Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Photo Submitted

SEEKING REMEDIES – Yukon patients are needlessly going without care because of the forced shutterings of alternative health care clinics, says Tana Shepherd, the chair of Yukon Allied Healthcare Professionals and the owner of Whitehorse Osteopathy. Photo by EMILIE DORY

Alternative health care field called miscategorized

The Yukon’s alternative health care professionals say they’ve been miscategorized as “personal services” under the territory’s COVID-19 restrictions.

By Gabrielle Plonka on April 27, 2020

The Yukon’s alternative health care professionals say they’ve been miscategorized as “personal services” under the territory’s COVID-19 restrictions.

That has forced the indefinite closures of several medical practices, they say.

“The issue is we’re inaccurately represented,” Tana Shepherd told the Star today.

“We’re not necessarily asking to have restrictions lifted on our sector prematurely, we’re asking for accurate representation so we can have profession-specific guidelines that enable us to provide service to Yukoners.”

Shepherd is the chair of Yukon Allied Healthcare Professionals and the owner of Whitehorse Osteopathy.

She represents the Yukon’s registered massage therapists, naturopathic doctors, osteopaths, somatic therapists, acupuncturists, chiropractors, athletic therapists, and physiotherapists.

Under current COVID-19 restrictions, these health care providers are characterized as “personal services” and were ordered to close indefinitely in mid-March.

Shepherd said health care practitioners would like to be placed in a separate category from hair salons and tattoo parlours.

“We recognize the importance of these services as well; however, being characterized similarly misrepresents the critical nature of our services for (the) mental, emotional and physical health of Yukoners,” Shepherd said.

Allied health practitioners say the forced closures of their clinics have “left a critical gap in health care” in the Yukon for treatment of chronic conditions, disease and pain as well as acute accidents, injuries and stress management.

Alternative health practitioners are advocating to be categorized separately and granted representation on the Yukon government’s Business Advisory Council.

Shepherd pointed out that in most Canadian jurisdictions, the health care sectors she represents are included in the Health Care Act and are categorized as primary health care services.

She argued that a lack of regulatory bodies for these professions in the Yukon has led to their mischaracterization as personal services.

Last Wednesday, Dr. Brendan Hanley, the Yukon’s chief medical officer, announced the territory will likely face some restrictions for 12-18 months until a COVID-19 vaccine is available.

Health care professionals are hoping to see a path for safe reopening within that timeline.

“Non-COVID health care concerns in our community do not disappear during a pandemic; prior to this situation, there was already a shortage of allied health care services as practitioners already operated with extensive waitlists,” Shepherd said.

“We want to work in collaboration with the (chief medical officer) to set high and appropriate profession-specific standards and guidelines for controlled and safe return to practice as restrictions on businesses are lifted.”

Shepherd noted that members of the allied health community are growing frustrated as local businesses, such as retail stores and the Better Bodies fitness centre, publicize plans for tentative re-opening this week while their clinics remain under a forced closure order.

Many health care practitioners in the Yukon are now fielding daily emails from patients with chronic disease and pain who are hopeful that services will resume, Shepherd said.

She sent two letters to Ranj Pillai, the minister of Economic Development, on behalf of Yukon Allied Healthcare Professionals on April 10 and on Friday.

In these letters, she requested:

• a seat for a health care representative on the Business Advisory Council;

• targeted financial assistance for health-specific expenses such as insurance and licensing fees; and

• guaranteed monthly income assistance for practitioners ineligible for the wage subsidy program.

Shepherd said she has not yet received a response from Pillai’s office on these requests – though it did confirm receipt of her email.

If a response is not received by the end of the week, Shepherd said, allied health care workers will start gathering patient feedback, potentially in the form of a petition.

Pillai provided the Star with a written statement this morning.

It explained that numerous individuals and organizations have expressed interest in joining the Business Advisory Council since it was established.

The council already has 30 members.

“We value the interest of the local business community in working together to identify issues and find solutions to various sector specific impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic,” Pillai said.

“In the coming days, we plan to announce a new approach to engaging with Yukon’s diverse business sector in a way that effectively incorporates their varied perspectives on how to comprehensively address the economic impacts of COVID-19 and plan for a re-emergence of Yukon’s economy.”

Comments (4)

Up 6 Down 2

Bandit on May 1, 2020 at 3:20 pm

@ E.Q.
I am assuming you are referring to my comment so I will try not to rant for long, but you are seriously misinformed my friend. I will provide this response in point form as it appears you don't grasp reality well.

-I did not refer to a haircut as an essential service, I just said I needed one.
-To become a Chiropractor in Canada takes a minimum of 7 years. No Mortar and Pestle required.
-Alternative Medicine has been around since the beginning of time.
-My Chiropractor, Dr. (Yes I said Dr.) Pederson who I have been seeing for 25+ years has done more for my health than any GP. Not only in his field of expertise but his 50 years of practicing Chiropractic Medicine and his vast knowledge of the human anatomy I put 100% trust in his treatments and recommendations.
-Dr. Don Branigan was our Family Dr. until he passed away and he also had alternative treatment options instead of pill pushing which wasn't accepted by the Old Boys Club so unfortunately he had his Hospital privileges stripped and couldn't be there for my sons birth. And he was also one of the BEST Mayors this town has ever had.
-And by the way, keep watching your infomercials because Dr. Ho is according to you rationale, nothing more than a Mortar and Pestle grinding Chiropractor with the title Dr. in front of his name.
-You should research what it takes to be a Sports Medicine Therapist, Osteopath or a Physiotherapist.
Rant over.

Up 7 Down 13

Ebenezer Quigly on Apr 30, 2020 at 9:41 am

I don't want to be paying for some person out picking berries and flowers for their mortar and pestle. When these people go to school for seven years and get Dr. in front of their names maybe then I will be interested in funding special services. By another bloggers logic Hairdressing appointments are one on one so why are they shut down? Dr. Ho has lots of great massage devices.

Up 17 Down 2

Bandit on Apr 29, 2020 at 3:18 pm

I agree with the comment from Michelle and totally support Tana Shepherd. I am not on SA or need the CERB, I am fortunate enough to still have a job in the Essential Services Sector, what I do need is a haircut, a visit with my Chiropractor and a new pair of Workboots but I can't get any of the above. However, I can get a bottle of Whiskey or a bag of Weed because they are considered Essential Services??? WTF

Up 23 Down 2

Michelle on Apr 29, 2020 at 1:23 pm

I agree, these services should not be under the same category as personal services. These are vital health care services. I personally know two people living in pain because they can not get in person appointments with a physiotherapist. One has been off work for over a month. Yes there is the telehealth option but I can not massage the muscles in my back.

These appointment are one on one, not large groups. They are protecting us from Covid but if my health is suffering from lack of care, what is the point.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.