Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT – ‘I think any police organization can always do better,’ Whitehorse RCMP Insp. Archie Thompson, right, told the Star this week. Barb McInerey, top left, Tracy-Anne PcPhee

‘Unfounded’ sexual assault cases to be reviewed

Yukon RCMP are reviewing all sexual assault cases deemed as unfounded in 2016.

By Emily Blake on February 24, 2017

Yukon RCMP are reviewing all sexual assault cases deemed as unfounded in 2016.

RCMP across the country have been compelled to re-examine these cases following a breakthrough Globe and Mail investigative report.

“I think any police organization can always do better,” Whitehorse RCMP Insp. Archie Thompson told the Star in an interview Tuesday.

“I’ll be keenly interested in what the results of the review determine, and then we’ll take steps from there.”

The Globe and Mail’s 20-month investigation looked at sexual assault allegations between 2010 and 2014 from more than 870 police forces across the country.

They found that police dismiss one of every five sexual assault reports as unfounded.

This means they determined a crime was neither committed nor attempted.

The Yukon had some of the highest rates of unfounded cases in the country:

• 29 per cent of cases in Whitehorse;

• 35 per cent in Dawson City;

• 37 per cent in Haines Junction; and

• 21 per cent in Watson Lake.

“I just want to make sure the public understands we take very seriously the need to thoroughly investigate sexual assaults,” Thompson said.

He added that a thorough investigation means “leaving no stone unturned.”

He gave the example of an uncle reporting the sexual assault of his 16-year-old niece who the police find is engaging in a consensual sexual relationship with her 20-year-old boyfriend as a case that would be deemed unfounded.

But even before the Globe and Mail’s investigation, many sexual assault survivors have come forward with complaints about how police handle these crimes. 

“If anybody’s not satisfied, they can speak with a supervisor at the RCMP,” explained Insp. Thompson.

“I’m confident that if any of their concerns can be addressed, they will be.”

He noted they are working with community partners, including the Yukon Women’s Coalition, to provide ongoing training for staff.

They also have a specialized response unit for cases of domestic violence, sexual assault and child welfare, where staff with specialized training assist with these investigations.

“One story where a victim doesn’t have a positive experience that leaves him or her to leave the system, and we know that affects other victims who might want to come forward, is too many,” Justice Minister of Tracy-Anne McPhee told the Star Monday.

“Individuals that are reporting a very traumatic event deserve to have the support of the services that are there to support them.”

She noted that the Yukon’s rate of sexual violence is three times higher than the national average.

“The safety and well-being of victims are a priority,” she said.

McPhee added one of her commitment mandates is to review and improve services in the territory.

She wants greater co-ordination among the RCMP, the territorial victim’s services branch and medical professionals.

One project close to completion is a 12-module program across the territories called Essential Skills for Northern Victim Services Workers. It’s aimed at community members who may receive disclosures of sexual assault.

“A victim’s first experience with someone of authority is very important,” she said.

Barb McInerney, executive director of Yukon Women’s Transition Home Society, told the Star there are many reasons why someone may not want to report a sexual assault to the police.

“There’s a whole array of different reasons, especially since sexualized violence is such a brutalized invasion of sense of self,” she said.

These reasons include a person’s capacity to report, past difficulties with police or the legal system, inability to attend court, and factors like poverty, oppression, safety and family limitations.

There are also many tight-knit communities in the Yukon that may make reporting difficult.

“It’s very hard to move forward when you might be seeing the person that assaulted you everyday,” explained Elaine Michaud, executive director of Les EssentiELLES, the French-language women’s organization in Whitehorse.

But there are many resources within the territory for survivors who do not want to go to the police.

Kaushee’s Place and Betty’s Haven provide residential support services, referrals, advocacy, and accompaniment for victims of violence.

They also offer a third-party reporting service where survivors are able to anonymously report the details of an assault to police.

Other resources include “kits on ice” where evidence kits are saved for up to six months while a person decides whether to report to police.

And Victim Link is a 24-hour toll-free confidential phone line based in B.C. for victims of crime.

Also, women’s groups stress a need for a change in societal attitudes.

“The first step to help out survivors is make sure that there’s a better social response when someone discloses,” said Michaud.

“There’s still a lot of victim blaming, a lot of doubt.”

Comments (10)

Up 0 Down 0

Let us have our voice-doubters are the problem on Mar 3, 2017 at 2:36 am

When I was 12 I was sexually assaulted by a 16 year old. If I had reported it, I would not have received justice. It would have been he said, she said. It would have been, you were drinking, so you got what you deserved. Many of my friends also were victims of this type of thing. I grew up here and nothing has changed. Would be great to change this. I had a supportive family, went to university and I work with youth every day, but I still don't share my story, and I'm 43 now.
THIS NEEDS TO CHANGE! Partying, high risk behaviour and other factors which can lead to sexual assault need to be the core problems that we are combating. We need to stop blaming people who are sexually assaulted and stop talking about innocent men getting accused--there are reasons why many of us have never reported an assault--we just get blamed and the perpetrators get off. For anybody who would cry wolf over something like this, despicable absolutely. But there are more of us who try (or would like to be brave enough) to come forward but those of you who think it's just' slutty young girls making stuff up on innocent men' keep the problem the same. Oh and I also had 40 year olds coming on to me when I was 14. I was involved in sport and there are many lecherous men out there. There are also great men--I married one and my dad was one, just saying that not all men are good and we need to give credibility to women/men or girls or boys or anybody reporting crimes of this sensitive nature.

Up 4 Down 1

Community Gal on Mar 2, 2017 at 10:17 am

@ Spectrum "What kind of good "honest man" is sleeping with extremely drunk "girls barely past puberty". False accusations also consist of young children being interviewed. They have carnal knowledge because they are being molested and threatened. They have been known to report/accuse an adult male that they trust would not hurt them. This is because the abuse is escalating and they have to talk to someone about it. But they are terrified of the abuser and his threats so they accuse someone they feel safe with. In three Yukon cases that I know of, a grown man was accused and charged with the crime yet the abuser was a teenaged boy (three teenaged boys, a different one in each case) who, in each case, was caught with the child. In each case their records were sealed and protected because they were Young Offenders. Sad but true. If the outcome of all this is better education and interview techniques then I will be thankful.

Up 6 Down 1

Tom Stevens on Feb 28, 2017 at 1:45 pm

@SPARKY

Yes you are exactly right..not
Complain to the supervisor who approved the action to begin with..excellent idea..The Commander will tell you to file a complaint which in 90% of the cases will be investigated by the subjects co workers. The RCMP Public Complaints Commission has no authority to discipline, change or re direct an investigation, they are civil servants with no teeth and often take years to come to a decision as they are so overwhelmed with complaints. And even if they rule against the RCMP they do not have to accept it. There is no legal Territorial oversight as per the RCMP Act. You might want to look at the millions just awarded to resolve complaints by female RCMP and Civilian staff to compensate for lack of justice of their complaints for the past 20 years, and you expect outsiders will get better?
There are some good honest people in the RCMP but only a fool will believe the system of oversight and complaints is fair, effective or efficient.

Up 4 Down 7

Sparky on Feb 28, 2017 at 9:18 am

@ tom Stevens.
As far as I know there is also an independent federal group. Something like commission for public complaint against the RCMP.
That is aside from complaining to the supervisor, talking to the detachment commander and even go to the territorial oversight level if you are unsatisfied with the other outcomes. You can also sue if things are really bad. Another option...you against all that too?
Yeah, there is no system to complain or raise concerns about the RCMP.

Up 9 Down 10

Spectrum on Feb 27, 2017 at 7:39 pm

@ False_Accusations_Destroy_Lives "(too many cases from elsewhere in Canada of honest men's careers destroyed by lying little girls barely past puberty). Sad but true." What kind of good "honest man" is sleeping with extremely drunk "girls barely past puberty".

Up 18 Down 5

Tom Stevens on Feb 27, 2017 at 10:57 am

“If anybody’s not satisfied, they can speak with a supervisor at the RCMP,” explained Insp. Thompson.
“I’m confident that if any of their concerns can be addressed, they will be.”

Apparently Insp. Thompson has never tried to get an RCMP complaint addressed. If he thinks this is how you resolve an issue with the RCMP investigation he is willfully blind or has clearly drank too much of the kool-aid.

Up 8 Down 11

JUDITH HARROWER on Feb 26, 2017 at 7:01 am

While the media found possible poor investigations every outpost should willingly review their cases to ensure that they completed an appropriate and fully investigated process. Only then will the slate be wiped clean and trust may be restored and the public's pride of our National Police Force.

Up 23 Down 4

Just be kind on Feb 26, 2017 at 6:36 am

I truly feel for any person (not just women) that have to endure a single or repeated sexual assault at anytime throughout their life. That aside, for any number of reasons the number of false claims will remain high...I also feel for the persons (not just men who are falsely accused...that is a terrible astigmatism too to be accused of such a thing...it is the kind of accusation that no matter the proof found or not found, you are guilty in the eyes of society)

While I appreciate the work that women's shelters do in the community. I was once the lone man on a woman's shelter bod (not in Yukon). To say I felt unwelcome is an understatement. Meetings were basically anti-men rallies, I honestly don't think they were able to look at a case independently. Hope the groups here are better.

Up 20 Down 7

Just Sayin' on Feb 25, 2017 at 2:47 pm

Statistics can be manipulated and provide a skewed picture of what is occurring anywhere. The sad thing I keep reading is how women have all these support services and so forth. However, this is another side to the story which Ms. Doolittle of the G&M did not investigate; how many sexual assaults occur on men? It happens, but there is a paradigm in society where we deem men to be strong, ergo, sexual assault cannot occur to them. This is why there are no services for men or shelters for men in the Yukon. In BC there are because it occurs often. If a SA crime occurs against a man they are to suck it up and deal with it, but if it is occur against a woman, well it should be investigated to the N'th degree and there should be support workers and everything to help them. Society needs to move past what type of genitalia one has and realize anyone can be sexually assaulted. The RCMP also need to realize this.

Sexual assault accusations destroy lives and should be investigated thoroughly. A person may believe a crime has occurred because they got an icky feeling or woke up and couldn't remember, but the law should not take these people's story as fact without a thorough investigation.

Up 32 Down 14

False_Accusations_Destroy_Lives on Feb 25, 2017 at 10:46 am

Doubtless that serious sexual assault is a crime, and should be reported. But this story supports the 'cry wolf' theories. Just because a man touches a woman on the knee they are not committing rape, or attempted rape. A hopelessly drunken 16-year old girl, who spends 16 hours a day transfixed by the internet, and the social media channels that feed her undeveloped little mind, is no expert witness. The system (certainly up here in the Yukon with 3 times the national average) needs to make clear to alleged accusers that if their case is unfounded and their experience however traumatic to them, is in fact nothing vaguely resembling a crime then there are consequences for the accuser as much as the true victim accused. Anonymity of the accuser should not be guaranteed if it transpires that they were simply too drunk to know what happened after their fifth vodka! (too many cases from elsewhere in Canada of honest men's careers destroyed by lying little girls barely past puberty). Sad but true.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.