Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Photo Submitted

FRESH VEGETABLES – Carcross-Tagish First Nation and North Star Agriculture have partnered to supply the Yukon with fresh produce, as seen above at the Edmonton aquaponics facility, left. GREEN BOUNTY – The partnership aims to supply such leafy greens as lettuce and kale to the market in 18 months or so. Inset Tanner Stewart, Sonny Grey, Andy Carville, left-right. Photos by NUTRAPONICS CANADA CORP.

Venture eyes a year-round produce supply

A new partnership between the Carcross-Tagish First Nation (CTFN) and North Star Agriculture wants to be supplying the Yukon with fresh produce – all year long.

By Chuck Tobin on May 12, 2017

A new partnership between the Carcross-Tagish First Nation (CTFN) and North Star Agriculture wants to be supplying the Yukon with fresh produce – all year long.

North Star CEO Sonny Gray told lunch guests gathered Tuesday for the partnership announcement they intend to be supplying such leafy greens as lettuce and kale to the market in 18 months or so.

“Together, we will be tackling food security in the Yukon by building an aquaponics facility large enough to provide the Yukon with fresh vegetables, year-round,” Gray told his guests.

“We recognized in the Carcross-Tagish First Nation a lot of our own ethics and values. They believe in their community and their vision regarding the future of agriculture in the territory aligns with ours.”

Among the guests was Ranj Pillai, the territorial minister responsible for agriculture, and Eloise Clark, president of the Yukon Agricultural Association.

“Congratulations once again,” Clark told Gray in casual conversation after his presentation. “We are here to support you 100 per cent.”

North Star Agriculture Inc. and the CTFN will be forming a corporation to own and operate the business, with the First Nation owning 51 per cent of the corporation.

The intention is to break ground this fall, following completion of architectural and detailed design work currently underway, Gray explained in an interview afterwards.

He has been clear since announcing his business proposal over a year ago that it wasn’t his intention to compete with the territory’s existing agricultural community and the market gardeners who sell their goods locally.

His intention is to compete with the 18-wheelers hauling vegetables up the highway from places like California and Mexico.

And it’s pretty clear sailing from here on, Gray insisted.

They’ve been assured that because of the design of the facility they plan to build in the Carcross area, and its anticipated water use, the proposal will not require a screening by the Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment Board. Nor will it require approval from the Yukon Water Board, he said.

Gray said Environment Yukon is preparing authorization to allow for the importation of the non-indigenous tilapia fish they’ll be using in their aquaponics project.

The four-storey, 39,000-square-foot growing facility will be a closed system.

The only water leaving the site will be in the vegetables and berries they plan to sell around the territory, along with a little evaporation.

Water coming in will be from a well, although daily volumes were unavailable at this point.

Essentially, the water will be looped through the fish tanks and the beds of produce stacked vertically. Waste from the fish will provide the nutrients for the plants.

It’s based on the same design developed by Nutraponics Canada Corp. for its facility in Edmonton, which has been in commercial production for three years.

“It is with great excitement and joy that I speak with you all here today,” Nutraponics CEO Tanner Stewart told Tuesday’s guests.

“Nutraponics Canada Corp. started back in 2010, when our founders were trying to understand how to grow Rhodolia faster in a greenhouse setting.

“By 2014, we had morphed into an indoor vertical farming company dedicated to the practice of aquaponics whereby an ecosystem of fish and plants are farmed and raised together, utilizing 95 per cent less fresh water than traditionally farmed crops, with no herbicides, pesticides, or GMO seeds.”

While Nutraponics will not be an owner in the new corporation as yet unnamed, it did provide the licensing approval for Gray and the First Nation to use their system, Gray said.

He said Nutraponics remains as a partner in business, providing updates in technology and advancements in the business as they arise.

It will be Nutraponics that will oversee the construction of the facility and installation of the equipment because of its expertise.

Gray pointed out Nutraponics has also ensured the corporation it will have the exclusive rights to the Nutraponics system right across the North – the Northwest Territories, Nunavut and Alaska.

They’ve already been in formal contact with the N.W.T., Gray said.

He declined to discuss the money needed to the bring the business into production, though the Whitehorse-area farmer and businessman said raising the financing was never a concern of his.

He did thank the federal government Tuesday for its $75,000 contribution through the Canadian Northern Economic Development Agency to help fund the feasibility study and business plan.

The new partnership is currently finalizing a location for the facility in the Carcross area, he said.

Gray said it’s expected the business will need between 20 and 30 full-time employees.

Carcross, he told Tuesday’s audience, is in a much better position than Whitehorse is to respond to additional housing needs.

Annual production is estimated at 200,000 kilograms of produce and 200 tonnes of fish.

Stewart explained while almost two-thirds of space on the ground floor will be dedicated to the fish tanks, the growing beds will be stacked vertically, reaching skyward from the floor to the ceiling.

It’s expected the facility will yield 10 to 12 harvests of produce through the year, while it generally takes about 10 months for a fingerling tilapia to reach a commercial size, he explained.

Stewart said it’s simply a matter of replacing the harvestable tilapia with fingerlings – one adult out, one fingerling in.

It’s just like the leafy vegetables, berries and spice.

One bed of Romaine lettuce out, one bed of seedlings in.

“This is at the top of the food chain as far as water conservation goes in farming,” Stewart said. “You don’t get much better than this.”

CTFN Chief Andy Carvill said the First Nation is excited about the project, its economic development opportunities, year-round production of quality produce and stronger food security.

“It is partnerships like this that are making a change in the North,” Carvill said. “It is partnerships like this that are making changes in the community.”

Pillai said the project fosters everything the new Liberal government stands for: economic development, First Nation involvement, food security....

“The Yukon government will watch where this goes to see how we can help,” the minister told the audience.

Gray said while the project will initially depend on electricity from the grid, they plan to explore renewable options such as solar and wind.

There will also be backup generation installed as part of the project, and perhaps backup generation for the backup generation, given the sensitivity of the plants and fish to any changes in their environment, he said.

Gray told the audience it was through his initial research into building a small aquaponics facility in his garage to provide for his wife and their five sons that led to where they are today.

As a farmer, he said, he always has meat in the freezer, and enough root vegetables like potatoes, beets and carrots to get them through the winter.

It was the fresh, leafy greens they were missing.

While he was thinking about how he could scale an aquaponics facility to the size his family would need, Gray said, “the stars aligned.

“Nutraponics visited Whitehorse to speak at the Circumpolar Conference. It wasn’t long before I was on a flight to Edmonton, headed out to see Tanner’s facility.

“We hammered out a strong partnership, and have worked hard side-by-side ever since.”

Comments (24)

Up 0 Down 1

north_of_60 on May 18, 2017 at 5:25 pm

Any moratorium on pot hole lake fish farms does not effect the CTFN on settlement lands. It's THEIR land, they decide what it's used for. There are small lake fish farms in the Yukon that counter the unproven claims of the aquaponics aficionados.

Also Icy Waters already produces more char than the Yukon can eat, and it produces top quality fish that people want, not junk fish like tilapia that's already cheap at the stores.

Make aquaponics work without government subsidies or not at all.

Up 2 Down 2

Groucho d'North on May 18, 2017 at 3:51 pm

I hope we get a top quality fish & chip shop out of this project, the real English style all wrapped in a newspaper to go.
BTW, What's the deal with the new Mr. Mikes construction? I'm ready to spend my money.

Up 3 Down 2

Donovan McGlaughlin on May 18, 2017 at 3:28 pm

@north_of_60.....There is a moratorium on pot hole lake fish farms in the Yukon and there seems to be no plans to address it any time soon. Aquaponics is a way better way to raise fish. You can monitor disease faster, and the water quality is MUCH better and can easily be adjusted. To much ammonia from the fish will kill everything in and around the lakes. You can't just discharge the over polluted water in a lake. The influx of ammonia rises to fast for mother nature to handle it. The bacteria need to turn Ammonia to nitrates takes weeks to develop to handle a large influx of fish. Just like in Aquaponics you have to have a balance of bacteria for it to work correctly. Otherwise you have a lot of dead fish and plants. Plus lakes freeze in the winter and the fishes growth is severely stunted compared to Aquaponics.

Up 9 Down 2

north_of_60 on May 17, 2017 at 9:29 pm

Instead of an aquaponics factory, it would be far better if the CTFN raised char, trout and kokanee in a few of the many small lakes on their settlement lands. This is proven 'fish farming' that others are already doing in the Yukon very successfully. It would provide employment out-on-the-land, and it would produce a high value product that everybody wants, with a minimum amount of complicated technology and expense.

Up 3 Down 0

north_of_60 on May 17, 2017 at 9:19 pm

@Charles. If you're buying frozen wild Pacific fish like salmon, pollock, sole and pacific cod, and the package says 'product of China', that means it is being harvested by Chinese factory ships in the Pacific where it's processed, flash frozen and packaged on board.

Up 6 Down 1

Charles on May 17, 2017 at 12:36 pm

@ Math & N of 60; I agree this is an enormous idea with a dubious economic future. It assumes a lot of tilapia being consumed at higher prices than big box stores, but have you ever turned over the frozen fish packages from well known big companies based on E. coast. Well the HQ might be on E. coast, but most fish packages say 'Product of China'. Next question is; where does the 'fresh' fish sold in those stores come from?

Up 7 Down 0

Donovan McGlaughlin on May 17, 2017 at 12:11 pm

@ ProScience Greenie...... During the winter the lights are on for 10 hrs a day, but the plastic roofline is closed off so no light can get through except through the windows. I never have them on at night, I like the northern lights show better.
@Math..... I also agree on the math. I believe this venture is overkill. It would be better to raise just what the community needs. Each community could have the same type of system on a "normal" scale rather than this "super sized" project. By normal I mean raising only in the neighborhood of 400-600 fish per year per community. This would make each communities system cost less and optimize the system to their needs.
@north_of_60......I also agree that tilapia is "junk" fish. I promote Trout. It far outsells tilapia here in the Yukon. With our Salmon stocks diminishing, Trout is a suitable substitute as it is from the salmoniod family. Perch are another suitable fish as the Great Lakes Institute has a breeder program already for this fish.
I'm not promoting this venture, just trying to dispel some of the myths and disinformation around Aquaponics. It is a system that I have devoted my life to and believe in......just not on as large a scale as this.

Up 14 Down 2

Math on May 16, 2017 at 10:04 pm

I question some math as 200 tonnes of fish requires every Yukon man, woman, child and baby to eat several times the national average annual fish consumption, but now of just their tilapia. That building will cost many millions. Remember too that they will only gross wholesale prices, must skillfully process and package every pound to pass health and safety and freight it. This business will be logistically highly complex and at the mercy of the taste whims of a very small Yukon customer base that is highly price sensitive. Ask around and you will also find the data that we actually don't want to eat that much kale and lettuce in the cold winter season, we've moved from salad to soup. In the summer local gardeners and farmers will beat this.

So good luck to them because somebody involved evidently has very deep pockets and a very high risk tolerance. I just find the scale worrisome and hope the pocket is not the taxpayer again. If it's their own investment money, have at it.

Up 13 Down 2

north_of_60 on May 16, 2017 at 6:35 pm

"$10 per pound" for junk fish like tilapia? Superstore sells tilapia for $3.58 per pound, when it's not on sale for even less. This appears to be yet another waste of taxpayer money to grow very expensive food that not many people actually want to eat.

I have no problem with this scheme just as long as NO government funding is involved. If it's as good as the proponents claim, then it can succeed on it's own with bank-loan financing just like every other entrepreneur has to do.

Up 1 Down 0

ProScience Greenie on May 16, 2017 at 5:29 pm

So Donovan McGlaughlin, your greenhouse is covered at night to eliminate light pollution? If so, good on you. If not, that is a bad thing. Being big on preserving the night sky perhaps we should have our governments work on legislation to ensure zero light pollution from these types of operations. Not too many other potential negatives. For those not getting the growing problem of light pollution look up an image of this - Canadian light pollution satellite map - its not pretty, especially Whitehorse and the bigger communities.

Up 7 Down 6

Donovan McGlaughlin on May 16, 2017 at 2:30 pm

@ just say'in With 200 tonnes estimated in fish @ $10 per pound current market rate that comes to about 4 million dollars a year. I believe this should at least cover the operating costs. If it doesn't then something is seriously wrong with the system.

Up 4 Down 9

Donovan McGlaughlin on May 16, 2017 at 1:50 pm

Just Say'in ..... I NEVER said it was the biggest. U of B.C. has the largest in Canada that I know of. This one is just bigger that most. Please do not put words in my mouth. AND only growingpower.org was issued a "genius" award for 500k, again putting words. Better yet please take the time to actually READ what I wrote and take a minute to let it digest before you start telling me what I didn't say. Thank you.
Everybody told Henry Ford he was wasting money on that dang automobile no one wants, we have perfectly good horses and wagons. Glad he didn't listen.

Up 4 Down 9

Donovan McGlaughlin on May 16, 2017 at 1:43 pm

Salar on May 15, 2017 at 8:14 pm

@donomac .....what happens to the affluent that will surely need to drain somewhere...they will have 'grey water' and what guarantees are there this affluent and the fish brought up here will not introduce disease or create eutrification"
There is NO discharge or grey water in Aquaponics....You are constantly adding water due to plant uptake and evaporation. The water is purified by the plants so the fish can survive. In an aquarium you discharge water to bring the nitrate levels down so the fish can survive, with aquaponics the plants take the nitrates out of the water. Most systems run about 2 ppm of nitrate as the plants have taken care of the rest.
Tilapia stocks are mainly male fish as female take an extra 4-5 months to mature to a market size. The main stocks of Aquaponics comes from B.C. from a company that has taken XX and YY fish for breeding as there is a 98% chance of all male fish. These fingerlings are what they sell for Aquaponic stock. They are also monitored by DFO and Environment Canada for disease and have had a 100% success rate. And the Aztecs were wiped out by disease from the Spaniards, not from starvation.
Just Say'in ..... As far as how much...I can't tell you because I'm NOT INVOLVED with this venture. I can tell you that it cost's me about $.10 a head to raise romaine lettuce, about .28 a lb for beans and peppers and .35 a lb for tomatoes. I keep the costs down by making my own food for the fish from garden waste and my dinner left overs like chicken and fish.
My system is small and only can produce 1500 heads per week. I have one 650gph 24v pump that runs the system. It is a CHOP (constant height one pump) system that runs me an honest $20 per month to run during the summer. My heating comes from in-floor heat via an OWB. Plus I have almost 1500 gallons of water that is heated to 28c. My "greenhouse" is a hybrid that is of my own design and has worked very well. It is a well insulated building with double 12 mil southern roof line that is insulated in the winter and opened up in the summer to allow natural light to enter the building for 12 hours a day. In the winter I run LED lighting that runs my hydro bill up to $150.
My system can supply Dawson City with all the romaine it uses year-round, on less than 1/10 of an acre. If I expanded I could supply the entire Yukon. But that would require at least 2 full time employees and a dedication I am not ready for at this time. If I had the permits to raise trout it would be a worthwhile venture, but not now.
I have to agree that this venture is overkill. From the little I have been able to gather, it will be a huge task, that, in all reality, probably will not work as planned. These systems take at least a full year to grow the bacteria needed to produce the planned numbers they are talking about. If they try to run the # of fish they claim before they have properly cycled the system there will be a lot of dead fish. I am not a fan of raising tilapia....I'm trying to get permits to replace my goldfish with Rainbow or Brown Trout. Most won't raise them because they have a lower stocking density that tilapia, and require you to actually work to keep the system running correctly.
You know the Wright brothers were wasting their time with that ridiculous airplane....thank god they didn't listen to the armchair critics.
Keep asking...I'll Keep answering.....I'm an Aquaponic nut!!

Up 15 Down 3

Just Say'in on May 15, 2017 at 10:12 pm

@Donovan

Just like I said, it is not being done all over. If you say this is the biggest one and it is going to be in little Carcross then that says something.
You also stated how these are funded, and sited the Rockefeller Foundation, well we are not the Rockefeller's.

You sound like you are involved so I will ask you. How much does it cost to build a 39,000 sq ft 4 story building? How much will the electric bill be per month heating this huge thing? Heating the water, Make-up air systems to get rid of the humidity so it doesn't destroy the building, Massive grow lights, Huge pumps for the Fish Tanks and to circulate through the garden. Two complete back-up generating systems, when is the last time you priced those out????? 30 Full Time employees??? I can calculate that one, and so can everyone else. 1 Million Dollars or more.

How much do you think you will get from Lettuce anyway? Plus the masses will still buy the fish and lettuce from the sources they use now. You are only going to get a little piece of the business and you are selling a perishable product. Do the math man. I hope the Government wakes up, but of course none of them have any business experience. I cannot believe the stupidity.

Up 8 Down 3

Salar on May 15, 2017 at 8:14 pm

@donomac .....what happens to the affluent that will surely need to drain somewhere...they will have 'grey water' and what guarantees are there this affluent and the fish brought up here will not introduce disease or create eutrification......yeah the Aztecs faired well...

Up 7 Down 11

Donovan McGlaughlin on May 15, 2017 at 2:13 pm

"Just Say'in on May 14, 2017 at 3:33 pm
If these types of operations were viable then they would be everywhere down south."
Actually these systems ARE all over down south. MOST are small operations nowhere as big as the one planned here. In Milwaukee one organization growingpower.org has been growing 1,000,000 lbs of food and 20,000 lbs of tilapia year-round on 3.5 acres of land for a little over 12 years. Their new venture was funded by the Rockefeller Institutes "Genius" award of $500k. It is a reclaimed 5 story warehouse that produces 1,000,000 lbs of lake Perch every 6 months and over 3,000,000 lbs of food.
The Siberians have 4 LARGE farms producing food all year round. In B.C. there are over 1000 permitted Aquaponics facilities licenses issued. The University of British Columbia has an extensive course in Aquaponic as well as 15+ other Universities in North America. Alberta has the toughest inspection and permitting standards in Canada. This is nothing new as a matter of fact the earliest recorded use of Aquaponics was found in China around 800BC. The Aztecs fed their cities of 1 million people with this very same system of growing.
This venture is a modern version of the old system, they haven't reinvented the wheel, they just modernized it.
Bill Williams "Are pesticides being used if the fish don't produce enough nutrients will it be supplemented with a non organic fertilizer?"
The answer is NO. Pesticides will kill the fish as well as non organic fertilizer. The ammonia from the fish waste is broken down by naturally occurring bacteria in the water and air. These bacteria convert the ammonia to nitrites then to nitrates. Nitrates are what every plant requires to grow and they have free access to it in the water that the root are suspended in. It's called the Nitrogen Cycle and it happens every day in our rivers and fish populated water bodies all over the Yukon. The plants clean the deadly to the fish, nitrates out of the water, cleaning it for the fish and the cycle continues.
JC "... the anticipated water usage sounds a bit suspicious to me." The Yukon Water Act allows for the use of up to 300cm3 of water a day to be drawn for agriculture use without special permits or YESAB review. The amount sounds correct to me. A head of lettuce takes exactly 1 gallon of water to grow over a 5 week period. I believe they are citing the building design because it will be more of a warehouse space than a "greenhouse". The design of the system keeps the fish inside the building and virtually eliminates the risk of accidental release. Tilapia die off when the water temperature drops to 12c. This is the average UPPER water temperature of water bodies in the Yukon, the deeper you go the colder it gets.
Hope this answers your questions. Fire away and I'll try to answer them. And NO, I'm not part of this venture, just an Aquaponics nut with 8 years experience.

Up 20 Down 3

north_of_60 on May 15, 2017 at 1:53 pm

@PSG "hope that the finances are well monitored and the tax dollars invested are minimal. "

That's beautiful satire. This scam will be 100% taxpayer subsidized. Laundering the money through the Territorial or FN government does not change the source.

Up 21 Down 5

Just Say'in on May 14, 2017 at 3:33 pm

If these types of operations were viable then they would be everywhere down south. I think that the CTFN is being hoodwinked again like they were with all the 5 Star and 5 Diamond grandiose Hotel Schemes. There will always be someone willing to take your money and sell you a Vacuum. Don't be a Fool or you and your money will soon be parted.

Up 6 Down 6

ProScience Greenie on May 14, 2017 at 1:11 pm

Sounds good in theory. Worth a try but hope that the finances are well monitored and the tax dollars invested are minimal. Real carbon footprint vs. projected? This should all be out in the open.

One worry is the potential light pollution from the operation. They had better plan on covering the greenhouse roofs after dark to minimize night sky destroy light trespass. If not I'm 100% against it.

Suspect the GMO thing is a non-issue.

Up 21 Down 1

Bill williams on May 14, 2017 at 9:52 am

What are the heating and lighting options in the winter? That is what will make or break this operation. If the cost of the produce is too expensive people will just not buy it. Buying locally produced products will only garner loyalty if it is affordable. Are pesticides being used if the fish don't produce enough nutrients will it be supplemented with a non organic fertilizer? Wish CTFN all the luck with this project but let's hope it does not become a monorail scam orchestrated by a fly by night southern company.

Up 20 Down 8

jean on May 13, 2017 at 11:26 pm

"the First Nation is prepared to invest its own funds in the construction. Not all the financial details have been disclosed including the projected total cost or to what extent federal and territorial funding would play a role. " CTFN & YTG money all comes from the federal government, regardless of how people want to label it.

It's highly unlikely that many people in Carcross want to eat a lot of extremely expensive kale, spinach and tlapia. In any case it would be one heck of a sweet deal for the aquaponics company pushing this scam, even when it doesn't succeed.

In the long run it would be far cheaper for the federal government to buy food that people actually want from Whitehorse stores, and truck it to the community to give away for free.

Up 9 Down 11

Donovan McGlaughlin on May 13, 2017 at 8:07 am

I would like to thank Mr. Grey for being so vocal in this matter. I wish him and Carcross FN the best of luck. There is still a lot of work to be done in the permitting stages of this project. Fisheries still has to have our agreement with the Federal government amended for tilapia, and there is still no clear line of processing for permits. FN's through out the territory have to be consulted first, a complete project review must be done through YESAB, and inspection standards have to be established. I would like to see this project start in the fall, but I foresee it being delayed due to lack of legislation.
There is a long road ahead of those of us that are trying to implement these growing systems. Right now our only choice to run these types of systems is to build them with plant production as your only goal, because the only suitable unrestricted fish available to us is the Common Goldfish. They preform the same function as the tilapia do but are not a food source, just a nutrient source for the plants.
This system of growing can produce WAY more than just leafy greens. They can raise flowering fruits like tomato, cucumber, melons and squash. Just like raising greens, the plants consume less water and grow faster than soil based crops.

Up 7 Down 14

Bob on May 12, 2017 at 11:35 pm

Can someone tell me if the produce is either Organic or "Genetically Modified (GMO)" or "Genetically Engineered (GE)"?. For those of you who are wondering why I'm asking. Then, please go here: http://www.gmoevidence.com/criigen-gm-maize-and-roundup-can-cause-tumours-multiple-organ-damage-and-premature-death/ . There's many more articles on this website worth checking out. If you aren't interested in your health & that of your family's then don't bother.

Up 26 Down 8

jc on May 12, 2017 at 9:29 pm

The Carcross FN will own 51% of this operation. Would that be the real reason there won't be any screening by the Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic assessment Board nor require approval from the Yukon Water Board? Siting the design of the building and the anticipated water usage sounds a bit suspicious to me. But then -------

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.