Association head resigns
The procurement policy issue continues to bedevil the business community.
The procurement policy issue continues to bedevil the business community.
Terry Sherman, who was the president of the Yukon Contractors Association (YCA), resigned his position over the procurement policy controversy earlier this week.
“It was a hard decision to walk a way from YCA,” he told the Star.
“There is a certain number of members that do not want nor like the FNPP (First Nations Procurement Policy) and would rather be the problem than the solution.
“The Yukon government has tried to work with YCA to build the technical requirements along with First Nation governments to make sure this FNPP will work for all Yukon citizens and achieving the goals set out in the policy,” Sherman said.
“But you have to be at the table for collaboration with meaningful outcomes. So I have decided to keep working on solutions and will not be part of the problem.”
In January, the Star obtained a letter the YCA’s Sherman sent to the government over the policy.
The letter outlined a series of questions from the YCA and criticisms it has of the process leading up to the announcement of the policy.
The letter sought an immediate meeting with cabinet ministers Richard Mostyn, Ranj Pillai and John Streicker, and YCA member representatives.
“We wish to discuss the concerns our members have brought forward, and we request that the government delay implementation of the new policy until 2022,” the letter read.
“The YCA received member inquiries, requests for information, and concerns after the policy was announced.
“On Jan. 7, we hosted in-person and online forums to hear from our members on the details that have been provided to date. Combined attendance for both meetings was 72 company members, representing over 80 per cent of our membership. The majority of those members concurred with the enumerated issues shared below.”
The letter, signed by Sherman, goes on to read: “While our members firmly support the objectives outlined in the policy, there was a consensus that the policy, as written, is divisive and pits Yukon businesses against each other.”
It lists a lack of consultation by the government as a prime criticism.
“This definition of a Yukon First Nations business makes it most effective to establish shell companies which would neither develop nor enhance relationships and they fail to provide any development of relevant sector skills or experience.
“More concerning to YCA members, they provide a very lucrative and easy opportunity for Outside companies to establish in the Yukon while circumventing Yukon business requirements.
“The YCA objects as well to the ambitious timelines established in the policy,” the letter adds.
“The proposed policy has massive changes to the procurement process and the timelines are far too soon for implementation.”
Chad Harwood, the YCA’s vice-president, has replaced Sherman on an interim basis.
“The former president resigned, I am the VP so I have to step in,” Harwood told the Star.
“Why the president resigned has not been disclosed to me; however, we were working on the First Nations procurement policy at the time.”
Comments (18)
Up 0 Down 2
Salt on Mar 10, 2021 at 11:24 pm
@Edie rue
Take a look around. This hasn't been turtle island for a long time.
Up 24 Down 5
Vern Schlimbesser on Mar 8, 2021 at 11:04 am
@Tater
Collective rights vs individual rights is a great area to do some research.
What amazed and shocked me was Pierre Elliot Trudeau's cautions in this area. (I hated him with a passion, but re-reading his words about this made me re-think the whole thing).
Your view is valid and believe it or not PET championed that point of view. He said (I paraphrase of course), "any time you give a group of people special rights it comes at a cost to everyone else" and he opposed it. (I have a hard time supporting any politician named Trudeau, but we know the current one inherited his mothers looks, and unfortunately, her intellect.)
Up 22 Down 6
dick on Mar 8, 2021 at 8:07 am
@Edie rue, I don't forget where I am. In a Yukon that is diversified, fair, and inclusive. Where everyone is equal, and belongs to all Yukoners, to enjoy!
Up 45 Down 11
Tater on Mar 6, 2021 at 2:26 pm
Just a couple of thoughts. Firstly, when you "give" any group of people an advantage over another group, you have problems. Remember the USA 50 years ago in dealing with certain groups. Secondly, where is the taxpayer in this issue? They are the ones who have to pay for such policies.
Up 29 Down 20
Josey Wales on Mar 6, 2021 at 9:01 am
Hey Wilf..."Why is the liberal exploiting FN people by trying to buy them with tax payers money? This has been tried in the past and it failed across Canada."
You just illustrated what seems to be the Liberals mission statement.
Just like down south, the Democrats NEED those big failed cities full of ethnic voters, keep others on an economic plantation that never is liberated.
The metric Democrats, what used to be Canada the LIBERAL blowholes, absolutely bank on that policy of racial division under the guise of help/white guilt/equity...and empowerment.
Other than the white guilt our political BLOWHOLES vent daily, none of the others are even addressed.
Our PM uses terms like Genocide as it relates to the cultural elites with zero issue ever so casually and with much pride in displaying its virtue stating so.
Funny thing is, the YLP (team SS) & the CLP know exactly the tension they create with this s**t! they wish it so, they want the divide, the fight, the claim of racial purity/superiority to come to a head.
A tad wordy Wilf, but my attempt to answer ya...OJW
Up 40 Down 5
Yukoner92 on Mar 5, 2021 at 11:04 pm
Has anyone heard from Currie Dixon on this yet? How come no one has gone to him for comment and why hasn't he come out with a statement on his own? I think with a looming election we deserve to know where he stands and what he will do if elected.
Up 26 Down 14
Josey Wales on Mar 5, 2021 at 9:05 pm
gee...a while back Rosa Parks just wanted to sit up front on the bus.
Up here? We have folks having their very own transit system, wish not sharing a bus with "those people"? We have an entire tiers of industry based on race, actual AND alleged historical grievances. It really does make me sad so many cannot see it for the tool it is, a very divisive tool too.
The Liberals have used the cultural elites as political pawns since the first "freebie" of firewater and shiny things. Now? They have done a great job of ripping our wee place to bits, everyone squabbling for Longshanks leftovers.
The amount of zeros left of the decimal doled out up here JUST in the last 6 years EXCLUSIVELY for the poor, oppressed and allegedly downtrodden cultural elites should blow anyone's mind...should they be paying any attention.
Harder to with race baiting and whack a mole politics, and the chronic well engineered weapons of MASS Distraction.
"I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character. " MLK Gee what a radical racist he was eh?
YFN? Having a hard time, broke and feel there is no future for you as an individual? Talk to your leaders, if they are anything like "ours" (and they most certainly are) they are making out quite well as are their cronies...just like they traditionally have done.
Oh yeah, Thank the CLP for reversing the FNAA, where your people AND "ours" knew where the money went. That act, was only up for two years of the entire time since 1867 before PM BFF axed it!! Now it is like it's always has been...completely unaccountable and untraceable...IS EXACTLY ...THEE.. issue why hope...feels like a carrot in front of a horse tied to a long long stick.
That long stick YOUR leaders use, not ours as much.
Up 43 Down 11
Leonard on Mar 5, 2021 at 8:47 pm
Sherman quit because he does not want to be part of the problem? Maybe the problem was that the membership didn’t like the fact this policy was rubber stamped by YG and First Nations without any consultation with existing local businesses. Maybe the problem was a 15 to 20% bid advantage for FN companies over other local non-FN businesses.
We’ve seen before large outside corporations set up shell companies for an edge on bids in communities. Companies in the Yukon have grown and can do most jobs making them more competitive, including plenty of FN owned or partnered companies. FN development corps are major players in manufacturing, road construction, fuel services, building supplies, air transport, building construction and commercial building rentals.
I’m not sure which wrong is being righted by this procurement policy. I have never seen a tender eliminate anyone’s bid for being First Nation. Now Sherman is going to be part of the solution. Does this mean he’s going to work for the Liberals or a First Nation development corp.?
Up 16 Down 64
Edie rue on Mar 5, 2021 at 5:00 pm
I am enjoying every minute watching white people get their heckles up when they feel it’s not fair. Honestly, I couldn’t care less if every current contracting company got pissy and ran south. Don’t forget where you are folks.
Up 38 Down 10
funny claimed there was a conflict of interest on Mar 5, 2021 at 4:56 pm
then on March 4th 2021 Terry Sherman is introduced as a guest in the legislature for the libs. Good faith my a$$
Up 46 Down 11
dick on Mar 5, 2021 at 3:46 pm
@Patti Eyre and it also teaches all are create equal.
Up 60 Down 29
Isn't Terry Sherman a staunch liberal supporter? on Mar 5, 2021 at 3:38 pm
Tough to say you're having fair and open consultation when the president did everything against the members.
Up 29 Down 40
Juniper Jackson on Mar 5, 2021 at 3:22 pm
What does Brendan Hanley say about this??
Up 82 Down 34
Wilf Carter on Mar 5, 2021 at 2:59 pm
Why is the liberal exploiting FN people by trying to buy them with tax payers money. This has been tried in the past and it failed across Canada.
Up 40 Down 22
Wilf Carter on Mar 5, 2021 at 2:51 pm
Nailed on what can take place when one group gets an edge over the other.
Up 21 Down 99
Patti Eyre on Mar 5, 2021 at 2:49 pm
Very carefully chosen words! And they’re pretty clear in that some contractors are just bigots, let’s be honest about that! The bible teaches acceptance and tolerance.
Up 56 Down 36
John T. on Mar 5, 2021 at 2:32 pm
Watch. Sherman the Liberal quit because the YCA didn’t like that he was trying to toe the party line. He quit and will probably run for the liberals. I’m really glad to see Chad step in and hope he stays there. He is not only friendly, but works to represent everyone. Sherman has never done that.
Up 74 Down 8
jason on Mar 5, 2021 at 2:18 pm
They're not wrong about the shell companies. Within the NWT policies, there are tons and tons of inactive JV's from national companies. In my opinion, affirmative action policies are a double-edged sword. Of course it is good to level the playing field for disadvantaged groups, however, in business specifically the bar for entry is necessarily high. Reason being is that you ultimately want the business to be able to stand up on it's own and deliver great work, FN or non-FN. I'm not entirely sure that joint venture companies which essentially pay a premium to a FN to use their name (in some cases, not all) is a good thing in the long-term. In my opinion, what is really needed are investments in FN established businesses like Pelly Construction. Those that have met the bar for being a legitimate business on their own accord can do far more for Yukon than a J-V company that has very little actual benefit in terms of local capacity development