Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Photo Submitted

Michael Nehass

Trauma, violence rocked offender’s childhood

On Monday, Yukon Supreme Court heard about inmate Michael Nehass’ traumatic upbringing, his deteriorating mental health and the prolonged effect incarceration has had on him.

By Pierre Chauvin on February 2, 2016

On Monday, Yukon Supreme Court heard about inmate Michael Nehass’ traumatic upbringing, his deteriorating mental health and the prolonged effect incarceration has had on him.

The full week has been set aside to hear a Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms challenge Nehass filed last November.

In the application, Nehass argues procedural delays and detention conditions infringed on his constitutional rights protected by the Charter.

He is asking the court to stay the current proceedings and to release him from custody.

Dr. Peggy Koopman, a psychologist, testified about Nehass’ life after reviewing dozens of medical and psychological reports.

At age two, his parents separated.

A year later, Nehass lost his mother to a traffic crash. He went to live with his father and step-mother.

“Life was very difficult at that time (for him),” said Koopman.

His stepmother inflicted cruelty on him – locking him in his room for long periods of time.

Before the age of five, he was banging his head against walls, screaming. Around the same time, he was sexually assaulted, Koopman said.

There was a lot of alcohol and drug abuse in his family, she said.

He first starting drinking at age nine.

Around the same time, he started harming himself and losing control in an “hysterical way.”

At 12, he made his first suicide attempt.

“It was an attempt to demonstrate emotional pain,” said Koopman.

At 14, he had his first drug-induced psychosis. He used drugs to self-medicate and escape situations he was in, but he couldn’t handle them, Koopman said.

Nehass developed another personality, akin to imaginary friends young children have sometimes, she said.

“She is making me look like a wingnut!” Nehass shouted.

There was violence in the community where Nehass was living, Koopman noted.

Over the years, he was diagnosed with FASD, attention deficit disorder, an anxiety disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder.

He was also diagnosed with an attachment disorder, resulting from the fact that he wasn’t able to develop trusting and nurturing bonds with loved ones – and all further relationships would be hampered by that.

“Life is not safe and people can’t be trusted,” Koopman said as an example of what people with an attachment disorder might feel.

From age 15 on, he made several suicide attempts, including swallowing razor blades in 2008.

Nehass interrupted Koopman repeatedly throughout the hearing, shouting at times that she was lying.

He said his own lawyer, Sarah Rauch, is part of a conspiracy against him and that nobody was listening to him about information he had on missing and murdered aboriginal women.

Koopman also quoted from research published out of the Harvard Medical School detailing psychological consequences of prolonged solitary confinement.

The hearing back in January 2014, when Nehass appeared naked and shackled via videoconference, was “extremely” traumatic, she noted.

The appearance later prompted an apology from the presiding judge for not having adjourned earlier.

On Monday, Justice Scott Brooker adjourned three times in the hour-and-a-half-long hearing when Nehass wouldn’t stop yelling over him, the witness or the Crown.

He threatened to fire his own counsel several times.

Nehass was scheduled to take the stand today.

Testimonies for the defence are expected to continue until Thursday, before adjourning until the end of February.

Comments (8)

Up 1 Down 0

mary laker on Feb 8, 2016 at 4:23 pm

A) He is dangerous based on past behaviour and mental state. The public should not be put at risk by setting him loose in society.

B) He does not belong in prison. He is not mentally well to say the least, and his solitary confinement incarceration probably has made him sicker. But it was necessary based on his violence, including punching a guard in the face so hard that a bone was sticking out of his face.

Please get Michael squared away in a facility that will make it impossible to ever hurt another member of the public, and where he might find some peace and enjoyment of life. Is this really so hard?

Years have gone by with all this game playing in the courts. Get on with it!

Up 49 Down 32

Ban the trolls on Feb 4, 2016 at 8:31 am

I for the life of me can't believe some of the insensitive comments regarding this person. I am not condoning what he has done when breaking the law. At the same time he has gotten a raw deal for all of his life. The hater trolls could not possible even imagine what this young man has gone through in his short life.

Up 19 Down 22

Linda Rosa RN on Feb 3, 2016 at 2:43 pm

There is one recognized disorder of attachment and that is "Reactive Attachment Disorder." It is a rare disorder characterized as a child being either very withdrawn or overly clingy or over friendly with unfamiliar people. There are no aggressive or violent features associated with RAD.

There is a quack diagnosis known as "Attachment Disorder" (AD):
"RAD vs AD"
http://www.childrenintherapy.org/attachmentdisorder.html

AD is associated with a highly abusive therapy and parenting method called "Attachment (Holding) Therapy."
http://www.childrenintherapy.org/essays/index.html

Any child can get this label as it has a laundry list of signs (including "good behavior"). It is mainly adopted children caught up in this "therapy cult" and some don't make it out alive. Any child needing actual help won't get even a proper evaluation.

So what was going on in this case? Perhaps the authorities should take another look at this person's upbringing.

Up 61 Down 45

tired of this excuse. on Feb 3, 2016 at 9:16 am

I hate that excuse of trauma. Pretty much everyone has trauma growing up in different degrees. Something that seems minor to one person can actually be quite detrimental to another.

But there's a difference--some people choose to rise above and some people choose to use it as an excuse when it works to their advantage.
Sounds like he was diagnosed with a few things (FASD, ADHD, anxiety, PTSD) when he was younger. I would imagine at that time, he was likely offered help to address his issues. He didn't take them. You can't help someone who doesn't want to be helped.

I'm sorry all of this happened to him. But it doesn't give him the right to go out and do this to other people. He needs help. He does not need to be free.

Up 53 Down 17

Yukoner on Feb 3, 2016 at 7:54 am

And yet another reason to not let him go. Between this mans lawyer and himself he should most likely never be released as I'm sure if he wasn't already a wing nut, his words not mine, he surely is now and can't be trusted outside of jail.

Up 40 Down 17

JC on Feb 2, 2016 at 9:58 pm

And he wants to be released from custody? And the sad thing is, he will be.

Up 53 Down 16

Thomas Brewer on Feb 2, 2016 at 3:49 pm

Just because he had a crappy upbringing doesn't mean that society shouldn't be protected from him.
Slap the dangerous offender label on him and throw away the keys.

Up 70 Down 5

June Jackson on Feb 2, 2016 at 3:27 pm

I hope that Mr. Nehass is transferred to a facility for the criminally insane.
I surely don't want him loose on the streets again. Who gets the blame when he kills someone?

The story of Mr. Nehass's life is not unique to him. I know so many people with brutal backgrounds, terrible, violent childhoods...and they are not in jail with the string of charges against Mr. Nehass.

I agree that prison is not the right place for him, but neither should he be free. He needs to be where he can be kept safe from himself and others can be kept safe from him.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.