
Photo by Photo Submitted
Stacey Hassard and Valerie Royle
Photo by Photo Submitted
Stacey Hassard and Valerie Royle
There is a housing emergency in the Ross River Dena Council community, says Chief Jack Caesar.
There is a housing emergency in the Ross River Dena Council community, says Chief Jack Caesar.
He’s calling on the Yukon’s political party leaders to take immediate action.
The situation has gotten so bad that nearly half of the 130 homes in the community of about 415 people are unsafe to live in, Caesar says in an Oct. 22 letter addressed to the four political party leaders.
A recent environmental study in the eastern Yukon community shows that high levels of toxic mould, radon, petroleum and/or sewage are present in 45 to 47 occupied homes, according to the letter.
Another 16 have deteriorated to the point where they had to be abandoned.
“RRDC (Ross River Dena Council) needs immediate and sustained help from the Yukon and Canadian governments to address the current emergency housing crisis affecting the health of many of our people,” says Caesar.
The contaminants are “significantly affecting the health of the families” who live in these homes, he said. Babies, toddlers and elders are at risk.
Most of these homes are damaged beyond repair, says Caesar.
Emergency temporary homes for 48 to 60 families are needed before winter.
The RRDC does not have a land claim and self-governing agreement with Canada. It is a band under the Indian Act.
Technically, housing for Ross River is the responsibility of Canada, but some of the Yukon’s political parties say they too have a duty to confront the housing crisis, as a matter of public safety.
On Thursday, the Yukon Liberals confirmed they would allocate money to housing in Ross River in the 2017-18 territorial budget.
“Obviously, it’s going to require a financial commitment,” said Liberal spokesperson Valerie Royle.
“How much money that’s going to be, we need to get in and assess the situation. Yes, we’ll work with the federal government, but no, we will not shirk any responsibility on this.
“These are Yukoners, and they’re living in Third World conditions. This is a crisis.”
The Yukon New Democrats said they too would commit territorial dollars to housing in Ross River, determining the amount in conjunction with the federal government.
“We believe that the federal government has dropped the ball quite badly, and we aren’t going to sit around and wait for them to take action,” said Denise MacDonald, the NDP’s campaign spokesperson.
“Ideally, we would like the feds to come up and cough up quite a big share, but we will be one of the funders.”
Stacey Hassard is the minister responsible for the Yukon Housing Corp. for the Yukon Party government.
He was not available for an interview Thursday.
However, he said in an email that if re-elected Nov. 7, he would direct the housing corporation to draft a plan for how to address the issue “until the feds live up to their obligations.”
Ted Laking, the Yukon Party’s campaign spokesperson, followed that up.
He said a solution could include “money or other supports,” but ultimately, the decision would be made by Canada, the Ross River Dena Council and the Yukon government together.
Last April, the Yukon government announced $3 million for a new government staff residence in Ross River. The building will have six units with one or two bedrooms each.
As soon as construction on the residence is finished, the housing corporation will turn over four or five units to Ross River citizens, Hassard said in a Sept. 15 letter to Carolyn Bennett, the minister of Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC). The letter was provided to the Star by the Yukon Party.
It’s unclear if Ross River citizens must be Yukon government employees to be eligible for a unit in the new building.
As of last April 18, a lot for the residence had been chosen. Construction was slated to begin this fall, but the move-in date has yet to be determined.
Though the Yukon Green Party is not running enough candidates to form a majority government, it too was a recipient of Caesar’s letter.
Party leader Frank de Jong said the housing crisis requires the involvement of all orders of government – federal, territorial and First Nation.
He said the Yukon government should set aside funds in the 2017-18 budget for temporary emergency housing for the families in greatest need.
de Jong also called for staff and resources to study the possibility of moving the community to higher ground near the Campbell Highway “out of a permafrost area and to take advantage of geothermal potential.”
A lack of adequate housing in Ross River has been a major problem for “many, many years,” said Carl Sidney, the Liberal candidate in Pelly-Nisutlin, which includes Ross River.
“The people are very sick, and they’ve actually moved out of their homes, and most of the homes that have mould issues are condemned,” said Sidney, who was in Ross River recently for the council’s general assembly.
“It just doesn’t seem that the territorial government is listening to the people in the community.”
Sidney said history has made people in the community afraid to approach governments with their problems.
There’s a fear they might get kicked out of their homes, he said.
Letters outlining the housing emergency and what is needed to remedy the situation were sent to Canada and to Hassard in September, Caesar says in his Oct. 22 letter.
From the Yukon government, Caesar asked for:
• 48 to 60 emergency homes before winter;
• 20 to 40 homes to be torn down;
• training so that Ross River citizens could design and renovate their homes; and
• assistance to study the development of three new subdivisions, among other requests.
In the six weeks since Caesar sent his letter to the Yukon government, Ross River has received no help apart from Hassard’s letter to the INAC minister, Caesar says in his letter to the candidates.
Canada has come through with some “minor emergency funding,” he says.
The federal government promised to renovate 10 homes at $25,000 each, demolish 10 others and build three duplexes.
“Unfortunately,” says Caesar, “these funds do not even come close to addressing the extent of the emergency in our community.”
INAC is providing the RRDC with $2.2 million for housing planning, renovations and construction, in addition the core funding it gives to Ross River for housing each year, spokesperon Erin Macphearson said in an email today.
"Providing and managing housing for First Nations living in the community of Ross River is the responsibility of the Ross River Dena Council. However, the Government of Canada does provide funding and support to the Ross River Dena Council to help provide safe and affordable housing," she said.
“INAC will continue to work together with Ross River Dena Council to find solutions to the current housing problems.”
In the 1960s, the Canadian government forced Ross River Dena Council citizens to relocate to their current site on the Canol Road south of the Pelly River.
The community, which is a member of the Kaska Tribal Council, now sits on permafrost, which has seen thawing as a result of climate change.
“Our old community had no permafrost issues and was chosen for good reason,” says Caesar in the letter.
“The actions of permafrost, and the lack of maintenance funding for RRDC homes, means that the condition of our homes continues to deteriorate, often very fast.”
Parcels of thawing permafrost sink relative to areas of frozen permafrost, and this can damage infrastructure and buildings sitting on top.
The situation in Ross River is made worse by the fact that the houses inherited by the community were in poor condition to begin with, says the letter.
“Each year, our community goes further and further into a hole we are unable to climb out of,” says Caesar’s letter.
“The health problems resulting from these toxic homes will be a significant cost in the long term. Many of our citizens struggle with addictions.
“There is no path to healing if you do not have a safe home.”
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (39)
Up 0 Down 2
Slough is the name. on Nov 4, 2016 at 12:19 pm
People's hatred and ignorance is amazingly stunning... Get informed before you make judgemental comments and try to look so smart. So much ignorance and hatred!
What Is Radon?
Radon is a radioactive gas that is generated through the breakdown of uranium inside the earth. It's invisible, odorless and tasteless, with no immediate health symptoms.
Radon gas enters buildings primarily through cracks and other holes in the foundation. Once inside a structure, radon is trapped and levels of the gas can become concentrated. The EPA has established a recommended action level for radon at 4 picoCuries per liter (pCi/L). For radon concentrations at or above 4 pCi/L, the EPA recommends that steps be taken to reduce exposure levels to below the action level.
"In the 1960s, the Canadian government forced Ross River Dena Council citizens to relocate to their current site on the Canol Road south of the Pelly River. The community, which is a member of the Kaska Tribal Council, now sits on permafrost, which has seen thawing as a result of climate change."
Up 6 Down 2
A Concerned Yukoner on Nov 3, 2016 at 9:50 pm
The comment from "Ross River Citizen" show just how out of touch even someone from the community of Ross River is! Ross River First Nation is NOT Self-Governing, they have NOT signed a treaty, have NOT established a legal traditional territory and so are unable to enforce laws or regulate hunting in their area, nor do they have settlement lands to create a sustainable economy for their people. They even pay taxes like the other Self-Governing FN's in the Yukon.
Unfortunately Ross River First Nation continues to be exploited by industry and are consistently ignored by Yukoners and all levels of government. Canada has NEVER apologized for the forceful relocation nor have they admitted to their part in the construction of inadequate housing in the community.
Reading the comments below is sad and deeply concerning. We continue to absolve ourselves from the situation in Ross River and other First Nation communities across Canada, claiming it is not our responsibility, providing insensitive solutions for an extremely complex situation. Shame on us. We have contributed to this crisis in more ways then we understand.
It's unfortunate RRDC has resorted to election time politicking to get their voice heard; I don't agree with it. I hope that one day they find the strength to do things differently... I hope we all can help them get there.
Up 20 Down 16
Ross River citizen on Nov 3, 2016 at 3:46 pm
Hey RRDC,
You wanted your own government, we gave it to you.
That means YOU are responsible for YOUR citizens, not ME or MY government.
Create a community for your people, then tax and manage the budget like a real 'nation'.
If things aren't working out you then can come back and be 'Canadian again'. That means you have to pay taxes, and follow the same hunting guidelines the rest of us do.
No? You want a double standard?
Pffffff
Up 20 Down 4
canon2000 on Nov 3, 2016 at 2:36 pm
Give them the right to their own resource and allow them to sell hunting permits and let them control the extraction of gas and oil on their own land then they wont be needing our help.
Up 25 Down 10
Blah, Blah, Blah on Nov 2, 2016 at 2:35 pm
Ban The Trolls..... It's not able being a bigot, racist, or haters. This is the year 2016! It's about being equal. It's time for the FN to get over it and start paying their way. Everyone else has to pay their own way in life. If I were to let my house get run down nobody would be there to replace it for me.
Up 25 Down 6
drum on Nov 1, 2016 at 7:27 pm
Valerie Royle - left the Yukon Government making big money as advisor. So So Typical of this government. Just move them around and let them get big big bucks as consultants. What do they actually do besides put big balances in their bank accounts???
Up 34 Down 9
Jonathan Colby on Nov 1, 2016 at 7:18 pm
No, I think the voting system is working properly. A lot of people have 0 empathy for FN or their crisis. What can you do? The comments section is hardly the place where people change their minds.
Up 14 Down 47
Ban the trolls! on Nov 1, 2016 at 3:15 pm
I am thinking it is time for the Star to check their voting system again. One or more of the neo con trolls must have hacked into the voting system. I know there are a lot of bigot, racist haters out there, but not that many!!
Up 53 Down 17
Blah, Blah, Blah on Nov 1, 2016 at 1:10 pm
So tired of the FN crap. It's time they are made equal and start doing things on their own. Start earning a wage for a living and be responsible for what they have. Maybe that way they would take some pride in what they have. I have been working since I was 13 in order buy things for myself, never have I had anything given.
Up 50 Down 2
YukonMax on Nov 1, 2016 at 10:12 am
Okay. So, build some homes under a Yukon College Apprenticeship for carpenters, plumers, electricians, roofers, drywall installer, painter, flooring, landscaping and then you end up with residents that have the abilities to fix them when needed. Or at the very least end up with residents that have no excuses no to fix them.
Up 27 Down 6
Just Sayin' on Nov 1, 2016 at 9:40 am
In regards to Ross River being relocated. It used to flood constantly thereby perpetuating the issues of mould. As well, the reason there was no permafrost in the old flooding location is because the ground water was at a higher level ergo there was no permafrost.
Up 9 Down 52
Ban the trolls on Oct 31, 2016 at 9:00 pm
@ wow Luke, well if you don 't like the way we do things here, you know full well what you can do eh? There is no comparing what you believe, think is right or wrong. This is FN country, always has been and always will be. "borders on offensive".
Up 37 Down 7
Fed up Yukoner on Oct 31, 2016 at 7:26 pm
I considered voting for the Liberals till I saw Valerie Royle's name as their spokesperson. Why do these not very useful people keep on being employed, it just takes away my confidence in common sense and good use of taxpayers $$. Taxpayers $$ being used inefficiently by the Liberals and the folks who run housing in Ross River, what else is new.
Up 41 Down 10
drum on Oct 31, 2016 at 5:51 pm
Maybe a stupid question -
Does that article not say they get a yearly amount of money from the Federal Government for house maintenance. Where has that money gone? They must have some people who take pride in their home and do maintenance.
Do they have to account for the money that the taxpayers of this country give to them every year and show if they spent it on what it was supposed to be spent on??? If not - why not? I have to do my taxes every year and tell the government what taxes I have paid and they decide if I owe money or not.
Up 32 Down 8
ProScience Greenie on Oct 31, 2016 at 4:36 pm
Wonder if it ever occurs to Politico and Ban the trolls that perhaps some of the comments here critical of the situation are from Yukoners with FN ancestry? Perhaps they should get out more so they can hear what members of other Yukon FNs are saying. Doing so might make them think twice about calling others racists and bigots so easily.
Up 51 Down 15
Wow! on Oct 31, 2016 at 2:49 pm
@Ban the trolls:
Everybody on earth is a "just temporary user of this land"...
Unfortunately some people think that they are better than others!
We all are here on this planet only for some time, it doesn't matter which color, race, language, amount of money or attitude somebody has!
Just in case you didn't know...
Up 72 Down 9
Why on Oct 31, 2016 at 2:48 pm
Why did they wait so long to ask for help? 60 homes needed why not ask at like 15-20. Seems like they are going like Attawapiskat First Nation all over. Waiting for a state of emergency situation. Do they not have a housing department? Why was their staff not renovating or keeping up the maintenance on these houses?
Up 82 Down 13
Luke on Oct 31, 2016 at 2:46 pm
@north_of_60, I agree 100% with your comment. People who get things for free do not and will not appreciate them.
@marc, you are everything that is wrong in this world with "Who cares why the houses have become unsafe to live in, it's become a housing emergency and we need to fix it." Well I do care how the houses got to the state their in, and I'm sure so does the majority of tax payers whose monies fund this never-ending circus. But hey please strap on your tool belt, head over to Ross River and give'r I'm sure you'll be met with open arms.
Lastly and on a personal note, I'm a fairly recent immigrant to Canada. Been here about 20 years since coming over from a communist controlled eastern-european s**t hole most of you could not point out on a map. It boggles my mind the opportunity people have in this country that they squander.
Which brings me to the comment from "ban the trolls", mainly this gem: 'Most of you have no idea how First Nations continue to struggle from the adjustments that need to be made to live in the newcomers world...'
Really? I mean really? Come on. Get real. My country was leveled to the ground and ceased to exist in WW2 that's only one generation. So get your s**t together, stop living in the past, and stop blaming this generation of 'whitey'. It's ridiculous and borders on offensive.
Up 55 Down 7
Just Say'in on Oct 31, 2016 at 2:17 pm
So Valerie Royal is now a Liberal spokesman isn't that nice. I thought we were through with her. After her run as head of WCB and Dept. of Education how is that possible. Disgracefully bad management to the point the YP had to move her on.
Up 47 Down 6
Mark Sanders on Oct 31, 2016 at 11:37 am
Bleach will get rid of mold if it's not too extensive.
Up 26 Down 98
Ban the trolls on Oct 29, 2016 at 10:50 pm
Man oh man I cannot believe the number of truly ignorant comments there are for this story. Most of you have no idea how First Nations continue to struggle from the adjustments that need to be made to live in the newcomers world, I am not saying that the FN is faultless but at the same time some of these comments are down right wrong.
You so call taxpayers don't give FNs any funding, what you are doing is paying for stealing their land and way of life that sustained them for thousands of years. You people don't want to admit you are just temporary users of this land.
Up 90 Down 12
Lalaland on Oct 29, 2016 at 5:02 pm
As a Yukoner no one ever supplied a house for me. When I wanted a place to live I worked my a-- off to put a roof over my head. When it needed repairs I worked some more and saved to pay to have it done. You know what, when I look at my home I see all my sweat and efforts over the years what it represents and because of that I take care of it. I couldn't imagine being able to say, hey I need a new roof, plumbing, or a entire new house, etc. and expect government or anyone else to jump. Life doesn't work that way at least for most of us.
Up 71 Down 14
Just Say'in on Oct 29, 2016 at 3:12 pm
OK so I would like a house as well, how do I get it? Oh Yeah I don't qualify, just get back to work and shut up. Nothing to see here.
Up 23 Down 73
marc on Oct 29, 2016 at 2:43 pm
Who cares why the houses have become unsafe to live in, it's become a housing emergency and we need to fix it. It's not about how or why or who or should of and could of, it's about kids and elders living in substandard housing right here in the Yukon...
Up 106 Down 17
north_of_60 on Oct 29, 2016 at 2:12 pm
They were given free houses by the taxpayers of Canada, which they didn't maintain, and are now toxic. Yet, there are houses all over the Yukon of the same age and construction which have been maintained as healthy places to live. Now they want more money from the taxpayers of Canada to supposedly build more houses which they won't maintain.
Every year the taxpayers of Canada give them large amounts of money to supposedly maintain their houses. Far more than what we spend on annual maintenance for our houses. The money gets spent, and the maintenance isn't done effectively, if at all. Any calls for responsible accountability or transparency are dismissed as "racist".
“The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again, but expecting different results”
Up 66 Down 12
Just sayin' on Oct 29, 2016 at 12:46 pm
Ugh, what is Mr. Caesar doing; every time there is an issue he wants to run to the government and demand they take care of the issues which are occurring in his community. I have been to Ross River folks, go take a walk around and one will see the difference. There are people who take pride in their dwellings and others who don't. When you chuck a television out your window and do not take the proper care to fix the window, of course weathering will take a toll on your house. When one removes a pipe because they need it for their cabin and water leaks around, that is when you turn the water off and or do not remove it from your house. These issues are ones that have transpired forever, some people respect what they have while others do not. If every single house in Ross river was like this other than the government houses than one could say it was an issue. However, there are people in the community who care for the accommodations and have minimal issues with their housing.
Mr. Sidney, you were the chief for TTC and numerous individuals in your own band are living in dilapidated conditions especially in the area labeled as 'Smarchville' and you are going to change it in someone else's backyard, before you change your own? If you can't clean up your own backyard, why are you trying to clean up someone else's? Did you think as to how the Carbon tax will effect the prices to build these housing projects as your Liberal government supports it. Let's not forget how the C tax is going to increase the cost of living for everyone in RR.
Mr. Hassard, you have been the MLA for five years and why in the world are you waiting until the election year to get these projects completed? Typical YP, time for us to get reelected.
NDP, where for art thou? Right, you guys are just gonna give everyone money, until there is no money left, then what? They remind me of those people who try to buy friends. I know what I will dress up for Halloween, an orange pumpkin, and instead, I will take kids candy when they come to my door, so they can learn what the NDP really do.
As well, Mr. Caesar, your area has numerous mining companies such as Yukon Zinc and BMC in the area, instead of begging the government to take care of you and your people, how about you use these companies to fund programs for you? It is a win for both; they can get tax deductions and better community reputations while you get new housing for your people. I know YZ was under the leadership of the previous government in place, but I doubt they ever looked at bettering the community just ensuring their pockets didn't have proverbial holes.
Up 83 Down 10
Groucho d'North on Oct 29, 2016 at 12:32 pm
I wonder who could be creating all the damage to those homes? Somebody should teach them how to do maintenance before things fall apart.
Up 15 Down 45
In 2007 there was work done on the need for housing in the Yukon on Oct 29, 2016 at 11:40 am
At that time there was a need for $200 million to be invested in housing in the Yukon. $100 of that would be just for First Nations communities.
I worked on the study.
First Nations existing housing is substandard at the best.
I just sent a request to our MP and three leaders to have the Federal Government immediately have 50 Net-Zero Energy Housing units build in the Yukon.
This paper has a copy of the request.
Since 2007 the housing has gotten worse.
Right now the Yukon is receiving $14 million for housing development from the Federal Government.
When Paul Martin had a request for housing across Canada he received a number of $9 billion, which was over inflated.
He wanted to put $5 billion into housing, which would solved problems like this.
I have spent 25 years in all types of housing and managed housing for First Nation communities and seen the problems.
It is bad.
The cost of the 50 net-zero energy houses would cost $24 million dollars
What I suggest to the Federal Government is to bring ATCO work camps from Spruce Grove AB and set them up for the next couple years until this major issue is resolved.
They will have treatment systems and water holding facilities with these camps.
It is going to take two years to fix the problem in Ross River.
Do not put a bandaid on the problem do it right this time.
The Village should be up on the bench coming into town, where it is gravel base, close to the Campbell highway.
Larry there are 50 homes need to go that I requested to you several days ago.
When I was in Ross River many times going hunting on the Canol the First Nation were very friendly and stopped and cut wood for our camp.
Yukon Housing can manage the program.
Pelly Crossing needs housing also, just go and look. Other communities are in need of housing.
MP we need actually 300 of these Net-Zero Energy Housing in the Yukon as I explained to you in my request.
I did not know that housing was that bad in Ross River.
The Federal Government has a responsibility to these first nation people.
Depending on the type of mold it could be dangerous to human health.
Yukon has blue and white mold which can make you sick. If you see brown mold stay away from it. It has to be removed by people trained in removing it. I have never seen brown mold in the Yukon.
There are 4000 types of mold in the world.
So MP let Ross River hear from you ASAP. Time does not wait.
Winter is here. Rent the camps MP and get ATCO to set them up. They are comfortable and warm.
How many housing units are available in Faro as temp housing?
We need quick solutions and less talk.
Up 53 Down 16
ProScience Greenie on Oct 29, 2016 at 9:45 am
And speaking of a very paternalistic, bloated and always dysfunctional INAC, how could it be healthy for the Yukon to have an NDP government with a leader that was the former Yukon boss of INAC to form the next government. Not the best track record that's for sure.
Up 45 Down 51
Alex Gandler on Oct 29, 2016 at 9:43 am
golf courses - a new bridge to Riverdale - soccer fields - petulant lawsuits - cheaper beer are all items that the Padloski Party would rather spend money on it seems
Up 49 Down 8
ProScience Greenie on Oct 29, 2016 at 9:41 am
Not just lawyers. Millions go to consultants, experts, planning, meetings, studies, travel and a very paternalistic, bloated and always dysfunctional INAC. It is heartbreaking but just the way it is with nobody, including RRDC, wanting to stop it and focus on actually fixing the problem. As long as it is business as usually these 'emergencies' will continue.
Up 95 Down 15
north_of_60 on Oct 28, 2016 at 11:28 pm
They didn't maintain the houses the taxpayers of Canada gave them. Now the houses are toxic and they want the taxpayers of Canada to give them new houses to not maintain.
Their ongoing problems are always somebody else's fault.
Up 33 Down 52
John on Oct 28, 2016 at 10:18 pm
The Yukon party was made aware of the terrible housing situation in Ross River years ago through the Northern housing energuide audit which clearly showed housing in Ross river was below any acceptable standards. What did they do for our friends and neighbours in Ross river- absolutely nothing!! Who cares who's jurisdiction or whatever- kids and elders are living in substandard housing. YP knew that and has done nothing.
Up 17 Down 67
Politico on Oct 28, 2016 at 8:14 pm
This is a situation years in the making by many levels of governments. From the posters here the racism that allowed this to happen is still rampant in the Yukon. Governments make treaties, break them then complain that money for housing is spent on lawyers. Pivot, spin and make false equivalency blame.
Up 56 Down 13
jc on Oct 28, 2016 at 5:40 pm
When those homes were built they were for one family. Years ago I used to manage government housing. One of the problems was too many people living in one house at a time. This is what causes mold and mildew. These people have to be taught how to take care of their own homes. Pouring money into them all the time from the tax payers purse is not the answer. It's just getting too expensive. And another idea, maybe build the houses out of logs instead of those ugly pre fab shoe boxes.
Up 46 Down 13
Thomas Brewer on Oct 28, 2016 at 4:51 pm
Will be laying odds on how quickly RRDC signs a self government agreement, AFTER the federal government build MILLIONS of dollars of new homes in the community....
Beverly Hills #2 if you've been around long enough to know that reference.
Up 74 Down 16
Tater on Oct 28, 2016 at 4:44 pm
Well, when my house needs repairs, I either do it myself or hire someone. Of course, I didn't sit around all day complaining or occasionally doing some subsistance hunting or fishing. I got a job so I could pay for the repairs.
Up 47 Down 45
Herman Kaglik on Oct 28, 2016 at 4:29 pm
But sending hundreds of thousands to other countries is a higher priority then taking care of our own backyard!
Up 108 Down 13
overnight emergency on Oct 28, 2016 at 4:14 pm
Maybe they should have hired carpenters instead of lawyers