Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Harlan Meade, Liz Hanson and Brad Cathers

Hanson’s jaw dropped at huge donation to Liberals

The Yukon Liberal Party received the single largest campaign donation in 2016

By Sidney Cohen on June 13, 2017

The Yukon Liberal Party received the single largest campaign donation in 2016 – $50,000 from the small, Vancouver-based exploration company Copper North Mining Corp.

On Monday, Elections Yukon released a list of contributions made to political parties and candidates in 2016.

Copper North’s was the largest gift to any party by tens of thousands of dollars (the second-largest donations were each worth $10,000).

Many would see this as interesting, considering that the publicly-traded company is not exactly flush with cash.

According to its fourth quarter financial statements, Copper North had a working capital deficit of more than $802,000 on Sept. 30, 2016, and had not turned a profit since its inception.

Copper North owns the Carmacks copper project, an oxide copper, gold and silver deposit 38 km northwest of the Village of Carmacks.

The company was blocked from developing the site more than five years ago, after the Yukon Water Board rejected its water licence application. There were concerns from First Nations and others that the project could contaminate the Yukon River and its salmon population.

Since then, the company has reworked its approach to managing the mining operation as well as increasing exploration efforts to expand the value of the deposit.

Company president and CEO Harlan Meade declined to comment this morning on his company’s sizable donation to the Liberals.

He also kept mum on the status of the Carmacks Project.

“Until we’ve fully completed our financing for this next step, we’re really not talking about it because people tend to misinterpret what’s going on,” he told the Star.

Meade added that some kind of announcement will be made in about a month’s time.

“We’re going forward; it’s been slower than we’d like, but we’re getting ready to take the next step,” he said.

NDP Leader Liz Hanson said her “jaw dropped” when she saw the Copper North gift to the Liberals.

“Anyone from anywhere can donate as much as they want to the Yukon political process and that leaves the government open to the appearance of undue influence from interests from outside of Yukon,” she said.

“And that’s not good for a government that ultimately has to make decisions based on the recommendations of, for example, YESAB (the Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment Board) when it comes to a large mine.”

She called on the Liberal government to take a page from the NDP’s playbook and ban corporate, union and Outside donations.

Last year, the Yukon NDP railed against what it called “big money in politics.” It made an unsuccessful attempt to pass a private member’s bill that would put an end to such donations to political parties. It also proposed capping individual contributions at $1,500.

In 2016, however, the NDPs plushest contributions came from unions outside the Yukon.

The party received $10,000 from the Toronto-based UNIFOR union, $7,000 from the Canadian Labour Congress in Ottawa and $5,000 from United Steel Workers in Burnaby, B.C.

The New Democrats also welcomed corporate donations from companies that gave the same amount to the three major parties: $2,500 from Alkan Air Ltd., $1,500 from Whitehorse Motors Ltd. and $1,000 from Total North Communications Ltd.

Alkan Air gave an additional $999 to the Yukon Party in 2016.

Hanson’s campaign received its own donation of $1,500 from the Northern Carpenters and Allied Workers, Local 2499.

When asked about the apparent contradiction in her party’s message on political financing, Hanson said that as long as the rules are as they are, her party will “play by the rules.”

She said political contributions were “a debate within the party,” and that “it was the party that finally agreed” to accept donations from entities and Outsiders.

Hanson said her “preference has been not to take them.”

Of the four territorial parties, the NDP garnered by far the greatest number of discreet contributions, with 449 donations throughout 2016, and 181 campaign donations, most of which were from Yukon residents.

Outside and union donations to the NDP were not lost on Yukon Party MLA Brad Cathers.

He recalled how Hanson hosted a fundraiser in Edmonton in April 2016, and then tabled her bill proposing to bar Outside political contributions the following month.

“We saw that as being a bit hypocritical on their part to have such an abrupt change of heart on the issue of Outside donations just after they finished their last Outside fundraiser,” said Cathers.

On the topic of Copper North’s substantial gift to the Liberals, however, Cathers was tight-lipped.

“That is certainly something we noticed. I’m not going to comment on individual sources,” he said.

The previously governing Yukon Party attracted the most corporate and Outside donors in 2016.

Major donations included $10,000 from Victoria Gold Corp, $6,800 from Yukon Wilderness Adventure, $6,000 from Shoppers Drug Mart (former premier Darrell Pasloski owned both Shoppers Drug Marts in Whitehorse before entering politics in 2011), $5,800 from Midnight Sun Drilling, and $5,400 from a numbered company.

The Yukon Party also brought in more revenue than any other party last year, raising more than $236,000.

Yukon Liberal Party president Devin Bailey said he’s not concerned about the optics of accepting an outsized donation from a mining company.

“I don’t really see how it’s any different from the NDP receiving $35,000 from the Federation of Labour in 2011, or other big union contributions, or the Yukon Party receiving contributions over the years from other mining companies,” he said early this afternoon.

“This was just one contribution that, instead of being over a number of years, they gave it all in one shot.”

It’s the job of the party’s executive to make sure the Liberals are in the strongest position possible ahead of an election, he said.

“We follow all the rules that are in place,” Bailey added.

Other large donations to the winning party include $7,500 from Vancouver’s Selwyn Chihong Mining Ltd., and $5,000 from Whitehorse law firm Cabott & Cabott, of which former Liberal campaign chair Laura Cabott is a partner.

The Liberals raised more than $233,000 in 2016.

Jocelyn Curteanu, a Liberal party candidate and current city councillor, spent more than any other nominee on her campaign. She reported expenses of a little more than $21,000.

Curteanu, who lost the riding of Copperbelt South to the Yukon Party’s Scott Kent, raised about $14,700.

Cathers spent the second most on his campaign, submitting a little under $17,800 in expenses. He raised about $7,500 and received about $10,200 from the party for his campaign.

The Yukon Green Party raised nearly $6,000 in 2016.

Yukon Premier Sandy Silver donated $1,000 to the Yukon Liberal Party in 2016 and $3,000 to his own campaign and Hanson gave nearly $1,500 to the NDP.

Pasloski did not appear to contribute any money to his party nor campaign in 2016. Names are not published on donations under $250.

Green Party Leader Frank de Jong contributed $400 to his own campaign.

Comments (11)

Up 6 Down 1

Groucho d'North on Jun 17, 2017 at 7:27 pm

The ____ government that money can buy. I'm not sure that would be anything to be proud of or brag about.

Up 20 Down 6

Nile on Jun 14, 2017 at 2:59 pm

Don't look for the staff names. Look for their husbands/wives/partners on the donation list. They don't want to make it look to obvious.

Up 13 Down 6

ProScience Greenie on Jun 14, 2017 at 12:47 pm

huh? - I despise Trump and the Tea Party even more than I despise the SJW progressive crowd on the opposite fringe of the political spectrum. Could spend hours around the campfire ranting about Trump to you. Also see no need for any non-metallurgical coal mining in this day and age except perhaps in areas where coal is local and with modern generators it would be more energy efficient and produce less GHGs than using other energy sources.

The NDP was built by farmers and resource/factory workers - blue collar. Today's NDP is highly white collar and not afraid to throw blue collar workers under the bus. In fact they have driven many to the far right. Not good.

Up 21 Down 9

Curious George on Jun 14, 2017 at 7:04 am

Few people in the Premier's office appear to have made donations to the Yukon Liberals. His current Chief of Staff, EA, Admin Assistant, Director of Communications, Principal Secretary, and even his Director of Strategic Initiatives (who was actually a candidate) did not feel it worthwhile to donate to the party that now employs them (at least above the public disclosure amount). Only Silver's Director of Research and Planning appears to have donated to the Party.

Also, none of the ministerial EAs, except Mostyn's, appear on the donor rolls either. In fact, rather than reward people who donated to his party/campaign, Silver seems to have rewarded those who did not donate instead.

Maybe it is better not to donate to the Liberals? Loyalty doesn't appear to be to their supporters.

Up 10 Down 22

huh? on Jun 13, 2017 at 9:54 pm

"Definitely not our parent's and grandparent's NDP that were all about good jobs for miners and other resource workers."
Uh, Pro Science, our parents and grandparents NDP were about safe working conditions and fair wages, not getting more mining jobs. Geez, you sound like Trump glorifying coal mining.

Up 29 Down 5

jc on Jun 13, 2017 at 9:41 pm

Hanson is just jealous. Not to mention, sore loser.

Up 19 Down 23

Darrel Drugstore's Smartest Neighbour on Jun 13, 2017 at 9:32 pm

MEH - if I had the money I'd have given $50,000 to the Yukon Liberals
The Fentie-Pasloski Party was well beyond its "best before date"

Up 23 Down 4

Facts Straight on Jun 13, 2017 at 5:07 pm

Firstly, other than a couple of long-time Liberal staff I don't see any correlation between the donation names and the cabinet staff. Even looked? As for the Premier's EA - not on the list so research before you accuse somebody here.

Secondly, cabinet staff are political appointees not public servants. So it would hardly be unusual to find committed party people who built the platform then hired to advise cabinet in its implementation. Every party and government works this way. The Yukon Party had a revolving door between the Party executive, cabinet advisors and its candidate selections for years.

Up 14 Down 7

June Jackson on Jun 13, 2017 at 4:44 pm

Not a very subtle way of buying your way into the sitting government. Though $50K are peanuts to these dudes.

Can someone please provide a link or quote where the NDP (or Conservatives or Greens) said they were against mining or development? I have read about 'responsible' mining and development.

I am not NDP..I used to be Liberal, I don't know what I am now.

Up 35 Down 14

Nile on Jun 13, 2017 at 3:35 pm

And how many of those who made donations now have ties inside the cabinet office. The premiers EA comes to mind.

Up 58 Down 18

ProScience Greenie on Jun 13, 2017 at 3:29 pm

Maybe if Hanson and her crew were not so rabidly anti-mining they might see some donations from the mining community. Definitely not our parent's and grandparent's NDP that were all about good jobs for miners and other resource workers. So sad that they despise Yukon resource workers.

Also feel sorry for all the non-NDP unionized workers that see their dues go to that party. Not at all fair.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.