Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

TALKING RECYCLING – Shannon Clohosey, the city’s manager of environmental sustainability, speaks to the approximately 50 people attending a public meeting on recycling the raven recycling Society held tuesday evening at the Westmark Whitehorse hotel. the society’s danny lewis, Joy Snyder (standing) and Jacqueline Bedard are seen left to right at the front. the yukon government is holding an open house on recycling from 3-8 p.m. today at the Kwanlin dun Cultural Centre. Inset Brad Cathers, left, Sandy Silver

Show leadership on recycling: Silver to gov’t.

Liberal Leader Sandy Silver blasted Community Services Minister Brad Cathers in the legislature Tuesday for scant progress on the Yukon recycling front.

By Christopher Reynolds on October 29, 2014

Liberal Leader Sandy Silver blasted Community Services Minister Brad Cathers in the legislature Tuesday for scant progress on the Yukon recycling front.

“It’s very clear that this government is not going to meet its commitment of 50-per-cent waste diversion by 2015 without Raven being completely open,” Silver told the legislature.

The Raven Recycling Society, the only non-profit recycling plant in the Yukon, announced last month it was shutting down its non-refundables drop-off service due to lack of funding.

The closure, effective Oct. 15, has impacted thousands of environmentally conscious Yukoners looking to deposit their mixed plastic and cardboard.

Answering Silver, Cathers would neither reaffirm the target of 50-per-cent waste diversion by 2015 set earlier by the government nor deny that it could be achieved.

“How does starving the largest recycling facility in the territory help the premier meet his commitment of enhancing recycling?” Silver asked in an interview this morning.

“Where’s the leadership on this?”

He pointed to a “180-degree turn” in policy that he said begged a larger question: “Does the Yukon Party no longer support the previous environmental and social principles that led to the original investments into a public good?”

In his rebuttal, Cathers noted that last year, both Raven and P&M Recycling — the territory’s only other recycling facility — jointly approached the government to ask for diversion credits of $75 per tonne for non-refundables.

The government complied, matching the City of Whitehorse for a total $150 per tonne.

Last month, Raven requested that combined diversion credits be more than doubled to $330 per tonne.

“We’ve asked them for more information and ... I asked my deputy minister this morning to remind them that we are still waiting for that information,” Cathers said Tuesday.

“We are continuing to work with the city on identifying sustainable long-term and cost-effective solutions for processing recyclables in the Yukon.”

He noted the government has commissioned a study to examine the matter.

Cathers and Environment Minister Currie Dixon are scheduled to sit down with the mayor and city council Friday to “talk about next steps.”

Silver is skeptical.

“You don’t take away an integral service or public good without an alternative plan or objective. So, what are these?” he asked Cathers Tuesday.

“Or are we witnessing here just a complete absence of forethought on this particular file?”

Silver put forward a motion Tuesday urging the government “to adequately fund Raven Recycling.”

The government’s supplementary budget, unveiled last week, pushed back spending of $841,000 in Building Canada Fund money, earmarked last spring for a territorial recycling program, to next year.

A further $864,000 from the federal purse slated for solid waste management will no longer be put to use in 2014.

Dwayne Muckosky, director of community operations for Community Services, said the department is looking to make arrangements with municipalities on a “system” for recycling.

“We’ve got more work to do to develop a long-term sustainable model for recycling,” he told the Star early this afternoon.

Until two weeks ago, Raven sorted, compacted and shipped to Outside mills high volumes of cardboard, mixed paper and mixed plastics as well as tin, glass, Tetra Paks and Styrofoam.

About 75 per cent of Raven’s materials are non-refundables, “yet we only get half of the cost of processing the non-refundables” from the government, Joy Snyder, Raven’s executive director, told the Star last month.

Neither Raven nor P&M receive base funding.

Cathers has said the government is seeking public consultation on possible changes to the territory’s Beverage Container Regulations (BCR). The revisions would enrich the cash flowing to recycling plants for handling “refundables” like Coke cans or Kokanee bottles.

“(Raven and P&M) would likely see the amount that they receive per recyclable beverage container double ... but the specifics of that are one of the things that we’re seeking public input on,” he stated last month.

Snyder said the plan is not ideal. “The BCR funding is limited and we compete for it.”

Raven, now 22 years old, continues to accept bottles, aluminum cans, scrap metal, computers and other materials “that come with a stable funding source,” the society has said.

An open house on recycling regulations runs from 3 to 8 p.m. today at the Kwanlin Dun Cultural Centre.

Comments (11)

Up 3 Down 2

Internet Troll on Nov 4, 2014 at 4:38 pm

Owner of P&M = Pat McInroy, President of Yukon Party
Blue Bin Program Founder = Graham Lang, Former YP MLA's son, Conservative Senator's Nephew

Do the math. It's not hard to figure out that something questionable has happened here. Yukoners will get no help from the Yukon Party slime bags on this issue. This was intentional on their part. They are just eliminating the competition.

Up 2 Down 7

Wilf Carter on Oct 31, 2014 at 12:07 pm

I am glad to see the Yukon Government is making the first step in dealing with harmful actions of senior management against Yukon Government employees. The Yukon Government introduced a Wrongdoing Act yesterday. Good step and let's see what in it. Does the act have teeth to stop the harmful actions of senior management or will senior management pay lip service to it like all the other acts in the Yukon Government?
The Ombudsman made decisions on complaints I filed about the Yukon Government Public Service Commission and Economic Development and the Ombudsman stated that it appears that the Yukon Government used proper procedure in my complaint. This is only one example of how the agencies and departments protect senior management not the employees.
What about all of the 100's of Yukon Government employees that have been harmed by the senior management of this government? Yukon Government set up an inquiry to find out the truth and made the 100's of Yukon Government employees that have been harmed by senior management actions corrected. I have had 267 calls in the last month on this subject. Does it take a public law suit to bring out all the facts so all Yukon can see the truth? Show me your actions Mr. Premier on this very important issue to Yukon voters. Make a wrongdoing into a right-doing as your act calls for?

Up 14 Down 6

gary on Oct 30, 2014 at 8:30 pm

I highly doubt raven recycling is being honest! They are constantly looking for more handouts from city or ytg. Maybe the annual salary of management should be reviewed.

Up 14 Down 1

north_of_60 on Oct 30, 2014 at 6:46 pm

Why isn't the CoW's Department of Sustainability Department making any statements or doing anything about the recycling issue? One could get the impression that the DSD only manages studies by southern 'experts' and pushes social engineering programs. How does the CoW justify the money spent on this Department? What does the DSD actually DO?

Up 7 Down 3

yukon56 on Oct 30, 2014 at 5:48 pm

Wilf is everywhere,Hmmmmmm

Up 10 Down 4

yukon56 on Oct 30, 2014 at 4:20 pm

Wilf is defiantly setting up for a run at something

Up 15 Down 13

Wilf Carter on Oct 29, 2014 at 10:55 pm

Mr Brewer, I understand that the owners-family of P&M has been in the waste management business for years in the Yukon. So are you glad someone got into the waste management business to protect the Yukon environment? I do not see any Liberals or NDP getting into the waste management business but like to talk about it a lot in the house of the Yukon Government and have all the solutions to waste management. So if waste management is such an issue why don't the liberals and the NDP get into business of waste management/recycling? Lots of talk no action. Get into the facts liberals and NDP and back up your statements because you cannot do that but like to make noise that means nothing!

Up 7 Down 14

Wilf Carter on Oct 29, 2014 at 8:06 pm

So senior management will defend there wrongful actions but the minister of the Public Service Commission will not stop the wrongful actions as stated in the house today no matter what? The truth is coming forward of a hand full of senior managers whom make the rest of senior managers look bad. Why don't the good managers bring forth the truth on wrongful managers that are harming Yukon Government employees and the public business of the Yukon? Look at the Public Service Commission and Economic Development they are in a mess. Senior management you have a role to stand up for yourself and stop wrongful bad management! Why should the Yukon pay salaries and benefits for people whom are incompetent in the delivery of our public business? Does any one agree and believe this?

Up 19 Down 6

Max Mack on Oct 29, 2014 at 5:06 pm

The Raven Recycling "funding" issue might make for great political theatre. But, placing the blame on YTG seems disingenuous and Raven's move to cease "public drop-off" services seems politically motivated.

I would like to see an examination of Raven's projects and spending over the last several years. I would also like to see an objective, full cost-benefit analysis conducted on the issue of recycling in a Yukon context.

Recycling, on its face, is good for the environment. But the cost of maintaining full recycling facilities in the Yukon may exceed benefits by a wide margin.
Recycling at any cost might be enormously expensive and counter-productive on so many levels.

Up 22 Down 29

Thomas Brewer on Oct 29, 2014 at 4:56 pm

With P&M Recycling being owned by the President of the Yukon Party Executive, there's really no way that this government is going to back Raven.

Simple nepotism.

Up 8 Down 22

Wilf Carter on Oct 29, 2014 at 4:22 pm

Sandy the Garbage man. Do think garbage is the number one issue in the Yukon? NDP were on the same sing song about garbage but at least they started to bring forth the facts on what is taking place in the Yukon Government as far as the abuse of employees and out of control and lack accountability of senior officials in the Yukon Government,

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.