and 500 are teachers.

Earlier this week in the legislature, Scott Kent, the Yukon Party’s Education critic, said the official Opposition has heard the Liberal government is slashing the budget for substitute teachers as part of its initiative to save money.

“Substitutes play an important role in the day-to-day operations of a school,” Kent told the legislature during question period.

“They cover teachers in a multitude of circumstances and schools depend on them.

“We have heard Holy Family has been asked to cut their budget for substitute teachers in half. Does the premier believe that cutting the substitute teacher budget is appropriate?”

Premier Sandy Silver notified Kent he wouldn’t comment on the source of the Yukon Party’s information. But he did tell Kent he was mistaken.

“... These are not the words of the territorial government,” Silver said.

“They are the words of the Yukon Party. They keep on talking about cuts. Now they’re talking about cuts to substitute teachers. This is not something that is being contemplated right now by this government.”

Harding said she has not heard anything about any cuts to the Holy Family Elementary School’s substitute teachers budget.

Comments (9)

Up 0 Down 1

YukonMax on Oct 19, 2018 at 5:49 am

I was raised in the 60's and can't remember a substitute teacher covering for mine unless my teacher was really, really sick or dead. 30 + students per class. We didn't have a substitute assigned to our school either. We didn't need it. What's going on?

Up 2 Down 1

Groucho d'North on Oct 18, 2018 at 4:27 pm

If teachers are now bemoaning what the real world in the profession is requiring of them, I'd say they made a bad choice maybe back in high school when they decided what to be when they grew up. All professions require upgrading from time to time, just look at the computer industry if you feel bad as a teacher. Imagine what the people who repair your 'whatever' have to learn each year. As employees we need to invest in our own education if we want to remain an asset to our employers and customers. I hear lots of whining from teachers about how unfair they have it, then quit teaching and find a different job. Good luck finding one with the same pay, benefits and terms you presently receive.

Up 6 Down 6

My Opinion on Oct 16, 2018 at 7:39 pm

Aren't you full of Opinions as well. You seem to know my education level, my level of expertise, and I assume, my motives.

Well you are completely wrong. I work on average 12 hours a day six days a week. Self employed and do not get paid for half of it. I have trained many through Apprenticeship to Journeyman. Have spent countless hours mentoring young workers though this process. You obviously are involved in the education end of things due to your Outrage at someone questioning your effort.

You my friend are very judgemental and self righteous. Now go mark those papers.

Up 12 Down 5

To 'My Opinion' on Oct 15, 2018 at 8:23 pm

Hey 'My Opinion' You clearly know nothing about teaching. Teachers are assigned different teaching jobs every year--they don't just get the same assignment every year! It's very stressful actually to not know if you'll be teaching classes you've taught before so you can do this with expertise. Some are lucky and get to stay doing what they've done, like PE, Shop, or Reading Recovery. Others are expected to prep for new classes. I'm glad that you're a genius who knows it all...and you wouldn't need to prep your classes, photocopy, contact parents (a great deal now, 5 times over the semester) or discipline students, because clearly you're a gifted person. Clearly you'd teach all day and stay at the school from 3:00-7:00 for free, because you don't need to be paid to all of the tasks that are expected of teachers. I hope if you have kids in school that you value their teachers. You sound like an arrogant, uneducated, unaware judge without a clue.

Up 16 Down 17

My Opinion on Oct 14, 2018 at 9:36 pm

Isn't that what professional development days are for? Oh I forgot those are for fishing in Haines. Hahaha. You think we don't see you guys on those days or what?

Up 15 Down 20

My Opinion on Oct 14, 2018 at 9:34 pm

175 subs cannot keep up with the absenteeism of our teachers? That is totally crazy.

These teachers teach the same programs year after year, they just roll it out again. Sure here and there they may change it a bit but they are not re inventing the wheel everyday, Give me a break.

In the real world I do not get to bill out time to prep for my job. I am supposed to know how to do it. No wonder our kids emerge from High school with barely a grade school knowledge.

Up 11 Down 11

Doug Ryder on Oct 13, 2018 at 11:54 pm

The ironies of liberalism... The ignorance of an uninformed electorate will create its own fascism... Vote for it, fight for it...
Have you ever seen a coyote gnawing on its own leg to escape a trap? Sounds like a lot of liberal voters right about now! Nom, nom, nom, nom... [echoing all across the country]

Up 15 Down 12

Wilf Carter on Oct 13, 2018 at 7:45 am

We will soon see a teacher teaching three grades in the same class room. Our education needs an overhaul. I had a great talk with teachers this past week and it was a real learning experience for me about the education system.

Up 24 Down 4

They better not.... on Oct 12, 2018 at 10:34 pm

I voted in the Liberals and I can vote them out. You better NOT cut substitutes. I'm married to a teacher who works her tail off, but when she's sick, just like any other government employee, she needs coverage. And when she has a prep, she should not be subbing for somebody else. Teachers already work a great deal outside of the paid work day, so it's not fair to have teachers teaching somebody else's classes to save the Libs money!!
Did you know that teachers are entitled to a prep according to the collective agreement? You gonna pay those teachers covering extra?? I think not. Most people did not become teachers to have an easy job, but because they love teaching students and doing extra curriculars, such as coaching them. Get a flipping grip!!! This government acts more like a conservative government than a liberal government. You've already made 'cuts' to ensure that teachers who volunteer on students teams and need to travel cannot do that without using leave without pay. How about some of the other government workers use leave without pay when they are coaching a soccer team and want to go on the tournament? This Liberal needs to get a grip....and you have lost our large family's support.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.