Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Pictured above: SANDY SILVER and BRAD CATHERS

‘The premier needs to learn to live within his means’: YP

With large territorial deficits looming,

By Sidney Cohen on May 10, 2017

With large territorial deficits looming, the Yukon Party is challenging the the premier’s decision to add more than 200 full-time positions to the government’s payroll.

The Yukon government will add 201.75 full-time equivalent positions to the public service this fiscal year, the premier revealed Tuesday in the legislature.

This could push the total number of full-time Yukon government employees to above 4,800 in 2017-18 – one year before the government expects to run a $48.9-million deficit.

“The premier is blaming his red ink in future budget years on this previous (Yukon Party) government but has already significantly increased the size of the public service,” Yukon Party Finance critic Brad Cathers said in an interview today.

“Premier (Sandy) Silver, when in opposition, was very critical of increases to the public service, and told Yukoners that repeatedly, and yet now in office, again he’s breaking his word.”

The 201.74 new full-time equivalent jobs in 2017-18 are “mostly for teachers,” Silver said in the legislature Tuesday.

The Department of Education is getting 135.71 new full-time equivalent employees in 2017-18, said Silver.

It’s unclear whether these jobs will be in Whitehorse or in the communities.

He added that 88 of those hires – which are teachers and teaching assistants – were made by the previous Yukon Party government.

Cathers disputed Silver’s claim that 88 of those new positions were Yukon Party hires in an interview this morning.

He doesn’t believe the number is accurate, and challenges the premier to back it up with evidence.

In the fourth quarter of the 2016-17 fiscal year, there were 4,623.1 full-time equivalent Yukon government employees, cabinet spokesperson Janine Workman confirmed today.

The rest of the new full-time staff are spread throughout the government.

Additionally, several full time staff are being shuffled out of one department and into another.

Each new full-time position added to the public service comes with the long-term costs of pensions and benefits, noted Cathers.

“All of these things are impacts on the government’s future financial picture.”

In the House on Monday, Silver suggested the Yukon Party made similar decisions about hiring full-time staff.

The government added about 167 full-time positions between the fourth quarters of 2015-16 and 2016-17, he said.

When asked whether the Yukon Party indeed created 167 new full time equivalent jobs in the last year of its mandate, Cathers said “I’m not sure about the numbers on that.”

The former Yukon Party cabinet minister conceded that there are times when growing the public service is warranted.

“Continuing care and home care are areas that we did that,” he said.

“We do recognize that there are times when to meet the needs of a growing population, that there are some new hires required.”

What’s concerning to the official Opposition, said Cathers, is that the Liberal government is expanding the Department of Finance by adding 10.6 full-time positions this fiscal year.

The government estimates it will spend $1.13 million on personnel in Finance, up 54 per cent from last year’s estimated $844,000 personnel budget.

“The ballooning of Department of Finance is a total waste of money,” said Cathers.

“The premier needs to learn to live within his means, and that means differentiating between what’s nice to have and what’s required.”

On Monday Silver, who is also minister of Finance, defended his Finance department hires.

He said they are a “strategic investment,” and that the government will ultimately see returns in the form of a financially stable Yukon government.

“We were very critical about how we’re going to move forward — what hires are going to be had,” he said.

“We did a good job of spending the money that we need to do now to make sure that the fiscal balance and the fiscal scrutiny is there for decisions for tomorrow.”

Silver reiterated that his government is not considering cutting public sector jobs as a way to reign in spending in future years, and Cathers said today that the Yukon Party is not calling for layoffs.

The Yukon government will spend an estimated $516.5 million on personnel this year – a little over a third of the territory’s $1.44-billion budget.

Neither the premier nor the minister of the Public Service Commission could be reached before today’s press deadline.

Comments (15)

Up 0 Down 0

Just Cruisin' on May 17, 2017 at 12:34 am

It's hard to take the "need for deficits" argument seriously when so much money is being wasted every year on consultants doing feasibility studies that just gather dust on shelves.

Up 25 Down 14

CastStones on May 12, 2017 at 9:49 am

By all means Slick, more rhetoric from a member from the former government that didn't know what fiscal responsibility meant.

Up 34 Down 3

The Middle Road on May 11, 2017 at 7:55 pm

Since devolution the Yukon Government budget has increased spending by 500%

I don't think that we have seen a 500% improvement in quality of life or in services provided.

Up 14 Down 16

BnR on May 11, 2017 at 7:38 pm

Dear "he is a liberal blah blah blah"
Debt for no purpose eh? An example perhaps? So Silver is just taking the money and throwing into the river? I guess I'm not expecting much from you, given the incoherent format you choose to comment in. The JD and coke format? Regardless, this budget will not put is into debt, so you are simply prognosticating through an apparently foggy crystal ball.
All our budgets, even the previous YP ones, had a purpose. Spending always has a purpose, unless you are indeed throwing it into the river. One might not agree on that purpose, but the government was elected and is following a course.
Please do us all a favour and start crafting legible comments.

Up 14 Down 4

ralpH on May 11, 2017 at 5:19 pm

@ Pete Repete it is because they repeat the same mistakes year after year. Problem?? Let's fix it by throwing more money at it. And their response is, we took action. But all that has happened is another layer of bureaucracy has been created and the problem still exists. Except in most cases it is buried deeper and harder to fix. SO my friend those chicken littles that show up year after year and tout the same message, is about the only common sense I hear on these sorted issues.

Up 15 Down 24

Pete Repete on May 11, 2017 at 4:29 pm

There are about four posters here who interminably submit the same message. The sky is falling the Liberals are courting disaster even though they just submitted a very prudent plan considering the current economic climate. These four will be submitting very similar posts next year with nothing innovative or new just never ending complaint even when there is no cause.

Up 44 Down 10

ProScience Greenie on May 11, 2017 at 9:51 am

So another 201.75 people will win the lotto for a sweet job-for-life with all the benefits and perks. Hopefully the jobs go to Yukoners only and in a fair manner free of the usual nepotism and other tainted YTG hiring ways.

Hard to imagine that the Libs could bloat the government anymore than the YP did. The YP were all about bloat.

Up 28 Down 16

He is a liberal from Nova Scotia on May 10, 2017 at 9:28 pm

and supports going into debt for no reason, like our mayor. They are lovers of debt and no purpose, other than no care for our children future, to pay off this no no need for debt financing.

Up 24 Down 13

Willard on May 10, 2017 at 9:16 pm

There is nothing worse than being condescending to by a former failure.

Up 26 Down 32

jc on May 10, 2017 at 9:11 pm

That's why they are known to some as lieberals. But up here in Yukon, his government will last about as long as Pat Duncan's. And again, the YP will have to tighten the belt at the taxpayers expense to straighten everything out again.

Up 29 Down 21

Nile on May 10, 2017 at 9:03 pm

The Liberals are just ensuring they get re-elected by hiring more government workers from out east.

Up 49 Down 14

BnR on May 10, 2017 at 6:10 pm

Brad telling Silver to live within his means? Oh that's rich.
New hospitals in Watson and Dawson that the hospital Corp can't afford to maintain or properly staff? Anyone driven by and looked at the new Salvation Army? Looks like a fancy European boutique hotel.
The YP were spending like there was no tomorrow.

Up 22 Down 14

June Jackson on May 10, 2017 at 5:43 pm

At the risk of repeating myself... we are soooooooo screwed...

Up 28 Down 5

ralpH on May 10, 2017 at 5:38 pm

There has been a lot of questions lately about education and the grading system that the Dept of Education wants to implement. My question is where has the needs assessment that shows more teaching positions are required? If You look at current staffing, student enrollment, and the percentage of those that are above the norm makes me wonder if more is just not a quick fix bandaid that the Premier hopes will make the reality of a failed system go away. As I stated before, there needs to be a grading system for those that teach our kids and if they do not meet that standard then replacement needs to happen. Sorry but a knee jerk reaction is all this is.

Up 33 Down 14

Thomas Brewer on May 10, 2017 at 4:32 pm

Oh that's rich (pun intended) Yukon Party... who took a huge surplus and put us into a deficit.
Thanks very much for that. Not.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.